The Most Reliable Propane Furnace, Ranked

Voting rules: Choose the propane furnace you think is the most reliable!

Updated on May 2, 2024 06:55

In the chill of winter, the reliability of a propane furnace can mean the difference between a cozy home and a cold one. Homeowners often struggle to choose a dependable model that will efficiently and safely heat their homes during the frosty months. A comprehensive list of reliable furnaces, ranked by public opinion, can greatly simplify this decision. By participating in the voting process, users contribute to the accurate ranking of these essential home appliances. This collective input ensures that the list reflects real-world performance and user satisfaction. Moreover, for anyone considering a new purchase, this ranked list offers a curated starting point, influenced by the experiences and preferences of a wide audience.

What Is the Most Reliable Propane Furnace?

1

86
votes
Lennox ML180UH

Lennox

This propane furnace is highly reliable due to its durable construction and advanced control system, which ensures optimal performance and energy efficiency.
The Lennox ML180UH is a highly reliable propane furnace designed to provide consistent and efficient heating. It is built with quality materials and advanced technology to ensure optimal performance.

AFUE Rating: 80%

Heating Capacity: 45,000 - 135,000 BTU/h

Energy Efficiency: ENERGY STAR certified

Heat Exchanger Material: Aluminized Steel

Ignition System: Hot Surface
2

29
votes
Carrier Performance 96

Carrier Corporation

With its two-stage heating system and advanced control board, the Carrier Performance 96 propane furnace offers reliable and efficient operation.
The Carrier Performance 96 is a highly reliable propane furnace that offers efficient and consistent heating performance. It is designed and manufactured by Carrier Corporation, a leading HVAC company with a reputation for quality and innovation.

AFUE Rating: 96%

Heating Input: 40,000 - 120,000 BTUH

Fuel Type: Propane

Heat Exchanger Material: Stainless Steel

Variable Speed Blower: Yes
3

36
votes
Trane XC95m

Trane

The Trane XC95m is a high-efficiency propane furnace that is known for its reliability and durability. It features a variable-speed motor and advanced control system for optimal performance.
The Trane XC95m is a high-efficiency propane furnace that offers exceptional comfort and reliability. It is designed to deliver consistent warmth and save energy while operating quietly.

AFUE Efficiency: up to 97.3%

Stage Modulation: Variable-speed

Heat Exchanger: Aluminized Steel

Blower Motor: Variable-speed ECM

Burner Type: Multi-port In-shot
4

30
votes
Rheem R801P

Rheem

The Rheem R801P propane furnace is a reliable and affordable option that offers high-efficiency heating and advanced diagnostics for easy maintenance.
The Rheem R801P is a highly reliable propane furnace designed for residential heating purposes. It is known for its durability, efficiency, and exceptional performance.

BTU Input: up to 100,000 BTU

BTU Output: up to 80,000 BTU

Energy Efficiency: Up to 80% AFUE (Annual Fuel Utilization Efficiency)

Heat Exchanger: Aluminized steel

Ignition System: Direct spark ignition
5

20
votes
Goodman GMVC96

Goodman Manufacturing Company

The Goodman GMVC96 propane furnace is a reliable and efficient option that features a two-stage heating system and advanced control board for optimal performance.
The Goodman GMVC96 is a highly reliable propane furnace that offers exceptional performance and energy efficiency. It is designed to provide consistent warmth and comfort in residential settings.

BTU Capacity: up to 100,000 BTU

Efficiency: 96% AFUE

Heat Exchanger: Stainless steel tubular

Multi-Speed Blower Motor: Variable-speed ECM

Quiet Operation: Low-noise operation
6

13
votes
American Standard Platinum 95

American Standard

The American Standard Platinum 95 propane furnace is a reliable and high-efficiency option that features a variable-speed motor and advanced diagnostics.
The American Standard Platinum 95 is a highly reliable propane furnace ideal for providing efficient and consistent heating in residential and light commercial spaces. It is designed to deliver maximum comfort while minimizing energy consumption and operating costs.

AFUE Rating: Up to 96%

Heating Capacity: 60,000-120,000 BTU

Modulating Burner: Yes

Heat Exchanger: Stainless steel

Ignition System: Hot surface
7

5
votes
Bryant Evolution Plus 95s

Bryant

The Bryant Evolution Plus 95s propane furnace is a reliable and energy-efficient option that features a modulating gas valve and advanced control system for optimal performance.
The Bryant Evolution Plus 95s is a highly reliable propane furnace designed to provide efficient heating for residential spaces. It is a top-of-the-line model in Bryant's Evolution Plus series, offering advanced features and technologies for optimum performance and comfort.

Efficiency: Up to 95% AFUE

Heating Capacity: 40,000 - 120,000 BTU

Variable Speed Blower: Yes

Modulating Gas Valve: Yes

Multi-Poise Design: Yes
8

4
votes
York Affinity YP9C

York

The York Affinity YP9C propane furnace is a reliable and efficient option that features a modulating gas valve and advanced control system for optimal performance.
The York Affinity YP9C is a high-efficiency propane furnace known for its reliable performance and advanced features. It is designed to provide efficient heating while offering improved comfort and control.

Annual Fuel Utilization Efficiency (AFUE): up to 98%

Heating capacity: 60,000 - 120,000 BTU

Modulating burner: adjusts heat output in small increments for precise temperature control

Two-stage heating: provides consistent and even heat distribution

Variable-speed ECM blower motor: ensures quiet operation and enhanced energy efficiency
9

1
votes
Heil QuietComfort VC 97

The Heil QuietComfort VC 97 propane furnace is a reliable and high-efficiency option that features a two-stage heating system and advanced control board for optimal performance.
The Heil QuietComfort VC 97 is a propane furnace designed for reliable and efficient heating. It offers advanced features for enhanced comfort and convenience, making it a top choice for residential heating solutions.

AFUE Rating: up to 97%

Variable-Speed Blower Motor: adjusts airflow for optimal comfort

Two-Stage Gas Valve: provides efficient fuel utilization

Convertible to Liquid Propane (LP) Gas: ensures flexibility in fuel source

Advanced Noise Reduction: delivers quiet operation
10

6
votes
Coleman Echelon CP9C

Coleman

The Coleman Echelon CP9C propane furnace is a reliable and efficient option that features a modulating gas valve and advanced control system for optimal performance.
The Coleman Echelon CP9C is a highly reliable propane furnace that provides efficient and consistent heating for residential and commercial spaces. Designed with advanced technology and durable construction, this furnace ensures optimal performance and energy savings.

Efficiency: Up to 98% AFUE

Heat Output: 60,000 - 120,000 BTU

Modulating Gas Valve: Allows for precise temperature control

Variable-Speed Blower Motor: Enhances comfort and reduces noise

Aluminized Steel Heat Exchanger: Ensures maximum heat transfer and durability

Missing your favorite propane furnace?

Graphs

Discussion

Ranking factors for reliable propane furnace

Brand Reputation

The reputation of the brand that produces the propane furnace is key. Brands with a long-standing reputation for quality and reliability may be more trustworthy than lesser-known brands.
Warranty

A reliable propane furnace should come with a comprehensive warranty, which can give you peace of mind and protection against future repair costs.
Installation

Proper installation of the furnace is key to its reliable and efficient operation. Look for a reputable contractor who has experience installing propane furnaces.
Maintenance

Regular maintenance of the furnace is also critical for reliable operation. Look for a furnace that is easy to maintain or comes with a maintenance plan to ensure it lasts for many years without frequent breakdowns.
Price

While price should not be the only factor considered when choosing a reliable propane furnace, it is still an essential factor to consider. Choose a furnace that is within budget, yet also meets the criteria mentioned above.

About this ranking

This is a community-based ranking of the most reliable propane furnace. We do our best to provide fair voting, but it is not intended to be exhaustive. So if you notice something or Propane furnace is missing, feel free to help improve the ranking!

Statistics

2246 views
227 votes
10 ranked items

Voting Rules

A participant may cast an up or down vote for each Propane furnace once every 24 hours. The rank of each Propane furnace is then calculated from the weighted sum of all up and down votes.

More information on most reliable propane furnace

Propane furnaces are a popular heating solution for many households due to their reliability, efficiency, and affordability. Propane is a versatile fuel that can be used for heating, cooking, and even powering generators. Propane furnaces work by burning propane gas to produce heat, which is then distributed throughout the home through a duct system. When it comes to selecting the most reliable propane furnace, there are a few factors to consider. The first is the furnace's efficiency rating, which is measured by its annual fuel utilization efficiency (AFUE) score. The higher the AFUE score, the more efficient the furnace is at using propane to heat your home. Another important factor to consider is the furnace's size and heating capacity. A furnace that is too small for your home will struggle to keep up with your heating needs, while a furnace that is too large will waste energy and money. It's important to choose a furnace that is appropriately sized for your home to ensure optimal performance and efficiency. Finally, it's important to choose a reputable brand and model of propane furnace. Look for furnaces that have high customer ratings and positive reviews, as well as those that come with a warranty or guarantee to protect your investment. With the right propane furnace, you can enjoy reliable, efficient heating for years to come.