The Most Popular Andrew Lloyd Webber Musical: A Ranking of the Beloved Productions

Choose the musical you think is the most popular!

Author: Gregor Krambs
Updated on Apr 15, 2024 06:47
Step into the world of musical magic and cast your vote in the grand ranking of the most popular Andrew Lloyd Webber musicals! Here at StrawPoll, we're hosting the ultimate showdown featuring the spellbinding works of the legendary composer – from the enchanting realms of "The Phantom of the Opera" to the roaring feline fiesta of "Cats." Thousands of fans have already joined the chorus, and now it's your turn to make your voice heard. Will your favorite musical claim the top spot? Or perhaps you'd like to suggest a hidden gem that deserves the limelight? Dive into this melodious extravaganza, and together, let's celebrate the genius of Andrew Lloyd Webber. The stage is set, the curtains are drawn – it's time to cast your vote and let the show begin!

What Is the Most Popular Andrew Lloyd Webber Musical?

  1. 1

    The Phantom of the Opera

    Andrew Lloyd Webber
    This is arguably Andrew Lloyd Webber's most popular musical, with its haunting music and dramatic storyline. It has been running for over 30 years in London's West End and remains one of the most successful musicals of all time.
    The Phantom of the Opera is a musical that tells the story of a mysterious masked figure who haunts the Paris Opera House. He becomes infatuated with a young soprano singer, Christine, and becomes her mentor and teacher. As their relationship develops, the Phantom's obsession grows, leading to love, jealousy, and tragedy.
    • Genre: Musical
    • Premiere: October 9, 1986
    • Setting: Paris Opera House, France
    • Based on: Le Fantôme de l'Opéra by Gaston Leroux
    • Music: Andrew Lloyd Webber
    The Phantom of the Opera in other rankings
  2. 2
    This musical is based on T.S. Eliot's "Old Possum's Book of Practical Cats" and features iconic songs like "Memory." It was also recently adapted into a movie in 2019.
    Cats are a domesticated animal known for their independent and mysterious nature. They are small, carnivorous mammals that are often kept as pets for their companionship and grace. Cats have been domesticated for thousands of years and have a long history of association with humans.
    • Species: Felis catus
    • Average Lifespan: 13-17 years
    • Size: Small to medium
    • Weight: 5-15 pounds
    • Coat: Varies greatly, from short to long, and various colors and patterns
  3. 3
    This rock opera tells the story of the last week of Jesus' life and has become a classic since its debut in 1970. It features popular songs like "I Don't Know How to Love Him" and "Superstar."
    Jesus Christ Superstar is a rock opera that tells the story of the last week of Jesus's life through the perspective of Judas Iscariot. It explores themes of love, betrayal, and the conflict between Jesus and Judas. The musical features catchy rock and pop music composed by Andrew Lloyd Webber and thought-provoking lyrics written by Tim Rice. Jesus Christ Superstar has gained a cult following since its debut in 1970 and remains one of Andrew Lloyd Webber's most iconic works.
    • Genre: Rock opera
    • Premiere Date: October 12, 1970
    • Setting: Jerusalem, during the last week of Jesus's life
    • Main Characters: Jesus, Judas, Mary Magdalene, Pontius Pilate
    • Musical Style: Rock, pop
    Jesus Christ Superstar in other rankings
  4. 4
    This musical tells the story of Argentine political leader Eva Perón and features songs like "Don't Cry for Me Argentina."
    Evita is a popular musical written by Andrew Lloyd Webber. It depicts the life of Argentine political leader Eva Perón, from her humble beginnings to becoming the First Lady of Argentina. The musical explores themes of ambition, power, and the cult of personality, showcasing Eva's rise to prominence and her controversial legacy.
    • Year of Premiere: 1978
    • Genre: Musical Drama
    • Setting: Argentina
    • Based on: The life of Eva Perón
    • Main Characters: Eva Perón, Che Guevara, Juan Perón
  5. 5
    This musical is based on the story of Joseph from the Bible and features upbeat songs with a variety of musical styles.
    Joseph and the Amazing Technicolor Dreamcoat is a musical based on the biblical story of Joseph from the Book of Genesis. It is a light-hearted and family-friendly production that combines various musical styles, including pop, rock, and country.
    • Premiere Date: March 1, 1968
    • Running Time: Approximately 2 hours
    • Number of Songs: Over 20 songs
    • Main Characters: Joseph, Jacob, Potiphar, Pharaoh
    • Setting: Various locations including Canaan and Egypt
    Joseph and the Amazing Technicolor Dreamcoat in other rankings
  6. 6

    Sunset Boulevard

    Andrew Lloyd Webber
    This musical is based on the classic film of the same name and tells the story of faded star Norma Desmond. It features the memorable song "As If We Never Said Goodbye."
    Sunset Boulevard is a musical created by Andrew Lloyd Webber, based on the 1950 film of the same name. The story revolves around Norma Desmond, a faded silent movie star, and her relationship with a struggling young screenwriter, Joe Gillis. Set in the glamorous and dark world of Hollywood, the musical explores themes of obsession, fame, and the cruel reality of the entertainment industry.
    • Premiere Date: July 12, 1993
    • Genre: Musical Drama
    • Setting: Hollywood, 1950s
    • Based on: Sunset Boulevard (1950 film)
    • Book: Don Black and Christopher Hampton
    Sunset Boulevard in other rankings
  7. 7

    Love Never Dies

    Andrew Lloyd Webber
    This sequel to The Phantom of the Opera continues the story of the Phantom and his love for Christine. Though it received mixed reviews, it still has a dedicated fanbase.
    Love Never Dies is a musical written by Andrew Lloyd Webber, which serves as a sequel to his hit musical The Phantom of the Opera. The story takes place ten years after the events of the original musical and follows the Phantom, who has escaped from Paris to start a new life in Coney Island. There, he reunites with his love interest, Christine Daaé, who is now a famous opera singer.
    • Genre: Musical Drama
    • Premiere: March 9, 2010
    • Setting: Coney Island, New York
    • Characters: Phantom, Christine Daaé, Raoul, Meg Giry, Madame Giry
    • Music: Andrew Lloyd Webber
    Love Never Dies in other rankings
  8. 8
    Starlight Express
    CHR!S · CC BY-SA 3.0

    Starlight Express

    Andrew Lloyd Webber
    This musical is unique in that it is performed entirely on roller skates. It tells the story of a group of trains competing in a race and features upbeat songs like "Rolling Stock."
    Starlight Express is a popular musical created by Andrew Lloyd Webber. Set in a world where toy trains come to life, the story revolves around a young steam engine named Rusty who dreams of becoming the fastest engine in the world and winning the championship race. With a blend of rock, pop, and disco music, the show takes the audience on a thrilling journey filled with dazzling roller-skating performances.
    • Genre: Musical
    • Premiere Date: 1984
    • Setting: Toy train world
    • Music: Andrew Lloyd Webber
    • Lyrics: Richard Stilgoe
    Starlight Express in other rankings
  9. 9

    Song and Dance

    Andrew Lloyd Webber
    This musical is split into two acts - the first featuring a one-woman show and the second a ballet. It features the popular song "Tell Me on a Sunday."
    Song and Dance is a musical that combines two distinct acts to tell a heartfelt story. Act one, titled 'Tell Me on a Sunday,' follows the journey of an English girl named Emma as she moves to New York City in search of love and success. Act two, titled 'Variations,' showcases a lone male dancer expressing his emotions through movement. The two acts are connected thematically and explore themes of love, loneliness, and self-discovery.
    • Premiere Date: 1979
    • Genre: Musical
    • Music: Andrew Lloyd Webber
    • Lyrics: Don Black (Tell Me on a Sunday) and Richard Maltby Jr. (Variations)
    • Book: Andrew Lloyd Webber and Don Black
  10. 10

    The Beautiful Game

    Andrew Lloyd Webber
    This musical tells the story of a group of young people in Northern Ireland during the Troubles. It features a score with a mix of rock and traditional Irish music.
    The Beautiful Game is a musical by Andrew Lloyd Webber that explores a story set in Belfast, Northern Ireland, during the late 1960s. The plot revolves around a group of teenagers who are involved in a local football (soccer) team and their struggles with love, friendship, and the political conflict between Catholics and Protestants.
    • Premiere Date: September 2000
    • Setting: Belfast, Northern Ireland
    • Genre: Musical
    • Themes: Love, friendship, political conflict
    • Music by: Andrew Lloyd Webber

Missing your favorite musical?


Ranking factors for popular musical

  1. Box office success
    How much revenue the musical has generated through ticket sales, both initially and over time, including domestic and international performances.
  2. Critical acclaim
    The reviews and ratings received by the musical from critics, as well as any major awards won, such as Tony Awards, Olivier Awards, and others.
  3. Popularity of the music
    The chart performance and sales of the soundtrack or cast album, as well as the recognition and popularity of individual songs from the musical.
  4. Longevity and number of productions
    The length of time the musical has run in theaters, as well as the number of different productions, including regional, touring, and international productions.
  5. Cultural impact
    The extent to which the musical has permeated popular culture, including references in other forms of media, such as television, films, and books.
  6. Fan following
    The size and dedication of the musical's fan base, as evidenced by social media presence, fan websites, and fan-created content, such as art, videos, and fan fiction.
  7. Innovativeness
    The extent to which the musical pushed boundaries in terms of storytelling, music, staging, or other elements of theatrical production.
  8. Artistic quality
    The overall quality and consistency of the music, lyrics, book, and production elements, as well as the performances by the actors.
  9. Influence on the industry
    The impact the musical had on the development of musical theater, either by inspiring other creators or by setting new trends in the industry.

About this ranking

This is a community-based ranking of the most popular Andrew Lloyd Webber musical. We do our best to provide fair voting, but it is not intended to be exhaustive. So if you notice something or musical is missing, feel free to help improve the ranking!


  • 150 votes
  • 10 ranked items

Voting Rules

A participant may cast an up or down vote for each musical once every 24 hours. The rank of each musical is then calculated from the weighted sum of all up and down votes.

More information on most popular andrew lloyd webber musical

Andrew Lloyd Webber is a renowned musical composer whose work has captivated audiences around the world. With his extensive catalog of musical productions, it's no surprise that many fans have their own opinions about which is his most popular. From his early hits like "Jesus Christ Superstar" and "Evita" to more recent productions like "Love Never Dies" and "School of Rock," Webber's musicals have become a staple of the theater world. Whether you're a die-hard fan or simply curious about his work, exploring the most popular Andrew Lloyd Webber musicals is a journey worth taking.

Share this article