The Most Popular Restaurant in Ohio: A Stellar Culinary Destination

Choose the restaurant you think is the most popular!

Author: Gregor Krambs
Jun 16, 2023 10:18 (Updated on Nov 23, 2023 09:02)
Welcome to StrawPoll, where your opinion matters! We're diving into the delicious world of Ohio's dining scene, and we need your help to determine the most popular restaurant in the Buckeye State. From mouthwatering steakhouses to scrumptious sushi bars, Ohio has a diverse array of culinary delights waiting to be ranked. Will it be the legendary Skyline Chili or a hidden gem waiting to be discovered? Cast your vote now or suggest a delectable contender we might have missed. Your taste buds and fellow foodies will thank you. Let's get ready to embark on a gastronomic journey that will tantalize your senses and satisfy your cravings!

What Is the Most Popular Restaurant in Ohio?

  1. 1

    Skyline Chili

    Nicholas Lambrinides
    Known for its signature Cincinnati-style chili, this Ohio-based chain has over 130 locations and has become a beloved staple of the Buckeye State's culinary scene.
    Skyline Chili is a renowned restaurant chain in Ohio, known for its unique take on chili dishes. The restaurant offers a variety of dishes with their signature chili as the main ingredient.
    • 1: Established in 1949
    • 2: Known for Cincinnati-style chili
    • 3: Uses a secret family recipe
    • 4: Offers various chili-based menu items
    • 5: Popular dishes include chili cheese coneys and 3-way chili
  2. 2

    Graeter's Ice Cream

    Louis Graeter
    Founded in 1870, Graeter's is a Cincinnati-based ice cream company that has become famous for its French pot process, which produces dense, creamy ice cream with a unique texture.
    Graeter's Ice Cream is a renowned ice cream parlor and restaurant chain in Ohio, known for its indulgent and high-quality ice cream creations. It was founded in 1870 by Louis Graeter in Cincinnati, Ohio, and has since gained a loyal following of ice cream enthusiasts.
    • Founding Year: 1870
    • Location: Cincinnati, Ohio
    • Specialty: Handcrafted French Pot ice cream
    • Signature Flavor: Black Raspberry Chocolate Chip
    • Unique Process: French Pot process, made in small batches
  3. 3
    This Cleveland-based restaurant is famous for its gourmet grilled cheese sandwiches, which are made with artisanal bread and creative fillings like macaroni and cheese, pierogies, and falafel.
    Melt Bar and Grilled is a popular restaurant in Ohio known for its delicious grilled cheese sandwiches and extensive craft beer selection. With a quirky and retro atmosphere, it offers a unique dining experience that combines comfort food with a modern twist.
    • Location: Multiple locations in Ohio
    • Specialty: Gourmet grilled cheese sandwiches
    • Menu Variety: Over 30 different specialty grilled cheese sandwiches
    • Craft Beer Selection: Extensive range of craft beers from local and national breweries
    • Vegetarian Options: Several vegetarian and vegan sandwich options available
  4. 4

    Jeni's Splendid Ice Creams

    Jeni Britton Bauer
    Founded in Columbus, Jeni's has gained a cult following for its innovative flavors, like Goat Cheese with Red Cherries and Brambleberry Crisp.
    Jeni's Splendid Ice Creams is a popular and highly regarded ice cream brand known for its innovative flavors and high-quality ingredients. Created by Jeni Britton Bauer, a celebrated ice cream maker and entrepreneur, the brand has gained a loyal following for its unique and delicious offerings.
    • Flavor Variety: Jeni's offers a wide range of flavors, including both classics like vanilla and chocolate, as well as creative and unique options like Brambleberry Crisp and Brown Butter Almond Brittle.
    • High-Quality Ingredients: The ice cream is made using only the finest and carefully sourced ingredients, resulting in a rich and satisfying taste.
    • Innovation: Jeni's is known for its innovative approach to ice cream flavors, often introducing unexpected and exciting combinations that surprise and delight customers.
    • Texture: The ice cream has a creamy and smooth texture that melts in your mouth, providing a luxurious eating experience.
    • Commitment to Sustainability: Jeni's is dedicated to sustainability practices, using ingredients that are responsibly sourced and supporting local farmers.
    Jeni's Splendid Ice Creams in other rankings
  5. 5

    Tony Packo's Cafe

    Tony Packo Sr.
    This Toledo institution is known for its Hungarian-style hot dogs and chili, as well as its extensive collection of signed hot dog buns from celebrities like Burt Reynolds and Jamie Farr.
    Tony Packo's Cafe is a renowned restaurant located in Toledo, Ohio. It has gained popularity for its unique Hungarian-American cuisine and its speciality food item, the Hungarian hot dog. The restaurant holds historical significance as it was established in 1932 and has been featured in the hit television show M.A.S.H. Due to its charm and great food, Tony Packo's Cafe has become an iconic destination for locals and tourists alike.
    • Location: Toledo, Ohio
    • Cuisine: Hungarian-American
    • Specialty: Hungarian hot dog
    • Established: 1932
    • TV Appearance: M.A.S.H
  6. 6
    The Thurman Cafe
    Nheyob · CC BY-SA 4.0

    The Thurman Cafe

    Nick Suclescy
    Located in Columbus, The Thurman Cafe is famous for its massive burgers, which are stacked high with toppings like bacon, ham, and fried eggs.
    The Thurman Cafe is a legendary restaurant located in Columbus, Ohio. Known for its massive burgers and lively atmosphere, it has been a favorite among locals and tourists alike for over 75 years.
    • Established: 1942
    • Type of Cuisine: American
    • Famous Dish: Thurman Burger
    • Burger Size: Huge (Over 1 lb)
    • Burger Toppings: Varies from classic to unique combinations
  7. 7

    The Golden Lamb

    Jonah Sech
    This Lebanon landmark is Ohio's oldest continuously operating restaurant, having served customers since 1803. It's known for its classic American fare and historic ambiance.
    The Golden Lamb is a historic landmark restaurant located in Lebanon, Ohio. It holds the distinction of being the oldest continuously operating business in the state, originally opening its doors in 1803. Over the years, it has gained a reputation for its delicious comfort food, charming ambiance, and a commitment to preserving its rich history. The Golden Lamb is a beloved destination for locals and visitors alike, offering a unique dining experience that combines tradition with exceptional hospitality.
    • Year Established: 1803
    • Location: Lebanon, Ohio
    • Cuisine: American, Comfort Food
    • Status: Continuously operating
    • Historic Landmark: Yes
  8. 8

    Slyman's Restaurant

    Joe Slyman
    This Cleveland deli is known for its towering corned beef sandwiches, which are piled high with meat and served on rye bread.
    Slyman's Restaurant is a legendary eatery located in Cleveland, Ohio. Known for its iconic corned beef sandwiches, this family-owned establishment has been a favorite among locals and visitors alike since its inception in 1963.
    • Specialty: Corned beef sandwiches
    • Year Established: 1963
    • Location: Cleveland, Ohio
    • Family-Owned: Yes
    • Seating Capacity: Approximately 120
  9. 9
    Schmidt's Sausage Haus und Restaurant
    Sebastian Wallroth · CC BY 4.0
    Located in Columbus, Schmidt's is famous for its German-style sausages and cream puffs, which draw long lines of hungry customers.
    Schmidt's Sausage Haus und Restaurant is a popular German restaurant located in Columbus, Ohio. It has been serving authentic German cuisine since 1886 and is known for its delicious sausages and hearty dishes.
    • Location: Columbus, Ohio
    • Cuisine: German
    • Year Established: 1886
    • Specialty: Sausages
    • Popular Dishes: Bratwurst, Bahama Mama, Jumbo Cream Puffs
  10. 10

    The Brown Dog Cafe

    Chef Shawn McCoy
    Located in Blue Ash, this upscale restaurant is known for its farm-to-table cuisine, which features locally sourced ingredients and creative flavor combinations.
    The Brown Dog Cafe, located in Blue Ash, Ohio, is a highly popular restaurant known for its unique concept and exceptional culinary experience. Offering a contemporary American cuisine with a touch of global influence, this charming establishment has become a local favorite for its delicious food, cozy atmosphere, and friendly service.
    • Location: Blue Ash, Ohio
    • Cuisine: Contemporary American with global influence
    • Atmosphere: Cozy and inviting
    • Chef: Chef Shawn McCoy
    • Popular Dishes: Braised Short Ribs, Lobster Risotto, Brown Dog Burger

Missing your favorite restaurant?


Ranking factors for popular restaurant

  1. Customer Reviews and Ratings
    Opinions and ratings from customers on platforms like Yelp, Google Reviews, and TripAdvisor play a significant role in determining a restaurant's popularity.
  2. Quality and variety of cuisine
    The types of dishes a restaurant offers, the taste, and the overall presentation play a major part in its popularity.
  3. Price and value for money
    If the restaurant provides satisfying meals at reasonable prices, this will make it more popular among patrons.
  4. Atmosphere and ambiance
    The overall atmosphere, including cleanliness, lighting, and decor, can make a difference in attracting customers and making them feel comfortable.
  5. Service and staff
    The quality of service and friendliness of staff can greatly influence a customer's experience and impact the restaurant's popularity.
  6. Location and accessibility
    A popular restaurant should be in a convenient location, with easy parking and/or access to public transportation.
  7. Menu options
    A variety of dishes catering to different dietary preferences and restrictions, such as vegetarian, vegan, and gluten-free options, can attract diverse customers.
  8. Reputation and awards
    Restaurants with a good reputation, positive media coverage, or awards can be an indication of its popularity.
  9. Consistency
    A consistently satisfying dining experience can help a restaurant stay popular over time.
  10. Social media presence and engagement
    A strong social media presence and engagement with customers can help promote the restaurant's popularity.
  11. Unique features and experiences
    Anything that sets the restaurant apart from others, such as a unique dining experience or signature dish, can influence its popularity.
  12. Word of Mouth
    The popularity of a restaurant can spread through friends, family, and colleagues' recommendations, so their satisfaction should also be considered.

About this ranking

This is a community-based ranking of the most popular restaurant in Ohio. We do our best to provide fair voting, but it is not intended to be exhaustive. So if you notice something or restaurant is missing, feel free to help improve the ranking!


  • 204 votes
  • 10 ranked items

Voting Rules

A participant may cast an up or down vote for each restaurant once every 24 hours. The rank of each restaurant is then calculated from the weighted sum of all up and down votes.


More information on most popular restaurant in ohio

Ohio is a state that is known for its diverse cuisine, ranging from classic American fare to international delicacies. With so many options available, it can be difficult to determine which restaurant is the most popular among Ohioans. However, through extensive research and analysis of user-generated polls and rankings, we have been able to identify the restaurant that reigns supreme in Ohio. In this section, we will delve deeper into the factors that contribute to the popularity of this restaurant and why it has earned the title of the most beloved eatery in the state.

Share this article