The Most Difficult Hit to Get in Baseball: Uncovering the Ultimate Challenge

Choose the hit you think is the most difficult!

Author: Gregor Krambs
Updated on Apr 17, 2024 06:38
Step up to the plate and take a swing at one of the most hotly debated topics in baseball: What is the most difficult hit to get in the game? At StrawPoll, we've curated a comprehensive ranking to settle the score once and for all. Thousands of fans have already cast their votes, but we need your expertise! Will it be the elusive inside-the-park home run, the perfectly placed bunt, or perhaps the legendary grand slam? Or is there a missing option that deserves consideration? Don't be left on the bench – join the action and make your voice heard. Cast your vote now or suggest an addition to our ranking, and together, let's knock this debate out of the park!

What Is the Most Difficult Hit to Get in Baseball?

  1. 1
    61
    votes
    A perfect game is the most difficult hit to achieve in baseball. It requires the pitcher to retire all 27 batters without allowing a hit, walk, or error. Only 23 pitchers have achieved this feat in Major League Baseball history.
    The Perfect Game is an extraordinary achievement in baseball where a pitcher successfully retires all 27 opposing hitters, resulting in no opposing player reaching base throughout the entire game.
    • Number of pitchers: 1
    • Number of innings: 9
    • Number of batters faced: 27
    • Strikeouts: At least 10 (Based on game length)
    • Maximum of 81 pitches: Since 1991
  2. 2
    23
    votes
    Hitting four home runs in a single game is a rare feat that only 18 players have accomplished in MLB history. It requires exceptional power and consistency at the plate.
    Four Home Runs in a Game refers to the impressive feat of a single player hitting four home runs in a single baseball game. This accomplishment is extremely rare and considered one of the most difficult hits to achieve in baseball.
    • Number of players who have accomplished: 18
    • Most recent player to accomplish: J.D. Martinez (September 4, 2017)
    • Most home runs hit in a game by a single player: 4
    • Total number of games played in MLB history: over 220,000
    • Percentage of games in which this feat has been accomplished: less than 0.01%
  3. 3
    31
    votes

    Hitting for the Cycle

    John Reilly
    Hitting for the cycle means getting a single, double, triple, and home run in the same game. It requires a combination of speed, power, and hitting ability. Only 332 players have achieved this feat in MLB history.
    Hitting for the Cycle is a rare feat in baseball where a batter successfully records a single, double, triple, and home run in a single game.
    • Type: Achievement
    • Difficulty: High
    • Occurrences: Approximately 330 in MLB history (as of 2021)
    • First Recorded Cycle: October 6, 1882
    • Record for Most Cycles in a Career: Babe Herman, Bob Meusel and John Reilly (3 each)
  4. 4
    12
    votes
    An unassisted triple play is a rare defensive play where a single fielder records three outs in one play without any assistance from their teammates. It requires quick reflexes, good instincts, and the ability to read the game. Only 15 players have achieved this feat in MLB history.
    The Unassisted Triple Play is a rare and extraordinary baseball play that occurs when a fielder, without the assistance of any other player, records three outs in a single play.
    • Date Created: July 19, 1909
    • Fielding Position: Usually a middle infielder (shortstop or second baseman)
    • Requirements: Bases loaded and no outs
    • Execution: Catching a line drive, stepping on second base to retire the runner from that base, and tagging the runner coming from first base
    • Frequency: Extremely rare, with only 15 occurrences in Major League Baseball history
  5. 5
    17
    votes
    An inside-the-park grand slam occurs when a batter hits a home run without leaving the field of play. It requires a combination of power, speed, and good baserunning instincts. Only a handful of players have achieved this feat in MLB history.
    The inside-the-park grand slam is a rare and exciting play in baseball where a batter hits a home run by running and touching all four bases without the ball leaving the playing field. It is considered one of the most difficult hits to achieve as it requires exceptional speed, awareness, and base running skills.
    • Baserunners: There must be baserunners on all three bases at the time of the hit
    • Timing: The hit must be perfectly placed and have enough power to reach the deep outfield
    • Speed: The batter must possess exceptional speed to outrun the defense and complete the play
    • Fielding Errors: The defense must make mistakes, such as misjudging or mishandling the ball, to create an opportunity for the inside-the-park grand slam
    • Running Mechanics: The batter must take sharp angles and make quick decisions to navigate the bases efficiently
  6. 6
    15
    votes
    Getting five hits in a single game is a challenging feat that requires consistent hitting and good plate discipline. Only a few players have achieved this feat in MLB history.
    In baseball, '5 Hits in a Game' refers to a rare achievement where a player manages to hit safely five times in a single game. It is considered one of the most difficult and impressive feats in baseball.
    • Frequency: Extremely rare, with less than 50 occurrences in MLB history.
    • Skill requirement: Requires exceptional batting skills and consistency.
    • Hits types: The five hits can be any combination of singles, doubles, triples, or home runs.
    • Performance impact: A player achieving 5 Hits in a Game generally has a considerable impact on the team's offensive performance.
    • Significance: It is viewed as an extraordinary achievement and typically receives significant media attention and recognition.
  7. 7
    5
    votes
    Hitting three home runs in a single game is a challenging feat that requires exceptional power and consistency at the plate. Only a few players have achieved this feat multiple times in MLB history.
    Hitting three home runs in a single game, also known as a '3 Home Runs in a Game' feat, is considered one of the most difficult and impressive accomplishments in baseball. It involves a player hitting three home runs in a single game, meaning they hit the ball over the outfield fence and successfully reach all the bases, scoring three runs for their team each time.
    • Difficulty: Considered highly difficult due to the rarity of hitting multiple home runs in a single game.
    • Record: The record for the most '3 Home Runs in a Game' is held by Sammy Sosa, who achieved it twice.
    • Frequency: Since the inception of the Major League Baseball, there have been over 300 instances where a player hit three home runs in a game.
    • Impact on the Game: Hitting three home runs in a game often leads to a significant boost in a team's chances of winning due to the increased scoring.
    • Elite Company: Players who have accomplished this feat are often revered and regarded as some of the game's best power hitters.
  8. 8
    15
    votes
    Getting four hits in a single inning is a rare feat that requires exceptional hitting and good luck. Only a few players have achieved this feat in MLB history.
    The '4 Hits in an Inning' is a rare feat in baseball where a player successfully achieves four hits in a single inning of a game. This requires the player to hit the ball and reach base safely four times consecutively during their team's turn at bat in a single inning.
    • Difficulty Level: Extremely difficult
    • Achievement Frequency: Very rare
    • Required Hits: 4
    • Consecutive Hits: Yes
    • Base Reached: Safe base reached on each hit
  9. 9
    10
    votes
    Getting six hits in a doubleheader requires consistent hitting over two games, which is a challenging feat. Only a few players have achieved this feat in MLB history.
    The '6 Hits in a Doubleheader' is a rare achievement in baseball where a player manages to accumulate six hits in the span of a doubleheader, a day consisting of two consecutive baseball games played by the same teams.
    • Difficulty: Extremely difficult
    • Frequency: Very rare
    • Number of Games: Two
    • Hits Required: Six
    • Batting Order: Player must usually have multiple plate appearances in both games
  10. 10
    7
    votes
    A walk-off grand slam is a rare feat that occurs when a batter hits a home run to end the game with his team winning by four or more runs. It requires a combination of power, timing, and good luck. Only a few players have achieved this feat in MLB history.
    A walk-off grand slam is a rare and exhilarating event in baseball where the batter hits a home run with the bases loaded in the bottom of the final inning, resulting in an immediate victory for the home team.
    • Difficulty: Considered one of the most difficult hits to achieve in baseball.
    • Game-winning: Results in an immediate victory for the home team.
    • Bases loaded: All three base runners are on base when the hit occurs.
    • Home run: The ball is hit over the outfield wall and out of reach of the opposing team.
    • Bottom of the final inning: The hit occurs in the last batting opportunity for the home team.

Missing your favorite hit?

Graphs
Discussion

Ranking factors for difficult hit

  1. Batting skill of the hitter
    A player with a high batting average and good plate discipline is more likely to get a hit than a player who struggles at the plate.
  2. Quality of the pitcher
    Facing a top-tier pitcher with a wide arsenal of pitches and pinpoint accuracy will make it more difficult to get a hit.
  3. Pitch selection and location
    A well-placed pitch, particularly one that is on the edge of the strike zone or has a lot of movement, will be harder to make solid contact with.
  4. Defensive positioning and skill
    An elite defense with players who have excellent range and quick reaction times can significantly reduce the likelihood of a hit.
  5. Ballpark dimensions and conditions
    The size and shape of a ballpark can affect the likelihood of a hit. Larger outfields with deeper fences can make it more difficult to hit a home run, while smaller parks can increase the chances of a fly ball becoming a hit.
  6. Type of hit
    Some types of hits are more difficult to achieve than others. For example, triples require both solid contact and good speed, making them rarer than singles or doubles.
  7. Game situation and pressure
    High-pressure situations, like the late innings of a close game or a crucial at-bat in the playoffs, can make it more difficult for a hitter to get a hit due to increased tension and pressure to perform.
  8. Weather conditions
    Factors like wind, rain, and temperature can affect a hitter's ability to make contact and the trajectory of the ball after it's hit, impacting the likelihood of a hit.
  9. Historical matchups
    Some hitters have difficulty against specific pitchers, and vice versa. Analyzing head-to-head matchups can sometimes provide an indication of how likely a hitter is to get a hit in a particular situation.
  10. Player's health
    If a player is playing through injury or fatigue, it can impact their ability to hit the ball effectively.

About this ranking

This is a community-based ranking of the most difficult hit to get in baseball. We do our best to provide fair voting, but it is not intended to be exhaustive. So if you notice something or hit is missing, feel free to help improve the ranking!

Statistics

  • 1743 views
  • 196 votes
  • 10 ranked items

Voting Rules

A participant may cast an up or down vote for each hit once every 24 hours. The rank of each hit is then calculated from the weighted sum of all up and down votes.

More information on most difficult hit to get in baseball

Baseball is a sport that requires precision, skill, and strategy. One of the most challenging aspects of the game is hitting. While hitting a baseball may seem like a simple task, it is actually one of the most difficult skills to master. In particular, hitting certain types of pitches can prove to be a real challenge for even the most talented players. One of the most difficult hits to get in baseball is the elusive "perfect game" – hitting a home run on every at-bat. This feat has only been achieved a handful of times in the history of the game, making it one of the ultimate challenges for any baseball player. Other difficult hits include the knuckleball, a pitch that is notoriously difficult to predict and hit, and the slider, which can be particularly challenging for left-handed batters. Ultimately, mastering the art of hitting in baseball requires a combination of natural talent, practice, and a deep understanding of the game.

Share this article