The Most Difficult Position in Hockey, Ranked

Voting rules: Choose the position you think is the most difficult!

Updated on Apr 30, 2024 06:25

In the fast-paced world of hockey, every position holds its unique challenges and skills, each demanding a different set of abilities from the players. Identifying the most demanding role can spark interesting debates among enthusiasts and experts alike. This ranking seeks to capture the collective opinion and provide insights on what makes each position uniquely tough. By casting your vote, you contribute to a dynamic tally that reflects the views of a diverse fan base. This not only fuels engaging discussions but also offers a deeper appreciation of the skills and pressures associated with each position. Your input is crucial in shaping a well-rounded perspective on the intricacies of hockey.

What Is the Most Difficult Position in Hockey?

1

54
votes
Goaltender

The goaltender is arguably the most difficult position in hockey due to the immense pressure and responsibility of preventing goals. They need to be quick, agile, and have lightning-fast reflexes to stop pucks that are traveling at speeds of over 100 miles per hour. They also need to have a strong mental game to stay focused and make split-second decisions.
The goaltender, commonly referred to as the goalie, is the position in hockey responsible for defending the team's net and preventing the opposing team from scoring goals. The goaltender is the last line of defense and plays a crucial role in the success of the team.

Equipment: Goaltenders wear specialized equipment including a mask, chest protector, leg pads, glove, and blocker to protect themselves from shots and facilitate making saves.

Skillset: Goaltenders require a unique skillset that includes exceptional hand-eye coordination, agility, quick reflexes, and the ability to read the game and anticipate the opposition's moves.

Positioning: The goaltender must have excellent positioning, knowing the optimal angles and depth in the net to cut down the shooting angles of the opposing players.

Glove Saves: Goaltenders make saves using their glove hand, snatching the puck out of the air, which requires precise hand-eye coordination and quick reflexes.

Butterfly Style: Many goaltenders utilize the butterfly style, where they drop to their knees and spread their leg pads to cover the bottom of the net, providing maximum net coverage.
2

18
votes
Defenseman

Defensemen are responsible for protecting their team's net, which means they need to be strong skaters, have excellent positioning, and be able to read plays quickly. They also need to be able to make smart passes and contribute to the team's offense when the opportunity arises.
A defenseman is a key position in ice hockey, responsible primarily for defending against opposing players and protecting their team's goal. They play a critical role in both offensive and defensive strategies, providing support to the forwards while also preventing the opposing team from scoring.

Position: Defense

Primary Responsibilities: Defending against opposing players, protecting the team's goal

Defensive Skills: Stick checking, body checking, shot blocking, positioning

Offensive Skills: Outlet passes, joining the rush, setting up plays from the blue line

Physicality: Strong physical presence and ability to win battles along the boards
3

22
votes
Center

Centers are responsible for both offense and defense, which means they need to be strong skaters, have excellent stickhandling skills, and be able to make quick decisions on the ice. They also need to be able to win faceoffs and control the flow of the game.
The center is one of the most crucial positions in American football. Positioned at the center of the offensive line, the center serves as the starting point of every offensive play. Their primary responsibility is to hike or snap the ball to the quarterback, initiating the play. Additionally, they play a vital role in blocking the defensive players on the opposing team and creating gaps for the running backs.

Position: Center

Primary responsibility: Snapping the ball to the quarterback

Secondary responsibilities: Blocking defensive players, creating gaps for running backs

Position on the field: In the middle of the offensive line

Importance for the team: Critical for initiating offensive plays
4

8
votes
Forward

Forwards are responsible for scoring goals, which means they need to be fast, have excellent stickhandling skills, and be able to shoot accurately. They also need to be able to work well with their linemates and create scoring opportunities for their team.
The forward position in hockey is one of the most crucial and challenging positions on the ice. As the offensive powerhouse of the team, forwards play a vital role in creating scoring opportunities and contributing to their team's success. They are responsible for driving the play forward, coordinating attacks, and putting the puck in the net.

Skating Ability: Forwards must possess excellent skating ability to maneuver quickly around the ice and keep up with the pace of the game.

Stickhandling: Given the need to maintain control of the puck while navigating through opponents, forwards must have exceptional stickhandling skills.

Shooting Accuracy: Forwards must have a keen eye for the net and the ability to shoot accurately to score goals.

Offensive Awareness: Having a high hockey IQ is crucial for forwards, as they need to read plays, anticipate opportunities, and make quick decisions to create scoring chances.

Defensive Responsibility: While their primary focus is on offense, forwards also have defensive responsibilities, including back-checking and supporting the team's defensive efforts.
5

16
votes
Power forward

Cam Neely

Power forwards are a type of forward who are known for their physicality and ability to play a strong, physical game. They need to be strong skaters, have excellent puck control skills, and be able to dominate in the corners and along the boards.
The power forward is a key position in hockey, known for its unique combination of physicality, scoring ability, and playmaking skills. This role was popularized by the legendary hockey player Cam Neely.

Physicality: Possesses great size, strength, and toughness to engage in physical battles along the boards, in the corners, and in front of the net.

Scoring ability: Exhibits a strong ability to score goals, often through a combination of net-front presence, accurate shooting, and opportunistic scoring.

Playmaking skills: Displays exceptional passing ability and hockey IQ to set up teammates with scoring opportunities.

Forechecking: Utilizes aggressive forechecking to hound opponents and disrupt their breakout plays.

Net-front presence: Excels at establishing position in front of the net, creating screens, deflections, and scoring chances.
6

9
votes
Enforcer

Enforcers are a type of player who are known for their physicality and ability to fight on the ice. They need to be strong skaters, have excellent fighting skills, and be willing to stand up for their teammates.
The Enforcer is a position in hockey that refers to a player whose primary role is to physically intimidate opponents and protect teammates. They are known for their aggressive and fearless play style.

Physicality: Enforcers typically excel in physical attributes such as size, strength, and toughness.

Fighting Skills: Enforcers are skilled fighters and are often involved in on-ice altercations to protect their teammates and set the tone of the game.

Intimidation: Their mere presence on the ice is often enough to dissuade opponents from taking liberties with their teammates.

Protecting Teammates: Enforcers act as enforcers of the unwritten rules of hockey, ensuring that opponents face consequences for crossing the line.

Leadership: Enforcers tend to possess strong leadership qualities, rallying their team and motivating their teammates through their actions.
7

12
votes
Penalty killer

Penalty killers are players who are responsible for defending their team when they are short-handed. They need to be strong skaters, have excellent positioning, and be able to read plays quickly to prevent the opposing team from scoring.
The penalty killer is a crucial position in hockey that involves players who are tasked with defending the team while it is short-handed due to a penalty. Their ultimate goal is to prevent the opposing team from scoring a power-play goal.

Skating ability: Possessing exceptional skating skills enables penalty killers to quickly cover space and pressure the opposition.

Stick handling: Having good stick handling skills allows penalty killers to disrupt passes and clear the puck effectively.

Defensive positioning: Maintaining proper defensive positioning and understanding the game flow are crucial for penalty killers to anticipate plays and intercept passes.

Shot blocking: Being willing to sacrifice one's body by blocking shots is an essential aspect of penalty killing.

Physicality: Possessing the ability to deliver hits and engage in physical battles is important for penalty killers to gain possession and disrupt the opposition's set up.
8

11
votes
Faceoff specialist

Faceoff specialists are players who are responsible for winning faceoffs, which can be crucial to controlling the flow of the game. They need to have excellent hand-eye coordination, be able to read their opponent's movements, and be able to win faceoffs consistently.
The 'Faceoff specialist' is a crucial position in hockey, primarily responsible for winning faceoffs and gaining possession of the puck at the start of play or after a stoppage. This position requires high levels of skill, strategy, and quick reflexes.

Expertise in faceoff techniques: Requires extensive knowledge and practice in different faceoff strategies, including stick positioning, hand placement, and body leverage.

Exceptional hand-eye coordination: Ability to track the puck and react swiftly to changes in direction during faceoffs.

Strong physical strength: Important for gaining leverage and winning battles against opponents during faceoffs.

Quickness and agility: Enables the specialist to react rapidly to faceoff situations and effectively maneuver on the ice.

Tactical awareness: Understanding game situations and adapting faceoff strategies accordingly, including adjusting positioning based on offensive or defensive needs.
9

4
votes
Captain

Captains are players who are responsible for leading their team on and off the ice. They need to have strong communication skills, be able to motivate their teammates, and be able to make quick decisions under pressure.
The Captain is a leadership role in ice hockey, responsible for leading the team both on and off the ice. The captain is often considered the most difficult position in hockey due to the extensive responsibilities and pressures associated with the role.

Leadership: The captain must provide guidance, inspiration, and motivation to teammates.

Communication: The captain acts as a liaison between players, coaches, and officials, ensuring effective communication.

Decision Making: The captain makes critical decisions on the ice, such as calling plays and determining strategies.

Team Representation: The captain represents the team in official functions, media interviews, and public appearances.

Discipline: The captain helps maintain discipline among teammates, encouraging teamwork and accountability.
10

6
votes
Rookie

Rookies are players who are new to the NHL and are still learning the ins and outs of the game. They need to be able to adapt quickly to the fast-paced, physical nature of the game, and be able to handle the pressure of playing in front of large crowds and media attention.
The Rookie is a term used in hockey to refer to a player who is in their first season in the National Hockey League (NHL) or any other professional league. This position is considered one of the most difficult in hockey due to various factors such as the transition from amateur to professional play, higher competition, physicality, mental pressure, and the need to quickly adapt to the fast-paced nature of the game.

Experience: The player is in their first season in the NHL or any other professional league.

Transition: The player needs to adjust from amateur to professional play, facing higher competition and more physicality.

Adaptability: Quickly adapting to the fast-paced nature of the professional game is crucial for a rookie.

Competitive Pressure: Rookies face immense pressure to perform and make a lasting impression during their first season.

Learning Curve: Rookies must learn the nuances of professional play, understand team strategies, and improve their skills.

Missing your favorite position?

Graphs

Discussion

Ranking factors for difficult position

Physical demands

The level of strength, speed, agility, endurance, and coordination required for each position should be considered.
Tactical and strategic demands

Each position requires a specific understanding of the game, as well as the ability to make quick decisions and adapt to various situations on the ice.
Responsibility for offensive and defensive play

The ability to contribute to the attack, as well as to help defend against the opposition, is essential for all positions, but some positions may have more responsibilities in either offensive or defensive situations.
Mental strength and leadership

Some positions may require a higher level of mental toughness and the ability to lead and guide teammates during a game.
Technical skills

Each position requires specific technical skills, like shooting, passing, skating, and stickhandling, that can be difficult to master and require consistent practice.
Decision-making and anticipation

The ability to quickly assess situations, predict your opponents' moves, and make fast decisions is crucial in hockey, especially for positions that are consistently involved in the play.
Communication and teamwork

The ability to effectively communicate with teammates and work together to execute plays and strategies is essential for all positions.
Defensive awareness and positioning

The ability to read plays and maintain proper positioning in defensive situations is vital for preventing goals and limiting scoring opportunities.
On-ice vision and spatial awareness

A player's ability to see the entire ice and be aware of their surroundings plays a significant role in their effectiveness at any position.
Adaptability and versatility

Some positions may require players to adapt to different roles and responsibilities throughout a game, depending on game situations and strategies. Skills like adapting to different lines and matchups, as well as having a diverse skillset, can be valuable in evaluating the difficulty of a position.

About this ranking

This is a community-based ranking of the most difficult position in hockey. We do our best to provide fair voting, but it is not intended to be exhaustive. So if you notice something or position is missing, feel free to help improve the ranking!

Statistics

1802 views
159 votes
10 ranked items

Voting Rules

A participant may cast an up or down vote for each position once every 24 hours. The rank of each position is then calculated from the weighted sum of all up and down votes.

Trendings topics

Don't miss out on the currently trending topics of StrawPoll Rankings!

More information on most difficult position in hockey

Ice hockey is a fast-paced and physically demanding sport, and every position on the ice comes with its own unique set of challenges. However, some positions are widely considered to be more difficult than others. The debate over which position is the most difficult in hockey has been ongoing for years, and it's a topic that generates a lot of discussion among players, coaches, and fans alike. In this article, we'll explore some of the factors that make certain positions more challenging than others and try to determine which position truly deserves the title of the toughest in hockey.