The Most Overrated Candy, Ranked

Voting rules: Choose the candy you think is the most overrated!

Updated on Apr 25, 2024 06:27

Every year, millions of candies are sold around the world, with some receiving more hype and attention than their taste might merit. It generates endless debates and discussions on which sweets are actually worth the hype. This discussion helps consumers make better choices and spend their money on candies that truly delight them. By participating in this ranking, you contribute to a crowd-sourced assessment that helps clarify which candies might be overhyped. This ranking not only entertains but also informs by aggregating diverse opinions into a comprehensive guide. Your votes matter in shaping a more accurate reflection of the candy landscape.

What Is the Most Overrated Candy?

1

72
votes
Evan-Amos · Public domain

Candy Corn

George Renninger

This overly-sweet, waxy candy is often associated with Halloween but has become a polarizing treat. Some people love it, while others cannot stand it.
Candy Corn is a tri-colored confectionery that resembles the shape of corn kernels. It has a distinct yellow tip, an orange center, and a white base. The texture is soft and chewy, with a sugary taste that some describe as honey-like. Candy Corn is often associated with Halloween and is commonly found in seasonal candy assortments.

Colors: Yellow, orange, and white

Texture: Soft and chewy

Taste: Sugary, sometimes described as honey-like

Seasonality: Commonly associated with Halloween

Shape: Resembles corn kernels
2

40
votes
Tootsie Rolls

Leo Hirschfeld

These chewy, chocolate-flavored candies have been around since 1896, but many people find them bland and unexciting.
Tootsie Rolls are a chewy chocolate-flavored candy that has gained popularity over the years. They have a distinct texture, similar to taffy, and a rich chocolate taste. Tootsie Rolls are often considered a classic American candy and have become a staple in many households.

Size: Approximately 3.5 inches (8.9 cm) in length

Shape: Cylindrical

Texture: Chewy

Flavor: Chocolate

Ingredients: Sugar, corn syrup, palm oil, condensed skim milk, cocoa, whey protein concentrate, artificial and natural flavors
3

17
votes
Evan-Amos · Public domain

Necco Wafers

Oliver R. Chase

These thin, chalky disks come in a variety of flavors but are often criticized for their lack of taste and texture.
Necco Wafers are a type of candy that come in the form of small, round, pastel-colored discs. They have a chalky texture and are often described as tasting like a mix of various flavors, including lemon, lime, orange, clove, cinnamon, wintergreen, and chocolate.

Shape: Round discs

Texture: Chalky

Flavors: Multiple (lemon, lime, orange, clove, cinnamon, wintergreen, and chocolate)

Colors: Pastel-colored

Ingredients: Sugar, corn syrup, gelatin, natural and artificial flavors
4

18
votes
Glane23 · CC BY-SA 3.0

Good & Plenty

The Hershey Company

These licorice-flavored candies are often cited as one of the worst Halloween treats, with their divisive taste and hard texture.
Good & Plenty is a classic licorice candy with a colorful candy shell. The bite-sized pieces have a firm, chewy texture and offer a sweet, yet slightly tangy flavor. It has been enjoyed by candy lovers for decades.

Type: Licorice candy

Shape: Cylinder-shaped pieces

Colors: Pink and white

Texture: Chewy

Flavor: Sweet and slightly tangy
Good & Plenty in other rankings
- Position 6 of 10 in Most popular type of licorice
5

16
votes
Famartin · CC BY-SA 4.0

Milk Duds

The Hershey Company

These chewy, caramel-covered chocolates are often difficult to eat and can get stuck in your teeth.
Milk Duds are a popular caramel candy that have gained a reputation for being overrated. They are small, bite-sized candies with a caramel core coated in a chocolate-flavored shell. The texture is chewy and sticky, and the flavor combination of caramel and chocolate is sweet and rich.

Size: Small, bite-sized

Texture: Chewy and sticky

Flavor: Sweet and rich caramel with a chocolate shell

Calories: Approximately 170 calories per serving

Ingredients: Sugar, corn syrup, skim milk, vegetable oil, cocoa powder, whey protein concentrate, salt, and natural and artificial flavors
Milk Duds in other rankings
- Position 4 of 10 in Most underrated candy
6

12
votes
Whoppers

This malted milk ball candy is often criticized for its grainy texture and lack of flavor.
Whoppers are a malted milk ball candy that consists of a malted milk center surrounded by a thin chocolate coating. They have a unique texture that is crunchy on the outside and chewy in the middle, offering a blend of sweet and malty flavors. Whoppers are favored by some for their nostalgic appeal and distinctive taste.

Type: Candy

Flavor: Malted milk and chocolate

Texture: Crunchy exterior, chewy center

Shape: Round balls

Size: Approximately 1 centimeter in diameter
7

7
votes
Bit-O-Honey

This chewy candy is made with honey and almond bits but has a reputation for being too hard and sticky.
Bit-O-Honey is a chewy candy known for its unique combination of honey and almond flavors. It has a taffy-like texture that offers a long-lasting chewy experience. The candy is individually wrapped and has a distinct yellow and brown color scheme.

Flavors: Honey and almond

Texture: Chewy and taffy-like

Color: Yellow and brown

Wrapper: Individually wrapped

Size: Small rectangular pieces
8

9
votes
Dots

These fruit-flavored gummy candies are often criticized for their hard texture and lack of flavor variety.
Dots is a classic chewy candy that is often considered overrated due to its texture and taste. It is known for its small, round shape and bright, vibrant colors. Each candy is individually coated in sugar crystals, adding an extra layer of sweetness. Dots have a soft, chewy consistency that can be polarizing among candy enthusiasts. They come in various flavors, including cherry, strawberry, lemon, lime, and orange, which are denoted by their corresponding colors.

Type: Chewy candy

Shape: Round

Colors: Assortment of bright colors

Coating: Sugar crystals

Consistency: Soft and chewy
9

10
votes
IvoShandor · CC BY-SA 3.0

Hershey's Kisses

Milton S. Hershey

These classic chocolate candies are often cited as overrated due to their simple flavor and lack of creativity.
Hershey's Kisses is a popular chocolate candy that is shaped like a small drop or a Hershey's milk chocolate chip. It is wrapped in foil and typically comes in a variety of colors. The candy has a smooth, creamy texture and a rich milk chocolate flavor. It is known for its distinct shape and the signature 'kiss' marking on the top.

Size: Approximately 0.875 inches (2.22 cm) in height and 0.75 inches (1.91 cm) in diameter

Weight: Approximately 4.5 grams per piece

Ingredients: Sugar, chocolate, cocoa butter, milk, milk fat, soy lecithin, natural flavors

Calories: Approximately 22 calories per piece

Packaging: Individually wrapped in aluminum foil
Hershey's Kisses in other rankings
- Position 4 of 10 in Most popular Hershey product
- Position 8 of 10 in Most popular Hershey bar
10

4
votes
Mounds

These coconut-filled chocolates are often criticized for being overly sweet and lacking in chocolate flavor.
Mounds is a candy bar that consists of a rich, dark chocolate coating filled with a smooth and creamy coconut center. It is often described as an indulgent treat with a perfect balance of sweet and tropical flavors.

Flavor: Coconut

Coating: Dark chocolate

Texture: Smooth and creamy

Size: Regular bar size

Calories: 220 calories per bar

Missing your favorite candy?

Graphs

Discussion

Ranking factors for overrated candy

Popularity

Consider how popular or well-known the candy is. If a candy is widely known and consumed, it is potentially more likely to be overrated.
Hype

Look at the advertising and promotional efforts behind the candy. Excessive marketing, celebrity endorsements, and heavy social media presence can contribute to a candy being overrated.
Taste

Evaluate the actual taste of the candy. If it does not live up to its reputation or if the flavor is not as good as other similar candies, it may be overrated.
Texture

Assess the texture of the candy. If it is too hard, sticky, or otherwise unpleasant, it might be overrated.
Ingredients

Review the ingredients. If the candy has poor-quality or unhealthy ingredients, it could be overrated.
Value

Compare the price of the candy to other similar products. If it is significantly more expensive without a notable difference in taste or quality, it may be overrated.
Nostalgia and Sentimentality

Examine how much the candy's reputation relies on nostalgia or sentimental factors. If it is highly regarded mainly due to childhood memories or cultural significance but falls short in taste or quality, it may be overrated.
Packaging and Presentation

Consider the appearance of the candy and its packaging. If it is overrated due to its looks rather than taste or quality, that should be taken into account.
Variety and Innovation

Look at how unique or innovative the candy is. If it is overrated because it is seen as innovative or unique but does not deliver in taste or quality, it could be overrated.
Consistency

Analyze the consistency of the candy's quality over time. If it has become overrated due to its past reputation and does not currently deliver the same level of taste, texture, or quality, it may be overrated.

About this ranking

This is a community-based ranking of the most overrated candy. We do our best to provide fair voting, but it is not intended to be exhaustive. So if you notice something or Candy is missing, feel free to help improve the ranking!

Statistics

2366 views
213 votes
10 ranked items

Voting Rules

A participant may cast an up or down vote for each Candy once every 24 hours. The rank of each Candy is then calculated from the weighted sum of all up and down votes.

More information on most overrated candy

Background Information: Candy has been a staple in human diets for centuries, and it continues to be a beloved treat worldwide. From chocolate bars to gummy bears, there's a wide variety of candies that cater to every taste bud. However, not all candies are created equal, and some are more popular than others. In fact, some candies are so hyped up that they become overrated, leading to disappointment for those who try them. The question of what is the most overrated candy has been a topic of debate among candy lovers for years. Some argue that it's the classic candy corn, while others believe it's the overly sweet and artificial tasting Skittles. Others still think that the trendy and expensive artisanal chocolates are overrated. Regardless of personal preferences, it's clear that some candies simply don't live up to the hype. So, what is the most overrated candy? It's up to you to decide, and StrawPoll has thousands of polls and rankings to help you find out!