Most Comfortable High Heels for Extended Wear

We have researched 10 high heels for you.

Stepping out with confidence while enjoying a blend of style and comfort is the dream for any fashion-forward individual. High heels have long been a symbol of sophistication, but all too often, comfort takes a back seat to aesthetics. However, with advancements in shoe design, you no longer have to choose between elegance and ease.

Our curated selection focuses on footwear that promises to elevate your style quotient without the traditional pain points associated with towering stilettos or pumps. Discover footwear that combines innovative comfort technologies with chic designs, ready to carry you through any event with grace and poise.
To simplify the price comparison, we determine the prices for the individual articles on Amazon, Ebay and other shops and link the offers via partner links where applicable. This means that we receive a commission if you buy something that we recommend - the price does not change for you.

What to Look for in Most Comfortable High Heels

Important criteria

  • Arch support
  • Cushioned insole
  • Quality materials
  • Stable heel
  • Proper fit
  • Ergonomic design

1.) Heel Height and Design

When purchasing high heels, it is crucial to consider the heel height that can comfortably be worn for extended periods. Typically, heels ranging from 1 to 3 inches are more manageable for most people. The design of the heel also plays a significant role; wider heels or those with a chunky design provide more stability and distribute weight more evenly than stiletto heels, reducing the strain on your feet.

2.) Cushioning and Arch Support

Adequate cushioning is essential for comfort in high heels. Look for shoes with padded insoles or include additional gel inserts for better shock absorption. Proper arch support is equally important to prevent arch strain and potential injuries. Heels that support the arch of your foot can lead to better posture and comfort while walking.

3.) Material and Fit

The material of the heels can affect comfort levels; leather is often a good choice because it's breathable and tends to mold to the shape of your feet over time. When trying on high heels, ensure a snug but not tight fit to avoid blisters, and remember that feet can swell throughout the day, so try on heels in the afternoon or evening for an accurate fit.

4.) Toe Box Space

The toe box of the heel should provide enough room to wiggle your toes. A cramped toe box can lead to discomfort, blisters, and even long-term deformities such as hammer toes. Round or almond-shaped toe boxes tend to be more comfortable for most foot shapes, as opposed to pointy toe heels that can squeeze the toes.

The Most Comfortable High Heels of our Choice

Our Pick
DREAM PAIRS Women's Sdpu2350w High Heels Pumps
DREAM PAIRS Women's Sdpu2350w High Heels Pumps
Type/Color: White-pu Size: 7
  • Perfect Fit: Asymmetric instep strap provides secure fit.
  • Walk With Comfort: 3 inch heel with German sole for confident walking.
  • Cushioned Insole: Fabric-covered latex insole for comfort and support.
  • Classic & Timeless: Pointed toe adds elegance to outfits.
  • Fashionable Touch: Versatile style suitable for various occasions.
$ 43.99 *
View
on Amazon
Search
on Ebay
2
Naturalizer Womens Michelle Classic High Heel Pump
Naturalizer Womens Michelle Classic High Heel Pump
Model: D6572L1 Type/Color: Black Leather Size: 9
  • Women's pump with .5 inch platform and 3 inch heel
  • Sleek pump with walkable heel
  • Leather, patent leather, suede or fabric upper
  • Closed round toe and non-slip outsole
  • Contour+ technology for premium fit and comfort
  • Easy slip-on style for all-day comfort
  • Consciously packaged with 80% recycled paper
  • Shoes designed using sustainable materials
  • Versatile for work, office, business, casual occasions
$ 73.00 *
View
on Amazon
Search
on Ebay
3
IDIFU Women's IN4 Sabrina Platform Chunky
IDIFU Women's IN4 Sabrina Platform Chunky
Type/Color: Nude Nubuck Size: 8
  • Heel: 4.1 inch, platform: 0.79 inch.
  • Comfortable with true US size, all-day wear.
  • Unique platform design for casual or formal outfits.
  • Timeless solid colors fit any occasion.
  • IDIFU provides good after-sales service.
$ 36.99 *
View
on Amazon
Price Pick
ZAIWOO Metatarsal Pads Women
ZAIWOO Metatarsal Pads Women
Type/Color: Beige Size: One Size
  • Crafted from premium suede and gel materials.
  • Allows dancing with ease in stunning high heels.
  • Feels comfortable like walking on clouds.
  • Incorporates honeycomb anti-slip pattern for resistance.
  • Prevents feet from sliding inside the shoes.
  • Easy to apply inserts for instant comfort.
  • Can be cleaned and reused for stickiness.
  • Not recommended for cloth or suede bottoms.
  • Not a substitute for medical items.
  • 180-day no-reason refund policy available.
  • Contact customer service for dissatisfactory instances.
$ 12.88 *
View
on Amazon
5
DREAM PAIRS Nude Heels for Women Block
DREAM PAIRS Nude Heels for Women Block
Type/Color: Nude Size: 6
  • Comfortable retro heel with platform
  • Soft PU insole for all-day comfort
  • Adjustable straps for easy wear
  • Elongating effect for longer legs illusion
  • Timeless chic style in classic colors
$ 45.99 *
View
on Amazon
Search
on Ebay
6
DREAM PAIRS Women's Invest High Heels Platform
DREAM PAIRS Women's Invest High Heels Platform
Type/Color: Gold/Glitter Size: 8.5
  • Decorative rhinestones for stylish look
  • Open-toe design and rhombus mesh for breathability
  • Slingback ankle strap with adjustable buckle closure
  • Platform elevates ball of feet for added comfort
  • Stiletto heel creates long and lean look
  • Durable rubber sole for long-lasting wear
  • Latex padded insole for extra comfort
  • Measurements: Heel height: 4", Platform height: 1"
$ 46.99 *
View
on Amazon
Search
on Ebay
7
Naturalizer Womens Brenta Heeled Sandal
Naturalizer Womens Brenta Heeled Sandal
Type/Color: Black Size: 6.5 Wide
  • Heeled sandal with strappy details and platform sole
  • 3 1/4 inch heel for all day comfort
  • Women's shoes with manmade upper and round toe
  • Dressy sandal with solid or rhinestone straps
  • Consciously packaged shoe boxes made of recycled materials
  • Fashion sandal designed with sustainable materials
  • Suitable for indoor, outdoor, weddings, parties, events
  • Inclusive size range available for comfortable fit
$ 59.78 *
View
on Amazon
Search
on Ebay
8
Naturalizer Womens Anna Pointed Toe High Heel Pumps
Naturalizer Womens Anna Pointed Toe High Heel Pumps
Model: G5091LC Size: 8.5
  • Women's pointed toe pump with comfortable heel
  • Leather, metallic leather, suede or fabric upper
  • 3 inch heel with slip on fit and non-slip outsole
  • Contour+ technology for premium fit and all-day comfort
  • Consciously packaged: recycled paper + soy-based ink
  • Perfect for work, office, business casual, cocktail party
  • Available in inclusive range of sizes and widths
$ 113.95 *
View
on Amazon
Search
on Ebay
9
Naturalizer Womens Berlin Chunky High Heel Platform Pump
Naturalizer Womens Berlin Chunky High Heel Platform Pump
Model: H1960S1 Type/Color: Black Size: 7.5
  • Classic slip-on women's platform pump
  • Contour+ tech for premium fit and comfort
  • 3.75 inch high heel with non-slip outsole
  • Manmade upper with timeless almond toe
  • Consciously packaged: eco-friendly shoe boxes
  • Suitable for various occasions: work, parties, weddings
$ 33.48 *
View
on Amazon
Search
on Ebay
10
DREAM PAIRS Women' s Neina Sexy high Chunky
DREAM PAIRS Women' s Neina Sexy high Chunky
Type/Color: Black/Suede Size: 8
  • Heel height: 3" (approx), platform chunky heels
  • Slip on and adjustable buckle design
  • Convenient to wear and take off
  • Non-slip rubber soles for added safety
  • Latex padded insole for extra comfort
  • Relaxes feet and relieves pressure and pain
  • Open toe silhouette with slingback construction
  • Promotes airflow to keep feet dry
  • Suitable for working, dress, wedding, and other occasions
$ 42.99 *
View
on Amazon
Search
on Ebay
* All prices incl. VAT, plus shipping if applicable. Prices, delivery times and costs may change in the meantime. The selection of products was made independently of the manufacturer and without any claim to completeness. All links to products are external partner links through which we may receive compensation. All information without guarantee.

Discover Your Perfect Pair of Comfy High Heels

Busy Professionals
Stride with confidence and ease through your workday. Our selection caters to the dynamic professional seeking both style and comfort in their high heels.
Fashion-Forward Shoppers
Make a statement without compromising on comfort. Explore heels that blend the latest trends with a design that keeps your feet happy.
Wedding Attendees
Celebrate the special day in heels that won't distract you from the festivities. Find the balance between elegance and comfort.
Everyday Comfort Seekers
Experience all-day comfort without sacrificing your personal style. Our curated list includes heels suitable for daily wear with a touch of chic.

Questions You Might Ask

When selecting heel height, consider comfort, the event you'll be attending, and your experience walking in heels. Lower heels (1-2 inches) can be more comfortable for long durations and are suitable for work or casual events. Mid-height heels (2-3 inches) offer elegance without compromising much comfort. High heels (over 3 inches) make a statement and are often chosen for formal occasions, but require practice to walk in confidently.
To ensure a proper fit, try on heels at the end of the day when feet are at their largest, and walk around to gauge comfort. There should be no pinching or discomfort, and your heel should fit snugly against the back of the shoe without slipping. Ensure there's a small gap between the longest toe and the front of the shoe. Consider adjustable straps or laces for a customized fit.
Leather and suede are commonly preferred for high heels as they are durable and can mold to your feet over time for a better fit. Synthetic materials can be less expensive but might not provide the same level of comfort or breathability. Consider the occasion and frequency of use when selecting heel materials.
Look for high heels with padded insoles, arch support, and a cushioned ball area to enhance comfort. A sturdy heel and a platform under the front of the shoe can also reduce the pressure on your arch and ball of the foot. Additionally, choosing a heel with a wider base or a chunky heel can provide better stability than stilettos.
Yes, many issues with high heel fit can be corrected by a professional cobbler. They can stretch shoes that are too tight, add padding for better comfort, or even attach anti-slip soles to provide better traction. However, it's always best to find a pair that fits well from the start to reduce the need for alterations.

Currently Active Poll

How to Choose the Most Comfortable High Heels

Heels elevate your style but shouldn’t bring you down with discomfort. Finding the perfect pair begins with understanding the key elements that result in a snug and comfortable fit. This guide provides you with the insider knowledge to select high heels that feel as fabulous as they look.

Understand Heel Types and Heights

High heels come in a dizzying array of shapes and heights, and each affects your comfort. Block heels offer greater stability than stilettos, while platforms can reduce pressure on the ball of your foot. Consider a mid-range heel height, as anything above three inches can increase discomfort, irrespective of the cushioning or shoe shape.
Don’t forget about the heel's width and placement. A wider heel distributes your weight more evenly, reducing the strain on your feet. Heels positioned directly under your heel bone, rather than at the back of the shoe, can also provide better support and balance.

Prioritize Quality Material and Construction

The material of your high heels can make a significant difference in comfort. Leather, for instance, tends to mold to the shape of your foot, providing a custom-fit feel that many synthetic materials can't match. However, if sustainability is a concern, there are quality vegan alternatives available.
Examine the construction of the heels. Well-constructed shoes with sturdy stitching and sufficient cushioning can withstand wear and tear while pampering your feet. Additionally, a seamless lining and absence of rough edges inside the shoe will prevent blisters and irritation.

Look for Supportive Features

To make high heels comfortable, support is key. Seek out shoes with ample arch support to align your feet and reduce strain. A padded footbed is crucial for absorbing shock and providing a cushy barrier between your sole and the ground.
Consider shoes with a slight platform under the toe box—even a quarter inch can make a difference. Also, a secure fastening mechanism like straps or a snug-fitting upper can prevent your foot from sliding forward, which causes toe squish.

Know Your Feet

Everyone’s feet are unique, and what works for one person might not work for another. It’s important to know not only your shoe size but also the width of your feet, and to recognize if you have high arches or flat feet, as these factors influence which shoes will be comfortable for you.
Always try on heels later in the day when your feet are likely to be slightly swollen from walking, which mimics how they will feel after being on your feet for a while in heels. Don’t just walk on carpet – find a hard surface to truly test how the shoes will perform.

Give Them a Proper Break-in

A good practice is to break in your heels slowly. Wear them around the house for short periods to get your feet accustomed to the shape and height. Apply moleskin to areas prone to rubbing or use gel inserts for extra cushioning and a better fit.
If there is some tightness, shoe stretchers or a visit to a professional cobbler can work wonders in making your high heels fit like a glove. Remember, comfortable heels are not just about the right purchase, but also about how you treat and adapt them to your feet.

Final Considerations Before Purchase

When you're ready to make a purchase, do a final check for any overlooked comfort features. Make sure there's enough space for your toes, and that your heel isn’t slipping out. Walk around to see if the shoes stay snug without pinching.
Don’t compromise on comfort for style. It's worth investing in a pair of heels that you can wear confidently and pain-free. Keep in mind that the most comfortable high heels are the ones you can wear all day, and still dance in at night!

Hands-on Reviews and Recommendations from Discussion-Boards

In the quest to find the most comfortable high heels, various sources have been scrutinized to provide valuable insights. These sources have been carefully curated and organized into four distinct categories that include expert reviews, discussions from dedicated forums, insightful Reddit threads, and informative videos. The intent is to direct you to trustworthy test reports and dependable recommendations, helping you make an informed decision based on the best available resources on this topic.
Nov 19, 2021 — If you're looking for a supportive, grippy slipper that you can wear year-round, the Vionic Relax slippers are a good option. But if your feet...
Read more | Helpful?
My vote goes to Jimmy Choo. I have a couple of pairs and they never kill my feet like all the others.
Read more | Helpful?
In general, block heels and round/square toes will be more comfy than stilettos and pointy toes. Most people can easily wear up to a 3in heel. I...
Read more | Helpful?
Lifestride and Sofft make supremely comfy heels! Upvote 2
Read more | Helpful?
My personal most comfortable heels are the Sarah Flint Perfect Pump 100 which have really great arch support. ( Comfort in heels depends on good...
Read more | Helpful?
Life Stride is a brand I've bought repeatedly. They make good quality heels in a variety of sizes, including wide width. They aren't too pricey, ...
Read more | Helpful?
Are These Amazon Best-Rated High Heels Comfortable ...
YouTube Logo
Review | According to Amazon reviews, Dream Pairs Heels are one of the most comfortable high heels on Amazon. People love Dream Pairs and ...

Share This Article

More about Clothing & Accessories on StrawPoll