The Most Difficult Joint Replacement Procedure: Ranking the Challenging Surgery

Choose the joint replacement procedure you think is the most difficult!

Author: Gregor Krambs
Updated on Apr 16, 2024 06:38
Welcome to StrawPoll, where your opinion matters! We're excited to present our latest ranking, "What is the most difficult joint replacement procedure?" Joint replacement surgeries are complex medical interventions, and we're eager to know which one you think is the most challenging for surgeons and patients alike. From hip replacements to knee, shoulder, and even ankle procedures, we've got it all covered. Cast your vote for the toughest joint replacement surgery, and if you think we've missed out on any, feel free to suggest your own! Join thousands of others who have participated in our polls and rankings on various topics, and let's explore the intriguing world of joint replacements together. Don't wait any longer; dive into the discussion now and make your voice heard!

What Is the Most Difficult Joint Replacement Procedure?

  1. 1
    67
    votes
    TAR is considered one of the most difficult joint replacement procedures due to the complex anatomy and biomechanics of the ankle joint. The procedure involves replacing the damaged ankle joint with an artificial joint, which requires precise positioning and alignment to ensure proper function.
    Total ankle replacement (TAR) is a surgical procedure that involves replacing a damaged ankle joint with an artificial implant. This procedure is recommended for patients with severe ankle arthritis or other chronic conditions that cause significant pain and impairment. Unlike ankle fusion surgery, which permanently eliminates joint motion, TAR aims to restore function and allow for more natural movement of the ankle.
    • Material: Various materials, including cobalt chromium, titanium, and polyethylene
    • Design: Different designs available, such as three-component, two-component, or mobile-bearing designs
    • Surgical approach: Can be performed through a traditional open surgery or minimally invasive techniques
    • Prosthesis fixation: May use cemented or uncemented fixation methods
    • Weight-bearing capacity: Allows patients to gradually return to weight-bearing activities
  2. 2
    23
    votes
    This procedure is used to treat severe rotator cuff tears, shoulder arthritis, and other conditions that cause shoulder pain and limited mobility. The surgery involves reversing the position of the shoulder joint, which requires a high level of technical skill and precision.
    Reverse shoulder replacement is a complex surgical procedure that involves reversing the positions of the ball and socket in the shoulder joint. Unlike traditional shoulder replacements, where a prosthetic ball is attached to the upper end of the humerus and a socket is attached to the scapula, reverse shoulder replacement uses a prosthetic socket in place of the ball and a prosthetic ball in place of the socket. This allows the deltoid muscle, rather than the damaged rotator cuff, to become the primary muscle responsible for shoulder movement. The procedure is commonly performed in cases of significant rotator cuff tears or shoulder arthritis where a traditional replacement would not be effective.
    • First performed: 1985
    • Primary use: Treatment of massive rotator cuff tears or shoulder arthritis
    • Prosthesis design: Socket and ball positions are reversed
    • Ball size: Variable, based on patient anatomy
    • Socket design: Deep and concave, to accommodate the reversed ball
  3. 3
    31
    votes

    Bilateral hip replacement

    Sir John Charnley
    This procedure involves replacing both hip joints at the same time, which can be challenging due to the potential for complications such as blood loss, infection, and nerve damage.
    Bilateral hip replacement is a surgical procedure where both hip joints are replaced with artificial implants. It is commonly performed to alleviate pain and improve function in patients with severe hip degeneration or advanced arthritis in both hips.
    • Procedure Type: Surgical
    • Surgical Approach: Anterior, Posterior or Lateral
    • Anesthesia: General or Regional
    • Incision Size: Medium to large
    • Operative Time: Approximately 2-3 hours
  4. 4
    23
    votes

    Total knee replacement

    Sir John Charnley
    This surgery involves replacing the entire knee joint with an artificial joint, which requires precise placement and alignment to ensure proper function and stability. Complications can include blood loss, infection, and nerve damage.
    Total knee replacement, also known as total knee arthroplasty, is a surgical procedure to replace a damaged or worn-out knee joint with an artificial implant. It involves removing the damaged cartilage and bone from the surfaces of the knee joint and replacing them with metal and plastic components.
    • Procedure type: Surgical
    • Purpose: To replace a damaged knee joint
    • Components: Metal and plastic
    • Implant lifespan: 10-20 years on average
    • Recovery time: 4-6 weeks
    Total knee replacement in other rankings
  5. 5
    22
    votes

    Total shoulder replacement

    Dr. Charles S. Neer II
    This procedure involves replacing the damaged shoulder joint with an artificial joint, which can be challenging due to the complex anatomy and biomechanics of the shoulder joint. Complications can include nerve damage, infection, and implant failure.
    Total shoulder replacement, also known as total shoulder arthroplasty, is a surgical procedure that involves replacing the damaged or diseased shoulder joint with a prosthetic implant. It is primarily performed to relieve severe pain and improve joint functionality in patients with conditions such as arthritis, fractures, or rotator cuff tears.
    • Implant Material: The prosthetic components are typically made of metal (such as titanium or cobalt-chromium) and plastic (polyethylene).
    • Prosthesis Design: The implant consists of a metal ball attached to the upper arm bone (humerus) and a plastic socket secured to the shoulder blade (scapula).
    • Glenoid Component Fixation: The plastic socket is usually fixed in place using cement or press-fit techniques.
    • Humeral Component Fixation: The metal ball is fixed onto the humerus bone either with cement or by using a press-fit technique.
    • Prosthesis Types: There are various types of total shoulder replacement implants, including anatomical (standard), reverse, and partial.
  6. 6
    10
    votes

    Elbow replacement

    Sir Peter L. Kennaugh
    This surgery involves replacing the damaged elbow joint with an artificial joint, which can be challenging due to the limited space and complex anatomy of the joint. Complications can include nerve damage, infection, and implant failure.
    Elbow replacement is a surgical procedure that involves removing a damaged or diseased elbow joint and replacing it with an artificial joint. It is mainly performed to relieve pain and restore function in patients with severe arthritis, traumatic injuries, or other elbow conditions that cannot be effectively treated by non-surgical methods.
    • Material: The artificial joint is typically made of metal alloys, such as cobalt-chromium or titanium.
    • Components: Elbow replacement consists of three main components: humeral (upper arm bone) component, ulnar (forearm bone) component, and a plastic spacer placed between them.
    • Stabilization: The artificial joint is designed to mimic the natural elbow joint, providing stability during movement.
    • Range of motion: The goal is to restore a functional range of motion, including flexion (bending), extension (straightening), pronation (palm-down rotation), and supination (palm-up rotation).
    • Surgical approach: Elbow replacement can be performed using an open surgical approach or minimally invasive techniques.
  7. 7
    11
    votes

    Wrist replacement

    Dr. Robert W. Beasley
    This procedure involves replacing the damaged wrist joint with an artificial joint, which can be challenging due to the small size and complex anatomy of the joint. Complications can include nerve damage, infection, and implant failure.
    Wrist replacement is a surgical procedure that involves replacing the damaged or painful wrist joint with an artificial joint. It is typically performed to alleviate severe arthritis, trauma, or other conditions affecting the wrist joint. The wrist replacement procedure aims to restore joint function, reduce pain, and improve the overall quality of life for patients.
    • Material: Metal and plastic components
    • Types of wrist replacement: Partial or total wrist replacement
    • Implant fixation: Cemented or press-fit
    • Range of motion: Allows flexion, extension, supination, and pronation
    • Number of components: Usually consists of two components - one for the radius and one for the carpus
  8. 8
    10
    votes
    This surgery involves replacing the damaged finger joint with an artificial joint, which can be challenging due to the small size and intricate anatomy of the joint. Complications can include nerve damage, infection, and implant failure.
  9. 9
    6
    votes
    This procedure involves fusing the ankle joint together to create a stable, immobile joint. It is considered difficult due to the complex anatomy and biomechanics of the ankle joint, and the potential for complications such as nerve damage and infection.
    Total ankle fusion, also known as ankle arthrodesis, is a surgical procedure to treat severe ankle arthritis by permanently fusing the bones of the ankle joint. This procedure eliminates the movement in the ankle joint, reducing pain and improving stability.
    • Primary purpose: To reduce pain and increase stability in severe ankle arthritis cases.
    • Procedure type: Surgical fusion of the tibia, fibula, and talus bones of the ankle joint.
    • Ankle range of motion: Eliminated, as the joint is fused and immobilized.
    • Implant usage: In some cases, metallic plates, screws, or rods may be used to support the fusion.
    • Recovery time: Varies, typically 8-12 weeks for initial bone fusion, followed by a rehabilitation period.
  10. 10
    4
    votes

    Sacroiliac joint fusion

    Dr. Mark Reiley
    This surgery involves fusing the sacrum and ilium bones together to stabilize the sacroiliac joint. It is considered challenging due to the complex anatomy of the joint and the potential for complications such as nerve damage and infection.
    Sacroiliac joint fusion is a surgical procedure performed to alleviate chronic lower back pain caused by dysfunction or degeneration of the sacroiliac joint. The sacroiliac joint is located between the sacrum (the triangular bone at the base of the spine) and the ilium (the large, fan-shaped bone of the pelvis). The procedure involves fusing the sacrum and the ilium to create a solid joint, eliminating the movement that causes pain.
    • Procedure type: Surgical
    • Purpose: Relieve chronic lower back pain
    • Joint involved: Sacroiliac joint
    • Bones involved: Sacrum and ilium
    • Fusion method: Creating a solid joint between sacrum and ilium

Missing your favorite joint replacement procedure?

Graphs
Discussion

Ranking factors for difficult joint replacement procedure

  1. Complexity of the joint anatomy
    Certain joints have more intricate structures, which can make the replacement procedure more difficult. This includes the articulating surfaces, ligaments, tendons, and muscles surrounding the joint.
  2. Technical challenges
    Some joint replacement procedures may require more advanced surgical techniques or specialized instruments and implants. This can increase the duration and complexity of the surgery.
  3. Infection risk
    The risk of infection varies depending on the joint being replaced and the patient's overall health. Infections can lead to complications and even failure of the joint replacement, requiring further surgical intervention.
  4. Rehabilitation process
    The length and intensity of the post-surgery rehabilitation process varies depending on the joint replaced. Some joints may require a longer recovery period and more intensive physical therapy, which can increase the overall difficulty of the procedure.
  5. Patient factors
    The patient's age, overall health, weight, and medical history can impact the success of a joint replacement procedure. A more difficult procedure may be required for patients with certain health conditions or risk factors.
  6. Revision surgery
    In cases where a previous joint replacement has failed or worn out over time, a revision surgery may be necessary. Revision surgeries are generally more challenging than primary joint replacement procedures, due to factors such as scar tissue, bone loss, and altered anatomy.
  7. Surgeon's experience
    Joint replacement procedures can have varying levels of difficulty depending on the surgeon's experience and familiarity with the specific joint and approach.
  8. Prosthesis longevity
    The lifespan of joint replacement prostheses can vary based on the specific joint and materials used. Certain joints may require more frequent replacements or revisions, increasing the overall challenge of the procedure.

About this ranking

This is a community-based ranking of the most difficult joint replacement procedure. We do our best to provide fair voting, but it is not intended to be exhaustive. So if you notice something or procedure is missing, feel free to help improve the ranking!

Statistics

  • 1802 views
  • 207 votes
  • 10 ranked items

Voting Rules

A participant may cast an up or down vote for each procedure once every 24 hours. The rank of each procedure is then calculated from the weighted sum of all up and down votes.

Categories

Trendings topics

Don't miss out on the currently trending topics of StrawPoll Rankings!

More information on most difficult joint replacement procedure

Joint replacement surgery is a common procedure performed on millions of people every year. It involves the removal of a damaged joint and replacing it with a prosthetic one. While joint replacement surgery is generally safe and effective, some procedures are considered more difficult than others. Factors such as the location and complexity of the joint, the age and overall health of the patient, and the experience and skill of the surgeon can all play a role in determining the difficulty of the procedure. In this article, we will explore some of the most challenging joint replacement surgeries, and what makes them so complex.

Share this article