The Most Difficult Time Signature, Ranked

Choose the time signature you think is the most difficult!

Author: Gregor Krambs
Updated on May 6, 2024 06:26
For musicians, both aspiring and seasoned, mastering time signatures forms a cornerstone of their skill set. Yet, some time signatures prove more challenging to grasp than others, creating a gradient of difficulty that can vary widely from one musician to another. Establishing which time signatures are toughest can help educators tailor their teaching strategies and assist learners in anticipating potential challenges. This dynamic ranking accumulates votes from users who share their personal experiences and opinions on the complexity of different time signatures. By participating, you contribute to a resource that not only highlights these complexities but also serves as a guide for others to understand where they might need to focus their practice or teaching efforts. Your input ensures the ranking stays current and reflective of real-world experiences.

What Is the Most Difficult Time Signature?

  1. 1
    37
    votes
    This time signature is irregular and odd, making it difficult to count and play. It is used in various genres of music, including progressive rock, jazz, and classical music.
    The 19/16 time signature is a complex and uncommon time signature with 19 beats per measure. It is characterized by its asymmetrical division of beats, resulting in a challenging and intricate rhythmic structure.
    • Beats per Measure: 19
    • Top Number: 19
    • Bottom Number: 16
    • Tempo: Varies
    • Beat Division: Irregular and asymmetrical
  2. 2
    29
    votes
    This time signature is similar to 19/16, but even more irregular and complex. It is primarily used in avant-garde and experimental music.
    The time signature 23/16 is a highly complex and extreme time signature in music, characterized by its unusual grouping of beats and division of musical phrases.
    • Number of beats: 23
    • Note value of each beat: 16th note
    • Metrical grouping: Varied groupings such as 3+2+3+2+3+2+3+2+3
    • Overall duration per measure: 6.875 seconds
    • Challenges for performers: Complex polyrhythms and syncopation
  3. 3
    21
    votes
    This time signature is a combination of 3/8 and 4/8, making it challenging to feel the pulse and rhythm. It is used in various types of music, including Balkan and Middle Eastern music.
    The time signature 11/8 is a complex meter that consists of eleven beats per measure. It is commonly used in progressive rock, jazz fusion, and world music genres. The rhythmic pattern of 11/8 divides the beats into uneven groupings, creating a unique and intricate feel.
    • Number of beats per measure: 11
    • Beat division: Usually grouped as 3+3+2+3
    • Complexity: High
    • Notation: Usually written as 4/4 + 3/8 or 8/8 + 3/8
    • Feel: Complex, asymmetrical, and challenging
  4. 4
    16
    votes

    7/4

    This time signature is an odd meter, and it can be challenging to count and play. It is commonly used in progressive rock and jazz music.
  5. 5
    16
    votes
    This time signature is a combination of 6/8 and 7/8, making it challenging to play and count. It is used in various genres of music, including Balkan and Middle Eastern music.
    The time signature 13/8 is an irregular time signature commonly used in progressive rock and fusion music. It consists of 13 eighth notes per measure, making it complex and challenging to grasp. The 13/8 time signature is known for creating a sense of tension and unpredictability in music.
    • Number of Beats: 13
    • Note Value: 8th note
    • Accentuation: Varies depending on composition
    • Subdivisions: 3+3+3+4 or 4+3+3+3, among others
    • Common Usage: Progressive rock, fusion, and jazz fusion
  6. 6
    9
    votes

    9/8

    This time signature is a combination of 3/4 and 6/8, making it challenging to feel the pulse and rhythm. It is used in various types of music, including Irish and Bulgarian folk music.
    The time signature 9/8 is a compound triple meter commonly used in various styles of music. It consists of nine eighth-note beats grouped into three groups of three. This time signature creates a complex rhythmic pattern that can evoke a sense of urgency or drive in the music.
    • Beats per measure: 9
    • Note value: Eighth-note
    • Meter type: Compound triple
    • Beats per group: 3
    • Memorable songs in 9/8: Money by Pink Floyd, Turn It On Again by Genesis
  7. 7
    5
    votes

    5/4

    This time signature is an odd meter, and it can be challenging to count and play. It is used in various types of music, including progressive rock and jazz.
    The time signature 5/4 is a musical meter that is characterized by five beats in a measure, where the quarter note serves as the basic unit of time. It is considered to be an asymmetric time signature due to its odd number of beats, which differs from commonly used time signatures in music.
    • Number of Beats: 5
    • Basic Time Unit: Quarter note
    • Type: Asymmetric
    • Time Signature Notation: 5/4
    • Beat Groupings: Varies (e.g., 2+3, 3+2)
  8. 8
    6
    votes
    This time signature is a combination of 6/8 and 9/8, making it challenging to play and count. It is used in various genres of music, including Balkan and Indian music.
    The time signature 15/8 refers to a musical meter in which there are fifteen beats in a measure, with each beat lasting an eighth note. It is considered one of the more complex and irregular time signatures commonly used in music.
    • Beats per measure: 15
    • Duration of each beat: 1/8 note
    • Subdivisions: 5 groups of 3 eighth notes
    • Common music genres: Progressive rock, jazz fusion, world music
    • Famous songs in 15/8: Take Five (Paul Desmond), Black Napkins (Frank Zappa)
  9. 9
    6
    votes
    This time signature is an irregular and complex meter, making it challenging to count and play. It is primarily used in avant-garde and experimental music.
    The time signature 17/16 is an irregular and complex meter used in music. It consists of 17 beats per measure, with each beat lasting one sixteenth note.
    • Number of Beats per Measure: 17
    • Duration of Each Beat: One sixteenth note
    • Meter Type: Irregular
    • Accentuation: Can vary depending on the composition
    • Complexity: Considered highly complex
  10. 10
    3
    votes
    This time signature is a combination of 7/8 and 14/8, making it challenging to feel the pulse and rhythm. It is used in various types of music, including Bulgarian and Macedonian folk music.
    The time signature 21/8 is a complex and irregular time signature with a total of 21 beats per measure. It is often considered one of the most difficult time signatures due to its intricate rhythmic structure.
    • Number of beats per measure: 21
    • Top number of the time signature: 21
    • Bottom number of the time signature: 8
    • Irregular grouping of beats: Yes
    • Complex rhythmic structure: Yes

Missing your favorite time signature?

Graphs
Discussion

Ranking factors for difficult time signature

  1. Complexity of the time signature
    More complex time signatures have more beats per measure and a less common base note, making them harder to read, count, and play. For example, a simple 4/4 time signature might be easier to manage compared to a 7/8 or 5/4 time signature.
  2. Subdivision of beats
    The way beats are subdivided within a time signature can affect its difficulty. A regular subdivision, such as in 4/4 where beats are subdivided into equal parts, may be easier to play than irregular subdivisions, like in 7/8, where the beat might be broken into groups of 2 and 3.
  3. Syncopation
    Time signatures with heavy use of syncopation, where emphasized notes occur off the main beats, can be more challenging to play, especially for beginners. Syncopation can make it harder to maintain a steady rhythm and feel comfortable within a particular time signature.
  4. Rhythmic patterns
    The specific rhythmic patterns used in a piece can affect the difficulty of a time signature. For instance, a piece written in a compound time signature like 9/8 can become more difficult if it incorporates numerous complex rhythmic figures or frequently changes the emphasis of beats.
  5. Familiarity
    Time signatures that are less common or frequently used in a particular genre or culture can be more challenging for musicians unfamiliar with them. Familiarity with a time signature often comes with practice and exposure, making it easier over time.
  6. Tempo
    The tempo, or speed, at which a piece is played can significantly impact the difficulty of a time signature. Fast tempos can make it more challenging to maintain accurate counting and execution of rhythms in complex time signatures.
  7. Interaction with other parts
    In ensemble settings, the difficulty of a time signature can be affected by the rhythmic complexity and interaction between different parts. For example, a drummer playing a complex rhythm in a difficult time signature must closely coordinate with other musicians to maintain a cohesive performance.
  8. Instrument and technique
    The specific instrument and techniques used may also affect the difficulty of playing in a particular time signature. Some instruments may lend themselves better to certain time signatures, and players with certain skills or techniques may find some time signatures more challenging than others.

About this ranking

This is a community-based ranking of the most difficult time signature. We do our best to provide fair voting, but it is not intended to be exhaustive. So if you notice something or Time signature is missing, feel free to help improve the ranking!

Statistics

  • 2990 views
  • 146 votes
  • 10 ranked items

Movers & Shakers

Voting Rules

A participant may cast an up or down vote for each Time signature once every 24 hours. The rank of each Time signature is then calculated from the weighted sum of all up and down votes.

Categories

Trendings topics

Don't miss out on the currently trending topics of StrawPoll Rankings!

More information on most difficult time signature

When it comes to music, time signature determines the rhythm and overall feel of a piece. While most music is written in common time (4/4), there are countless other time signatures that can be used to create unique and complex rhythms. One of the most challenging time signatures to master is undoubtedly 7/8, which is characterized by its uneven grouping of beats. Other difficult time signatures include 5/4, 9/8, and even 11/16, which require a high level of skill and precision from musicians. Whether you're a seasoned musician or just starting out, exploring different time signatures is a great way to push your musical abilities to the next level.

Share this article