The Most Successful Alternative Approach to Bail-out: A Comparative Ranking

Choose the approach you think is the most successful!

Author: Gregor Krambs
Jun 16, 2023 10:18 (Updated on Dec 7, 2023 10:11)
Welcome to StrawPoll, where your voice matters! We're excited to present our latest ranking, "What is the most successful alternative approach to bail-out?" As economic landscapes shift and the need for creative financial solutions rises, we've compiled a list of innovative strategies that have been making waves around the world. From debt restructuring to community support initiatives, we've got it all covered. But, we need your help to make this ranking the most comprehensive and accurate one out there. Cast your vote for your favorite alternative approach or suggest a missing option that you believe deserves a spot in the limelight. Join the conversation, make your opinion count, and let's explore the future of financial resilience together!

What Is the Most Successful Alternative Approach to Bail-out?

  1. 1
    This approach involves renegotiating the terms of the debt to make it more manageable for the borrower. It can be done through a variety of methods such as reducing the interest rate or extending the repayment period.
    Debt restructuring is an alternative approach to bail-out that involves modifying the terms and conditions of existing debt contracts between a debtor and its creditors. This is done in order to alleviate the burden of unsustainable debt and avoid default or bankruptcy. The process typically involves negotiating new payment terms, interest rates, and maturity dates with creditors to make the debt more manageable for the debtor.
    • Debt repayment terms: Negotiating new payment terms to extend the maturity and reduce the immediate financial pressure on the debtor.
    • Interest rate adjustments: Changing the interest rate applied to the debt to lower the cost of servicing the debt.
    • Principal reduction: Reducing the principal amount owed by the debtor, usually in exchange for certain concessions.
    • Debt-to-equity swaps: Converting a portion of the debt into equity ownership in the debtor's company.
    • Bond buybacks: Repurchasing outstanding bonds at a discount to reduce overall debt burden.
  2. 2
    In some cases, bankruptcy may be a more effective solution than a bail-out. Bankruptcy can provide a fresh start for a company by eliminating its debts and allowing it to restructure its operations.
    Bankruptcy is a legal process that provides a way for individuals, businesses, and organizations to address and resolve their debts when they are unable to pay them off. It allows the debtor to obtain relief from their financial obligations by either discharging the debts entirely or developing a plan to repay a portion of the debts over time.
    • Debt relief: Bankruptcy allows debtors to obtain relief from their debts, either through complete discharge or through developing a repayment plan.
    • Legal protection: Bankruptcy provides legal protection to debtors by putting an automatic stay on debt collection efforts, including creditor lawsuits, wage garnishments, and foreclosure.
    • Creditors' claims: Bankruptcy allows creditors to submit their claims and participate in the distribution of the debtor's assets based on a priority system.
    • Different types: There are different types of bankruptcy proceedings, including Chapter 7 (liquidation), Chapter 11 (reorganization), and Chapter 13 (individual repayment plan). The availability of these types may vary by jurisdiction.
    • Financial evaluation: Bankruptcy involves a thorough evaluation of the debtor's financial situation, assets, liabilities, and income to determine the most appropriate course of action.
  3. 3
    This approach involves the government taking over control of a company or industry. This can be done to prevent a company from going bankrupt or to ensure that an essential industry remains operational.
    Nationalization is a bail-out approach where the government takes complete or partial ownership and control of a struggling private company or industry. It involves converting privately-owned assets and operations into public ownership to stabilize the company and protect the economy. Nationalization can be temporary or permanent, depending on the circumstances and goals of the government.
    • Control and Ownership: The government takes control and ownership of the struggling company or industry, typically by acquiring a majority stake.
    • Stabilization: Nationalization aims to stabilize the company, prevent its collapse, and protect jobs.
    • Government Intervention: Nationalization involves significant government intervention in the economy.
    • Funding: The government provides financial support and capital injection to keep the company afloat.
    • Public Benefit: Nationalization is often justified on the grounds of protecting public interest and ensuring long-term economic stability.
  4. 4
    Private equity firms can provide capital to struggling companies in exchange for a stake in the business. This can be a more effective solution than a bail-out because it allows the company to remain private and retain control over its operations.
    Private Equity Investment is a financial strategy that involves investing in privately-held companies in order to acquire significant ownership stakes and actively manage them to maximize the value of the investment. It is typically carried out by private equity firms or investors seeking higher returns and greater control over their investments.
    • Investment Focus: Investment in privately-held companies
    • Ownership Stakes: Acquiring significant ownership stakes in target companies
    • Active Management: Actively managing target companies to maximize value
    • Higher Returns: Seeking higher returns on investments
    • Control: Exercising greater control over portfolio companies
  5. 5
    This approach involves converting a portion of a company's debt into equity. This can help to reduce the company's debt burden and provide it with more financial flexibility.
    A debt-for-equity swap is an alternative approach to a bail-out where a company's debt is exchanged for ownership equity in the company. This is typically done when a company is facing financial distress and is unable to meet its debt obligations. The debt holders agree to forgive a portion of the debt in exchange for ownership stakes in the company, thereby providing a capital infusion and reducing the debt burden on the company.
    • Debt restructuring: Existing debt is restructured into equity ownership
    • Financial distress: Used by companies facing financial distress
    • Debt forgiveness: Debt holders agree to forgive a portion of the debt
    • Ownership stakes: Debt holders receive ownership equity in the company
    • Capital infusion: Provides a capital infusion for the company
  6. 6
    Selling off assets can provide a company with much-needed cash to pay off its debts. This can be an effective solution if the company has valuable assets that can be sold without disrupting its core operations.
    Asset Sale is an alternative approach to bail-out that involves the sale of distressed assets by a financial institution or government authority. It is designed to alleviate financial stress and restore stability to the institution or economy. The asset sale may involve selling off non-performing loans, distressed real estate, or other troubled assets.
    • Objective: To offload distressed assets and improve the financial health of the institution/economy
    • Method: Selling off non-performing loans, distressed real estate, or other troubled assets
    • Purpose: Restore stability and alleviate financial stress
    • Implementation: Carried out by financial institutions or government authorities
    • Beneficiaries: Financial institution or economy as a whole
  7. 7
    Instead of providing a bail-out, the government can offer loans to struggling companies. These loans can be used to pay off debts or to fund new projects.
    Government Loans is a financial assistance program implemented by the government to provide loans to struggling businesses or individuals during a financial crisis. It aims to stimulate economic growth, safeguard jobs, and prevent bankruptcy by injecting capital into the economy through accessible borrowing.
    • Purpose: To support businesses and individuals facing financial hardships during economic downturns.
    • Eligibility criteria: Specific guidelines set to qualify for loans, including financial viability, creditworthiness, and adherence to specified conditions.
    • Loan terms: Defined repayment periods, interest rates, collateral requirements, and borrowing limits.
    • Application process: Established procedures to apply for government loans, including document submission and evaluation.
    • Transparency and accountability: Regulations to ensure transparent allocation of loans, accountability of borrowers, and monitoring mechanisms.
  8. 8
    In some cases, forgiving a portion of a company's debt can be an effective solution. This can reduce the company's debt burden and provide it with more financial flexibility.
    Debt forgiveness is an alternative approach to bail-out that involves the partial or complete cancellation of outstanding debts owed by individuals, businesses, or nations. This approach aims to provide relief and alleviate financial burdens by eliminating or reducing the debt burden on the debtor.
    • Debt cancellation scope: Debt forgiveness can apply to different levels, such as individual, corporate, or national debt.
    • Partial or complete debt cancellation: Debt forgiveness can involve either a partial or complete cancellation of debts.
    • Voluntary or mandated forgiveness: Debt forgiveness can be implemented voluntarily by creditors or mandated by governments or international organizations.
    • Eligibility criteria: Debt forgiveness programs may have specific eligibility criteria that debtors must meet to qualify for debt relief.
    • Economic impact: Debt forgiveness can have various economic impacts, including stimulating economic growth, reducing financial burdens, and improving debt sustainability.
  9. 9
    Partnering with another company can provide a struggling company with access to new markets, products, and technologies. This can help to boost its revenue and improve its financial position.
    Strategic Partnerships refer to a collaborative and mutually beneficial relationship between two or more entities for the purpose of achieving common goals. It is an alternative approach to bail-out in which instead of government intervention or financial assistance, organizations form strategic partnerships to overcome financial challenges and promote long-term sustainability.
    • Collaboration: Requires collaboration between two or more entities.
    • Mutual Benefit: Partnerships aim to benefit all involved parties.
    • Shared Objectives: Partners align their objectives and work towards achieving common goals.
    • Risk Sharing: Partners typically share risks associated with financial challenges.
    • Resource Sharing: Entities pool their resources to overcome financial difficulties.
  10. 10
    Refinancing a company's debt can provide it with more favorable terms and lower interest rates. This can help to reduce its debt burden and improve its financial position.
    Debt refinancing is a financial strategy that involves the restructuring of existing debt obligations, typically by negotiating new loan terms with more favorable interest rates or extending the repayment period. This approach aims to reduce the cost of debt and improve financial stability for individuals or organizations facing financial challenges.
    • Interest Rate: Lowering the interest rate on the refinanced debt
    • Loan Term: Extending the repayment period to reduce monthly payments
    • Debt Consolidation: Combining multiple debts into a single refinanced loan
    • Credit Score Impact: Potential improvement in credit score if obligations are met
    • Financial Flexibility: Improved cash flow and increased ability to meet other financial obligations

Missing your favorite approach?


Ranking factors for successful alternative approach

  1. Cost-effectiveness
    The alternative approach should be cost-effective and should not create a burden on taxpayers.
  2. Timely intervention
    The approach should intervene in a timely manner to prevent the collapse of the financial system or the economy.
  3. Structural reforms
    The approach should address the root causes of the financial crisis, including the need for structural reforms to prevent future crises.
  4. Protecting stakeholders
    The approach should protect the interests of stakeholders, including depositors, shareholders, and employees.
  5. Transparency and accountability
    The approach should be transparent and accountable, with clear rules and regulations to prevent abuse and corruption.
  6. Political feasibility
    The approach should be politically feasible and should have the support of relevant stakeholders, including policymakers, regulators, and market participants.
  7. Moral hazard
    The approach should avoid creating moral hazard, where market participants take on excessively risky behavior with the expectation of government bailouts in the event of failure.

About this ranking

This is a community-based ranking of the most successful alternative approach to bail-out. We do our best to provide fair voting, but it is not intended to be exhaustive. So if you notice something or approach is missing, feel free to help improve the ranking!


  • 158 votes
  • 10 ranked items

Voting Rules

A participant may cast an up or down vote for each approach once every 24 hours. The rank of each approach is then calculated from the weighted sum of all up and down votes.


More information on most successful alternative approach to bail-out

Background: The concept of bail-out is not a new one. It has been used for decades to prevent the collapse of financial institutions, companies, and even entire economies. However, the traditional approach to bail-out has been criticized for being too costly, ineffective, and unfair. This has led to the emergence of alternative approaches that aim to address these issues and provide a more sustainable and equitable solution to bail-out. One of the most successful alternative approaches to bail-out is the use of bail-in. This approach involves using the assets of the failing institution or company to absorb losses, instead of relying on taxpayer money. This means that bondholders, shareholders, and other investors are required to contribute to the rescue effort, rather than being bailed out by the government. Bail-in has been implemented in several countries, including the UK, Cyprus, and Spain, and has proven to be effective in reducing the cost of bail-out and preventing moral hazard. It also promotes greater responsibility and accountability among investors, as they are more likely to carefully assess the risks of their investments. While bail-in is not a perfect solution, it offers a promising alternative to the traditional bail-out approach. As the global economy becomes increasingly interconnected and complex, it is important to explore new approaches to financial stability and crisis management.

Share this article