The Most Popular Eyebrow Pencil: Revealing the Top Contenders

Choose the eyebrow pencil you think is the most popular!

Author: Gregor Krambs
Updated on Feb 12, 2024 06:04
Discover the ultimate eyebrow game-changer with StrawPoll's exclusive ranking of the most popular eyebrow pencils! Thousands of makeup enthusiasts have cast their votes and the battle for the perfect brow is fiercer than ever. Whether you're a beginner or a brow connoisseur, we've got you covered with top-rated favorites and hidden gems that will have your arches looking on point. Can't find your go-to pencil on the list? No problem! Join the conversation by suggesting a missing option and help crown the true brow champion. So, what are you waiting for? Dive into the world of brow-wow and explore the definitive ranking of the best eyebrow pencils on the market. Your perfect brow match awaits!

What Is the Most Popular Eyebrow Pencil?

  1. 1
    64
    votes
    This is a cult favorite and has been a go-to for many makeup artists and beauty enthusiasts. It has a fine tip that allows for precise application and is available in a range of shades.
    The Anastasia Beverly Hills Brow Wiz is a highly acclaimed eyebrow pencil that is beloved by beauty enthusiasts worldwide. It is designed to effortlessly define, shape, and fill in eyebrows, giving them a natural and polished appearance. The Brow Wiz is known for its ultra-fine tip, allowing for precise application and the creation of hair-like strokes. With its long-wearing and smudge-proof formula, this pencil ensures that your perfect brows stay in place all day. Available in a range of shades, the Brow Wiz caters to different hair colors and tones, enabling everyone to find their ideal match. Whether you desire a soft, subtle, or bold look, this pencil is versatile enough to achieve your desired results. The spoolie brush on the other end helps to groom and blend the product for a seamless finish.
    • Tip Size: Ultra-fine
    • Formula: Long-wearing, smudge-proof
    • Shade Range: Multiple shades available
    • Application: Defines, shapes, and fills in eyebrows
    • Finish: Natural and polished
    Anastasia Beverly Hills Brow Wiz in other rankings
  2. 2
    30
    votes
    Another popular option, this pencil has a similar fine tip and comes in a range of shades. It also has a spoolie brush on the other end to blend and groom the brows.
    The Benefit Cosmetics Precisely, My Brow Pencil is a highly popular eyebrow pencil known for its precise application and natural-looking results. It is designed to create hair-like strokes to mimic the appearance of real brows. The pencil has a fine tip that allows for precise application and control, giving you the ability to create sharp, defined brows. The formula is long-lasting and smudge-proof, ensuring that your brows stay in place throughout the day. It also comes with a spoolie brush on the other end to blend and groom the brows for a polished finish.
    • Tip Size: Ultra-fine
    • Formula: Long-lasting and smudge-proof
    • Finish: Natural-looking
    • Application: Hair-like strokes
    • Control: Precise
  3. 3
    18
    votes
    This is a drugstore favorite and provides a budget-friendly option for those looking for a good brow pencil. It has a triangular tip for easy filling and shaping.
    The Maybelline New York Brow Define + Fill Duo is a highly popular eyebrow pencil that offers a convenient 2-in-1 solution for perfectly defined and filled brows. It is designed to effortlessly shape, define, and fill in eyebrows, giving them a natural and polished look.
    • 2-in-1 Design: Combines a precise pencil and a filling powder in one product
    • Precision Pencil: Features an ultra-precise pencil tip for accurate and defined application
    • Filling Powder: Contains a soft powder to fill in sparse areas and create a full brow look
    • Blendable Formula: Allows for easy blending and customizing the intensity of the color
    • Long-lasting: Provides all-day wear and stays put without smudging or fading
  4. 4
    25
    votes
    NYX is known for its affordable yet high-quality products, and this brow pencil is no exception. It has a thin tip for precise application and comes in a range of shades.
    The NYX Professional Makeup Micro Brow Pencil is a widely popular eyebrow pencil that helps you achieve perfectly defined brows. It has a micro-sized tip for precise application and mimicking the look of natural brow hairs. The formula is long-lasting and smudge-proof, ensuring your brows stay in place all day. Available in a range of shades, it allows you to find the perfect match for your hair color and skin tone.
    • Tip Size: Micro-sized
    • Application: Precise
    • Formula: Long-lasting, smudge-proof
    • Shades: Multiple
    • Hair Color Match: Yes
    NYX Professional Makeup Micro Brow Pencil in other rankings
  5. 5
    19
    votes
    This drugstore option also has a fine tip for precise application, and the spoolie brush on the other end helps blend and groom the brows. It comes in a variety of shades to match different hair colors.
    The L'Oreal Paris Brow Stylist Definer is a highly-rated and popular eyebrow pencil designed to help you achieve precise and defined brows. It features an ultra-fine tip that allows for effortlessly filling and shaping of eyebrows. The smooth and creamy formula glides on easily, providing a natural-looking finish. The pencil also comes with a spoolie brush for blending and taming unruly hairs. Whether you desire a natural or bold brow look, the L'Oreal Paris Brow Stylist Definer is a versatile tool that caters to all preferences.
    • Type: Mechanical eyebrow pencil
    • Tip: Ultra-fine tip for precision
    • Formula: Smooth and creamy
    • Finish: Natural-looking
    • Brush: Includes spoolie brush
    L'Oreal Paris Brow Stylist Definer in other rankings
  6. 6
    16
    votes
    This pencil is waterproof and designed to last all day. It has a fine tip for precise application and comes in a range of shades.
    The Tarte Cosmetics Amazonian Clay Waterproof Brow Pencil is a highly sought-after eyebrow pencil that provides long-lasting, natural-looking brows. It is designed to fill in sparse areas and shape the brows with precision.
    • Waterproof: Yes
    • Clay-infused formula: Yes
    • Long-lasting: Up to 12 hours
    • Natural-looking: Yes
    • Precision application: Yes
  7. 7
    9
    votes
    This pencil has a matte finish and a triangular tip for easy filling and shaping. It also has a spoolie brush on the other end to blend and groom the brows.
    The Smashbox Cosmetics Brow Tech Matte Pencil is a highly popular eyebrow pencil that is designed to help you achieve perfectly defined and natural-looking brows. It features a matte finish for a more subtle and soft eyebrow look.
    • Product Type: Eyebrow Pencil
    • Finish: Matte
    • Application: Easy and precise
    • Long-lasting: Yes
    • Waterproof: No
  8. 8
    7
    votes
    This affordable option is a fan favorite among beauty influencers. It has a fine tip for precise application and comes in a range of shades.
    The ColourPop Cosmetics Brow Boss Pencil is a highly popular eyebrow pencil that helps you achieve perfectly defined and filled-in brows effortlessly. It is designed with a precise tip and a creamy formula for smooth application and easy blending. Whether you prefer a natural or bold look, this pencil offers buildable color that lasts all day without smudging or fading.
    • Shade Range: Available in various shades to match different hair colors
    • Tip Type: Fine-point pencil tip for precise application
    • Formula: Creamy texture that glides on smoothly
    • Pigmentation: Intense color payoff
    • Longevity: Long-wearing, smudge-proof, and fade-resistant
  9. 9
    3
    votes

    Charlotte Tilbury Brow Lift

    Charlotte Tilbury
    This pencil has a unique shape that allows for easy filling and shaping. It also has a highlighter on the other end to accentuate the brow bone.
    The Charlotte Tilbury Brow Lift is a highly popular eyebrow pencil that is designed to define, shape, and fill in eyebrows with ease. It creates natural-looking brows that are perfectly sculpted and groomed to enhance the overall facial features.
    • Shade Range: Available in 5 shades to match different hair colors
    • Formula: Waterproof and smudge-proof
    • Application: Dual-ended with a pencil and brush for precise application and blending
    • Texture: Smooth and creamy for effortless application
    • Long-lasting: Stays put all day without fading or transferring
  10. 10
    6
    votes
    This pencil has a fine tip for precise application and comes in a range of shades. It is also formulated with vitamin E to nourish the brows.
    The Kevyn Aucoin Precision Brow Pencil is a highly popular eyebrow pencil designed to create precise and natural-looking brows. With its ultra-fine tip and long-wearing formula, it allows for easy and precise application, helping you to achieve beautifully defined brows that last all day.
    • Tip Type: Ultra-fine
    • Longevity: Long-wearing
    • Application: Easy and precise
    • Finish: Natural
    • Lasting Power: All day

Missing your favorite eyebrow pencil?

Graphs
Discussion

Ranking factors for popular eyebrow pencil

  1. Pigmentation
    The color payoff and intensity of the eyebrow pencil should be adequate and easy to build upon. It should match the user's eyebrow color or complement their hair color for a natural look.
  2. Texture
    The eyebrow pencil should have a smooth and creamy texture for easy application without tugging or pulling on the skin.
  3. Longevity
    The eyebrow pencil should have good staying power and be resistant to smudging, fading, or melting throughout the day, even in hot or humid conditions.
  4. Precision
    The pencil tip should be thin and fine enough for creating precise hair-like strokes and defining the shape of the eyebrows.
  5. Blendability
    The eyebrow pencil should be easily blendable to create a soft, natural, and seamless finish.
  6. Ease of use
    The pencil should be easy to hold, maneuver, and apply, especially for those who may be new to makeup or have limited experience with eyebrow products.
  7. Packaging
    The packaging should be practical, sturdy, and convenient to use, ideally including a spoolie brush or comb for grooming and blending the product.
  8. Price
    The eyebrow pencil should be reasonably priced, offering a good balance between quality and affordability.
  9. Brand reputation
    The manufacturer of the eyebrow pencil should have a good reputation for producing high-quality and effective cosmetic products.
  10. Reviews and recommendations
    The eyebrow pencil should have a large number of positive reviews from users and endorsements from beauty experts or influencers.

About this ranking

This is a community-based ranking of the most popular eyebrow pencil. We do our best to provide fair voting, but it is not intended to be exhaustive. So if you notice something or pencil is missing, feel free to help improve the ranking!

Statistics

  • 1673 views
  • 197 votes
  • 10 ranked items

Voting Rules

A participant may cast an up or down vote for each pencil once every 24 hours. The rank of each pencil is then calculated from the weighted sum of all up and down votes.

Categories

More information on most popular eyebrow pencil

Eyebrow pencils have become a staple in many people's beauty routines, helping to shape and define eyebrows for a polished look. With so many options on the market, it can be overwhelming to choose the right one. From powders to gels to pencils, there are various types of eyebrow products available. However, eyebrow pencils remain one of the most popular choices due to their ease of use and precision. Whether you're looking for a natural or bold look, there's an eyebrow pencil out there for everyone. In this article, we'll explore the most popular eyebrow pencils on the market and help you find the perfect one for your needs.

Share this article