The Most Difficult Hole in Golf: A Challenging Encounter

Choose the hole you think is the most difficult!

Author: Gregor Krambs
Jun 16, 2023 10:18 (Updated on Dec 2, 2023 16:49)
Step right up, golf enthusiasts and avid players, and prepare to tee off on a thrilling challenge that will put your knowledge and passion for the game to the ultimate test! Here at StrawPoll, we're hosting a nail-biting ranking of "What is the most difficult hole in golf?" and we need your expert opinions to crown the true king of golfing challenges. Navigate your way through a vast array of golf courses, iconic holes, and mind-boggling obstacles as you vote for your favorite or even suggest a hidden gem that we've missed. Will it be the infamous 17th at Sawgrass or perhaps the treacherous 8th at Pebble Beach? Swing into action, and let's discover together the most formidable hole in golf that can turn even the most seasoned pros into mere amateurs. Cast your votes now and revel in the gripping world of golf's most enigmatic and testing holes!

What Is the Most Difficult Hole in Golf?

  1. 1
    44
    votes
    Known as the "Golden Bell," this par-3 hole is only 155 yards long, but it requires a precise tee shot over Rae's Creek to a narrow, sloping green surrounded by three bunkers. Many golfers have found themselves in the water, resulting in high scores.
    Description
    The Augusta National Golf Club, Hole 12 is a stunning par 3 hole located in Augusta, Georgia. It is famously known as 'Golden Bell' due to the bell-shaped flower that surrounds the green. The hole is situated near Rae's Creek, with a picturesque stone bridge leading to the green.
    • Par: 3
    • Yardage: 155 yards
    • Difficulty: Moderate
    • Hazards: Rae's Creek, bunkers
    • Green Size: 5,600 square feet
    Augusta National Golf Club, Hole 12 in other rankings
  2. 2
    27
    votes
    The infamous "Island Green" is a par-3 hole that measures only 137 yards, but it requires a tee shot over water to a small green surrounded by bunkers. The wind can also make club selection difficult.
    Description
    The TPC Sawgrass, Hole 17, also known as the 'Island Green', is one of the most iconic and challenging holes in golf. It is located at the TPC Sawgrass Stadium Course in Ponte Vedra Beach, Florida. The hole is renowned for its unique design and the level of difficulty it poses to golfers.
    • Location: TPC Sawgrass Stadium Course, Ponte Vedra Beach, Florida
    • Par: 3
    • Yardage: 137 yards
    • Surrounding: Water hazard
    • Green Shape: Island
    TPC Sawgrass, Hole 17 in other rankings
  3. 3
    33
    votes
    This par-4 hole measures 427 yards and requires a tee shot over the ocean to a narrow fairway. The approach shot is uphill to a small, undulating green.
    Description
    Pebble Beach Golf Links, Hole 8 is a challenging par-4 hole known as 'The Cliffs'. It is situated atop a rocky outcrop with stunning panoramic views of the Pacific Ocean. This hole was designed by Jack Neville and Douglas Grant, and it has garnered a reputation as one of the most difficult holes in golf.
    • Par: 4
    • Yardage: 416 yards
    • Difficulty: Difficult
    • Location: Pebble Beach, California
    • Terrain: Rolling fairway with elevated greens
  4. 4
    12
    votes
    This par-4 hole measures 483 yards and requires a tee shot to a narrow fairway with a bunker on the right side. The approach shot is uphill to a small green surrounded by bunkers.
    Description
    Pinehurst No. 2, Hole 5 is widely regarded as one of the most challenging holes in golf due to its strategic design and demanding features. It requires precise shot placement and strategic decision-making.
    • Par: 4
    • Yardage: 481 yards
    • Fairway: Narrow and undulating
    • Green: Small and well-protected
    • Bunkers: 10 strategically placed
  5. 5
    19
    votes
    This par-4 hole measures 428 yards and requires a tee shot to a narrow fairway with bunkers on both sides. The approach shot is uphill to a heavily bunkered green that slopes from back to front.
    Description
    Oakmont Country Club, Hole 3 is renowned as one of the most challenging holes in golf. It is a par 4 hole that demands accuracy and strategic shot placement throughout. The hole features numerous hazards and unforgiving rough, making it a real test for even the most skilled golfers.
    • Par: 4
    • Yardage: 426 yards
    • Fairway Width: 26 yards
    • Bunkers: 7
    • Green Size: 5,500 square feet
    Oakmont Country Club, Hole 3 in other rankings
  6. 6
    11
    votes

    St. Andrews, Hole 17

    Old Tom Morris
    Known as the "Road Hole," this par-4 hole measures 495 yards and requires a tee shot over the corner of the Old Course Hotel to a narrow fairway with a bunker on the left side. The approach shot is downhill to a green with a bunker in front and the road behind.
    Description
    St. Andrews, Hole 17 is a renowned and challenging hole located at the Old Course in St. Andrews, Scotland. It is known for its strategic layout and unpredictable winds that test even the most skilled golfers. The hole is situated near the coastline, adding an additional level of difficulty due to the ever-changing coastal winds. It requires precision and careful decision-making from tee to green.
    • Location: St. Andrews, Scotland
    • Course: Old Course
    • Hole Number: 17
    • Par: 4
    • Yardage: 455 yards
  7. 7
    4
    votes
    This par-4 hole measures 444 yards and requires a tee shot to a narrow fairway with bunkers on both sides. The approach shot is uphill to a green with severe undulations that make putting difficult.
    Description
    Shinnecock Hills Golf Club, Hole 14 is considered one of the most difficult holes in golf. It is a par 4 hole located at Shinnecock Hills Golf Club in Southampton, New York.
    • Par: 4
    • Yardage: 501 yards
    • Handicap: 1
    • Fairway: Narrow, sloping right-to-left
    • Greens: Small and undulating
    Shinnecock Hills Golf Club, Hole 14 in other rankings
  8. 8
    8
    votes

    Royal Melbourne Golf Club, Hole 12

    Dr. Alister MacKenzie
    This par-5 hole measures 515 yards and requires a tee shot to a narrow fairway with bunkers on both sides. The approach shot is uphill to a green protected by bunkers and a steep slope.
    Description
    The Royal Melbourne Golf Club, Hole 12, is considered one of the most challenging and iconic holes in golf. It is a par 3 hole that poses a number of obstacles to players.
    • Length: 155 yards
    • Par: 3
    • Difficulty Level: Very Difficult
    • Design Style: Strategic and Challenging
    • Fairway: Narrow with strategically placed bunkers
  9. 9
    11
    votes
    This par-4 hole measures 499 yards and requires a tee shot to a narrow fairway with bunkers on both sides. The approach shot is downhill to a green with bunkers and water hazards on both sides.
    Description
    The Carnoustie Golf Links, Hole 18 is a renowned and challenging golf hole known as 'Home' or 'Tom Morris' at Carnoustie Golf Course. It is a par-4 hole located in Carnoustie, Scotland, and is famous for its difficulty and significant role in major championships.
    • Length: 499 yards
    • Par: 4
    • Bunkers: 5
    • Fairway: Narrow and undulating
    • Out of bounds: Present on the left and right side
  10. 10
    0
    votes
    This par-4 hole measures 502 yards and requires a tee shot to a narrow fairway with bunkers on both sides. The approach shot is uphill to a green with severe undulations that make putting difficult.
    Description
    The Winged Foot Golf Club, Hole 10 is considered one of the most difficult holes in golf. It is a par 4 hole that demands accuracy and strategy from golfers. The hole is known for its challenging tee shot and the heavily guarded green.
    • Par: 4
    • Yardage: 495 yards
    • Hole Handicap: 1
    • Tee Shot: Narrow fairway with bunkers on both sides
    • Green: Severely sloped and well-guarded by bunkers

Missing your favorite hole?

Graphs
Discussion

Ranking factors for difficult hole

  1. Length
    The distance from the tee to the hole significantly impacts the difficulty level. Longer holes require more shots and often cover more obstacles, increasing the chance for increased scores.
  2. Fairway width
    Narrower fairways make it more challenging for golfers to hit the ball accurately and avoid landing in hazards like thick rough, bunkers, and water.
  3. Hazards
    The number and placement of hazards, such as water, bunkers, and trees, play a significant role in a hole's difficulty. Holes with a high number of strategically placed hazards force golfers to execute precise shots and use more course management.
  4. Green complexity
    The shape, size, and undulation of the greens affect putting difficulty. Small or undulating greens require more accurate approach shots and can lead to increased three-putts.
  5. Wind conditions
    Golf holes that are exposed to strong and unpredictable winds can drastically impact shot accuracy and distance control, making them more difficult.
  6. Elevation changes
    Holes with significant elevation changes between the tee and the green, or on the green itself, can make accurate club selection and shot execution more challenging.
  7. Doglegs
    Holes with sharp bends in the fairway force golfers to shape their shots, adding complexity and difficulty to the hole.
  8. Risk-reward factor
    Some holes offer different routes or aggressive lines that present a significant risk of finding a hazard but also reward successful execution with a lower score. The difficulty of these holes stems from the decision-making process and the balance between risk and reward.
  9. Playing conditions
    Weather conditions, like rain or dry fairways, and course setup, such as pin placements, can also dramatically affect a hole's difficulty on any given day.
  10. Historical scoring average
    A hole's difficulty can be somewhat determined by its historical scoring average. High scoring averages indicate that the hole is challenging for many golfers.

About this ranking

This is a community-based ranking of the most difficult hole in golf. We do our best to provide fair voting, but it is not intended to be exhaustive. So if you notice something or hole is missing, feel free to help improve the ranking!

Statistics

  • 1687 views
  • 169 votes
  • 10 ranked items

Voting Rules

A participant may cast an up or down vote for each hole once every 24 hours. The rank of each hole is then calculated from the weighted sum of all up and down votes.

More information on most difficult hole in golf

Golf is a sport that requires precision and patience, and every golfer knows that some holes on the course are more challenging than others. The most difficult hole in golf can vary depending on the course, but typically it's the one that requires the most skill, strategy, and concentration to navigate successfully. Golfers often dread these holes, but they also relish the challenge of conquering them. From narrow fairways and deep bunkers to tricky water hazards and undulating greens, the most difficult holes in golf test even the most seasoned players. So, what is the most difficult hole in golf? Let's explore some of the most notorious contenders and find out.

Share this article