The Most Overrated Baseball Team, Ranked

Choose the baseball team you think is the most overrated!

Author: Gregor Krambs
Updated on May 1, 2024 06:28
In the world of baseball, debates often heat up over which teams are not quite living up to the hype surrounding them. This discussion has taken center stage among fans and critics alike, leading to endless discussions and varied opinions. Establishing a list where users can vote on the most overrated baseball teams provides a structured way to see community consensus and challenge popular perceptions. On this site, your votes help in shaping an ongoing, real-time ranking that reflects current sentiments around the most overrated teams in baseball. By participating, you contribute to a clearer picture of where these teams stand according to the collective fan base. It's an engaging way to see how your opinions stack up against others and to potentially sway the standings with your own views.

What Is the Most Overrated Baseball Team?

  1. 1
    79
    votes
    They have a huge fan following and a long history of success, but their recent performances have not been up to the mark.
    The New York Yankees is a Major League Baseball team based in the Bronx, New York. They are known for their rich history, success, and popularity, which has earned them the reputation of being one of the most overrated baseball teams.
    • Established: 1901
    • Total World Series Championships: 27
    • Total American League Pennants: 40
    • Total playoff appearances: 56
    • Most Valuable Player (MVP) Award winners: 23
    New York Yankees in other rankings
  2. 2
    44
    votes

    Boston Red Sox

    John I. Taylor
    Similar to the Yankees, they have a large fan following and a storied history, but their recent performances have not been impressive.
    The Boston Red Sox is a Major League Baseball team based in Boston, Massachusetts. They are considered one of the most iconic and successful franchises in baseball history. The team was established in 1901 and has since gained a large and dedicated fanbase known as the Red Sox Nation.
    • World Series Titles: 9
    • American League Pennants: 14
    • Division Titles: 10
    • Retired Numbers: 11
    • Hall of Famers: 19
    Boston Red Sox in other rankings
  3. 3
    25
    votes

    Los Angeles Dodgers

    Walter O'Malley
    They have a talented team, but their huge payroll and consistent underperformance in the playoffs make them overrated.
    The Los Angeles Dodgers is a professional baseball team based in Los Angeles, California. They are widely considered as one of the most overrated teams in baseball. Despite their popularity and large fan base, their on-field performances often fail to live up to the high expectations placed upon them.
    • Established: 1883
    • Home Stadium: Dodger Stadium
    • World Series Titles: 6
    • National League Pennants: 24
    • Division Titles: 19
  4. 4
    14
    votes

    Atlanta Braves

    William Bartholomay
    They have been consistently good in recent years, but their lack of success in the playoffs makes them overrated.
    The Atlanta Braves are a professional baseball team based in Atlanta, Georgia. They are a member of the National League East division and have a rich history dating back to 1871. The team has won numerous division titles and World Series championships, making them one of the most successful franchises in Major League Baseball.
    • Home Stadium: Truist Park
    • Founded Year: 1871
    • Division Titles: 20
    • World Series Championships: 3
    • Hall of Famers: 14
  5. 5
    23
    votes

    St. Louis Cardinals

    William O. Bidwill
    They have a big fan following and a reputation for success, but their recent performances have not been up to the mark.
    The St. Louis Cardinals are a professional baseball team based in St. Louis, Missouri. They are one of the most popular and successful teams in Major League Baseball (MLB).
    • Founded: 1882
    • Home Stadium: Busch Stadium
    • World Series Titles: 11
    • NL Pennants: 19
    • Central Division Titles: 13
  6. 6
    13
    votes

    Chicago Cubs

    William Hulbert
    They won the World Series in 2016, but their inconsistent performances in recent years make them overrated.
    The Chicago Cubs are a Major League Baseball team based in Chicago, Illinois. They are considered by many to be one of the most overrated teams in baseball. Despite having a large and passionate fanbase, the Cubs have often been hyped up and overrated in terms of their success and potential.
    • World Series Titles: 3
    • National League Pennants: 17
    • Division Titles: 6
    • Hall of Fame Players: 18
    • All-Star Selections: 73
    Chicago Cubs in other rankings
  7. 7
    7
    votes
    They have a talented team, but their lack of success in recent years makes them overrated.
    The Philadelphia Phillies is a Major League Baseball team based in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania. They were established in 1883 and have a rich history in the sport. The team plays their home games at Citizens Bank Park, a modern stadium with a seating capacity of over 43,000 spectators. The Phillies have won the World Series twice, in 1980 and again in 2008, and have also clinched multiple National League pennants. They are known for their passionate fans, who often fill the stadium, creating an electric atmosphere.
    • Year Established: 1883
    • Home Field: Citizens Bank Park
    • Seating Capacity: 43,651
    • World Series Titles: 2
    • National League Pennants: 7
    Philadelphia Phillies in other rankings
  8. 8
    8
    votes
    They won three World Series titles in five years, but their recent performances have not been impressive.
    The San Francisco Giants is a Major League Baseball team based in San Francisco, California. They were established in 1883, making them one of the oldest professional baseball teams in America. The team is part of the National League (NL) West division and their home games are played at Oracle Park. The Giants have gained a strong fan base and have had numerous successful seasons, resulting in multiple World Series victories.
    • Founding Year: 1883
    • League: National League (NL)
    • Division: NL West
    • Home Stadium: Oracle Park
    • World Series Titles: 8 (1905, 1921, 1922, 1933, 1954, 2010, 2012, 2014)
  9. 9
    3
    votes

    Houston Astros

    Houston Sports Authority
    They won the World Series in 2017, but their sign-stealing scandal has tarnished their reputation.
    The Houston Astros is a Major League Baseball team based in Houston, Texas. They were established in 1962 as the Houston Colt .45s before changing their name to the Astros in 1965. The team plays their home games at Minute Maid Park.
    • World Series Titles: 1
    • Pennants: 2
    • Division Titles: 10
    • All-Time Winning Percentage: 0.497
    • Retired Numbers: 10
  10. 10
    6
    votes

    New York Mets

    Joan Whitney Payson
    They have a talented team, but their inconsistent performances in recent years make them overrated.
    The New York Mets is a Major League Baseball team based in New York City. It was established in 1962 as an expansion team, and since then, it has gained a significant fan base and media attention. The Mets play their home games at Citi Field in Queens, New York.
    • Championships: 2 World Series championships (1969, 1986)
    • National League Pennants: 5 (1969, 1973, 1986, 2000, 2015)
    • Division Titles: 6 (1969, 1973, 1986, 1988, 2006, 2015)
    • Hall of Famers: Several notable players including Tom Seaver, Mike Piazza, and Gary Carter
    • All-Star Players: Numerous players in Mets history have been selected for the All-Star Game

Missing your favorite baseball team?

Graphs
Discussion

Ranking factors for overrated baseball team

  1. Media hype
    One of the primary factors in a team being overrated is the amount of attention and hype it receives in the media. If a team is constantly talked about and praised by analysts and journalists, this can contribute to them being seen as better than they actually are.
  2. Historical success
    If a team has a long history of success, this may lead to inflated expectations for their current performance. People often have a perception of a team being strong even if their current roster does not support this view.
  3. Star players
    A team that has a few star players may be seen as a constant threat, even if the rest of their roster is underperforming. People may overvalue individual players and associate their success with the team's success.
  4. Payroll
    Teams with higher payrolls are often overrated because the assumption is that money can buy success in baseball. However, a high payroll does not always lead to a winning team, and it can contribute to a team being seen as more talented than they are.
  5. Fanbase
    Large and passionate fanbases can contribute to a team being overrated because fans are frequently vocal about their support and may be biased in their evaluation of the team.
  6. Preseason predictions
    Sometimes, teams are overrated based on preseason predictions that later turn out to be over-optimistic. This can be due to factors such as projecting breakout seasons for young players or assuming career-best performances from aging veterans.
  7. Market size
    Larger market teams may receive more attention and therefore be overrated simply because they play in a big city. These teams can attract more talent and resources, but this does not always translate to success on the field.

About this ranking

This is a community-based ranking of the most overrated baseball team. We do our best to provide fair voting, but it is not intended to be exhaustive. So if you notice something or Team is missing, feel free to help improve the ranking!

Statistics

  • 2550 views
  • 225 votes
  • 10 ranked items

Voting Rules

A participant may cast an up or down vote for each Team once every 24 hours. The rank of each Team is then calculated from the weighted sum of all up and down votes.

Categories

More information on most overrated baseball team

Baseball is a sport that has been beloved by millions of fans for over a century. With its long history, there have been many teams that have risen to the top of the league, only to be deemed overrated by critics and fans alike. Whether it's due to inflated expectations, lackluster performances, or simply being in the wrong place at the wrong time, some baseball teams just never live up to the hype. In this article, we'll take a closer look at some of the most overrated baseball teams of all time and explore why they failed to meet expectations. So, which team do you think was the most overrated? Let's find out!

Share this article