Safest Ice Cube Trays for Your Home: Health & Safety Tips

We have researched 13 ice cube trays for you.

When it comes to enjoying a refreshing beverage at home, few things are as essential as ice. However, the safety and quality of your ice are often overlooked, hinging on the unassuming ice cube tray nestled in your freezer. In an era where health and safety are paramount, selecting the right ice cube tray has become more important than ever.

Our guide spotlights a variety of ice cube trays that prioritize safety while delivering performance and convenience. From materials that avoid harmful chemicals to designs that ensure easy release of ice, we've carefully curated choices that aim to elevate your home experience seamlessly. Each tray has been scrutinized under stringent criteria to ensure that only the safest options for you and your loved ones make it to your kitchen.
To simplify the price comparison, we determine the prices for the individual articles on Amazon, Ebay and other shops and link the offers via partner links where applicable. This means that we receive a commission if you buy something that we recommend - the price does not change for you.

What to Look for in Safest Ice Cube Trays

Important criteria

  • BPA-free
  • Food-grade materials
  • Easy release mechanism
  • Durable construction
  • Dishwasher safe
  • Proper lid to prevent spillage

1.) Material Safety

When purchasing ice cube trays, it is essential to consider the material from which they are made. BPA-free plastic or food-grade silicone are the safest options as they do not release any harmful chemicals into the ice. Silicone trays are flexible, making it easier to remove the ice, and often withstand extreme temperatures without cracking or deforming. Stainless steel is another safe choice, being durable and resistant to rust or corrosion. Avoid trays with unclear labeling on material safety to prevent potential health risks.

2.) Ease of Use

An ideal ice cube tray should combine safety with ease of use. Silicone trays with a push bottom allow for easy removal of the ice cubes, reducing the risk of breaking them. Trays that come with a lid can prevent spills and protect the ice from absorbing freezer odors. Consider whether the tray shape fits well in your freezer and if it is stackable, which is a convenient space-saving feature. Additionally, trays with unique shapes or larger sizes might require more freezer space, so assess your needs accordingly.

3.) Cleaning and Maintenance

To ensure longevity and hygiene, select ice cube trays that are easy to clean. Many silicone and plastic trays are dishwasher safe, which simplifies the cleaning process. However, trays with intricate designs or individual cube slots might be harder to clean thoroughly. Also, periodically check for signs of wear or discoloration, as these can indicate it is time to replace the tray. Regular maintenance and proper cleaning will prevent mold and bacteria build-up in your ice trays.

The Safest Ice Cube Trays of our Choice

Our Pick
Ruidake Silicone Ice Molds 2 Inch
Ruidake Silicone Ice Molds 2 Inch
Model: Cube 4 Type/Color: Fruit green Size: 1.95IN*1.95IN
  • Create four giant 1.95*1.95-inch ice cubes.
  • Big ice cubes melt slowly for taste preservation.
  • Removable lid prevents leaks and odors.
  • Stackable trays save space in the freezer.
  • Ice cubes suitable for various beverages and uses.
  • Healthy, washable, non-stick silicone design.
  • Effortless ice cube release for any occasion.
  • Responsive customer service available via Amazon.
$ 4.29 *
View
on Amazon
Search
on Ebay
2
Kitch Ice Tray Easy Release White Ice Cube Trays
Kitch Ice Tray Easy Release White Ice Cube Trays
Type/Color: White Size: (2 Pack - 32 Cubes)
  • Made in the USA with food grade materials
  • Includes 2 ice cube trays, each makes 16 cubes
  • Flexible and durable - twist to release cubes
  • Stackable in freezer without sticking
  • BPA free and dishwasher safe
$ 8.99 *
View
on Amazon
Search
on Ebay
3
Amytor Ice Cube Trays 3 Pack
Amytor Ice Cube Trays 3 Pack
Type/Color: Blue-3Pack Size: 3 Pack
  • Made of food-grade silicone and PP materials
  • 100% BPA Free and safe to use
  • Boil the trays before first use for safety
  • Suitable for bars and home use
  • Great for cooling cocktails and other beverages
  • Perfect for making ice cubes or adding juice, fruit, jelly, etc.
  • Easy to clean and store with removable lids
  • TPE material at the bottom ensures easy ice removal
  • No more ice cubes sliding off the counter
  • 3 pack trays provide a total of 42 ice cubes
  • Trays can be stacked together to save freezer space
$ 8.99 *
View
on Amazon
Search
on Ebay
4
VITEVER 3 Pack Large Ice Cube
VITEVER 3 Pack Large Ice Cube
Type/Color: Black Gray Blue Size: Medium
  • Silicone Cube Trays are BPA free.
  • Trays can contact food directly.
  • Fill molds with water, juice, food.
  • 24 ice cubes with 2-inch molds.
  • 3 packs freeze 24 cubes total.
  • Comes with tong and plastic container.
  • 9x6 inch container to store cubes.
  • Long lasting ice stays icy longer.
  • Perfect for ice drinks and alcohol.
  • Versatile for whiskey, bourbon, cocktails, juice.
  • Great gift for someone who loves iced drinks.
$ 14.99 *
View
on Amazon
5
OXO Good Grips Ice Cube Tray
OXO Good Grips Ice Cube Tray
Type/Color: White Size: 2 Pack
  • Lid slides to release ice cubes selectively
  • Lid allows efficient stacking
  • Cover prevents odors absorption
  • Rounded ice cube shape for easy release
  • Dishwasher safe and BPA free
$ 10.99 *
View
on Amazon
Search
on Ebay
6
LYDTICK Ice Cube Tray with Lid and Bin
LYDTICK Ice Cube Tray with Lid and Bin
Model: IceCube Type/Color: Green 21-Ice Size: Large
  • New design for easy ice release
  • Quick filling with no spills
  • Serve ice without touching with hands
  • Safe materials made of food-grade PP
  • Wide applications for various beverages and snacks
$ 16.99 *
View
on Amazon
7
Jrisbo Silicone Ice Cube Tray
Jrisbo Silicone Ice Cube Tray
Type/Color: Red Size: 10 x 3.8 x4.7 inches
  • Effortless ice cube release with soft bottom
  • Stackable trays with removable lids for space-saving
  • Made of food-grade silicone and PP material
  • Suitable for making adult and baby food
  • Easy to use, just fill and freeze
  • 4 trays, each making 14 cubes (total 56)
  • Approximately 1.8*1.3*0.9 inches per cube
  • BPA-free and durable for long-term use
  • Suitable for home, bar, party, etc.
  • Prompt customer support with a 24hr response
$ 9.98 *
View
on Amazon
8
Aibirui Silicone Ice Cube Tray with Lid,9
Aibirui Silicone Ice Cube Tray with Lid,9
Size: 1.3 inch Ice Cubes
  • Easy release design with wider bottom design
  • Soft silicone won't break with extended freezing
  • Separate compartments for effortless twist release
  • Safe, durable, BPA-free and odor-free silicone material
  • Covered lid prevents odors absorption in the fridge
  • Unique compact design with frosted textured lid
  • New lid structure prevents spills and excess freezing water
  • Each lid has a handle for easy removal
  • DIY your favorite ice cubes with fruits or foods
  • Suitable for a wide range of beverages and foods
  • Perfect for use at home, dormitories, parties
  • Dishwasher safe for easy cleaning after use
$ 9.99 *
View
on Amazon
9
PHINOX Ice Cube Tray with Lid and Bin
PHINOX Ice Cube Tray with Lid and Bin
Model: CTCJ012 Type/Color: Green Size: 3-tier
$ 23.99 *
View
on Amazon
10
Gorilla Grip Stackable Ice Cube Tray and Bin Set
Gorilla Grip Stackable Ice Cube Tray and Bin Set
Type/Color: Red
  • Convenient 3 in 1 design for ice
  • Set includes 1 bin, 2 trays, scoop
  • Each tray makes 28 cubes
  • Release ice easily with twist tray
  • Materials are BPA-free and dishwasher safe
  • Space-saving, stackable design for freezer
$ 13.99 *
View
on Amazon
Search
on Ebay
11
DclobTop Stackable Round Ice Cube Tray
DclobTop Stackable Round Ice Cube Tray
Type/Color: Blue Size: 1.2 in/ 99 balls
  • Stackable design maximizes freezer efficiency.
  • Storage container keeps ice cubes organized.
  • Ice trays for freezer create ice balls.
  • Materials ensure odor-free ice cubes.
  • Trays guarantee effortless ice cube removal.
  • 3-Tier Ice Trays make 99 round ice balls.
  • Ideal for cocktails, beverages, and coffee.
  • Suitable for guest houses, parties, and bars.
$ 9.99 *
View
on Amazon
Search
on Ebay
12
FDDAI Small Ice Cube Tray for Freezer:
FDDAI Small Ice Cube Tray for Freezer:
Type/Color: Green Size: Small
  • Easy to stack ice cube trays in freezer
  • Non-slip handles for twisting ice cube trays
  • Made of durable food-grade polypropylene material
  • Non-stick surface for quick ice release
  • Package includes 4 ice trays, bin, and scoop
  • Creates 0.7-inch hexagon-shaped ice cubes
  • Larger surface area cools drinks quickly
  • Multipurpose ice cube tray for home, parties, bars
$ 15.99 *
View
on Amazon
Search
on Ebay
13
WIBIMEN Mini Ice Cube Trays
WIBIMEN Mini Ice Cube Trays
Type/Color: Black Size: 4Pack/0.55In
$ 18.39 *
View
on Amazon
* All prices incl. VAT, plus shipping if applicable. Prices, delivery times and costs may change in the meantime. The selection of products was made independently of the manufacturer and without any claim to completeness. All links to products are external partner links through which we may receive compensation. All information without guarantee.

Top Picks: Safest Ice Cube Trays for All Needs

Eco-Conscious Shoppers
For those prioritizing environmentally friendly options, our selection of ice cube trays is ideal. Discover trays that align with your green lifestyle without compromising on safety.
Families with Small Children
We understand the importance of safety for families. Our recommended ice cube trays are designed with kids in mind—simple to use and made with safety as a priority.
Entertainment Hosts
Hosts looking to impress will find our recommended selection of ice cube trays perfect for any occasion. These trays provide safe, reliable ice without sacrificing style.
Budget Buyers
Affordable yet safe, our curated ice cube trays offer peace of mind for those on a budget. Enjoy the perfect balance between cost and safety with these options.

Questions You Might Ask

When choosing an ice cube tray, consider the material (silicone, plastic, metal), size and shape of the ice cubes, whether it has a cover to prevent spillage and odors, ease of release, stackability for storage, and whether it is dishwasher safe for easy cleaning.
Silicone trays are generally more flexible, making it easier to pop out individual cubes without twisting or cracking the tray. They are also more durable and can withstand extreme temperatures without getting brittle. Plastic trays are usually less expensive but can crack over time and may retain odors.
Yes, ice cube trays can be used for a variety of purposes, including freezing herbs, making small chocolate or candy batches, storing small items like jewelry or screws, or making frozen baby food portions.
Trays with covers are worth considering as they prevent spillage when transferring to the freezer, keep out freezer odors, and allow for stacking of multiple trays to save space.
Metal ice cube trays are durable, have a classic look, and can create clearer ice cubes. They can also transfer cold more efficiently, potentially freezing water faster. However, they may be more difficult to twist and release ice cubes compared to silicone trays.

Currently Active Poll

How to Choose the Safest Ice Cube Trays

Are you looking to chill your beverages without compromising on safety or style? Selecting the right ice cube tray is essential for ensuring your ice is clean, taste-free, and easy to use. In this guide, we'll explore what makes an ice cube tray safe, durable, and convenient so that you can make an informed decision for your home.

Material Matters: Safe Options for Ice Trays

When it comes to materials, not all ice cube trays are created equal. Silicone and food-grade stainless steel are top choices for safety and flexibility. Silicone trays are soft, which makes popping out ice cubes a breeze without the fear of cracking. Moreover, they're dishwasher-safe and resistant to odors and stains.
Stainless steel options are durable, resistant to rust, and effortlessly sleek. They can also withstand higher temperatures if you ever need to use them for baking or freezing liquids besides water. Avoid trays made from cheap plastics that can contain BPA or other harmful chemicals which may leach into water.

Size and Shape: Getting the Best Fit

The size and shape of the ice cubes you desire should influence your tray selection. Some trays produce large cubes that melt slower, ideal for spirits and cocktails. If you prefer quick-chilling beverages, consider trays with smaller compartments. Remember that the shape of the ice can range from traditional cubes to fancy spheres and novelty designs.
Take into account the size of your freezer and how much space you have available. Bulky trays may offer bigger cubes but can be a problem if freezer space is tight. Compact and stackable trays can save space and still provide ample ice.

Ease of Use and Maintenance

A safe ice cube tray must also be user-friendly. See if the tray is flexible enough to release cubes without a struggle, and whether it comes with a lid to avoid spills and contaminants. Lids can also be a boon for stacking and prevent freezer odors from infiltrating your ice.
Maintenance is key for safety. Look for trays that won't absorb smells and are easy to clean. Ideally, they should be dishwasher-friendly to ensure they can be sanitized regularly and effectively. A good quality tray shouldn't degrade or change in appearance after multiple wash cycles.

Brand Reputation and Certifications

A reliable brand can often be a shortcut to a safe and quality product. Research brands that specialize in kitchenware and read customer reviews. Positive feedback can indicate a worthy investment, while persistent complaints might raise a red flag.
To be extra sure about safety, check for ice cube trays that have been certified by relevant authorities. For example, FDA approval and BPA-free labels are important indicators of food-safe materials that won't harm your health.

Hands-on Reviews and Recommendations from Discussion-Boards

In this section, we've carefully curated a collection of links that we believe are the most informative and reliable on the topic of the safest ice cube trays. These links are categorized into four distinct groups: professional reviews, forum discussions, Reddit threads, and instructional videos. Each category offers a diverse perspective and detailed analysis to help you make an informed decision about the safest ice cube trays to use.
Jun 30, 2023 — Consumer Reports made a lot of ice in trays made from plastic, silicone, and stainless steel to find the best ice cube trays.
Read more | Helpful?
Aug 25, 2008 — Ice cube trays take up a lot of room in the freezer. The Iceorb makes ice cubes in a vertical tray -- and does a few other things as well.
Read more | Helpful?
Feb 24, 2010 — The Covered Ice Cube Tray is made from dishwasher-safe plastic. It makes a surprising amount of difference in your ice cubes, such as keeping ...
Read more | Helpful?
Jun 4, 2015 — How do you make the best ice cubes? Appliance Science looks at how to make clean, clear ice in any refrigerator with a freezer compartment.
Read more | Helpful?
Aside from the plastic twisty ones that came with the fridge/ freezer, we have some other cheap and nasty twisties which are OK in a pinch (eg if ...
Read more | Helpful?
Silicone is good for big whiskey cubes though. I recommend OXO, the ones with the blue covers (that are unneeded). Best trays I've used and...
Read more | Helpful?
I for the love of god can't find any good ice cube trays. I don't really have a preference on material as long as it's of good quality, ...
Read more | Helpful?
My dilemma, I'm looking for ice cube trays not made of plastic, but also not made in China. ... best I can recommend is to just get a silicon ice...
Read more | Helpful?
A friend recommended the OXO tray, and it's pretty good. Easy to fill, easy to get single cubes out, no after taste.
Read more | Helpful?
Top 5: Best Ice Cube Tray Reviews 2022 [Tested & Reviewed]
YouTube Logo
Top 5 Best Ice Cube Tray Reviews 2022 Product Link : ☄️1. Tovolo Sphere Ice Molds - Set of 2 Global Prices

Share This Article

More about Kitchen Appliances on StrawPoll