The Most Popular Mattress Firmness: Revealing Consumer Preferences and Trends

Choose the mattress firmness you think is the most popular!

Author: Gregor Krambs
Updated on Apr 17, 2024 07:19
Welcome to StrawPoll, where your vote shapes the ultimate rankings! As fellow sleep enthusiasts, we understand that finding the perfect mattress is a game-changer, and firmness plays a significant role in this quest. That's why we've curated a list of the most popular mattress firmness levels and invite you to have your say in our quest to determine the fan-favorite! So, whether you're a fan of the plush, cloud-like softness or an advocate for the sturdy, supportive firm feel, every vote counts! Not seeing your preferred firmness on the list? Don't worry – you can suggest a missing option, and together, we'll create a comprehensive ranking that will help guide dreamers on their journey to the perfect sleep. So, let's dive into the world of mattress firmness and shape the future of slumber, one vote at a time!

What Is the Most Popular Mattress Firmness?

  1. 1
    This is the most popular mattress firmness, as it provides a balance between support and comfort. It is ideal for people who sleep on their back or stomach, as it keeps the spine aligned.
    Medium Firm is a mattress firmness level that strikes a balance between softness and support. It is designed to provide a comfortable sleeping surface while offering enough firmness to support the body. The Medium Firm level is known for its versatility, as it can accommodate various sleeping positions.
    • Firmness Level: Medium Firm
    • Comfort Feel: Balanced
    • Recommended Sleeping Positions: Back, Stomach, and Combination Sleepers
    • Support: Good
    • Conforming Ability: Moderate
  2. 2
    Soft mattresses are popular among side sleepers, as they provide pressure relief on the shoulders and hips. They are also good for people who prefer a plush feel.
    Soft is a mattress firmness level that is designed to provide a plush and cushiony sleeping surface. It is characterized by its gentle give and sink-in feel, offering a hugging sensation for optimal comfort and pressure relief. Soft mattresses are often preferred by side sleepers or individuals seeking a cozier sleeping experience.
    • Firmness Level: Soft
    • Comfort Layer Thickness: Around 2 to 4 inches
    • Support Core: Usually made of high-density foam or innerspring system
    • Conforming Ability: High, molds to the sleeper's body shape
    • Pressure Relief: Excellent, helps alleviate joint and back pain
  3. 3
    Firm mattresses are popular among people who sleep on their stomach, as they provide a solid surface that helps to prevent the spine from arching. They are also good for people who prefer a more supportive feel.
    The Firm mattress is known for its sturdy and supportive feel, providing a solid foundation for a comfortable sleep. It offers a firm sleeping surface that is ideal for those who prefer extra support or have specific back or spinal alignment needs. This mattress ensures minimal sinkage and excellent body support throughout the night.
    • Firmness level: 7-9 out of 10 (10 being the firmest)
    • Materials: High-density foam, latex, or a combination of both
    • Top layer: Responsive foam for immediate comfort
    • Support system: Innerspring coils or dense foam core
    • Motion isolation: Limited motion transfer, ideal for couples
  4. 4

    Medium Soft

    Various mattress manufacturers
    This is a popular option for people who want a softer feel than a medium firm mattress, but still want some support. It is also popular among couples with different sleep preferences.
    Medium Soft is a mattress firmness that offers a balance between softness and support. It is designed to provide a comfortable sleeping surface that conforms to the body while still providing adequate support.
    • Firmness Level: Medium Soft
    • Comfort: Conforms to body contours
    • Support: Adequate support for pressure points
    • Motion Isolation: Reduces motion transfer
    • Durability: Long-lasting and maintains shape
  5. 5
    Extra Firm
    EHALAM BorG 600M · CC BY-SA 4.0

    Extra Firm

    Various mattress manufacturers
    Extra firm mattresses are popular among people who need extra support, such as those with back pain or heavier body types. They are also good for people who sleep on their stomach.
    The Extra Firm mattress is designed for individuals who prefer a highly supportive sleeping surface with minimal sinkage. This mattress offers a sturdy and rigid feel, providing excellent spinal alignment and maximum support.
    • Firmness Level: Extreme firmness
    • Support: High level of support
    • Comfort: Minimal sinkage or contouring
    • Spinal Alignment: Excellent alignment support
    • Motion Transfer: Low motion transfer
  6. 6
    Plush mattresses are popular among people who want a soft, luxurious feel. They are also good for people who prefer to sink into their mattress.
    Plush carpet is a luxurious and soft type of carpet that is known for its exceptionally comfortable feel underfoot. It offers a plush and cushioned surface that adds a cozy touch to any space. This type of carpet is perfect for areas where comfort is a priority, such as bedrooms, living rooms, and home theaters.
    • Pile Height: Generally ranges from ½ inch to ¾ inch
    • Material: Primarily made of synthetic fibers like nylon or polyester
    • Softness: Exceptionally soft and plush texture
    • Durability: Moderate to high durability, depending on the quality of the carpet
    • Comfort: Provides a luxurious and cushioned feel underfoot
  7. 7

    Ultra Soft

    Various mattress manufacturers
    Ultra soft mattresses are popular among people who want a cloud-like feel. They are also good for people who have chronic pain or injuries, as they provide maximum pressure relief.
    Ultra Soft is a mattress firmness option that offers a plush and cloud-like feel. It is designed to provide maximum softness and comfort, giving you the sensation of sleeping on a fluffy cloud. This firmness level is ideal for those who prefer a very soft and pressure-relieving sleeping surface.
    • Firmness Level: Ultra Soft
    • Comfort Level: Plush
    • Feel: Cloud-like
    • Ideal For: Those who prefer very soft and pressure-relieving sleep
    • Support: Good support for lightweight sleepers
  8. 8

    Medium-Firm to Firm

    Various mattress manufacturers
    This firmness range is popular among people who want a supportive feel, but also want some cushioning. It is also good for people who sleep in different positions.
    The Medium-Firm to Firm mattress is a popular choice known for its balanced level of support and comfort. It offers a slightly firmer feel than a medium mattress, providing additional support for those who prefer a more stable sleeping surface. The Medium-Firm to Firm mattress is designed to provide a good blend of support and pressure relief, making it suitable for a wide range of sleeping positions and body types. It offers enough firmness to promote proper spinal alignment while still allowing for some plushness and contouring.
    • Firmness Level: Medium-Firm to Firm
    • Support: Balanced support for optimal spine alignment
    • Comfort: Offers a slightly firmer feel for stability
    • Pressure Relief: Provides adequate pressure relief for various sleeping positions
    • Motion Isolation: Minimizes motion transfer for undisturbed sleep
  9. 9

    Medium to Medium-Soft

    Various mattress manufacturers
    This firmness range is popular among people who want a balance between support and comfort. It is also good for people who sleep in different positions.
    Medium to Medium-Soft is a popular mattress firmness level that offers a balanced combination of support and softness. It provides a comfortable sleeping surface that is suitable for a wide range of sleepers.
    • Firmness Level: Medium to Medium-Soft
    • Comfort: Balanced support and softness
    • Ideal Sleepers: Suitable for a wide range of sleepers
    • Pressure Relief: Effective in alleviating pressure points
    • Motion Isolation: Good motion isolation properties
  10. 10

    Dual Firmness

    Various mattress manufacturers
    Dual firmness mattresses are popular among couples with different sleep preferences. They allow each partner to have their own firmness level on their side of the bed.
    Dual Firmness is a mattress firmness design that offers different levels of firmness on each side of the mattress, allowing users to choose their preferred level of comfort. It provides a unique solution for couples or individuals who have different firmness preferences.
    • Firmness Options: Two different firmness levels on each side of the mattress (e.g., medium-firm and soft)
    • Customization: Allows for individual preference and personalized comfort
    • Support: Provides targeted support to different body types and sleeping positions
    • Versatility: Suitable for shared beds, accommodating different comfort preferences
    • Durability: Designed to maintain shape and support over time

Missing your favorite mattress firmness?


Ranking factors for popular mattress firmness

  1. Sleeping position
    The preferred sleeping position of the user is crucial in determining the ideal mattress firmness. Back and stomach sleepers generally need a firmer mattress to keep their spine aligned, while side sleepers might prefer a softer mattress to accommodate the contours of their body.
  2. Body weight
    A person's body weight also affects the perceived firmness of a mattress. Heavier individuals usually require a firmer mattress to provide adequate support, whereas lighter individuals may feel more comfortable on a softer mattress.
  3. Pain and pressure relief
    A mattress should have a balance of support and cushioning to alleviate pressure points and reduce pain for sleepers. The ideal firmness for pain relief may vary depending on the user's individual needs.
  4. Temperature regulation
    Mattress firmness also affects temperature regulation, with firmer mattresses typically sleeping cooler than softer ones. People who sleep hot might prefer a firmer mattress to help dissipate heat.
  5. Motion isolation
    Mattress firmness impacts motion isolation, which is the ability of a mattress to absorb motion and prevent it from transferring across the surface. Softer mattresses tend to have better motion isolation, while firmer mattresses have slightly reduced motion isolation.
  6. Durability
    The firmness of a mattress can influence its lifespan. A mattress with the right balance of support and comfort is less likely to sag and wear out compared to one that is too soft or too firm.
  7. Expert opinions
    Consultations with sleep experts, chiropractors, and physiotherapists can also inform the ranking of popular mattress firmness levels, as they can offer professional advice on which firmness levels cater to different sleep needs.

About this ranking

This is a community-based ranking of the most popular mattress firmness. We do our best to provide fair voting, but it is not intended to be exhaustive. So if you notice something or mattress firmness is missing, feel free to help improve the ranking!


  • 159 votes
  • 10 ranked items

Movers & Shakers

Voting Rules

A participant may cast an up or down vote for each mattress firmness once every 24 hours. The rank of each mattress firmness is then calculated from the weighted sum of all up and down votes.

More information on most popular mattress firmness

When it comes to buying a mattress, one of the most important decisions you'll have to make is choosing the right firmness. Mattress firmness refers to how soft or firm the mattress feels when you lie down on it, and it is determined by factors such as the materials used in the mattress and the level of support it provides. There are generally five levels of mattress firmness: very soft, soft, medium, firm, and very firm. Each level has its own benefits and drawbacks, depending on your sleeping style, body type, and personal preferences. According to a recent StrawPoll survey, the most popular mattress firmness is medium. This level of firmness offers a good balance of support and comfort for most people, making it a safe choice for those who are unsure of what firmness level to choose. However, it's important to note that everyone's body is different, and what works for one person may not work for another. It's always a good idea to test out different firmness levels before making a purchase, and to consult with a sleep expert if you're unsure about which level is right for you.

Share this article