Propane Smoker Reviews & Buying Guide 2019

Gregor

Hello, I'm Gregor and I put this site together. At first, you'll find an overview of recommended propane smokers, followed by a public poll and a general buying guide on propane smoker. Further down on this page, we do link to other well-written articles and reviews about propane smokers. At last, you'll be able to weight in your own opinion in the comments section.

If you choose to buy an item that I've chosen indepenently and recommended it here, I may earn commissions to support my efforts. For you, the price of the product will not change, I'm just saying this to be completely open with you.

1 0

The 10 Best Propane Smokers of Our Choice

Quick comparison in an overall view
Brand
Cuisinart
Dyna-Glo
Masterbuilt
Pit Boss Grills
Smoke Hollow
Char-Broil
Pit Boss Grills
Smoke Hollow
Smoke Hollow
Dyna-Glo
Name
COS-244 Vertical 36" Propane
DGY784BDP 36" Vertical LP
MB20050116 MPS 20B Patio-2-Portable
77435 Vertical
3616DEW 36-Inch Digital
Vertical Liquid Propane Gas
77425 2.5
44241G2 44-Inch Vertical
44-Inch Vertical Popane Gas Smoker
44241GW 44-Inch 2-Door
Signature Series DGSS1382VCS-D
Image
Cuisinart COS-244 Vertical 36
Cuisinart COS-244 Vertical 36" Propane Smoker, Black
Recommendation
Dyna-Glo DGY784BDP 36
Dyna-Glo DGY784BDP 36" Vertical LP Gas Smoker
Masterbuilt MB20050116 MPS 20B Patio-2-Portable Image
Masterbuilt MB20050116 MPS 20B Patio-2-Portable Propane Smoker, Black
Great Deal
Pit Boss Grills 77435 Vertical Image
Pit Boss Grills 77435 Vertical Lp Gas Smoker
Smoke Hollow 3616DEW 36-Inch Digital Image
Smoke Hollow 3616DEW 36-Inch Digital Electric Smoker with Window, Black
Char-Broil Vertical Liquid Propane Gas Image
Char-Broil Vertical Liquid Propane Gas Smoker
Pit Boss Grills 77425 2.5 Image
Pit Boss Grills 77425 2.5 Gas Smoker
Smoke Hollow 44241G2 44-Inch Vertical Image
Smoke Hollow 44241G2 44-Inch Vertical Popane Gas Smoker
Smoke Hollow 44241GW 44-Inch 2-Door Image
Smoke Hollow 44241GW 44-Inch 2-Door Propane Gas Smoker with Window
Dyna-Glo Signature Series DGSS1382VCS-D Image
Dyna-Glo Signature Series DGSS1382VCS-D Heavy-Duty Vertical Offset Charcoal Smoker & Grill
Rating
according to our criteria
92 %
in comparison
92 %
in comparison
90 %
in comparison
89 %
in comparison
87 %
in comparison
87 %
in comparison
85 %
in comparison
84 %
in comparison
82 %
in comparison
82 %
in comparison
Features
  • 5.45 square feet OF interior: The spacious 5.45 square foot interio...
  • Four 14 X 14-inch removable stainless steel shelves: Four stainless...
  • Built-in thermometer: Features easy-to-read thermometer on the fron...
  • A total of 784-square inch of cooking space for smoked flavored foo...
  • A 15,000 btu cast iron burner with an electronic push button igniti...
  • Porcelain enameled steel wood chip box with handles and lid for cho...
  • Two chrome-coated smoking racks
  • Built-in temperature gauge
  • Push-button ignition lights burner quickly and easily
  • Dual valve/dual burner system provides 100-350 temperature range
  • Three porcelain coated cooking grids 676 sq in
  • Stainless Steel burners - 13 500 btu total
  • New Digital Electronic Controls led Display Cooking Temp/Time Push ...
  • Tempered glass viewing window makes it easy to see the results with...
  • Large-capacity 3.0 cubic ft Cooking capacity external-loading wood ...
  • 595 square inch cooking surface with 3 chrome-plated cooking grates
  • 7,566 cubic inches of cooking space
  • Warming rack on top of smoker chamber
  • Dual valve/dual burner system provides 100-350 temperature range
  • Four porcelain coated cooking grids 884 sq in
  • Stainless Steel burners - 13 500 btu total
  • 6 5 cubic feet of cooking area capacity to easily handle enough foo...
  • 5 cooking grids: 2-standard cooking grids 2-jerky grids 1-rib rack ...
  • Dual door design with tempered glass viewing window
  • 6.5 cubic feet of cooking area capacity to easily handle enough foo...
  • 7 cooking grids: 4-standard cooking grids 2-jerky grids 1-rib rack ...
  • Dual door design with tempered glass viewing window.2 porcelain coa...
  • Features five chrome-plated cooking grates and a total cooking spac...
  • Heavy-Gauge Steel Body Construction The temperature gauge features ...
  • Cool-touch spring lid grip provides safer access to food
Offers
Show Offer
on Amazon.com
Show Offer
on Amazon.com
Show Offer
on Amazon.com
Show Offer
on Amazon.com
Show Offer
on Amazon.com
Show Offer
on Amazon.com
Show Offer
on Amazon.com
Show Offer
on Amazon.com
Show Offer
on Amazon.com
Show Offer
on Amazon.com

Results of the Straw Poll: Popular Propane Smokers

Every month, we analyze which products our readers like the most:

Which Propane Smokers Would You Buy Online? (July 2018)

  • 45.71 % (16 votes) Masterbuilt 20050614 Propane Smoker, 44-Inch, B...
  • 25.71 % (9 votes) Masterbuilt 20050211 Black Propane Smoker, 40-Inch
  • 14.29 % (5 votes) Smoke Hollow PS4415 Pro Series Propane Smoker, ...
  • 8.57 % (3 votes) Cuisinart COS-244 Vertical 36" Propane Smo...
  • 2.86 % (1 votes) Char-Broil Vertical Liquid Propane Gas Smoker
  • 2.86 % (1 votes) Smoke Hollow 38202G 38-Inch 2-Door Propane Gas ...
  • 0 % (0 votes) Masterbuilt 20050116 Portable Gas Smoker
  • 0 % (0 votes) Dyna-Glo DGY784BDP 36" Vertical LP Gas Smoker

35 total votes.

If you also want to vote on the best propane smoker, click here to view the poll.

Propane Smoker Buying Guide

Propane Smoker Image
Picture: COS-244 Vertical 36" Propane from Cuisinart

Propane gas smokers are cookers that use propane gas through a burner which is at the bottom of the unit to heat up multiple pans, that have wood and water, to produce steam. To help you know the temperature of the smoker from time to time and regulate it to the required temperature, they are fitted with temperature gauges and they also have vents which control the oxygen flow in the smoker. They are easy to manage and work with than charcoal smokers because they heat up fast and keep their temperature constant throughout the cooking process. They are cost-effective when compared to their electric counterparts and they allow you to cook using wood to give an excellent flavor and a luscious aroma.

With a gas smoker, your work is easy. You will only need to keep adding water and wood when they start running low and changing the propane gas tank if it runs out. You would probably need two tanks to ensure the replacement is easy and quick. It saves you the worries of finding your food cold or burnt since it is possible to set the temperature you desire and attend to other issues. A gas smoker is the best for people who don't have time to keep an eye on their smoker when cooking meat; be it brisket, a turkey or ribs.

There are things to consider when you go to purchase one, such as the features to help you in finding the best smoker for your home and their different types. Here are the various features you should take into account:

Cooking Space

The smoker's cooking space is a very fundamental feature due to the universal need to prepare a wide variety of food. If you need to cook sausages, a turkey, some veggies and a rack of ribs all in one meal, the smoker should not only have adequate space for all that, but it should also have multiple racks to help you arrange all your pans the way you want them to be.

The best type of a smoker for a person who wants to cook a lot of food at once is the Smoke Hollow 44 Inch Vertical Gas Smoker. Its cabinet is 44 inch, and it gives you room to smoke food without congesting it and facilitates easy removal of food from the smoker. It is easy for one to adjust the internal pans because it has two doors, without losing heat, and it is made of steel so heat loss is well catered for. It has its pros and cons, and they include;

Pros:

It has a large cooking area. It has two doors. It has adjustable clamps. It provides easy access to the water and wood pans.

Cons:

It has shelves that are difficult to maneuver.

Temperature Adjustment

Temperature is a vital feature to consider in cooking. You should make sure the smoker you are buying has enhanced controls for adjusting the smoking time and most importantly the temperature. Another way of controlling temperature is using a smart temperature probe, which helps you check the smoker's temperature using your mobile phone at any time.

The Masterbuilt 20050211 Black Propane Smoker is the best in this case because of its convenient temperature gauge. It is easy to monitor heat levels, and it is also huge with a locking door which helps keep the smoke in the smoker.

Pros:

It has one of the most accurate thermometers available on smokers. It has a push-button ignition which helps eliminate lighters and matches. It is insulated to ensure minimal heat loss and ensure consistent moisture in the smoker so that the flavor of the woods can permeate better into the meat. It has four adjustable and sturdy smoking racks for better support especially when it has to hold a lot of weight.

Cons:

It has small water pans thus a lot of frequent changing is needed. It has a small wood tray hence wood gets burned out fast, and a lot of constant checking is annoying. It has a single door design.

The Material's Quality

A smoker that is made from the best quality of material should mean that there will be no heat loss during cooking. The smoker should also not overheat and should be able to provide long-term services. A well-built smoker should have its doors, drawers, and racks functioning correctly thus improving the ease of operation and you would not have to fidget with it to get work done. Buying a cheap, poor quality smoker would become evident quickly.

Wood Chip Trays and Water Pans

You should buy a smoker that has sufficient wood trays and water pans which increases the ease of operation since you will not be continually refilling the unit. If the pans and trays are enough, the user will have more time to concentrate on other matters, and the smoker will not be a nuisance to him or her. A Smoke Hollow 38202G 38-Inch Propane Gas Smoker has large water pan and wood chip box, and it would be a good smoker for you. It also has a dual door design that helps users put in more wood and water without heat or smoke loss.

Pros:

It has a large chip box with a cover to prevent flare-ups and to put a lot of wood so there will be no constant refilling. It has a large water pan that holds a lot of water that would need a refill after some hours and constant monitoring is unnecessary. It is fuel efficient. It has two doors, and thus minimal heat loss.

Heat Distribution

This feature is connected to shape and design since the two determine how the temperature is going to be distributed to all parts of the smoker. When buying one, you should choose the smoker with the best heat distribution as it will save the amount of gas used and it would do its work efficiently. If heat is not well distributed, it will lead to some parts of the food being overcooked while others are not yet fully cooked.

Ease of Maintenance

You should make sure the smoker you buy has removable parts that you can clean with ease. If its parts are fixed, it will be tough to clean, and time wasting. The place you cook your food should always be clean to prevent hygiene-related illnesses. The Camp Chef Smoker 18 Inch Vault, is an easy to clean smoker which cooks your meat slow and low giving succulent meats, creating intense flavor and easy BBQ cooking.

Pros:

It is easy to clean, with removable racks. Heats to high temperatures of up to 500 degrees F and it handles baked foods like pizza. It has adjustable damper valves to facilitate better control of airflow. Efficient propane usage, making it cost effective.

Cons:

It has a single door design thus it has poor temperature control.

There are different groups of buyers for propane gas smokers, and they differ according to what they need the gas smokers for. The different kinds of groups are;

Those who want smokers for competition, parties or business - If you fall in this group of buyers, you will need a smoker that is portable, full and one that has a large capacity of smoking a lot of food and has enough room to smoke food without crowding it. The recommended smoker should have large water pans and wood chip trays too.

Those who want a smoker for family or hobby - For a family setting a small Traeger model should be the best choice. The smoker should be cost-effective in fuel usage, good in adjusting temperatures, should be of good quality for it to be long-lasting and easy to maintain.

Buyers who want a smoker for serious work need a cabinet version, or a larger barrel as their best choice.

Buying a cheap smoker may not give you the quality of services you are looking for. Thus, you should make sure you look for a smoker that has the features in this buying guide to ensure you buy the right smoker that is going to give you first-rate service. You should also consider the size of the gas smoker because it will help you create the barbecue feast you want.

Your Opinion Matters!

Helpful
Helpful
0
Surprised
Surprised
0
Thinking
Thinking
0
Disappointed
Disappointed
0

Propane Smoker Reviews & Additional Articles

New: Our editorial list of additional articles. We decided to gather informartion all around the internet and present you a list of helpful, external links to interesting reads about the best propane smokers and their reviews and guides.

Buying Guide Buyer guide to purchasing the most suitable propane or natural gas smokers in ...
0 persons liked this post.
helpful or   not helpful
Buying Guide Propane smokers don't require access to electricity as do pellet and electric smokers. This makes them more portable. And they are lightweight, although the   ...
0 persons liked this post.
helpful or   not helpful
Buying Guide Before you buy a smoker, it helps to understand how For the best results, there are a few guidelines to  ...
1 person liked this post.
Source: homus.org
helpful or   not helpful
Buying Guide Best Electric Smokers Buying Guide Reviews and Videos . Focus on your meat selection, using the best rubs, injections, and sauces, and of  ...
0 persons liked this post.
Source: bbqbeat.com
helpful or   not helpful
Buying Guide Consider a propane vertical smoker: convenient, easy to use and deliver to $500 will buy sturdier construction and more smoking capacity. ...
0 persons liked this post.
helpful or   not helpful

Share this article:

Why sharing? Because we wrote this article for you, our readers. And not for search engines.

The Propane Smokers of Our Choice At a Glance

You're not convinced by the previous writings about propane smokers? Of course you can just choose by visual impression, that's why we present you all our chosen products at a single glance. A click on any image is enough to open an external link to the best offer we could find.

Tips from YouTube about Propane Smoker

Today - Smoke Hollow Smoker Review

A brief overview and review of the Smoke Hollow Pro Series Propane Gas Smoker. The exact Smoker I have is this model: ...

Disclaimer: This video is not from us, but we found it relevant enough to show it here.

Comments

Conclusion for this Propane Smoker Buying Guide in July 2019

Finally, we want to present you our rating criteria for our propane smoker comparison, so you can better understand and comprehend our recommendations and the rating process itself. Furthermore, we still ask you to keep your eyes open for short term deals in order to make some great bargains with propane smoker in 2019.

Published by on StrawPoll.com (last update on ).

or

12 of 17 readers found this article helpful.

Your opinion will appear tommorow, since this page is cached for 24 hours.

(Corresponds to a rating of 3.53 / 5)