The Most Popular Neil Diamond Song: Revealing the Ultimate Fan Favorite

Choose the song you think is the most popular!

Author: Gregor Krambs
Updated on Feb 29, 2024 06:20
Step right up and join us as we embark on a sparkling journey through the timeless hits of the legendary singer-songwriter, Neil Diamond! Here at StrawPoll, we've curated a list of his most iconic tunes, and we want YOU to help us decide which masterpiece deserves the title of "The Most Popular Neil Diamond Song." From the soul-stirring melodies of "Sweet Caroline" to the poetic rhythm of "Cracklin' Rosie," we've got it all. So, whether you're a lifelong fan or just discovering the magic of Neil Diamond, don't miss your chance to make your voice heard. Cast your vote, suggest a missing gem, and let's celebrate the musical legacy of one of the greatest artists of all time together!

What Is the Most Popular Neil Diamond Song?

  1. 1

    Sweet Caroline

    Neil Diamond
    This song is arguably Neil Diamond's most popular and enduring hit, with its catchy tune and sing-along chorus. It has been played at sporting events, weddings, and parties for decades.
    Sweet Caroline is a popular song by Neil Diamond, released in 1969. It is a soft rock ballad that has since become an iconic anthem played at various events and gatherings. With its catchy melody and heartfelt lyrics, Sweet Caroline offers a feel-good and nostalgic vibe to listeners. The song's creator, Neil Diamond, wrote it as a tribute to Caroline Kennedy, the daughter of President John F. Kennedy.
    • Genre: Soft rock
    • Release year: 1969
    • Length: 3 minutes and 21 seconds
    • Album: Brother Love's Travelling Salvation Show
    • Peak chart position: No. 4 on the Billboard Hot 100
  2. 2

    Cracklin' Rosie

    Neil Diamond
    Another one of Diamond's most recognizable songs, "Cracklin' Rosie" features a memorable melody and lyrics that have become synonymous with good times and celebration.
    Cracklin' Rosie is a popular song by Neil Diamond that was released as a single in 1970. It is a catchy and upbeat track with a folk-rock sound.
    • Release year: 1970
    • Genre: Folk-rock
    • Album: Tap Root Manuscript
    • Length: 3 minutes and 01 seconds
    • Writer(s): Neil Diamond
  3. 3

    I Am...I Said

    Neil Diamond
    This introspective ballad showcases Diamond's powerful vocals and emotional depth. It has become a fan favorite and a staple of his live performances.
    I Am...I Said is a popular song by Neil Diamond, released in 1971 as part of the album 'Stones'. It is a poignant ballad that showcases Diamond's introspective and emotive storytelling style, exploring themes of loneliness, identity, and the search for meaning. The song is characterized by its heartfelt vocals, accompanied by piano and subtle orchestration, creating a deeply nostalgic and melancholic atmosphere.
    • Album: Stones
    • Release Year: 1971
    • Genre: Pop Rock
    • Length: 4:24
    • Label: MCA Records
  4. 4

    Song Sung Blue

    Neil Diamond
    A simple yet effective tune with a sing-along chorus, "Song Sung Blue" has become a classic Neil Diamond hit.
    Song Sung Blue is a popular song by Neil Diamond, an American singer-songwriter. It was released in 1972 as a single and became one of his most recognizable hits. The song features a catchy melody and heartfelt lyrics that explore themes of melancholy and the universal experience of sadness.
    • Release Date: 1972
    • Genre: Pop
    • Album: Moods
    • Length: 3:16
    • Record Label: Uni Records
  5. 5

    Cherry, Cherry

    Neil Diamond
    A high-energy rock song with a catchy riff, "Cherry, Cherry" is one of Diamond's earliest hits and still a fan favorite.
    Cherry, Cherry is a song written and performed by American singer-songwriter Neil Diamond. It was released as a single in 1966 and found great success, reaching #6 on the Billboard Hot 100 chart. The song combines elements of pop and rock genres, featuring catchy melodies and energetic guitar riffs.
    • Year Released: 1966
    • Genre: Pop, Rock
    • Chart Performance: Reached #6 on Billboard Hot 100
    • Songwriter: Neil Diamond
    • Length: 2 minutes and 41 seconds
  6. 6

    September Morn

    Neil Diamond
    This romantic ballad is one of Diamond's biggest hits from the 1980s, with a memorable chorus and lush instrumentation.
    September Morn is a sentimental pop ballad sung by Neil Diamond. It was released as the lead single from his album of the same name in 1979. The song portrays the bittersweet feelings of a relationship coming to an end in the autumn season. Diamond's heartfelt vocals combined with elegant orchestration create a nostalgic and poignant atmosphere.
    • Release Year: 1979
    • Genre: Pop
    • Album: September Morn
    • Length: 3:51
    • Label: Columbia
  7. 7

    Forever in Blue Jeans

    Neil Diamond
    With its upbeat tempo and catchy melody, "Forever in Blue Jeans" is a feel-good song that has become a staple of Diamond's live shows.
    Forever in Blue Jeans is a popular song by Neil Diamond. It was released in 1979 as a single from his album 'You Don't Bring Me Flowers'. The song has a catchy melody and relatable lyrics about the simple pleasures of life and the enduring qualities of love. It combines elements of pop, rock, and country music, making it a versatile and enjoyable tune for listeners of different genres. Forever in Blue Jeans became one of Diamond's signature songs and has remained a fan favorite throughout the years.
    • Release Year: 1979
    • Album: You Don't Bring Me Flowers
    • Genre: Pop, Rock, Country
    • Length: 3 minutes and 26 seconds
    • Writer(s): Neil Diamond, Richard Bennett
  8. 8
    A duet with Barbra Streisand, "You Don't Bring Me Flowers" is a poignant love song that has become a classic.
    You Don't Bring Me Flowers is a popular ballad that was released as a duet by Neil Diamond and Barbra Streisand in 1978. The song was written by Neil Diamond, Alan Bergman, and Marilyn Bergman. It tells the story of a couple whose relationship has lost its spark and the sadness that comes with it. The song gained immense popularity due to the emotional vocals and heartfelt lyrics delivered by both Diamond and Streisand.
    • Year: 1978
    • Genre: Pop
    • Duration: 3 minutes and 35 seconds
    • Album: You Don't Bring Me Flowers
    • Label: Columbia
  9. 9

    Hello Again

    Neil Diamond
    This romantic ballad showcases Diamond's smooth vocals and songwriting prowess. It has become a fan favorite and a staple of his live shows.
    Hello Again is a popular song by Neil Diamond that was released in 1981 as a single from his album The Jazz Singer. It is a romantic ballad that showcases Diamond's smooth vocals and heartfelt lyrics. The song's passionate melody and nostalgic theme resonated with audiences, contributing to its enduring popularity.
    • Release Date: 1981
    • Album: The Jazz Singer
    • Genre: Soft rock
    • Composer: Neil Diamond
    • Lyricist: Neil Diamond
  10. 10
    A patriotic anthem that celebrates the American spirit, "America" has become a beloved song that is often played at national events and celebrations.
    America is a popular song written and performed by Neil Diamond. It was released in 1980 as a single and later included in his album 'The Jazz Singer'. The song is an ode to the United States and explores themes of immigration, dreams, and the pursuit of happiness. It achieved widespread success and has become one of Neil Diamond's most iconic and beloved songs.
    • Release Year: 1980
    • Album: The Jazz Singer
    • Genre: Pop
    • Length: 4:18
    • Lyricist: Neil Diamond

Missing your favorite song?


Ranking factors for popular song

  1. Chart performance
    Analyzing the peak chart positions of the song across various countries, especially in Neil Diamond's home country (United States) and other major music markets such as the United Kingdom and Australia. The higher the song's chart ranking, the more popular it is likely to be considered.
  2. Sales and certifications
    Reviewing the number of copies the song has sold by assessing its certification level, such as Gold, Platinum, or Diamond, issued by organizations like the Recording Industry Association of America (RIAA), the British Phonographic Industry (BPI), and the Australian Recording Industry Association (ARIA).
  3. Radio airplay
    Evaluating how frequently the song has been played on radio stations, both during its initial release period and in the years that have followed.
  4. Streaming numbers
    Assessing the number of streams the song has garnered on digital platforms such as Spotify, Apple Music, and YouTube. Songs with higher streaming numbers are often considered more popular.
  5. Critical acclaim
    Analyzing the reviews and ratings provided by professional music critics and publications for the song to determine its impact on music history and its standing among experts.
  6. Awards and accolades
    Examining any prestigious awards or honors the song has received, such as the Grammy Awards, American Music Awards, or a place on various "greatest songs" lists published by music magazines and websites.
  7. Cultural impact
    Evaluating the song's cultural significance, including its inclusion in movies, TV shows, commercials, or its impact on popular culture in general. A song that has become iconic may be deemed more popular.
  8. Cover versions
    Looking at the number of cover versions of the song by other artists, which can indicate its popularity and influence on future generations of musicians.
  9. Longevity
    Assessing the song's staying power through continued airplay, sales, and its presence in popular culture. A song with long-lasting popularity is often considered a classic.

About this ranking

This is a community-based ranking of the most popular Neil Diamond song. We do our best to provide fair voting, but it is not intended to be exhaustive. So if you notice something or song is missing, feel free to help improve the ranking!


  • 199 votes
  • 10 ranked items

Voting Rules

A participant may cast an up or down vote for each song once every 24 hours. The rank of each song is then calculated from the weighted sum of all up and down votes.


More information on most popular neil diamond song

Neil Diamond is a legendary singer-songwriter who has been entertaining audiences for over five decades. With his unique voice and catchy tunes, he has captured the hearts of fans around the world. Over the years, Diamond has released many hit songs that have become classics. From "Sweet Caroline" to "I Am... I Said," his music has stood the test of time and continues to be beloved by fans of all ages. But which of his songs is the most popular? With so many great choices, it's tough to narrow it down, but we've done our research and have the answer for you. Keep reading to find out which Neil Diamond song takes the top spot.

Share this article