The Most Comfortable Pillow-top Mattress: A Ranking of the Best Options

Choose the pillow-top mattress you think is the most comfortable!

Author: Gregor Krambs
Updated on Apr 20, 2024 06:33
Welcome to StrawPoll, where your comfort is our top priority! We know how crucial a good night's sleep is, and that's why we've curated a list of the most heavenly pillow-top mattresses for you to rank. With thousands of satisfied sleepers voting for their favorite cloud-like cushions, you're sure to find the perfect match for your slumbering needs. But that's not all - if you believe we've missed a contender, we invite you to suggest it and join the conversation! So, dive into our plush poll and discover which pillow-top mattress truly reigns supreme in the realm of comfort. Let the ultimate countdown to dreamland begin!

What Is the Most Comfortable Pillow-top Mattress?

  1. 1
    104
    votes
    This mattress offers a plush pillow top layer that contours to your body for ultimate comfort. It also has individually wrapped coils for support and motion isolation.
    The Saatva Pillow Top Mattress is a luxurious and comfortable mattress designed to provide exceptional support and plushness for a good night's sleep. It is handcrafted using high-quality materials and advanced technology to offer optimal comfort and durability.
    • Mattress Type: Innerspring
    • Cover Material: Organic Cotton
    • Comfort Level: Plush
    • Support System: Individually Wrapped Coils
    • Pillow Top Material: Euro-style pillow top with hand-tufted stitching
  2. 2
    32
    votes
    This mattress has a luxurious pillow top layer made from high-density memory foam and micro coils. It also has a layer of gel-infused foam to regulate temperature.
    The Beautyrest Black K-Class Pillow Top Mattress is a luxurious and highly comfortable mattress designed with the utmost attention to detail. It offers exceptional support and plush comfort for a restful night's sleep.
    • Mattress Type: Innerspring
    • Comfort Level: Plush Pillow Top
    • Pillow Top Material: Luxurious AirCool Memory Foam
    • Individually Wrapped Coils: Yes
    • Motion Isolation: High
  3. 3
    18
    votes
    This mattress features a plush pillow top layer made from silk, wool, and cashmere for maximum comfort. It also has a layer of memory foam for pressure relief.
    The Stearns & Foster Lux Estate Cassatt Pillow Top Mattress is a luxurious and plush pillow-top mattress designed for ultimate comfort and support. It offers a combination of premium materials and advanced craftsmanship to provide a truly exceptional sleeping experience.
    • Mattress Type: Pillow Top
    • Comfort Level: Plush
    • Materials: Premium foams, cashmere, and silk
    • Support System: Individually wrapped coils
    • Motion Isolation: Excellent
  4. 4
    13
    votes
    This mattress has a thick pillow top layer made from memory foam and gel foam for a soft, supportive feel. It also has a layer of individually wrapped coils for added support.
    The Sealy Posturepedic Plus Warrenville III Ultra Plush Pillow Top Mattress is a luxurious and highly comfortable pillow-top mattress designed to provide exceptional support and a plush sleeping surface. It is engineered with the latest sleep technology to ensure a restful and rejuvenating night's sleep.
    • Comfort Level: Ultra Plush
    • Mattress Type: Pillow Top
    • Posturepedic Technology: Yes
    • Coil System: Response Pro HD Encased Coil
    • Support System: DuraFlex Edge
  5. 5
    10
    votes
    This mattress features a soft, cooling pillow top layer made from Tempur material. It also has a layer of memory foam for pressure relief and support.
    The Tempur-Pedic Cloud Supreme Breeze Pillow Top Mattress is a luxurious and highly comfortable mattress designed to provide maximum support and a rejuvenating sleep experience. It is expertly crafted by Tempur-Pedic, a renowned mattress manufacturer known for their innovative sleep solutions.
    • Mattress Type: Pillow Top
    • Comfort Level: Plush
    • Cooling Technology: Breeze Cooling
    • Motion Isolation: Excellent
    • Support System: Tempur-Adapt
  6. 6
    10
    votes
    This mattress combines a plush pillow top layer with a layer of gel-infused memory foam for ultimate comfort and support. It also has a layer of individually wrapped coils for added support.
    The Serta iComfort Hybrid Blue Fusion 3000 Pillow Top Mattress is a luxurious and high-quality pillow-top mattress designed for ultimate comfort and support. It combines the benefits of memory foam with the support of a hybrid innerspring system to provide a restful and rejuvenating sleep experience. With its plush pillow-top layer, this mattress offers a soft and cozy feel that gently cradles the body. The Blue Fusion 3000 Pillow Top Mattress is meticulously crafted by Serta, a renowned and trusted brand in the mattress industry.
    • Mattress Type: Hybrid Pillow Top
    • Comfort Level: Plush
    • Support System: Hybrid Innerspring
    • Top Layer Material: Memory Foam
    • Cover Material: Breathable Fabric
  7. 7
    2
    votes
    This mattress has a luxurious pillow top layer made from high-density memory foam and micro coils. It also has a layer of gel-infused foam to regulate temperature.
    The Simmons Beautyrest Platinum Spring Grove Luxury Pillow Top Mattress is a high-quality pillow-top mattress designed for ultimate comfort and support. It features a plush pillow-top layer that provides a luxurious and soft sleeping surface, while the underlying pocketed coil technology ensures optimal spinal alignment and minimizes motion transfer.
    • Mattress Type: Innerspring
    • Comfort Level: Luxury Firm
    • Pillow-Top Layer: Plush
    • Support System: Pocketed Coil
    • Motion Isolation: Excellent
  8. 8
    9
    votes
    This mattress features a soft, plush pillow top layer that can be adjusted to your desired level of firmness. It also has dual air chambers for personalized support.
    The Sleep Number c4 Smart Bed Pillow Top Mattress is a luxurious and exceptionally comfortable pillow-top mattress designed to provide optimal comfort and support for a restful night's sleep. It combines the innovative technology of the Sleep Number smart bed with the added cushioning and plushness of a pillow-top surface. The mattress is perfect for those who prefer a softer sleeping surface without compromising on support.
    • Mattress Type: Pillow Top
    • Firmness: Soft
    • Technology: Sleep Number Smart Bed
    • Material: High-quality memory foam and polyfoam layers
    • Adjustability: Dual-sided adjustable firmness
  9. 9
    14
    votes

    Ashley Chime 12 Inch Plush Hybrid Mattress

    Ashley Furniture Industries
    This mattress has a soft, plush pillow top layer made from memory foam and high-density foam. It also has a layer of individually wrapped coils for added support.
    The Ashley Chime 12 Inch Plush Hybrid Mattress is a luxurious and comfortable pillow-top mattress that offers a restful sleep experience. It is carefully crafted to provide a perfect balance between softness and support for a rejuvenating sleep. The mattress combines the benefits of both memory foam and innerspring coils to deliver exceptional comfort and durability. With its plush pillow-top surface, it cradles your body, relieving pressure points and ensuring a peaceful night's sleep. The Ashley Chime 12 Inch Plush Hybrid Mattress is designed to promote proper spinal alignment, reduce motion transfer, and provide exceptional breathability for a cool and comfortable sleep environment.
    • Mattress Type: Hybrid (Memory Foam and Innerspring)
    • Comfort Level: Plush
    • Thickness: 12 inches
    • Pillow-Top Surface: Yes
    • Support System: Individual Pocketed Coils
  10. 10
    2
    votes
    This mattress features a plush pillow top layer made from memory foam for ultimate comfort. It also has a layer of high-density foam for added support.
    The Lucid 14 Inch Plush Memory Foam Mattress is a luxurious and rejuvenating mattress that offers exceptional comfort and support. It is designed with multiple layers of high-quality memory foam, creating a plush and conforming sleep surface.
    • Mattress Thickness: 14 inches
    • Comfort Level: Plush
    • Materials: Memory Foam
    • Top Layer: 1-inch ventilated gel-infused memory foam
    • Second Layer: 3-inch ventilated memory foam

Missing your favorite pillow-top mattress?

Graphs
Discussion

Ranking factors for comfortable pillow-top mattress

  1. Material
    The type of materials used in the pillow top can greatly affect the comfort level. Look for high-quality materials such as memory foam, latex, or gel-infused foam for optimal comfort and support.
  2. Firmness
    The ideal firmness level varies from person to person, depending on factors such as sleeping position and personal preference. When selecting a pillow-top mattress, choose one with the right firmness for your needs: soft, medium, or firm.
  3. Thickness
    The thickness of the pillow top layer can impact the overall comfort of the mattress. A thicker pillow top provides a more plush and luxurious feel, while a thinner one offers less cushioning and a firmer surface.
  4. Durability
    A good quality pillow-top mattress should be able to withstand daily wear and tear and maintain its comfort and support over time. Look for a mattress with a strong and durable core and a high-quality pillow top layer that won't sag or lose its shape.
  5. Heat retention
    Some pillow top materials, such as memory foam, can trap heat and make the bed feel hotter. If you tend to sleep hot, opt for a mattress with a pillow top made from a more breathable material like latex or gel-infused foam.
  6. Pressure relief
    The best pillow-top mattresses reduce pressure on key areas of the body like the hips, shoulders, and lower back. Look for a mattress that contours to your body shape and offers targeted support, especially if you regularly experience pain or discomfort in these areas.
  7. Motion isolation
    If you share your bed with a partner, a mattress with good motion isolation will prevent their movements from disturbing your sleep. Memory foam and latex pillow tops are generally more effective at minimizing motion transfer than innerspring models.
  8. Price
    A pillow-top mattress can range from budget-friendly options to luxury models with a steep price tag. Consider your budget and balance the cost with the mattress's quality and features.
  9. Warranty and trial period
    A long warranty and generous trial period are an indication of the manufacturer's confidence in their product. Many companies offer at least a 10-year warranty and a trial period ranging from 30 to 120 nights.
  10. Customer reviews
    Researching and reading customer reviews can provide valuable insights into the real-life experiences of fellow sleepers. Pay attention to feedback about the mattress's comfort, durability, and overall value for money to help inform your decision.

About this ranking

This is a community-based ranking of the most comfortable pillow-top mattress. We do our best to provide fair voting, but it is not intended to be exhaustive. So if you notice something or Mattress is missing, feel free to help improve the ranking!

Statistics

  • 1681 views
  • 214 votes
  • 10 ranked items

Voting Rules

A participant may cast an up or down vote for each Mattress once every 24 hours. The rank of each Mattress is then calculated from the weighted sum of all up and down votes.

More information on most comfortable pillow-top mattress

When it comes to getting a good night's sleep, choosing the right mattress is essential. A pillow-top mattress is a popular choice for those who want extra cushioning and comfort. These mattresses feature an additional layer of padding sewn onto the top of the mattress, providing a soft and plush feel. Pillow-top mattresses come in a variety of materials, including memory foam, latex, and innerspring coils. While they are known for their comfort, it's important to note that pillow-top mattresses may not be suitable for everyone. Some people may find them too soft or may experience issues with durability. It's important to do your research and try out different options before making a final decision.

Share this article