Diaper Pail Reviews & Buying Guide 2019


Hello, I'm Gregor and I put this site together. At first, you'll find an overview of recommended diaper pails, followed by a public poll and a general buying guide on diaper pail. Further down on this page, we do link to other well-written articles and reviews about diaper pails. At last, you'll be able to weight in your own opinion in the comments section.

If you choose to buy an item that I've chosen indepenently and recommended it here, I may earn commissions to support my efforts. For you, the price of the product will not change, I'm just saying this to be completely open with you.

1 0

The 10 Best Diaper Pails of Our Choice

Quick comparison in an overall view
Mama Bear
Safety 1st
Diaper Genie
Baby Trend
Steel Odor Locking
Amazon Brand
Pack of 8
Classic Hands-Free Diaper
Easy Saver Diaper
1st Pail
Step Diaper Pail Powered
Diaper Genie Baby
Playtex Complete Diaper
1 Refill, White
Disposable Diaper Pail
Mini Hands-Free Diaper
Diaper Champ Deluxe,
Ubbi Steel Odor Locking Image
Ubbi Steel Odor Locking, No Special Bag Required Money Saving, Awards-Winning, Modern Design Registry Must-Have Diaper Pail, Gray
Mama Bear Amazon Brand Image
Amazon Brand - Mama Bear Diaper Pail Refills for Diaper Genie Pails, 2160 Count (Pack of 8)
DEKOR Classic Hands-Free Diaper Image
Dekor Classic Hands-Free Diaper Pail | Easiest to Use | Just Step - Drop - Done | Doesn't Absorb Odors | 20 Second Bag Change | Most Economical Refill System | White
Safety 1st Easy Saver Diaper Image
Safety 1st Easy Saver Diaper Pail
Great Deal
Munchkin Step Diaper Pail Powered Image
Munchkin Step Diaper Pail Powered by Arm & Hammer
Playtex Diaper Genie Baby Image
Playtex Diaper Genie Baby Registry Gift Set, Includes 1 Diaper Genie Complete Diaper Pail, 8 Diaper Genie Refills and 8 Diaper Genie Carbon Filters for Odor Control
Diaper Genie Playtex  Complete Diaper Image
Playtex Diaper Genie Complete Diaper Pail, Fully Assembled, with Odor Lock Technology, Includes 1 Pail & 1 Refill, White
Ubbi Disposable Diaper Pail Image
Ubbi Disposable Diaper Pail Plastic Bags, Made with Recyclable Material, True Value Pack, 75 Count, 13-Gallon
DEKOR Mini Hands-Free Diaper Image
Dekor Mini Hands-Free Diaper Pail | Easiest to Use | Just Step - Drop - Done | Doesn't Absorb Odors | 20 Second Bag Change | Most Economical Refill System | White
Baby Trend Diaper Champ Deluxe, Image
Baby Trend Diaper Champ Deluxe, Teeny-Tiny Taupe
according to our criteria
95 %
in comparison
93 %
in comparison
92 %
in comparison
92 %
in comparison
90 %
in comparison
88 %
in comparison
88 %
in comparison
85 %
in comparison
85 %
in comparison
84 %
in comparison
  • Save money - NO need TO buy special bags: No special bags refills o...
  • Most award winning diaper pail: The Ubbi diaper pail won nine award...
  • Steel locks IN odor: Unlike plastic steel is not porous and keeps t...
  • For use with all Diaper Genie Disposal Systems Including Diaper Gen...
  • Not for use with Munchkin pails Only for use with Diaper Genie pails
  • Made with 7 layers to help trap odors
  • Totally Hands-Free: Step Drop Done No Bending No Twisting No Squish...
  • Most Cost-Effective Diaper Pail Refill System on the Market Dekor R...
  • Effective Triple Odor Control Keeps the Smell in the Pail
  • Easy one-hand use
  • Uses standard plastic bags
  • Dorizer disc included Replacement discs sold separately (23900) War...
  • Create the freshest nursery with the step diaper pail proven 1 in o...
  • Get a pail give a tree -- for every diaper pail sold Munchkin will ...
  • Self-sealing system -- seals the bag shut as the lid closes
  • All-in-one baby gift set - The perfect starter kit and registry gif...
  • Ultimate diaper pail - Diaper Genie's ultimate diaper disposal syst...
  • Built IN antimicrobial - Upgrade your nursery with Diaper Genie The...
  • All IN one diaper pail - Diaper Genie's ultimate diaper disposal sy...
  • Built IN antimicrobial - Upgrade your nursery with Diaper Genie The...
  • Keep your nursery fresh - Unlike other pails without clamps the Com...
  • Ubbi Plastic Bags contain 20 recycled material
  • Convenient bags have a 13 gallon capacity
  • Includes 75 Ubbi Diaper Pail plastic bags total
  • Great Secondary Pail Perfect for Powder Room or Grandma's House
  • Effective Triple Odor Control Keeps the Smell in the Pail
  • Closed-Cell abs Plastic Works Like Metal Does Not Absorb Odors
  • Superior Odor Control
  • Easy to Use
  • Large capacity holds up to 30 diapers
Show Offer
on Amazon.com
Show Offer
on Amazon.com
Show Offer
on Amazon.com
Show Offer
on Amazon.com
Show Offer
on Amazon.com
Show Offer
on Amazon.com
Show Offer
on Amazon.com
Show Offer
on Amazon.com
Show Offer
on Amazon.com
Show Offer
on Amazon.com

Results of the Straw Poll: Popular Diaper Pails

Every month, we analyze which products our readers like the most:

Which Diaper Pails Would You Buy Online? (July 2018)

  • 51.43 % (18 votes) Dekor Plus Hands-Free Diaper Pail | Easiest to ...
  • 28.57 % (10 votes) Ubbi Money Saving, No Special Bag Required, Ste...
  • 8.57 % (3 votes) Amazon Brand - Mama Bear Diaper Pail Refills fo...
  • 5.71 % (2 votes) Creative Baby Tidy Diaper Pail, Pearl, Pearl/Bl...
  • 5.71 % (2 votes) Munchkin Step Diaper Pail Powered by Arm &a...
  • 0 % (0 votes) Tommee Tippee Simplee Diaper Pail Refill Cartri...
  • 0 % (0 votes) Planet Wise Reusable Diaper Pail Liner, To The ...
  • 0 % (0 votes) Playtex Diaper Genie Refills for Diaper Genie D...

35 total votes.

If you also want to vote on the best diaper pail, click here to view the poll.

Diaper Pail Buying Guide

Diaper Pail Image
Picture: Steel Odor Locking from Ubbi

A new baby brings lots of joy, love and diapers to your life. When you are dealing with dirty diapers at all hours of the day and night, you'll want an easy disposal method. Placing them in your household trash cans will cause the odor to linger, and running back and forth to the trash bin outside is not ideal, especially in inclement weather or at night. A diaper pail will allow you to hygienically store your dirty diapers to keep your house free of odors and minimize your trips outside to the garbage.

With many different options available to you, it can be hard to know where to begin in shopping for a diaper pail. Let this guide help you to understand the different features and styles available, and to make the best choice for you and your growing family.

What is a diaper pail?

A diaper pail is a specially designed trash can that contains the odor of dirty diapers. The lid seals tightly, and typically there is a mechanism to seal off the bottom of the pail from the top where the new diaper is placed in. The pail typically has either a carbon or baking soda filter to help absorb the smell.

Why should I use one?

The biggest reasons to use a diaper pail are convenience and hygienic practices. The diaper pail will prevent frequent trips to the outdoor garbage can, which can be difficult to accomplish with the baby in tow, or in rainy or cold weather. The pail will also contain odors when you throw the diapers away, which a typical garbage can will not do. Additionally, the diaper pail will save on plastic bag waste, since most models can hold a large number of diapers before needing to be taken to the outside garbage can.

When you are shopping for a diaper pail, there are many different styles on the market to cover every need and desire. Nearly all of the characteristics will come down to personal preference. It's important to read reviews of the cans that you are deciding between in order to make the most informed decision. Also, consider the following features to select the one that is right for you and your family.


Diaper pails are made out of several different materials. The most well known brands make their cans out of hard plastic. These cans are fairly quiet to use and tend to be less expensive. However, plastic tends to absorb odors, so over time there is a chance that plastic diaper pails will release more odors into the air.

Other diaper pails are made from stainless steel or other types of metal. These cans will be heavier than their plastic counterparts, though once in place there usually isn't a need to move the can often, if at all. The metal cans also wipe down and resist odors more effectively. They do come with a slightly higher price tag, which may be a factor if you are on a tight budget.

Foot Pedal
Diaper pails with foot pedals have an instant increase in their ease of use factor. Aside from the style of pail that is an open can with individual bags for the diapers, all other cans will be sealed with a lid to keep odors in. A diaper pail with a foot pedal will allow for easy, hands-free access to the can to dispose of the diaper quickly and easily. However, a foot pedal also makes it easy for a crawling baby to open the lid and release the smells or get access to the inside. Therefore, it is important to know whether the model that you are investigating includes this feature.

For diaper pails that utilize filters, the two most common types are carbon and baking soda. The carbon filters use activated charcoal, which absorb odors. Baking soda can also absorb odors, but it has a smaller surface area than carbon. Activated charcoal has a larger surface area that allows more of the the odor molecules to be absorbed into it.

However, depending on the design of the filter in the diaper pails, either substance can be just as effective. In some brands of diaper pails with baking soda filters, some of the baking soda will be sprinkled onto the new dirty diaper each time one is placed into the pail. It is recommended that either type of filter be changed every 30-90 days in order to continue to capture the odor molecules and reduce the smell in and around the diaper pail.

Diaper pails come in a variety of sizes. From a small, open bucket with individual bags for diapers to a large, round stainless steel can, this is an important feature to consider. While you want a can that will hold a lot of diapers, you also want a diaper pail that can fit into a designated space in the nursery or room in which you are storing the can. This is largely a matter of personal preference, as the size of the can does not dictate quality of performance.

While most diaper pails require special bags created just for that can, the design of some allow regular trash bags to be used. The custom bags tend to be more expensive than standard trash bags, but often have better odor absorbing capabilities. Additionally, the custom bags are designed to work within the mechanisms that keep the older dirty diapers away from the lid when it is opened to deposit a fresh diaper. Some bags are also designed to be cut and tied off as bags need to be taken and thrown away, which creates less waste than individual trash bags.

The true price of the diaper pail is calculated by considering not only the can itself, but also the cost of replacement bags and filters. A diaper pail may be relatively inexpensive, but if it requires custom bags and specific filters to be used and replaced regularly, those costs can add up. Some diaper pails can be used with generic versions or off-brands of the bags and filters, which tend to be less expensive and can help reduce your costs. You'll want to factor in the price of all of the components of the diaper pail prior to making your decision.

Most diaper pails are white in order to coordinate well with any nursery or room in which they are placed. However, some come in gray, taupe and even bright pink. If you prefer that your diaper pail has a bit more pizzazz, this may be a feature that weighs into your decision.

Once you've narrowed down the desirable features for your diaper pail, there are several questions that you should keep in mind as you evaluate your options. Be sure to read the reviews for the answers to the following questions

  • How well do diapers fit in when the bag is nearly full? Sometimes the mechanism separating the older diapers from the new does not work as well when the can gets close to full. This can lead to smells escaping and difficulty removing the full bag.
  • How easy is it to change the bag? The last thing that you want to deal after taking out a bag of dirty diapers is fight to put a new bag back in. A diaper pail with bags that are easily dropped in and fed through the mechanisms inside the can will save you precious moments while your baby is fussing.
  • How well does the diaper pail contain odors? Not all cans are created equal. Some cans may emit smells when the can is opened to dispose of another diaper, and others may have a detectable unpleasant odor even when closed. In addition to paying attention to the type of filter and mechanism for depositing diapers inside the pail, pay careful attention to the reviews.

Regardless of the diaper pail that you choose, you will be glad for the convenience and odor absorption it offers, especially with a new baby on hand.

Your Opinion Matters!


Diaper Pail Reviews & Additional Articles

New: Our editorial list of additional articles. We decided to gather informartion all around the internet and present you a list of helpful, external links to interesting reads about the best diaper pails and their reviews and guides.

Buying Guide So most new moms and dads invest in a diaper pail, a specialized bin that offers features to help contain the smell and allow you to conveniently complete  ...
0 persons liked this post.
helpful or   not helpful
Buying Guide Are you shopping for a diaper pail and overwhelmed by how many choices there are? Come read our diaper pail buying guide before you make your purchase. ...
0 persons liked this post.
helpful or   not helpful
Buying Guide Buyers Guide: As observed during my research Diaper Pails come with a number of features, below are my personal recommendations, what I  ...
0 persons liked this post.
Source: www.care.com
helpful or   not helpful
Best Jump to The Two Best Diaper Pails - The Best Diaper Pails: Ubbi vs Diaper Genie vs Diaper Dekor. There are 3 main diaper pails most people suggest:  ...
0 persons liked this post.
helpful or   not helpful
Buying Guide Ubbi Steel Diaper Pail is one of Amazon's best-selling diaper pails for a reason. It uses standard size trash bags no need to buy special refill bags. It's super  ...
0 persons liked this post.
helpful or   not helpful

Share this article:

Why sharing? Because we wrote this article for you, our readers. And not for search engines.

The Diaper Pails of Our Choice At a Glance

You're not convinced by the previous writings about diaper pails? Of course you can just choose by visual impression, that's why we present you all our chosen products at a single glance. A click on any image is enough to open an external link to the best offer we could find.

Tips from YouTube about Diaper Pail

Today - Munchkin STEP Diaper Pail Review

The Munchkin STEP Diaper Pail uses a step-lever and keeps bags sealed when the lid is open. Plus, the lavender-scented baking soda insert shields odors.

Disclaimer: This video is not from us, but we found it relevant enough to show it here.


Conclusion for this Diaper Pail Buying Guide in June 2019

Finally, we want to present you our rating criteria for our diaper pail comparison, so you can better understand and comprehend our recommendations and the rating process itself. Furthermore, we still ask you to keep your eyes open for short term deals in order to make some great bargains with diaper pail in 2019.

Published by on StrawPoll.com (last update on ).


12 of 16 readers found this article helpful.

Your opinion will appear tommorow, since this page is cached for 24 hours.

(Corresponds to a rating of 3.75 / 5)