Most Comfortable Eye Mask for a Perfect Night's Sleep

We have researched 13 eye masks for you.

Are you tired of tossing and turning at night, unable to block out that annoying sliver of light from the street lamp outside? Perhaps you're in search of that elusive aid for a good night's rest. Whether you're a frequent traveler, a daytime sleeper, or simply someone seeking a deeper sense of nighttime tranquility, finding the right accessory to enhance your sleep quality can be a game-changer.

In our quest for the ultimate sleep experience, we've tested and analyzed a variety of options to bring you the crème de la crème. Comfort, material, design, and effectiveness have all been taken into account. The search for the perfect solution to uninterrupted slumber may just be over. Let us guide you through a curated selection, poised to help you drift into dreamland with ease.
To simplify the price comparison, we determine the prices for the individual articles on Amazon, Ebay and other shops and link the offers via partner links where applicable. This means that we receive a commission if you buy something that we recommend - the price does not change for you.

What to Look for in Most Comfortable Eye Masks

Important criteria

  • Adjustable strap
  • Contoured design
  • Lightweight material
  • Breathable fabric
  • Memory foam padding
  • Soft lining

1.) Material Comfort

When purchasing the most comfortable eye mask, the material is a critical factor to consider. Look for soft, breathable fabrics such as silk or cotton which are gentle on the skin and reduce the likelihood of irritation during prolonged wear. Avoid rough materials or those to which you may have allergies, as these can cause discomfort or even disrupt your sleep. Additionally, consider masks with padding that can contour to the face, as this can enhance comfort and improve light blocking.

2.) Fit and Adjustability

The fit of an eye mask is essential for both comfort and effectiveness in blocking light. An adjustable strap is desirable to ensure that the mask can be tailored to your head size and shape, preventing it from being too tight or too loose. Look for masks with a strap that does not catch hair or create pressure points. Some masks also feature contoured designs or recessed areas for the eyes to minimize pressure on the eyelids and lashes and allow for eye movement during REM sleep.

3.) Weight and Thickness

Consider the weight and thickness of the eye mask. A lightweight mask may be more comfortable for prolonged wear and less likely to leave marks on your face. However, a slightly weighted mask can provide a gentle pressure that some find relaxing, mimicking the sensation of a comforting hand. Thickness can also play a role in how effectively the mask blocks out light and its overall feel — too thin, and it may let light in, too bulky, and it might be uncomfortable for sleeping, especially if you are a side sleeper.

4.) Ease of Maintenance

Look for an eye mask that is easy to clean, as hygiene is important when an item is in contact with the sensitive skin of your face. A machine-washable mask is preferable for convenience, but the care instructions should be checked to ensure the mask's durability. Some materials might require hand washing or specific cleaning products. Regular cleaning will prevent the build-up of oils and skin cells, which could lead to skin irritation or breakouts.

The Most Comfortable Eye Masks of our Choice

Our Pick
Kitsch Blackout Satin Sleep Mask
Kitsch Blackout Satin Sleep Mask
Model: 6240 Size: 1 Count (Pack of 1)
  • Premium quality satin fabric for a luxurious feel
  • Promotes healthy skin by not absorbing moisture
  • Optimal comfort with smooth, silky fabric and elastic strap
  • Gentle on lashes and brows, preventing frizz and damage
  • Fashionable designs to suit your style
$ 17.99 *
on Amazon
on Ebay
Bedtime Bliss Sleep Mask | Eye Mask for Sleeping Men
Bedtime Bliss Sleep Mask | Eye Mask for Sleeping Men
Model: BTB01 Type/Color: Black Size: 1 Count (Pack of 1)
  • 100% blackout design suitable for all sleepers
  • 3D breathable design with free sleep ear plugs
  • Patented design for total darkness and noise reduction
  • Lightweight and comfortable, doesn't touch the eyes
  • Ideal for travel, naps, and blocking out noise
  • Suitable for all face shapes with adjustable strap
$ 7.99 *
on Amazon
on Ebay
LitBear Sleep Mask for Side Sleeper Women Men
LitBear Sleep Mask for Side Sleeper Women Men
Model: LB-EB01 Type/Color: Black Size: 1 Count (Pack of 1)
  • No light leakage with adaptive hollow nose bridge
  • Completely blocks light for side sleepers with 15° tilt angle
  • Allows free eye blinking with 3D contoured cup eye sockets
  • Comfortable and soft with smooth cooling silk fabric
  • Adjustable elastic buckle strap for any sleeping position
  • Hand washable with water below 40℃ / 104℉
$ 12.23 *
on Amazon
on Ebay
Price Pick
Jersey Slumber 100% Silk Sleep Mask For A Full Night's Sleep
Jersey Slumber 100% Silk Sleep Mask For A Full Night's Sleep
Model: jer-001 Type/Color: Black Size: 1 Count (Pack of 1)
  • Sleep deeply anywhere, anytime
  • Increase REM sleep naturally
  • Blink freely & sleep in any position
  • Adjustable soft elastic strap
  • Uninterrupted sleep with no pills or supplements
$ 7.99 *
on Amazon
on Ebay
leeken 3D Sleeping Eye Mask
leeken 3D Sleeping Eye Mask
Type/Color: Mesh-black Size: 1 Count (Pack of 1)
  • Blocks lights effectively, creating total darkness
  • Made of soft and breathable sport fabric
  • Hemming design ensures durability and quick drying
  • Wide and deep eye space for comfort
  • Adjustable strap fits all head sizes
$ 13.99 *
on Amazon
FACEMOON Weighted Eye Mask for Sleeping
FACEMOON Weighted Eye Mask for Sleeping
Type/Color: Grey Size: 1 Count (Pack of 1)
  • Weighted relaxes, aids sleep faster and deeper.
  • Blocks light completely with 3D contour design.
  • Padded strap, ear-friendly, fits various head sizes.
  • High-quality memory foam, washable and breathable material.
  • Skin-friendly cotton surface, pressure-free on the nose.
  • Care instructions for washing and preserving shape.
$ 11.99 *
on Amazon
FengXinZi Sleep Mask, 3D Deep Contoured
FengXinZi Sleep Mask, 3D Deep Contoured
Type/Color: Pink Size: 1 Count (Pack of 1)
  • Comfortable, Breathable: High-density memory foam sleep mask.
  • No light leakage: Uniquely designed to block light completely.
  • No Eye Pressure: Deeper space with no eye pressure.
  • Adjustable: One size fits all with adjustable strap.
  • Top Handmade Technology: Precise cutting and hand sewing.
  • Note: Hand wash with water below 40°C.
$ 13.98 *
on Amazon
Mavogel Cotton Sleep Eye Mask
Mavogel Cotton Sleep Eye Mask
Type/Color: Grey Size: 1 Count (Pack of 1)
  • New ergonomic design to fit all head sizes.
  • Blocks light effectively with adjustable bending cartilage.
  • Soft wing design prevents mask movement and pressure.
  • Super breathable with 5 layers of comfortable fabric.
  • Handmade with tight, clean, and smooth seams.
$ 9.99 *
on Amazon
MZOO Sleep Mask for Side Sleeper Women Men
MZOO Sleep Mask for Side Sleeper Women Men
Model: sm034 Type/Color: Side Black Size: 1 Count (Pack of 1)
  • 100% Blackout
  • Fits facial contours, no light leakage
  • Suitable for Side Sleeper
  • Ultra-thin side design, no pressure on temple
  • Comfortable for Any Sleeping Position
  • No Pressure on Eyes
  • Wider and deeper eye space
  • Soft and Breathable
  • Upgraded design with air hole
  • Reduce pressure on the face
  • One Sizes Fits All
  • Fully adjustable buckle strap
  • Easy to adjust, does not catch hair
  • Gift Set
  • Ideal for meditation, Yoga, travel, napping
  • Perfect for parents, lovers, friends
$ 22.99 *
on Amazon
YIVIEW Sleep Mask for Side Sleeper
YIVIEW Sleep Mask for Side Sleeper
Model: EMK001 Type/Color: Black Size: 1 Count (Pack of 1)
  • Total blackout with upgraded nose cutout and 3D contours
  • Ultra-fit thin sides for maximum comfort in all positions
  • Wider 3D eye cups with zero pressure on eyes
  • Soft, breathable memory foam with air hole design
  • Fully adjustable strap for a comfortable fit
  • Hand wash before use. Do not bleach or iron.
$ 12.99 *
on Amazon
Manta Sleep Mask - 100% Light Blocking Eye Mask
Manta Sleep Mask - 100% Light Blocking Eye Mask
Model: SLEEP Type/Color: Gray Size: 1 Count (Pack of 1)
  • True blackout for 100% light blockage
  • No eye pressure with adjustable, deep eye cups
  • Customize position and angle for perfect fit
  • Soft, breathable, and durable materials
  • Designed for deepest-possible sleep in any environment
  • Ideal for midday nappers, travelers, sensitive sleepers, night shift workers
  • Includes mask, ear plugs, and wash bag
  • Machine washable
  • Money-back guarantee
$ 35.00 *
on Amazon
on Ebay
WAOAW Sleep Mask, Eye Mask for Sleep
WAOAW Sleep Mask, Eye Mask for Sleep
Model: YZ1 Type/Color: Black Size: 1 Count (Pack of 1)
  • 3D contoured sleep mask with excellent light blocking
  • Gentle contours for comfortable and dark sleep
  • Large surface area and recessed eye cavities
  • Wider eye space for your eyelids
  • Adjustable elastic straps won't catch your hair
  • Breathable cover feels soft and smooth on skin
  • Includes earplugs and travel pouch
  • Ideal for travels, meditation, yoga, napping, insomnia
$ 18.99 *
on Amazon
on Ebay
ZGGCD 3D Sleep Mask for Side Sleeper
ZGGCD 3D Sleep Mask for Side Sleeper
Type/Color: Purple Size: 1 Count (Pack of 1)
  • Latest 3D Design: Ergonomic eye mask design.
  • Deeper contours for free eye movement.
  • No pressure on eyes, protects eye makeup.
  • Perfect for all sleepers, including side sleepers.
  • Ultra-thin sides with 15° tilt angle.
  • Minimize pressure on temples when sleeping.
  • Blocks 100% of light, covers nose area.
  • Lightweight and breathable with air hole design.
  • Skin-friendly memory foam lining for comfort.
  • Top quality fabric, doesn't stain sheets.
  • Fit all sizes with adjustable head strap.
  • Durable and softer material, no hair damage.
  • Ideal for travel, napping, meditation, shift work.
  • 12 months warranty and 365 days support.
$ 13.99 *
on Amazon
on Ebay
* All prices incl. VAT, plus shipping if applicable. Prices, delivery times and costs may change in the meantime. The selection of products was made independently of the manufacturer and without any claim to completeness. All links to products are external partner links through which we may receive compensation. All information without guarantee.

Top Eye Masks for Supreme Comfort

Travel Enthusiasts
For those who are always on the go, finding the right eye mask can make all the difference. Look for options that provide a perfect balance of softness and light-blocking capabilities to help you rest better.
Sleep Perfectionists
If a good night's sleep is your priority, the right eye mask can help you achieve that. Consider masks that contour to your face shape while ensuring minimal pressure on your eyes.
Night Shift Workers
For those working irregular hours, a high-quality eye mask is essential. Find eye masks designed to provide maximum darkness and comfort to fit your unique schedule.
Sensitive Skin Types
If comfort and skin health are your concerns, seek out eye masks with hypoallergenic materials. These should offer a gentle touch while still being effective at blocking out light.

Questions You Might Ask

When choosing an eye mask, look for materials that are comfortable and gentle on your skin. Silk and satin are popular for their smoothness, helping prevent skin irritation and wrinkles. Cotton is breathable and a good option for those who prefer natural fibers. For blocking out light effectively, ensure the material is sufficiently thick or has a blackout layer.
Contoured eye masks are designed to fit the shape of your face, offering space for your eyes to move freely while you sleep. They are typically better for avoiding pressure on your eyelids and lashes, and can be more effective at blocking out light completely. Flat eye masks, on the other hand, offer simplicity and are often more lightweight, but they may not block light as effectively and can put more pressure on your eyes.
For travel, consider an eye mask with features like a travel pouch for easy storage, adjustable straps to fit various head sizes, and noise-canceling properties if you're sensitive to sound. An eye mask that can completely block out light and is made of memory foam can also make your travel more comfortable by adapting to your face shape.
Yes, hypoallergenic eye masks are available for those with allergies. Look for masks made of natural, non-irritating materials such as organic cotton or bamboo. Avoid eye masks with synthetic fragrances or dyes that could trigger allergic reactions.
The strap design is crucial for comfort and fit. Adjustable straps allow you to customize the fit to your head size, reducing the risk of it being too tight or too loose. Elastic straps offer flexibility, but they can wear out over time. Consider a mask with a Velcro or clip closure if you want a longer-lasting option or have a preference for how the mask secures around your head.

Currently Active Poll

How to Choose the Most Comfortable Eye Mask

In the quest for the perfect slumber, a comfortable eye mask can be your best ally. Whether it's blocking out light pollution in the city or finding respite during travel, a good eye mask is a simple, affordable sleep accessory that can significantly improve your rest. In this guide, we'll explore essential considerations to ensure you select an eye mask that's not just cozy but also conducive to a peaceful night's sleep.

Material Matters: Picking the Right Fabric

The fabric of your eye mask can make or break your comfort level. Look for soft, natural materials like silk or cotton that are gentle on the skin and promote breathability. Silk, in particular, is hypoallergenic and can be beneficial for those with sensitive skin, while cotton is ideal for absorbing any excess oils or sweat, keeping you comfy all night.
For those who prefer synthetic options, there are high-tech fabrics designed to regulate temperature and wick away moisture. These materials are perfect if you find yourself getting hot during the night. Whichever material you choose, make sure it feels comfortable against your face and doesn’t cause irritation or overheating.
Additionally, consider if the material is machine washable or requires special care. An eye mask that's easy to clean will likely last longer and provide a fresh, hygienic surface for your delicate eye area every time you use it.

Strap Comfort: Securing the Perfect Fit

The strap of an eye mask is crucial in ensuring it stays in place without applying pressure on your head or ears. Adjustable straps with a buckle or Velcro can be tailored to your head size for a snug, yet comfortable fit. However, make sure that any adjustment mechanism doesn't press into your skin when you're lying down.
Elastic bands are another common choice, but they can stretch out over time or be too tight, leading to potential discomfort or headaches. For side sleepers, look for an eye mask with a strap design that doesn't have bulky fittings or clasps that could dig into your head when you lay on your side.
For the ultimate luxury experience, some eye masks come with padded or contoured straps that provide extra cushioning. These can be particularly beneficial for those needing to wear an eye mask for prolonged periods, such as on long-haul flights.

Weight and Pressure: Finding Your Sweet Spot

The weight of an eye mask can contribute significantly to its comfort level. Some people prefer the lightest mask possible, barely feeling it on their face, while others benefit from the gentle pressure of a weighted mask, which can provide a soothing sensation akin to a comforting hug for your eyes.
If you're interested in a weighted eye mask, consider one filled with microbeads or natural grains. These materials conform to the shape of your face and are effective for relaxation. Remember, the goal is to feel a light, distributed pressure and not a burden on your eyes or forehead.
It's important to test the fit and feel of the eye mask to make sure it doesn't put undue pressure on your eyes. Your eyelashes should be able to move freely without touching the mask, and there shouldn't be any strain on the eye itself. This is imperative for REM sleep, where eye movement plays a key role in high-quality rest.

Block Out the Light: Ensuring Total Darkness

A primary function of an eye mask is to block out light, which can be detrimental to sleep quality. To ensure total darkness, look for an eye mask with a contoured design that fits snugly around your nose and cheekbones, preventing light leakage. A poorly fitting eye mask can let in light from below, which may disrupt your sleep cycle.
Some eye masks feature side panels that extend to cover more of your face, further reducing the chance of light penetration. Also, check the opacity of the material. Thinner materials may allow some light through, so opt for thicker, denser fabrics or layers that guarantee dark conditions for your slumber.
For the ultimate light-blocking effect, try to find a mask that wraps around to cover a part of the temples. This not only helps in creating a pitch-black environment but also helps keep the mask in place throughout the night, regardless of your sleep position.

Additional Features: The Extras That Enhance

Beyond the basics, eye masks may come with additional features that cater to specific needs. For instance, aromatherapy eye masks incorporate relaxing scents that can help induce sleep or reduce stress. Lavender is a popular choice, known for its calming properties.
For those prone to dry eyes or who wish to reduce puffiness, a gel mask that can be cooled in the refrigerator may offer therapeutic benefits. Meanwhile, some masks come with pockets or speakers designed to hold Bluetooth devices, allowing you to drift off to sleep with gentle music or white noise.
Lastly, when choosing an eye mask, reflect on your lifestyle and when you'd use it most. Frequent travelers might prioritize portability and a light-blocking design, whereas home users may focus on indulgent comfort. Regardless of the features, ensure that they align with your personal needs and enhance your sleep experience.

Hands-on Reviews and Recommendations from Discussion-Boards

We have curated a selection of the most authoritative and informative resources on the Most Comfortable Eye Masks. Our compilation includes various types of content such as expert reviews, lively forum discussions, engaging Reddit threads, and informative videos. These have been organized into four respective categories for your convenience and to provide a comprehensive understanding of the topic.
Nov 18, 2022 — Consumer Reports reviewed the best and worst sleep masks, including sleep masks from Lunya, Manta, and Mzoo.
Read more | Helpful?
Aug 7, 2023 — Drowsy Lavender Haze Sleep Mask · Best overall sleep mask · $79 at Drowsy ; Brooklinen Mulberry silk eye mask · Best value sleep mask · $29 at...
Read more | Helpful?
1 day ago — 1. Mavogel Cotton Eye Mask : · $19.99 $9.98 at Amazon Best for: Light blocking comfort ; 2. Grace & Stella Cooling Eye Mask: $14.99 $11.99 at...
Read more | Helpful?
Manta Sleepmasks are by far the best; a bunch of different styles like weighted, silk, cooling gel, and even one with bluetooth. I got the Pro...
Read more | Helpful?
Mantas are the absolute best of any I've tried. Super comfortable, very adjustable, compete blackout, and they come with all sorts of options.
Read more | Helpful?
I went down a rabbit hole with sleep masks and tried maybe 8 off Amazon. You have good answers already, my top are also Bucky and Manta. The...
Read more | Helpful?
My favorite is the alaska bear silk mask because it's so comfortable on my face, but it does slip off during the night. Best of luck!
Read more | Helpful?
Eye masks? · Blocks out all light and comfortable to wear (backed by 18 comments) · Foam cups prevent pressure on eyes (backed by 4 comments).
Read more | Helpful?
The Best Sleep Masks: 8 Reviewed And Compared - YouTube
YouTube Logo
... sleep mask in any sleeping position, but side sleepers might find these are the most comfortable as they are less lumpy than the other two...

Share This Article

More about Beauty & Personal Care on StrawPoll