The Most Popular Mafia Game: Ranking the Ultimate Fan-Favorite

Choose the game you think is the most popular!

Author: Gregor Krambs
Updated on Mar 4, 2024 06:17
Welcome to StrawPoll, where your opinions matter! Today, we invite you to dive into the thrilling underworld of Mafia games and help us crown the ultimate kingpin. We're on a quest to discover the most popular Mafia game of all time, and we need your help to sort through the vast, intriguing array of mobster adventures. Whether you're a seasoned crime lord or a rookie capo, your vote will help shape the definitive ranking of Mafia games. Will the intricate storylines of Mafia III capture your heart, or does the classic charm of Mafia: The City of Lost Heaven reign supreme? Perhaps you've got a hidden gem up your sleeve that deserves the spotlight. Cast your vote, suggest a missing contender, and together, let's uncover the Mafia game that truly rules the streets. Don't miss out on this action-packed showdown - join us at StrawPoll and help us make history!

What Is the Most Popular Mafia Game?

  1. 1

    Mafia Wars

    This was one of the first and most popular Mafia games on Facebook. It was a text-based game where players built up their own criminal empire and competed with others.
    Mafia Wars is an online multiplayer social game where players join criminal organizations and carry out various criminal activities to build their empire. It is a text-based game that allows players to progress by completing missions, engaging in battles, and earning in-game currency.
    • Platform: Web-based
    • Release Date: June 2008
    • Genre: Role-playing, strategy
    • Modes: Multiplayer
    • Player Interaction: Cooperative and competitive
  2. 2

    Mafia II

    2K Czech
    This is a popular Mafia-themed action-adventure game that was released in 2010. It has received critical acclaim for its engaging storyline, immersive world-building, and realistic depiction of life in the Mafia.
    Mafia II is an open-world action-adventure video game that was released in 2010. It is the sequel to the original Mafia game, developed by 2K Czech and published by 2K Games. The game is set in the 1940s and 1950s in the fictional city of Empire Bay, which is heavily influenced by real-life cities like New York, Chicago, and Los Angeles. Mafia II follows the story of Vito Scaletta, a war veteran who gets involved in a life of organized crime.
    • Genre: Action-adventure
    • Release Year: 2010
    • Platforms: PlayStation 3, Xbox 360, Microsoft Windows
    • Game Modes: Single-player
    • Open World: Yes
  3. 3

    Grand Theft Auto

    Rockstar Games
    San Andreas
    Grand Theft Auto is an action-adventure video game franchise that allows players to take on the role of a criminal in a sprawling open-world environment. The games feature a combination of driving, shooting, and exploration gameplay, with a heavy emphasis on story and character development.
    • Release Date: 1997
    • Genre: Action-adventure
    • Platforms: PlayStation, Xbox, PC
    • Open World: Yes
    • Single Player: Yes
    Grand Theft Auto in other rankings
  4. 4

    Mafia III

    Hangar 13
    This is the third installment in the Mafia video game series, which was released in 2016. It features a dynamic open-world environment and a compelling storyline that follows the rise of a black Vietnam War veteran who becomes a criminal boss in the 1960s.
    Mafia III is an action-adventure video game set in the open world of New Bordeaux, a fictionalized version of New Orleans in 1968. It follows the story of Lincoln Clay, a Vietnam War Veteran who seeks revenge against the Italian mob for their involvement in the death of his surrogate family. The game features a combination of third-person shooter and melee combat gameplay, as well as an immersive narrative with branching storylines and impactful decision-making.
    • Release Date: October 7, 2016
    • Platforms: PlayStation 4, Xbox One, Microsoft Windows
    • Genre: Action-adventure
    • Setting: Open world, 1968 New Orleans
    • Playable Characters: Lincoln Clay
  5. 5
    The Godfather
    Paramount Pictures (1972) · Public domain

    The Godfather

    Electronic Arts
    The Game
    The Godfather is a popular Mafia-themed video game inspired by the eponymous film series. It takes players into the 1940s and allows them to assume the role of a mobster operating in the fictional city of New York. The game provides an immersive and open-world environment where players can engage in various criminal activities, build their own criminal empire, and climb the ranks of the Corleone family.
    • Platform: PlayStation 2, Xbox, Microsoft Windows
    • Release Date: October 2006
    • Genre: Action-adventure
    • Single-Player: Yes
    • Multiplayer: No
    The Godfather in other rankings
  6. 6

    Saints Row 2

    Another game that isn't strictly a Mafia game, but features a lot of similar themes and gameplay. This open-world action-adventure game lets players take on the role of a gang leader and build up their criminal empire through a variety of missions and activities.
    Saints Row 2 is an open world action-adventure video game developed by Volition and published by THQ. It was released in 2008 and is the second installment in the Saints Row series. The game takes place in the fictional city of Stilwater, where the player controls a member of the 3rd Street Saints gang. Saints Row 2 features a diverse range of missions and activities, allowing players to progress through the storyline or engage in various side activities and mini-games. The game offers a multiplayer mode, both cooperative and competitive, allowing players to team up or compete against each other in the open world environment.
    • Release Year: 2008
    • Genre: Action-adventure
    • Platform: PlayStation 3, Xbox 360, Microsoft Windows
    • Setting: Open world, urban environment
    • Player Perspective: Third-person
    Saints Row 2 in other rankings
  7. 7
    City of Gangsters
    Omerta is a popular online Mafia game that simulates the criminal underworld. It offers players a chance to experience the life of a gangster, engaging in activities such as organizing crimes, managing businesses, and forming alliances. Famously known for its intense gameplay and strategic elements, Omerta has garnered a dedicated following over the years.
    • Release Date: 2003
    • Genre: Online Mafia Game
    • Platform: Web browser
    • Player Count: Large multiplayer community
    • Game Modes: Player-vs-Player, Player-vs-Environment
  8. 8
    Last Man Standing
    La Cosa Nostra is a popular Mafia game that originated in Sicily, Italy. It is a secretive and organized criminal society that is known for its strong hierarchical structure and strict code of conduct.
    • Origin: Sicily, Italy
    • Hierarchy: Follows a strict hierarchical structure
    • Code of Conduct: Adherence to a set of rules and ethics
    • Power: Influence over criminal activities such as drug trafficking, extortion, and illegal gambling
    • Family Units: Organized into individual family units led by a boss
  9. 9
    Organized Crime
    Gangsters is a popular Mafia game that allows players to live out the dangerous and thrilling life of a gangster. Set in various cities during the Prohibition era, the game provides an immersive experience that combines strategy, role-playing, and resource management.
    • Genre: Action, Strategy
    • Platform: Microsoft Windows
    • Release Date: 2001
    • Modes: Single-player, Multiplayer
    • Setting: Prohibition-era cities
  10. 10

    The Mafia Boss

    Silvio Dibiase
    This is a browser-based Mafia game that was first released in 2006. It lets players build up their own criminal empire and compete with others for power and influence. It features an engaging storyline, immersive gameplay, and a variety of activities to keep players engaged.
    The Mafia Boss is an online multiplayer text-based game that simulates the world of organized crime. Players take on the role of a Mafia boss and compete with other players to establish dominance in the criminal underworld. The game offers a rich and immersive experience, allowing players to recruit and train members, conduct illegal activities, participate in organized crime activities, and fight rival gangs. With its engaging gameplay and strategic elements, The Mafia Boss has gained popularity among fans of the Mafia genre.
    • Genre: Text-based Multiplayer Game
    • Platform: Web-based
    • Release Date: February 2006
    • Languages: English, Italian, Dutch, Spanish, Portuguese, Turkish
    • Number of Players: Thousands of active players

Missing your favorite game?


Ranking factors for popular game

  1. Number of Players
    The popularity of a Mafia game can be determined by the number of players who actively participate in the game. A larger player base will indicate a higher level of interest and engagement.
  2. Player Retention
    How long players continue to play the game and return for multiple sessions can indicate the game's ability to maintain player interest and how enjoyable the gameplay experience is.
  3. User Ratings and Reviews
    Players' ratings and reviews will provide insight into how well-received the game is and what aspects of the game players particularly enjoy or find challenging.
  4. Online Presence
    The number of active online forums, social media groups, and fan sites dedicated to discussing the game can indicate the game's overall popularity and player engagement.
  5. Tournament Participation
    How often the game is played in local and international gaming tournaments can show the game's competitive appeal and recognition in the gaming community.
  6. Media Coverage
    The amount of media coverage from gaming websites, magazines, and podcasts, as well as mentions by popular gaming influencers, can indicate the game's overall popularity and reach in the gaming world.
  7. Game Editions and Expansions
    The number of editions, expansions, or alternative versions of the Mafia game can indicate its ongoing popularity and sustained player interest.
  8. Sales Numbers and Downloads
    The number of game units sold or downloaded can provide a direct measurement of the game's reach and overall player base.
  9. Accessibility
    Features that cater to different age groups, skill levels, and interests can make the game more inclusive and increase the potential player base.
  10. Developer Reputation
    The reputation and pedigree of the game's developers can influence the game's popularity among the gaming community.

About this ranking

This is a community-based ranking of the most popular Mafia game. We do our best to provide fair voting, but it is not intended to be exhaustive. So if you notice something or game is missing, feel free to help improve the ranking!


  • 186 votes
  • 10 ranked items

Voting Rules

A participant may cast an up or down vote for each game once every 24 hours. The rank of each game is then calculated from the weighted sum of all up and down votes.

More information on most popular mafia game

Mafia games have been around for decades and have gained a tremendous following among gamers. These games typically involve a group of players who take on the roles of civilians and members of the mafia. The objective of the game is for the mafia to eliminate all the civilians, while the civilians must work together to identify and eliminate the mafia members. With the rise of online gaming, Mafia games have become more accessible and popular than ever. There are dozens of different Mafia games available, each with its own unique style and gameplay. Some of the most popular Mafia games include Mafia Wars, The Godfather, and Mafia II. But which Mafia game is the most popular among players? We've conducted a poll to find out, and the results may surprise you. Read on to discover the top Mafia games as voted by our community of players.

Share this article