The Most Dramatic Love Island Season, Ranked

Voting rules: Choose the season you think is the most dramatic!

Updated on May 7, 2024 06:26

For avid followers of Love Island, the emotional rollercoasters and unexpected twists form the core of each season's appeal. Sorting out which season stands out as the most dramatic can be a tough call given the unique stories each one presents. This task becomes even more intriguing when viewers get the opportunity to weigh in with their opinions. By casting votes for the seasons they found most riveting, fans contribute to a live ranking that reflects the collective perspective on drama intensity. This dynamic voting process not only engages the community but also can guide new viewers toward the episodes that might hold the most appeal. Voting is straightforward, and seeing how individual rankings shift with each new vote adds an element of ongoing excitement.

What Is the Most Dramatic Love Island Season?

1

42
votes
Love Island UK Season 5 (2019)

Richard Cowles

This season had a lot of drama with the arrival of new contestants and the Casa Amor twist. It also had memorable moments like the breakup of Tommy and Molly-Mae, and the controversy surrounding the treatment of Lucie.
Love Island UK Season 5 (2019) is the fifth season of the popular reality dating show Love Island in the United Kingdom. It was created by Richard Cowles and is known for its intense and dramatic moments.

Season Number: 5

Air Date: June 3, 2019 - July 29, 2019

Location: Mallorca, Spain

Number of Contestants: 36

Host: Caroline Flack
2

20
votes
Love Island UK Season 3 (2017)

ITV Studios

This season had a lot of drama with the love triangle between Chris, Olivia, and Mike. It also had memorable moments like the arrival of the Casa Amor contestants, and the controversy surrounding the treatment of Camilla.
Love Island UK Season 3 (2017) was a highly dramatic and entertaining season of the popular reality TV show Love Island. It aired in the United Kingdom in 2017 and captivated audiences with its twists, turns, and passionate romances.

Number of contestants: 38

Location: Mallorca, Spain

Duration: 59 episodes

Winning couple: Amber Davies and Kem Cetinay

Breakout stars: Camilla Thurlow and Chris Hughes
3

34
votes
Love Island Australia Season 1 (2018)

Endemol Shine Australia

This season had a lot of drama with the arrival of new contestants and the coupling and recoupling process. It also had memorable moments like the controversy surrounding the treatment of Grant and Tayla.
Love Island Australia Season 1 (2018) was the first season of the Australian reality TV show, Love Island. It featured a group of singles who were isolated in a luxurious villa in Mallorca, Spain, with the goal of finding love and winning a cash prize.

Number of episodes: 30

Broadcast network: Nine Network

Original release: May 27, 2018 – July 5, 2018

Location: Mallorca, Spain

Prize money: AU$50,000
4

11
votes
Love Island UK Season 4 (2018)

Richard Cowles

This season had a lot of drama with the love triangle between Wes, Laura, and Megan. It also had memorable moments like the arrival of the Casa Amor contestants, and the controversy surrounding the treatment of Georgia.
Love Island UK Season 4 (2018) was a highly dramatic and popular season of the reality TV show Love Island. It aired in the summer of 2018 and captured the attention of millions of viewers.

Aired: June 4, 2018 - July 30, 2018

Location: Mallorca, Spain

Contestants: 38 initial contestants

Winners: Jack Fincham and Dani Dyer

Villa: Luxury villa in Mallorca
5

20
votes
Love Island USA Season 1 (2019)

Love Island USA

This season had a lot of drama with the arrival of new contestants and the coupling and recoupling process. It also had memorable moments like the breakup of Zac and Elizabeth, and the controversy surrounding the treatment of Yamen.
Love Island USA Season 1 (2019) is a reality TV show that follows a group of single men and women as they live together in a luxurious villa in Fiji, hoping to find love and win a cash prize. The season is known for its intense drama, shocking twists, and unexpected romances.

Genre: Reality TV

Year: 2019

Country: United States

Location: Fiji

Number of Episodes: 22
6

12
votes
Love Island UK Season 6 (2020)

ITV

This season had a lot of drama with the arrival of new contestants and the Casa Amor twist. It also had memorable moments like the controversy surrounding the treatment of Ollie, and the breakup of Shaughna and Callum.
Love Island UK Season 6 (2020) is considered one of the most dramatic seasons of the popular reality TV show Love Island. The season followed a group of young and attractive contestants as they lived together in a luxury villa in Mallorca, Spain, in the hopes of finding love and winning a cash prize. The intense love triangles, shocking recouplings, and unexpected twists made this season truly unforgettable.

Number of episodes: 49

Start date: January 12, 2020

End date: February 23, 2020

Number of contestants: 30

Winning couple: Paige Turley and Finn Tapp
7

3
votes
Love Island Australia Season 2 (2019)

ITV Studios Australia

This season had a lot of drama with the arrival of new contestants and the coupling and recoupling process. It also had memorable moments like the controversy surrounding the treatment of Vanessa and Matthew.
Love Island Australia Season 2 (2019) was a highly dramatic season of the popular reality TV show. It featured a group of attractive singles who competed to find love and win a cash prize. The season was filled with explosive arguments, unexpected twists, and intense romantic entanglements.

Premiere Date: October 7, 2019

Number of Episodes: 35

Location: Mallorca, Spain

Host: Sophie Monk

Winners: Anna McEvoy and Josh Packham
8

11
votes
Love Island UK Season 2 (2016)

Richard Cowles

This season had a lot of drama with the love triangle between Olivia, Chris, and Mike. It also had memorable moments like the arrival of the Casa Amor contestants, and the controversy surrounding the treatment of Zara.
Love Island UK Season 2 (2016) is one of the most dramatic seasons of Love Island. It follows a group of single contestants who are brought together in a luxurious villa in Mallorca, Spain, with the goal of finding love and winning a cash prize. The season is known for its intense drama, unexpected twists, and shocking re-couplings.

Premiere Date: May 30, 2016

Location: Mallorca, Spain

Number of Contestants: 32

Duration: 6 weeks

Winners: Cara De La Hoyde and Nathan Massey
9

2
votes
Love Island USA Season 2 (2020)

This season had a lot of drama with the arrival of new contestants and the coupling and recoupling process. It also had memorable moments like the controversy surrounding the treatment of Johnny and Cely, and the breakup of Carrington and Laurel.
Love Island USA Season 2 (2020) is the second season of the American version of the popular reality TV show Love Island. The season follows a group of single contestants who live in a stunning villa in Las Vegas, Nevada, as they pursue their romantic connections and compete for love and a cash prize.

Premiere Date: August 24, 2020

Location: Villa in Las Vegas, Nevada

Host: Arielle Vandenberg

Narrator: Matthew Hoffman

Number of Contestants: 22
10

7
votes
Love Island Australia Season 3 (2021)

Endemol Shine Australia

This season had a lot of drama with the arrival of new contestants and the coupling and recoupling process. It also had memorable moments like the controversy surrounding the treatment of Teddy and Faye, and the breakup of Millie and Liam.
Love Island Australia Season 3 (2021) is the third season of the Australian reality TV show where a group of contestants live together in a luxurious villa in the hopes of finding love. The season is known for its intense drama, shocking twists, and passionate romances.

Number of Episodes: 40

Duration: Approximately 8 weeks

Location: Gold Coast, Australia

Host: Sophie Monk

Prize Money: AU $50,000

Missing your favorite season?

Graphs

Discussion

Ranking factors for dramatic season

The intensity of relationships and breakups

The emotional connection between the contestants and the intensity of their breakups can drive the drama in a Love Island season. Look for strong, passionate connections and eventual heartbreaking splits.
Bombshell arrivals and exits

The arrival of new contestants and the elimination of fan-favorites can cause significant turmoil and upheaval in the villa's dynamics. A high number of bombshell entrances and surprise exits can contribute to making a season more dramatic.
Love triangles and betrayals

Love triangles and betrayals add complexity to the romantic relationships and are central to the drama. The number of love triangles, betrayals, and partner swaps can be one of the top factors in determining the drama level of a season.
Fights and confrontations

Disagreements and verbal spats between contestants can elevate the drama and tension. Look for seasons with a significant number of fights or particularly intense confrontations.
Challenges and plot twists

The challenges and unexpected plot twists in a season can increase the level of drama by eliciting strong emotions from the contestants or forcing them to make life-altering decisions.
The suspense and unpredictability

A season with numerous twists that keep the audience guessing and the contestants on their toes can be considered dramatic.
Emotional moments

Emotional confessionals or moments of vulnerability can add depth and drama to a season. Look for seasons where contestants share their personal struggles, past experiences, or have emotional breakthroughs.
The audience's emotional investment

Viewer engagement in the season, including strong emotions towards specific contestants or storylines, is an essential factor in evaluating a season's drama.

About this ranking

This is a community-based ranking of the most dramatic Love Island season. We do our best to provide fair voting, but it is not intended to be exhaustive. So if you notice something or season is missing, feel free to help improve the ranking!

Statistics

5941 views
147 votes
10 ranked items

Voting Rules

A participant may cast an up or down vote for each season once every 24 hours. The rank of each season is then calculated from the weighted sum of all up and down votes.

More information on most dramatic love island season

Love Island is a reality TV show that originated in the UK and has since been replicated in various countries around the world. The show follows a group of attractive singles who are isolated in a villa and must couple up with one another in order to avoid being eliminated. The drama comes from the constant shifting of alliances, the arrival of new contestants to shake things up, and the emotional rollercoaster of watching relationships form, break down, and sometimes even rekindle. Love Island has become known for its over-the-top drama, heartbreak, and scandalous moments, making it a guilty pleasure for millions of viewers worldwide. With so many seasons to choose from, it's no wonder that fans are constantly debating which one was the most dramatic.