The Most Popular Elf on the Shelf: Ranking the Beloved Holiday Tradition

Choose the Elf you think is the most popular!

Author: Gregor Krambs
Updated on Feb 22, 2024 06:03
Welcome to StrawPoll's latest ranking - "What is the most popular Elf on the Shelf?"! We know the holiday season is incomplete without these mischievous little elves, and we're excited to see which one tops the chart as the ultimate fan favorite. With thousands of Elf on the Shelf variations to choose from, we've compiled a list of the most delightful, creative, and entertaining elves for you to vote on. But don't worry if your favorite elf is missing - you can suggest an option and see it climb the ranks! So grab a cup of hot cocoa, settle in, and join us in this jolly journey to discover the ultimate Elf on the Shelf that has captured hearts and imaginations all around the world. Cast your vote and share the festive fun with friends and family!

What Is the Most Popular Elf on the Shelf?

  1. 1
    34
    votes
    This is the original and most common Elf on the Shelf toy that started the trend. It's a popular choice for families who want to add a touch of magic to their holiday traditions.
    The Elf on the Shelf Boy is a popular holiday toy and tradition. It consists of a small, plush elf doll dressed in a red and white outfit. The doll is intended to be placed in various locations around the house every night leading up to Christmas, with the idea that it watches over the children and reports back to Santa Claus on their behavior.
    • Size: Approximately 10 inches
    • Material: Plush fabric
    • Outfit: Red and white clothing with elf hat
    • Accessories: Book containing Elf on the Shelf story
    • Recommended Age: 3 years and up
  2. 2
    19
    votes
    Another popular choice, this version of the toy features a female elf with a red skirt and a matching bow.
    The Elf on the Shelf Girl is a popular version of the Elf on the Shelf doll. It is designed to encourage good behavior in children during the Christmas season. The girl elf is a smaller figurine with a cheerful expression and rosy cheeks, dressed in a red and white striped elf outfit, and comes with a storybook. The doll is meant to be placed in different locations each day in the home, serving as Santa's scout to report back on the child's behavior to ensure they stay on the nice list.
    • Age Range: 3 years and up
    • Dimensions: 11 inches x 3 inches x 3 inches
    • Material: Plush fabric
    • Included Accessories: Storybook, keepsake box
    • Clothing: Red and white striped elf outfit
  3. 3
    30
    votes

    Elf on the Shelf Pets

    The Elf on the Shelf
    These adorable pets can be added to the Elf on the Shelf tradition to give kids even more fun and excitement during the holiday season.
    Elf on the Shelf Pets is an extension of the beloved Elf on the Shelf tradition, where children adopt a friendly scout elf that helps Santa Claus manage his naughty and nice lists during the holiday season. The Elf on the Shelf Pets introduces a pet component to the tradition, allowing children to adopt a miniature plush pet and include it in their Christmas-themed adventures.
    • Available pets: Various options including puppies, kittens, reindeer, and polar bears.
    • Miniature plush size: Approximately 5 to 6 inches tall.
    • Pet accessories: Includes special pet-sized accessories like beds, food bowls, and collars.
    • Poseable limbs: Allows the pets to be positioned and placed in imaginative scenes.
    • Interactive storytelling: Children can create unique stories and scenarios involving the scout elf and their adopted pet.
  4. 4
    4
    votes

    Elf on the Shelf Reindeer

    Chanda A. Bell
    This cute reindeer toy is a great way to add some holiday cheer to your Elf on the Shelf tradition. Kids will love seeing their elf buddy ride around on the back of this animal.
    The Elf on the Shelf Reindeer is a special companion to the popular Elf on the Shelf tradition. It is a plush reindeer toy that children can adopt and name, just like their Elf. The Reindeer serves as a magical guide for Santa's sleigh, assisting in the delivery of gifts during the holiday season.
    • Size: Approximately 9 inches tall
    • Material: Soft, high-quality plush
    • Color: Brown and white with fluffy antlers
    • Accessories: Comes with a red and white harness and a golden heart-shaped charm
    • Name: Can be given a personalized name by the child
  5. 5
    6
    votes
    This version of the toy is designed to be used for birthday celebrations. It's a great way to keep the Elf on the Shelf tradition going all year round.
    The Elf on the Shelf Birthday Tradition is an extension of the original Elf on the Shelf tradition that celebrates the birthdays of children. It brings the same magic and excitement to children's birthdays with the help of a special birthday-themed elf.
    • Concept: The Elf on the Shelf Birthday Tradition is based on the original Elf on the Shelf concept, where the elf is a scout sent by Santa to monitor children's behavior.
    • Birthday Elf: A special birthday-themed elf is introduced to help celebrate the child's birthday.
    • Arrival and Departure: Similar to the original tradition, the Birthday Elf arrives before the child's birthday and leaves after the celebration.
    • Birthday Countdown: The Birthday Elf helps create excitement by counting down the days leading up to the child's birthday.
    • Daily Surprises: Just like the original tradition, the Birthday Elf surprises the child daily with small treats, notes, or activities to make the birthday celebration more memorable.
  6. 6
    15
    votes
    This musical version of the toy is perfect for families who love to sing and dance during the holidays. It features a cute elf who sings and dances to classic holiday tunes.
    The Elf on the Shelf Musical is a live stage production based on the popular Elf on the Shelf book and toy franchise. It brings to life the magical story of Santa's scout elves who visit homes during the Christmas season.
    • Genre: Musical
    • Target Audience: Families
    • Duration: Approximately 90 minutes
    • Original Release: 2018
    • Story: Focuses on the adventures of the scout elves and their important role in monitoring children's behavior during the holidays
  7. 7
    8
    votes
    This collection features a variety of outfits and accessories for your Elf on the Shelf toy. Kids will love dressing up their elf in different holiday-themed outfits.
    The Elf on the Shelf Claus Couture Collection is a clothing line specifically designed for the beloved Christmas tradition of Elf on the Shelf. This collection allows families to dress up their Elf in a variety of festive outfits, enhancing the magical atmosphere during the holiday season.
    • 1: Designed for Elf on the Shelf
    • 2: Consists of a range of clothing options
    • 3: Festive and themed outfits available
    • 4: Allows customization of the Elf's appearance
    • 5: Provides additional fun and excitement to the Elf on the Shelf tradition
  8. 8
    4
    votes

    Elf on the Shelf Scout Elves at Play

    The Elf on the Shelf, LLC.
    This book and toy set features a variety of fun ideas and activities for your Elf on the Shelf toy. It's a great way to keep the tradition fresh and exciting year after year.
    The Elf on the Shelf Scout Elves at Play is a creative accessory set designed to enhance the experience of the popular Elf on the Shelf tradition. It allows children to engage in imaginative play with their Scout Elf, bringing the magic to life.
    • Recommended Age: 3 years and up
    • Includes: pop-out easel, inflatable chair, mini pennant, mirror, yarn, Christmas light string, book of elf-size cards and scout elf-sized message board
    • Materials: Durable plastic, cardboard, and fabric
    • Dimensions: Easel: 9.5 inches wide, 10 inches tall; Inflatable chair: 6.5 inches wide, 4.5 inches tall; Mini pennant: 3.5 inches wide, 6.75 inches tall
    • Weight: Approximately 1 pound
  9. 9
    4
    votes

    Elf on the Shelf Letters to Santa

    The Elf on the Shelf company
    This kit includes everything kids need to write their own letters to Santa, including special paper, envelopes, stickers, and of course, their Elf on the Shelf toy.
    Elf on the Shelf Letters to Santa is a special edition of the popular Elf on the Shelf toy that encourages children to write letters to Santa Claus. It provides a fun and interactive way for kids to express their holiday wishes and communicate directly with Santa. The set includes customizable letters, envelopes, and stickers for the children to personalize their messages. The letters can then be placed in the included miniature mailbox, which adds to the excitement of the activity. The Elf on the Shelf Letters to Santa offers a magical experience that captures the spirit of Christmas and enhances the imagination of children.
    • Toy type: Interactive holiday toy
    • Recommended age range: 3 years and up
    • Included items: Customizable letters, envelopes, stickers, miniature mailbox
    • Purpose: Encourages children to write letters to Santa Claus
    • Promotes: Imagination and creativity
  10. 10
    4
    votes
    This fun advent calendar features a different Elf on the Shelf activity for every day leading up to Christmas. It's a great way to count down the days and keep the holiday spirit alive.
    The Elf on the Shelf Advent Calendar is a holiday-themed calendar that helps families count down to Christmas with the iconic Elf on the Shelf character. Each day leading up to Christmas, children can open a door or a pocket on the calendar to reveal a surprise or a mini activity from the Elf on the Shelf world.
    • Theme: Christmas
    • Format: Calendar with doors or pockets
    • Characters: Elf on the Shelf
    • Surprises: Mini activities or surprises
    • Countdown: 25 days

Missing your favorite Elf?

Graphs
Discussion

Ranking factors for popular Elf

  1. Design and appearance
    The overall look of the Elf on the Shelf, including its clothing, facial expression, and the quality of its craftsmanship. Unique or special edition designs may increase the elf's popularity.
  2. Posability and functionality
    How easy it is to manipulate and pose the Elf on the Shelf in various settings. Its functionality in performing its intended purpose of watching over the home and reporting back to Santa Claus.
  3. Accessories and accompanying items
    The availability of additional items that enhance the Elf on the Shelf experience, such as clothing, props, and books.
  4. Online and social media presence
    The popularity of the Elf on the Shelf on social media platforms, as well as its official website, including user-generated content featuring creative ideas, photos, and stories.
  5. User ratings and reviews
    High ratings and positive reviews from customers who have purchased and used the Elf on the Shelf, providing insight into its overall quality, appearance, and value.
  6. Sales and market dominance
    The Elf on the Shelf's position in the market, in terms of total sales, along with its overall popularity compared to competing holiday toys or decorations.
  7. Tradition and cultural impact
    The significance of the Elf on the Shelf in contemporary holiday traditions and its impact on popular culture, including its adaptation into movies, television specials, and other forms of media.
  8. Brand loyalty and awareness
    The familiarity of the Elf on the Shelf brand and the loyalty of its customer base, who may be more likely to purchase additional products or recommend the Elf on the Shelf to friends and family.
  9. Price
    The affordability and value of the Elf on the Shelf, compared to other similar options, which may influence its overall popularity among consumers.
  10. Availability and accessibility
    The ease of purchasing the Elf on the Shelf, including its availability in popular brick-and-mortar stores and online retailers.

About this ranking

This is a community-based ranking of the most popular Elf on the Shelf. We do our best to provide fair voting, but it is not intended to be exhaustive. So if you notice something or Elf is missing, feel free to help improve the ranking!

Statistics

  • 1022 views
  • 128 votes
  • 10 ranked items

Voting Rules

A participant may cast an up or down vote for each Elf once every 24 hours. The rank of each Elf is then calculated from the weighted sum of all up and down votes.

More information on most popular elf on the shelf

The Elf on the Shelf has become an increasingly popular Christmas tradition in households around the world. This beloved holiday elf is known for watching over children and reporting back to Santa on their behavior each night. Originally created as a children's book in 2005, the Elf on the Shelf has since become a household name with countless variations and styles available for purchase. With so many options to choose from, it can be difficult to determine which version of the Elf on the Shelf is the most popular. However, with the help of StrawPoll's community of voters, we can uncover which Elf on the Shelf is beloved by the masses.

Share this article