The Most Difficult Rugby Position, Ranked

Voting rules: Choose the position you think is the most difficult!

Updated on May 4, 2024 06:25

Determining which position holds the title of most challenging in rugby is not only an intriguing question but also a contentious debate among enthusiasts and players alike. Each role comes with its own unique set of physical demands, strategic importance, and skill requirements. This makes for a diverse range of opinions on which position truly presents the greatest challenge on the field. By participating in this engaging website, users have the opportunity to cast their votes and influence the live rankings. This democratic approach allows the rugby community to voice their perspectives, building a comprehensive list that reflects the collective experience and wisdom of its members. The outcome can provide new insights and perhaps even settle some old disputes within the community.

What Is the Most Difficult Rugby Position?

1

27
votes
Prop

The prop is responsible for providing power in the scrum and needs to be strong and durable. They also need to be able to run and tackle effectively.
The prop is a physically demanding position in rugby that requires strength, power, and excellent technique. They are responsible for supporting the scrum and providing a solid foundation for the team. Typically, there are two props on the team, known as loosehead and tighthead props.

Physicality: Props are usually the largest players on the team, with strong builds and powerful frames.

Strength: Props must possess immense upper body strength to engage in the scrum and withstand the opposing pack's pressure.

Technique: Good prop players are skilled in scrummaging technique, with the ability to bind with the hooker and maintain a low, stable body position.

Scrummaging: Props anchor the scrum and provide stability and power to drive the scrum forward or resist the opposition's push.

Ball-carrying: Props are expected to make effective ball carries and gain meters by running hard and breaking tackles.
2

30
votes
Hooker

The hooker is also part of the front row and is responsible for hooking the ball back in the scrum. They also need to be able to throw accurately in the lineout.
The hooker is a position in rugby that requires physical strength and technical skills. The hooker is located in the front row of the scrum, between the two props. They are responsible for winning the ball during scrums and throwing the ball into lineouts. The position got its name from the initial motion of 'hooking' the ball back with their feet.

Physical Strength: A hooker must have good upper body strength to compete in scrums and to make effective tackles.

Throwing Accuracy: The hooker must have exceptional throwing accuracy to deliver the ball accurately during lineouts.

Scrum Technique: A hooker needs to have a solid scrum technique to withstand the immense pressure exerted during scrums and provide a stable platform for the team.

Ball Retrieval Speed: The hooker must have the ability to quickly dig the ball out of scrums and rucks to maintain possession and initiate attacks.

Mobility: Although positioned close to the scrum, a hooker needs to be agile and have good speed to contribute in loose play and support attacking moves.
3

24
votes
Flanker

The flanker is responsible for tackling, winning turnovers, and supporting the scrum. They need to be quick, agile, and have a high level of fitness.
The Flanker is a challenging and physically demanding position in rugby. As a member of the forward pack, the Flanker plays a crucial role in both the offensive and defensive aspects of the game. The primary duties of a Flanker include supporting the scrum-half, securing possession, and disrupting the opposition's play. It requires a combination of strength, speed, agility, and tactical awareness to excel in this position.

Position Number: 6 or 7

Location: Between the locks and the number 8

Role in the Scrum: Bind the scrum with the locks

Role in the Lineout: Lift and support the jumpers

Primary Skills: Tackling, rucking, ball carrying
4

24
votes
Scrum-half

The scrum-half is responsible for distributing the ball from the scrum and rucks. They also need to be able to kick and make quick decisions.
The Scrum-half is a key position in the sport of rugby. They are the link between the forwards and the backs, playing a crucial role in organizing and controlling the team's attack. The Scrum-half is responsible for distributing the ball quickly and accurately from the breakdowns, as well as orchestrating plays and making game-changing decisions.

Passing Skills: The Scrum-half must possess exceptional passing skills, being able to deliver accurate and fast passes in various situations.

Decision Making: They need to make quick decisions on whether to pass, run, or kick the ball, based on the current game situation.

Communication: Effective communication with teammates is essential for the Scrum-half to coordinate attacks and defensive strategies.

Vision: They must have excellent vision and awareness of the game, being able to spot gaps and opportunities to exploit.

Agility and Speed: The Scrum-half needs to be agile and quick, able to change direction rapidly and evade defenders.
5

20
votes
Fly-half

The fly-half is responsible for directing the team's attack and making strategic decisions. They also need to be able to kick accurately and make quick passes.
The fly-half in rugby is a key position, also referred to as the number 10. They act as the playmaker and strategic leader of the team, responsible for making decisions and orchestrating the team's attacking plays.

1: Excellent tactical awareness

2: Good kicking skills for field position and goal-kicking

3: Accurate passing abilities

4: Strong decision-making skills under pressure

5: Ability to read the game and exploit gaps in the defense
6

17
votes
Fullback

The fullback is responsible for catching high balls, kicking, and providing cover defense. They also need to be able to run with the ball and make tackles.
The fullback is a defensive position in soccer that is primarily responsible for guarding against attacking players and preventing them from scoring goals. They are typically positioned on the left and right sides of the defensive line, just ahead of the goalkeeper. Fullbacks play a crucial role in supporting the team's defense and initiating offensive plays by making accurate passes to their teammates. They need to possess a combination of defensive and attacking skills to be effective on the field.

Defensive Skills: Fullbacks must possess excellent defensive skills, including tackling, intercepting passes, and blocking shots.

Good Pace and Stamina: Fullbacks need to have good speed and stamina to keep up with the opposition's attackers and cover the defensive flanks throughout the match.

Tactical Awareness: They must have a strong sense of positioning, maintaining the defensive line, and reading the game to anticipate and intercept passes.

Passing Ability: Fullbacks should be able to make accurate short and long passes both defensively and to contribute to the team's attacking movements.

Crossing Skills: They should have the ability to deliver accurate crosses into the opposition's penalty area to create goal-scoring opportunities.
7

9
votes
Lock

The lock is responsible for jumping in the lineout and providing power in the scrum. They also need to be able to tackle and run effectively.
The lock in Rugby is a key position in the forward pack and is regarded as one of the most physically demanding positions on the field. Locks are typically the tallest and strongest players in the team, responsible for providing power and stability in the scrums, lineouts, and general play.

Physicality: Height and strength are paramount in order to compete in scrums, lineouts, and breakdowns.

Scrummaging: The lock plays a crucial role in the scrum, providing stability and drive to support the front row.

Lineout: The lock is a primary jumper in lineouts, responsible for contesting opposition throws and securing possession for their team.

Ball-Carrying: Locks often have the physical presence to break through defensive lines and gain territory with powerful runs.

Tackle Technique: Strong tackling ability is essential in order to bring down larger opponents effectively.
8

7
votes
Clément Bucco-Lechat · CC BY-SA 3.0

Number 8

William Webb Ellis

The number 8 is responsible for controlling the ball at the back of the scrum and providing power in the loose. They also need to be able to run and tackle effectively.
The Number 8 position in rugby is a highly demanding and physically challenging role. It is typically designated to a forward player and is situated at the back of the scrum. The Number 8's primary responsibilities include gaining possession of the ball, driving forward during scrums, making crucial tackles, and providing a link between the forwards and the backs during open play.

Physicality: Requires exceptional strength and endurance to withstand the physicality of the game.

Ball Control: Ability to control the ball at the base of the scrum and during pick-ups and carries.

Leadership: Often acts as a leader on the field, providing support and direction to teammates.

Tackling: Must possess strong tackling skills to bring down opponents effectively.

Running Ability: Good running agility and speed, allows for effective ball-carrying and gaining meters.
9

8
votes
Centre

The centre is responsible for both attacking and defending. They need to be able to pass, run, and tackle effectively.
The centre is a key position in rugby, typically occupied by two players who play in the midfield. The centre is responsible for both attacking and defensive duties, serving as a link between the forwards and the backs. They play a crucial role in creating opportunities for scoring and shutting down opposition attacks.

Good handling skills: Centres must have excellent ball-handling abilities, as they are involved in passing, offloading, and creating line breaks.

Strong running ability: Centres need to possess speed, power, and agility to break through the defensive line and gain territory.

Defensive skills: Centres must be strong tacklers and have good defensive positioning to prevent the opposition's attack.

Decision making: Centres need to make quick and accurate decisions, such as whether to pass, kick, or run with the ball.

Communication: Centres must effectively communicate with teammates, both in attack and defense, to coordinate strategies and make split-second decisions.
10

6
votes
Wing

The wing is responsible for scoring tries and providing cover defense. They need to be fast, agile, and have good ball skills.
The Wing is one of the most challenging positions in Rugby. It is a backline position that requires excellent speed, agility, and evasive abilities. The primary role of the Wing is to score tries by running with the ball and outpacing the opposition's defense, usually positioned on the outer edges of the backline.

Speed: Wings should possess exceptional speed to outrun opponents.

Agility: They must have superb agility to swiftly change directions and evade tacklers.

Evasion Skills: Excellent side-step, swerve, and sidestep skills are crucial for avoiding defenders.

Acceleration: The ability to quickly accelerate to top speed is essential.

Finishing Ability: Wings must have a knack for finishing try-scoring opportunities.

Missing your favorite position?

Graphs

Discussion

Ranking factors for difficult position

Physical demands

Rugby positions require different levels of strength, speed, agility, and stamina. Consider how physically demanding each position is based on the specific skills and attributes required.
Tactical understanding

Every position has a specific role to play in terms of tactics and strategy. Evaluate how complex the tactical requirements of each position are and how much responsibility is placed on the player.
Technical skills

Some positions demand a higher level of specific technical skills, such as kicking, passing, or scrummaging. Assess the level of skill required for each position and how challenging it is to master those skills.
Decision-making

Rugby is a fast-paced and dynamic game, and players need to make split-second decisions under pressure. Consider the level of decision-making required in each position and the potential impact those decisions have on the game's outcome.
Leadership and communication

Some positions involve more leadership and communication than others, whether it's directing play, organizing teammates, or motivating them to perform at their best. Examine how important these qualities are in each position and how difficult they are to master.
Adaptability

Rugby players must be able to adapt to changing game situations and make adjustments based on the opposition's tactics. Evaluate how flexible players in each position need to be and how challenging it is to adapt quickly and effectively.
Defensive responsibility

Protecting against the opposition's attacks is crucial in rugby, and some positions carry more defensive responsibility than others. Consider how difficult it is to maintain defensive discipline and make crucial tackles in each position.
Scrum and lineout responsibilities

Assess the importance of scrum and lineout expertise for each position, taking into account the technical skills and tactical understanding required to excel in these set-pieces.
Mental toughness

Rugby is a physically and mentally demanding sport, and players in certain positions may be under more pressure or scrutiny than others. Evaluate the mental resilience required to cope with these challenges and perform consistently at a high level.
Experience

Lastly, consider how much experience typically contributes to a player's ability to excel in a specific position and whether a position is more difficult for inexperienced players.

About this ranking

This is a community-based ranking of the most difficult Rugby position. We do our best to provide fair voting, but it is not intended to be exhaustive. So if you notice something or position is missing, feel free to help improve the ranking!

Statistics

2629 views
158 votes
10 ranked items

Voting Rules

A participant may cast an up or down vote for each position once every 24 hours. The rank of each position is then calculated from the weighted sum of all up and down votes.

More information on most difficult rugby position

Rugby is a physically demanding sport that requires strength, endurance, agility, and tactical skill. Each position on the field has its unique set of responsibilities, but some positions are more challenging than others. In general, the forwards are the larger, more powerful players who are responsible for winning possession of the ball and creating momentum, while the backs are smaller, quicker players who are primarily responsible for scoring tries and defending against the opposition's attacks. However, when it comes to determining the most difficult rugby position, opinions vary. Some argue that the hooker position is the toughest, as they are responsible for throwing the ball into the lineout, scrummaging, and tackling. Others believe that the prop position is the most demanding, as they are responsible for providing the power in the scrum and holding up the weight of the opposition's front row. The fly-half position is also often considered to be one of the most challenging, as they must be able to make quick decisions under pressure and dictate the flow of the game. Ultimately, the most difficult rugby position will depend on the individual player's strengths and weaknesses, as well as the strategies and tactics employed by their team. Regardless of position, rugby requires physical and mental toughness, teamwork, and a deep understanding of the game.