The Most Popular Hotel in New York City: A Top-Ranked Accommodation Choice

Choose the hotel you think is the most popular!

Author: Gregor Krambs
Updated on Apr 15, 2024 07:14
Discover the heart of the Big Apple by voting for your favorite sanctuary in the bustling city of New York! StrawPoll is thrilled to present our latest ranking: "What is the most popular hotel in New York City?". We've compiled a list of the most luxurious, charming, and iconic hotels that define the city's skyline and make every stay an unforgettable experience. But it's up to you, the traveler and the enthusiast, to determine which hotel truly stands out as the pinnacle of New York City hospitality. Cast your vote and make your voice heard, or suggest a hidden gem that deserves to be on our prestigious list. Dive into this exciting ranking and indulge in the glamour, history, and allure of New York City's finest hotels. Your next memorable adventure is just a click away!

What Is the Most Popular Hotel in New York City?

  1. 1
    57
    votes
    The Plaza Hotel
    Yarl · CC BY-SA 3.0

    The Plaza Hotel

    Henry J. Hardenbergh
    This iconic hotel has been featured in numerous films and TV shows and is located in the heart of Manhattan. It is known for its luxurious accommodations, impeccable service, and historic charm.
    The Plaza Hotel is an iconic luxury hotel located in the heart of New York City. It is renowned for its timeless elegance, exceptional service, and prime location on Fifth Avenue overlooking Central Park. With its rich history and opulent decor, The Plaza Hotel has been a symbol of luxury and grandeur since its opening in 1907.
    • Location: Fifth Avenue, Central Park South, Manhattan, New York City
    • Architect: Henry J. Hardenbergh
    • Completed: 1907
    • Height: 250 feet (76 meters)
    • Rooms: 282 guest rooms, including suites
  2. 2
    29
    votes

    The Waldorf Astoria

    William Waldorf Astor
    Another historic hotel with a prime location, the Waldorf Astoria has been a favorite of celebrities and dignitaries for over a century. It boasts elegant rooms, world-class dining, and a renowned spa.
    The Waldorf Astoria is a legendary luxury hotel located in New York City. It has a rich history, elegant architecture, and impeccable service, making it one of the most iconic and prestigious hotels in the world. The hotel offers stunning views of the city skyline and is renowned for its opulent interiors, upscale amenities, and world-class dining options. With its prime location on Park Avenue, the Waldorf Astoria has been a preferred destination for celebrities, world leaders, and discerning travelers since its opening in 1931.
    • Location: Park Avenue, New York City
    • Year Built: 1931
    • Architect: Schultze & Weaver
    • Number of Rooms: 1,413
    • Restaurants: 5
  3. 3
    13
    votes

    The Mandarin Oriental

    Mandarin Oriental Hotel Group
    This sleek and modern hotel offers stunning views of Central Park and the city skyline. It features a world-class spa, gourmet restaurants, and luxurious accommodations.
    The Mandarin Oriental is a luxury hotel located in the iconic Time Warner Center in New York City. This five-star hotel offers stunning views of the Manhattan skyline and Central Park, providing guests with a unique experience in the heart of the bustling city. With its elegant design, world-class amenities, and impeccable service, the Mandarin Oriental is a favorite choice among discerning travelers.
    • Location: Time Warner Center, New York City
    • Star Rating: 5 stars
    • Views: Manhattan skyline and Central Park
    • Design: Elegant
    • Amenities: World-class
  4. 4
    15
    votes
    The Four Seasons Hotel New York
    Jim.henderson · CC0
    Located in Midtown Manhattan, the Four Seasons offers spacious rooms, a top-rated restaurant, and a full-service spa. It is known for its impeccable service and attention to detail.
    The Four Seasons Hotel New York is a luxurious five-star hotel located in the heart of Manhattan, providing guests with exceptional service, stunning views, and top-notch amenities. This iconic hotel offers a sophisticated and elegant atmosphere, setting the standard for luxury accommodations in the city.
    • Location: 57 E 57th St, New York, NY 10022, United States
    • Number of Rooms: 368
    • Rating: 5 stars
    • Restaurants: 2
    • Spa: Yes
  5. 5
    15
    votes
    With a prime location overlooking Central Park, the Ritz-Carlton offers elegant accommodations, a renowned restaurant, and a luxurious spa. It is known for its impeccable service and attention to detail.
    The Ritz-Carlton New York, Central Park is a luxurious hotel located in the heart of Manhattan, offering breathtaking views of Central Park. It is renowned for its exceptional service, elegant decor, and world-class amenities.
    • Location: Central Park South, Manhattan, New York City
    • Rooms: 336
    • Suites: 59
    • Restaurants: 2
    • Spa: Yes
  6. 6
    6
    votes

    The St. Regis New York

    John Jacob Astor IV
    This iconic hotel boasts a prime location on Fifth Avenue and offers luxurious accommodations, world-class dining, and a renowned spa. It is known for its historic charm and impeccable service.
    The St. Regis New York is an iconic luxury hotel located in the heart of New York City. It is renowned for its timeless elegance and exceptional service, making it a top choice for discerning travelers.
    • Year Established: 1904
    • Location: Fifth Avenue, Manhattan, New York City
    • Number of Rooms: 238
    • Signature Suite: The Presidential Suite
    • Dining Options: 3 restaurants and 2 lounges
  7. 7
    6
    votes

    The Peninsula New York

    Architect H.L. Steven
    Located in Midtown Manhattan, the Peninsula offers sleek and modern accommodations, a rooftop bar with stunning views, and a renowned spa. It is known for its attention to detail and impeccable service.
    The Peninsula New York is a luxurious and iconic hotel located in the heart of Manhattan, offering unparalleled comfort and unparalleled service. With its sophisticated design, world-class amenities, and breathtaking views, it has become one of the most sought-after destinations for visitors to the city.
    • Location: 5th Avenue, Manhattan
    • Number of Rooms: 235
    • Room Types: Superior, Deluxe, Grand Luxe, Suites
    • Dining Options: Clement Restaurant, Gotham Lounge, Salon de Ning Rooftop Bar
    • Spa and Fitness Center: Yes
  8. 8
    5
    votes
    The Langham, New York
    Godsfriendchuck · CC BY-SA 4.0

    The Langham, New York

    The Langham Hospitality Group
    This luxurious hotel offers spacious and stylish accommodations, a renowned restaurant, and a full-service spa. It is known for its impeccable service and attention to detail.
    The Langham, New York is a luxurious hotel located in the heart of Manhattan, offering elegant accommodations and exceptional service. It embodies modern sophistication and timeless elegance, making it one of the most sought-after destinations in New York City.
    • Location: Fifth Avenue, New York City
    • Rooms: 234 spacious guestrooms and suites
    • Dining: On-site Michelin-star restaurant, Ai Fiori
    • Amenities: Spa, fitness center, swimming pool
    • Event Spaces: Grand ballroom and various meeting rooms
  9. 9
    8
    votes

    The Baccarat Hotel & Residences

    Starwood Capital Group
    This modern and stylish hotel offers luxurious accommodations, a renowned restaurant, and a full-service spa. It is known for its sleek design and attention to detail.
    The Baccarat Hotel & Residences is a luxurious and highly sought-after hotel located in the heart of New York City. Inspired by the elegance and glamour of the Baccarat crystal brand, this hotel offers a sophisticated and opulent experience for its guests. With its stunning architecture, refined interiors, and impeccable service, it has become a symbol of luxury in the city.
    • Swimming pool: Yes
    • Location: Midtown Manhattan
    • Number of rooms: 114
    • Number of residences: 60
    • Restaurants: 2
  10. 10
    4
    votes
    The Carlyle, A Rosewood Hotel
    Jim.henderson · CC0

    The Carlyle, A Rosewood Hotel

    Noel and John Lyle
    This iconic hotel has been a favorite of celebrities and dignitaries for over 80 years. It offers elegant accommodations, a renowned jazz club, and a luxurious spa. It is known for its historic charm and impeccable service.
    The Carlyle, A Rosewood Hotel is a luxurious and iconic hotel located on the Upper East Side of Manhattan in New York City. It was built in 1930 and offers classic elegance with modern amenities. The hotel has been a favorite among world leaders, celebrities, and distinguished guests for decades.
    • Location: Upper East Side, Manhattan
    • Year Built: 1930
    • Hotel Rooms: 189
    • Suites: 64
    • Restaurants: 3

Missing your favorite hotel?

Graphs
Discussion

Ranking factors for popular hotel

  1. Location
    The hotel's proximity to popular attractions, business centers, public transportation, shopping, dining, and entertainment options is crucial for ranking its popularity.
  2. Guest reviews and ratings
    The overall satisfaction of previous guests plays a significant role in a hotel's reputation. Reading trustworthy online reviews and ratings, such as on TripAdvisor, Google, and Yelp, can give a sense of the hotel's strengths and weaknesses.
  3. Amenities
    The availability and quality of on-site facilities and services, such as a fitness center, spa, pool, complimentary Wi-Fi, business center, concierge, and parking, can significantly impact the hotel's popularity.
  4. Room quality and comfort
    The cleanliness, size, decor, and comfort of the rooms all contribute to a hotel's ranking. Additionally, crucial factors like comfortable beds, modern bathrooms, and in-room amenities (such as a coffee maker, mini-fridge, and television) are essential for a pleasant stay.
  5. Value for money
    The price point of the hotel, compared to competing properties in the area with similar amenities and services, is a key factor for many travelers. Although affordability varies depending on the guest's budget, the general perception of pricing in comparison to what the hotel offers can significantly influence its rank.
  6. Customer service
    Attentive, friendly, and professional staff can elevate the guest experience and contribute to the overall popularity of a hotel. Hotels with excellent customer service tend to generate more positive word-of-mouth and repeat business.
  7. Dining options
    On-site restaurants, cafes, and bars can draw in both guests and non-guests alike. The quality, variety, and atmosphere of these dining venues can contribute to a hotel's ranking.
  8. Unique features or experiences
    Hotels that offer unique experiences, such as stunning views, signature spa treatments, or innovative technology, will stand out among competitors and gain popularity with travelers.
  9. Awards and recognition
    Hotels that receive prestigious awards or are regularly featured in travel publications can gain visibility and credibility, leading to increased popularity.
  10. Brand reputation
    The reputation of the hotel's parent brand can also impact its popularity. Travelers may be more inclined to choose a well-known hotel brand with a reputation for consistent quality and service.

About this ranking

This is a community-based ranking of the most popular hotel in New York City. We do our best to provide fair voting, but it is not intended to be exhaustive. So if you notice something or hotel is missing, feel free to help improve the ranking!

Statistics

  • 1095 views
  • 158 votes
  • 10 ranked items

Voting Rules

A participant may cast an up or down vote for each hotel once every 24 hours. The rank of each hotel is then calculated from the weighted sum of all up and down votes.

Categories

More information on most popular hotel in new york city

New York City is one of the most visited cities in the world, attracting millions of visitors every year. With so many options for accommodations, it can be overwhelming to choose the right hotel for your stay. That's why we conducted a poll to find out what the most popular hotel in New York City is. From luxury hotels in Times Square to boutique hotels in Brooklyn, the options are endless. Read on to learn more about the top contenders and see if your favorite hotel made the list.

Share this article