The Most Famous Killer in Indiana: A Notorious Legacy

Choose the killer you think is the most famous!

Author: Gregor Krambs
Updated on Apr 16, 2024 08:13
Welcome to StrawPoll, where the opinions of the masses are gathered and ranked! Today, we bring you a thrilling and spine-chilling ranking that will have you on the edge of your seat - "Who is the most famous killer in Indiana?" We've delved into the dark corners of Indiana's history, unearthing the notorious and infamous killers that have left their mark on the state. Now, it's your turn to cast your vote and decide who truly stands out as the most infamous amongst them. Will it be the cunning mastermind or the cold-blooded brute? The choice is yours! And, if you think we've missed a chilling contender, don't hesitate to suggest a new addition to our haunting list. Dive into the darkness and let your voice be heard - vote now and uncover Indiana's most famous killer!

Who Is the Most Famous Killer in Indiana?

  1. 1
    Known as the "I-70 Strangler," Baumeister is believed to have murdered at least 11 men in the Indianapolis area during the 1980s and 1990s. He committed suicide before he could be brought to trial.
    Herb Baumeister in other rankings
  2. 2
    Also known as the "Highway Killer," Eyler was convicted of murdering 21 young men in the Midwest during the 1980s. Many of his victims were prostitutes, whom he would pick up along highways.
  3. 3
    Belle Gunness
    Unknown authorUnknown author · Public domain
    A Norwegian-American serial killer who is believed to have murdered at least 14 people, including her own children and several suitors. She lured her victims to her farm in La Porte County, Indiana, where she would kill them and bury their bodies on her property.
    Belle Gunness in other rankings
  4. 4
    Carl Panzram
    Oregon · Public domain
    A notorious serial killer and rapist who confessed to killing at least 21 people, including two young boys, in the early 20th century. He was eventually executed in Leavenworth, Kansas.
    Carl Panzram in other rankings
  5. 5
    Dubbed the "Lipstick Killer" because he left messages scrawled in lipstick at the scenes of his crimes, Heirens was convicted of killing three people in the Chicago area in the 1940s. He was born in Evanston, Illinois, but spent much of his childhood in Indiana.
  6. 6
    John Wayne Gacy
    Des Plaines Police Department · Public domain

    John Wayne Gacy

    John Wayne Gacy
    Although he is best known for his crimes in Illinois, Gacy was born in Chicago and spent part of his childhood in Indiana. He was convicted of murdering 33 young men and boys in the 1970s, many of whom he buried in the crawl space of his home.
    John Wayne Gacy was an American serial killer who was active between 1972 and 1978. He sexually assaulted, tortured, and murdered at least 33 young boys and young men in Chicago, Illinois. Gacy was able to lure his victims to his home under the pretext of offering them employment or money. He would then capture and restrain them before subjecting them to prolonged periods of sexual abuse and eventually strangling them to death. Gacy's case gained significant media attention due to the high number of victims and the gruesome nature of his crimes. He was convicted in 1980 and sentenced to death. Gacy was executed by lethal injection in 1994.
    • Conviction: 1980
    • Sentence: Death
    • Target Victims: Young boys and young men
    • Notoriety: High media attention
    • Active Years: 1972 - 1978
    John Wayne Gacy in other rankings
  7. 7
    A notorious gang leader who ordered the murder of seven people in Indianapolis in 2006, including a pregnant woman and her unborn child. Mays was eventually sentenced to life in prison without parole.
  8. 8
    Convicted of killing three people during a robbery at a Fort Wayne restaurant in 2002, Jackson was sentenced to death and executed in 2009.
  9. 9
    A convicted sex offender who confessed to killing seven women in the Gary, Indiana area between 2013 and 2014. He was sentenced to life in prison without parole.
  10. 10
    Convicted of murdering his girlfriend in Jeffersonville, Indiana in 2014, Oberhansley is currently on death row. He had previously served time in prison for killing his ex-girlfriend in Utah.

Missing your favorite killer?


Ranking factors for famous killer

  1. The number of victims
    The killer's number of victims is an important factor in determining their level of infamy.
  2. Media coverage
    The amount of media coverage the killer received can also contribute to their level of fame.
  3. Method of killing
    The manner in which the killer killed their victims could also play a role in how famous they became.
  4. Duration of killing spree
    The length of time that the killer was active and the frequency of their attacks could also contribute to their level of notoriety.
  5. Impact on society
    Finally, the impact that the killer had on society and the community in which they operated could also be a significant factor.

About this ranking

This is a community-based ranking of the most famous killer in Indiana. We do our best to provide fair voting, but it is not intended to be exhaustive. So if you notice something or killer is missing, feel free to help improve the ranking!


  • 216 votes
  • 10 ranked items

Voting Rules

A participant may cast an up or down vote for each killer once every 24 hours. The rank of each killer is then calculated from the weighted sum of all up and down votes.

More information on most famous killer in indiana

Indiana, the "Crossroads of America," is known for its cornfields, basketball, and the Indianapolis 500. However, the state has also been home to some infamous criminals throughout history. From the notorious John Dillinger to the lesser-known Herb Baumeister, Indiana has seen its fair share of killers. But who is the most famous? This question has sparked heated debates and discussions among true crime enthusiasts. In this article, we delve into the lives and crimes of Indiana's infamous killers to determine who holds the title of the most famous killer in the Hoosier State.

Share this article