The Most Popular Etsy Shop: Ranking the Trendiest Online Marketplace

Choose the shop you think is the most popular!

Author: Gregor Krambs
Updated on Apr 20, 2024 07:04
Welcome to StrawPoll, your ultimate destination for discovering the most popular Etsy shops! With thousands of talented artisans and unique creations, it can be tough to decide which Etsy shops truly stand out from the crowd. That's where our latest ranking comes into play! We've curated a list of the top contenders, and now it's up to you, the people, to vote for your favorite or even suggest an undiscovered gem. Will it be a shop specializing in personalized gifts, handcrafted jewelry, or one-of-a-kind home decor? The power is in your hands! So, come on in, explore our ranking of "What is the most popular Etsy shop?" and cast your vote to help crown the ultimate fan-favorite Etsy shop!

What Is the Most Popular Etsy Shop?

  1. 1

    The Velvet Acorn

    Heidi May
    This shop specializes in handmade knitwear and has over 250,000 sales on Etsy. Their designs are unique and trendy, making them a favorite among fashion-forward buyers.
    The Velvet Acorn is a highly popular Etsy shop known for its unique and cozy knitwear designs. The shop is run by Heidi May, a talented designer and creator of beautiful handmade pieces. With a focus on comfort, style, and quality, The Velvet Acorn offers a range of knitted items for adults and children alike.
    • Product Types: Sweaters, cardigans, hats, scarves, mittens, blankets, and more
    • Materials: High-quality yarn such as merino wool and acrylic blends
    • Sizes: Various sizes available for adults, babies, toddlers, and children
    • Colors: An extensive range of color options to suit different preferences
    • Styles: Modern, rustic, and bohemian-inspired designs
    The Velvet Acorn in other rankings
  2. 2
    ModParty specializes in party decorations and has over 400,000 sales on Etsy. Their products are affordable, customizable, and perfect for any occasion.
    ModParty is a popular Etsy shop specializing in unique and stylish party decorations and supplies. From trendy banners to eye-catching balloon garlands, ModParty offers a wide range of products that will make any celebration unforgettable. The shop's distinctive designs and attention to detail have gained it a loyal customer base and numerous positive reviews.
    • Product Range: Party decorations and supplies
    • Design Style: Unique and stylish
    • Popular Products: Banners, balloon garlands
    • Customer Rating: 5 stars
    • Positive Reviews: Over 5000
  3. 3
    This shop sells handmade wooden signs and has over 200,000 sales on Etsy. Their signs are personalized, rustic, and make great gifts.
    BlueShedCrafts is a highly popular Etsy shop known for its handmade and unique crafts. Each piece is carefully created with attention to detail, making them perfect for home decor or gifts. From handcrafted ceramics to intricately designed jewelry, BlueShedCrafts offers a wide range of products to suit different tastes and preferences.
    • Location: New York, USA
    • Established: 2012
    • Product Categories: Home Decor, Jewelry, Ceramics, Accessories
    • Materials Used: Ceramic, Metal, Wood, Gemstones, Glass, Paper
    • Average Rating: 4.9 out of 5 stars
  4. 4
    This shop sells custom rhinestone t-shirts and has over 100,000 sales on Etsy. Their designs are fun, sparkly, and perfect for special events or gifts.
    BlingeeThingee is a highly popular Etsy shop specializing in custom-made and unique blinged-out accessories. Each piece is meticulously handcrafted to bring a touch of sparkle and glamour to any outfit or occasion. From sparkling phone cases to dazzling jewelry, BlingeeThingee offers a wide range of options for anyone looking to add a bit of bling to their life.
    • Products Offered: Phone cases, jewelry, keychains, hair accessories
    • Materials Used: High-quality crystals, rhinestones, pearls, and beads
    • Customization Options: Offers custom designs and personalization
    • Variety of Styles: Modern, vintage, bohemian, and more
    • Price Range: $10 - $100
  5. 5

    The Citrus Grove

    Jane Summers
    This shop specializes in personalized stationery and has over 200,000 sales on Etsy. Their products are high-quality, beautiful, and perfect for weddings or special events.
    The Citrus Grove is a vibrant and lively Etsy shop that specializes in handmade citrus-themed home decor and accessories. Each item is carefully crafted with exquisite attention to detail, bringing the refreshing and invigorating essence of citrus fruits into your living space. From zesty lemon-shaped pillows to beautifully hand-painted orange-inspired wall art, The Citrus Grove offers a diverse range of products that are sure to brighten up any room. With their dedication to quality craftsmanship and a passion for all things citrus, The Citrus Grove brings the vibrant colors and uplifting scent of citrus fruits into your everyday life.
    • Product Range: Home decor and accessories
    • Theme: Citrus fruits
    • Handmade: Yes
    • Attention to Detail: Exquisite
    • Product Variety: Diverse
  6. 6
    This shop sells handmade baby clothes and accessories and has over 150,000 sales on Etsy. Their designs are adorable, well-made, and perfect for any new parent.
    LittleLlamaShoppe is a vibrant and creative Etsy shop specializing in handmade accessories and home decor. With a playful and whimsical style, each item is meticulously crafted with attention to detail and quality materials, making them perfect for adding a touch of charm to any space. From cute llama-themed keychains and plush toys to colorful wall hangings and decorative pillows, LittleLlamaShoppe offers a variety of products that are sure to delight customers of all ages.
    • Theme: Llama-inspired
    • Product Range: Accessories and home decor
    • Style: Vibrant and whimsical
    • Crafting Method: Handmade with attention to detail
    • Materials: High-quality materials
  7. 7

    The Paper Peony

    Sarah Thompson
    This shop specializes in paper flowers and has over 100,000 sales on Etsy. Their flowers are beautiful, realistic, and perfect for weddings or home decor.
    The Paper Peony is a renowned Etsy shop that specializes in exquisite paper flower creations. Each item is meticulously handcrafted with attention to detail and artistic flair. The shop offers a wide range of paper flower arrangements and decor pieces that are perfect for weddings, events, or adding a touch of beauty to any space.
    • Year Established: 2012
    • Location: San Francisco, California
    • Number of Sales: 10,000+
    • Average Customer Rating: 5 out of 5 stars
    • Featured in: Martha Stewart Weddings, Elle Magazine
  8. 8

    The Purple Door

    Emily Jones
    This shop sells handmade jewelry and has over 150,000 sales on Etsy. Their designs are unique, beautiful, and perfect for any occasion.
    The Purple Door is a highly popular Etsy shop that offers a wide range of handmade crafts and home decor items. Each piece is meticulously crafted with attention to detail, ensuring exceptional quality and uniqueness. The shop features a variety of products, including personalized signs, farmhouse style decor, custom ornaments, and rustic home accessories. With a focus on rustic elegance, The Purple Door provides customers with an opportunity to add a touch of charm and personality to their homes or gift something special to their loved ones.
    • Location: Los Angeles, California
    • Established: 2012
    • Average Rating: 4.9/5
    • Number of Sales: 10,000+
    • Product Categories: Handmade signs, Home decor, Ornaments
  9. 9

    Lauren Lash Designs

    Lauren Smith
    This shop specializes in personalized gifts and has over 100,000 sales on Etsy. Their products are high-quality, customizable, and perfect for any occasion.
    Lauren Lash Designs is a highly popular Etsy shop specializing in unique and beautifully handcrafted jewelry pieces. Created by Lauren Smith, a talented artisan with a passion for creating intricate and one-of-a-kind designs, this shop attracts customers looking for elegant accessories to elevate their style. With attention to detail and a focus on quality, Lauren Lash Designs offers a wide range of jewelry items that cater to various tastes and preferences.
    • Type: Handcrafted jewelry
    • Specialization: Unique designs
    • Creator's Name: Lauren Smith
    • Focus: Attention to detail and quality
    • Product Range: Wide selection of jewelry items
  10. 10
    This shop sells custom pet portraits and has over 50,000 sales on Etsy. Their portraits are beautiful, realistic, and make great gifts for pet owners.
    CatAtelier is a popular Etsy shop that specializes in handmade cat-themed accessories and home decor. The shop offers a variety of unique items, all designed to celebrate the love for cats. From cute cat-shaped keychains and enamel pins to cozy cat beds and whimsical wall art, CatAtelier has something for every cat lover. The shop's creator, Olivia Andrews, is a talented artist and cat enthusiast who pours her passion for feline companions into every creation. With attention to detail and high-quality materials, CatAtelier has gained a loyal following of customers who appreciate the charm and craftsmanship of each piece.
    • Product Range: Accessories and home decor
    • Category: Handmade
    • Theme: Cat-themed
    • Items Available: Keychains, enamel pins, cat beds, wall art, and more
    • Quality: High-quality materials and attention to detail

Missing your favorite shop?


Ranking factors for popular shop

  1. Number of sales
    The total number of sales made by the shop is an important indicator of popularity. A higher number of sales suggests that the shop has a strong customer base and is consistently offering products that customers want to buy.
  2. Reviews and ratings
    Customer reviews and ratings can provide insight into customer satisfaction with the shop's products and service. A shop with many positive reviews and high ratings is likely to be more popular than one with few reviews or poor ratings.
  3. Shop age
    The length of time a shop has been in business can be a factor in its popularity. A shop that has been around for years and continues to maintain a strong customer base is likely doing something right.
  4. Product variety
    A shop with a diverse range of products may cater to a broader audience and attract more customers, ultimately increasing its popularity among Etsy users.
  5. Unique and personalized items
    Shops that offer unique, one-of-a-kind, or customizable products may be more popular among Etsy users who are looking for something different than what they can find in a traditional brick-and-mortar store.
  6. Pricing
    Competitive pricing can be a major factor in a shop's popularity. Customers are more likely to purchase from shops that offer fair and reasonable prices for their products.
  7. Social media presence
    A strong social media presence can help boost a shop's popularity by increasing its visibility and reach. Shops with many followers, likes, and engagement on platforms like Instagram, Facebook, and Pinterest are likely to be more popular among Etsy users.
  8. Frequent updates and new offerings
    Shops that regularly update their inventory with new products and designs may attract more customers and maintain a strong base of loyal shoppers.
  9. Branding and shop appearance
    A shop with professional branding and a visually appealing storefront can make a positive impression on potential customers and contribute to its popularity.
  10. Customer service
    A shop that provides excellent customer service, responds promptly to inquiries and handles orders efficiently, is likely to build a positive reputation and attract more customers.

About this ranking

This is a community-based ranking of the most popular Etsy shop. We do our best to provide fair voting, but it is not intended to be exhaustive. So if you notice something or Store is missing, feel free to help improve the ranking!


  • 179 votes
  • 10 ranked items

Voting Rules

A participant may cast an up or down vote for each Store once every 24 hours. The rank of each Store is then calculated from the weighted sum of all up and down votes.

More information on most popular etsy shop

Etsy has become a go-to destination for those looking for unique and handmade items. With over 4 million active sellers and 60 million items for sale, it's no wonder that Etsy has become a massive online marketplace for creative entrepreneurs. Among the many shops on Etsy, there are some that stand out as the most popular. These shops have gained a loyal following due to their high-quality products, exceptional customer service, and one-of-a-kind designs. In this article, we'll take a closer look at some of the most popular Etsy shops and what makes them so special. So, whether you're looking for handmade jewelry, vintage clothing, or unique home decor, we've got you covered.

Share this article