The Most Underrated Candy, Ranked

Voting rules: Choose the candy you think is the most underrated!

Updated on May 10, 2024 06:59

There are countless candies out there that capture the hearts of many yet do not always receive the recognition they deserve. By ranking these hidden gems, we offer a chance to shine a spotlight on those delightful sweets that are typically overshadowed by more mainstream choices. This process not only opens up new possibilities for candy lovers but also brings a fresh appreciation for the diversity of flavors and creations in the confectionery universe. With every vote cast in favor of a beloved yet underappreciated candy, our rankings evolve to better reflect the true favorites of our community. This democratic approach ensures that every opinion is valued and every lesser-known treat gets its moment. As you participate, you help curate a more inclusive and representative listing that can intrigue and inspire your next sweet adventure.

What Is the Most Underrated Candy?

1

39
votes
Whoppers

These malted milk balls have a unique texture and flavor that sets them apart from other candies.
Whoppers are a malted milk ball candy that consists of a malted milk center surrounded by a thin chocolate coating. They have a unique texture that is crunchy on the outside and chewy in the middle, offering a blend of sweet and malty flavors. Whoppers are favored by some for their nostalgic appeal and distinctive taste.

Type: Candy

Flavor: Malted milk and chocolate

Texture: Crunchy exterior, chewy center

Shape: Round balls

Size: Approximately 1 centimeter in diameter
2

39
votes
Raisinets

Chocolate-covered raisins may not sound like the most exciting candy, but the combination of sweet and chewy is irresistible.
Raisinets are a type of confectionery made from chocolate-covered raisins. They consist of plump, juicy raisins coated in a smooth and rich chocolate shell. The combination of the sweet, chewy raisins and the creamy chocolate creates a delightful taste experience.

Type: Chocolate-covered raisins

Raisin Variety: Plump, juicy raisins

Chocolate Coating: Smooth and rich

Flavors: Variants available with milk chocolate or dark chocolate coating

Packaging: Available in various sizes, including boxes and theater-sized packs
3

24
votes
Evan-Amos · Public domain

Junior Mints

James Howard Welch

These small chocolate mints have a refreshing taste that is perfect for after dinner or as a movie snack.
Junior Mints is a popular mint-flavored candy that consists of a creamy peppermint filling coated in smooth dark chocolate. It is known for its refreshing taste and irresistible combination of mint and chocolate flavors.

Type: Candy

Flavor: Peppermint

Coating: Dark Chocolate

Texture: Creamy

Shape: Round
Junior Mints in other rankings
- Position 7 of 10 in Most popular mint-flavored candy
4

21
votes
Famartin · CC BY-SA 4.0

Milk Duds

The Hershey Company

These chewy caramel balls covered in chocolate are a classic candy that are often overlooked.
Milk Duds are a popular caramel candy that have gained a reputation for being overrated. They are small, bite-sized candies with a caramel core coated in a chocolate-flavored shell. The texture is chewy and sticky, and the flavor combination of caramel and chocolate is sweet and rich.

Size: Small, bite-sized

Texture: Chewy and sticky

Flavor: Sweet and rich caramel with a chocolate shell

Calories: Approximately 170 calories per serving

Ingredients: Sugar, corn syrup, skim milk, vegetable oil, cocoa powder, whey protein concentrate, salt, and natural and artificial flavors
Milk Duds in other rankings
- Position 5 of 10 in Most overrated candy
5

8
votes
Bit-O-Honey

This old-fashioned candy has a unique flavor that is a mix of honey and almond.
Bit-O-Honey is a chewy candy known for its unique combination of honey and almond flavors. It has a taffy-like texture that offers a long-lasting chewy experience. The candy is individually wrapped and has a distinct yellow and brown color scheme.

Flavors: Honey and almond

Texture: Chewy and taffy-like

Color: Yellow and brown

Wrapper: Individually wrapped

Size: Small rectangular pieces
6

7
votes
Red Vines

The American Licorice Company

These chewy red licorice sticks are a favorite of many, but are often overshadowed by their black licorice counterparts.
Red Vines is a delicious and flavorful candy that has been enjoyed by candy lovers for decades. It is a type of red licorice rope candy with a soft and chewy texture. Red Vines are known for their vibrant red color and their sweet and slightly fruity taste. They are often enjoyed as a nostalgic treat and are a classic candy choice for movie nights and snacking. Red Vines are loved by many for their simplicity and addictive flavor.

Type: Licorice candy

Texture: Soft and chewy

Color: Vibrant red

Taste: Sweet and slightly fruity

Popularity: Underrated
7

14
votes
Evan-Amos · Public domain

Charleston Chew

Fox-Cross Candy Company

This chewy chocolate bar has a nostalgic appeal and a flavor that is often forgotten.
Charleston Chew is a delightful candy bar that has been delighting taste buds since 1925. It features a chewy nougat center surrounded by a rich chocolatey coating. The candy bar is named after the Charleston, a popular dance in the 1920s, as it was believed to have a similar fun and playful spirit. With its unique texture and delicious flavor, Charleston Chew offers a nostalgic and satisfying candy experience.

Size: Each Charleston Chew bar is approximately 3.5 ounces.

Flavors: The original Charleston Chew comes in vanilla, chocolate, and strawberry flavors.

Texture: Charleston Chew has a chewy and nougat-like texture that melts in your mouth.

Shape: It is a long, rectangular candy bar.

Packaging: The candy bar is individually wrapped in colorful, distinctive packaging.
8

10
votes
Alansplodge · CC BY-SA 3.0

Mary Janes

These peanut butter flavored taffy candies have been around for over 100 years, but are often overlooked in favor of newer candies.
Mary Janes are a classic American candy that have been delighting taste buds since the early 1900s. These chewy, taffy-like candies feature a rich, peanut butter flavor that is both unique and delicious. With their distinctive yellow and red wrapper, Mary Janes are easily recognizable and often overlooked in favor of other more popular candies.

Flavor: Peanut Butter

Texture: Chewy

Wrapper: Yellow and Red

Size: Approximately 1 inch in length

Shape: Rectangular
9

9
votes
Evan-Amos · Public domain

Goo Goo Clusters

These candy bars have been around since 1912 and are made with peanuts, caramel, marshmallow, and chocolate.
Goo Goo Clusters are a beloved candy treat that originated in Nashville, Tennessee. They are a unique combination of caramel, marshmallow nougat, fresh roasted peanuts, and real milk chocolate. The result is a delicious, gooey, and indulgent candy bar.

Original creation date: 1912

Ingredients: Caramel, marshmallow nougat, roasted peanuts, milk chocolate

Texture: Gooey and chewy

Size: Approximately 1.75 oz (49g)

Calories per serving: 220
Goo Goo Clusters in other rankings
- Position 4 of 10 in Most popular food in Tennessee
10

3
votes
Nik-L-Nip

These wax bottles filled with flavored liquid have a unique texture and are a fun candy to eat.
Nik-L-Nip is a classic bite-sized candy that offers a unique and enjoyable experience. It consists of small wax bottles filled with flavored syrup, providing a sweet and long-lasting treat. The wax bottles can be bitten off to release the liquid inside, allowing for a delicious and playful consumption method.

Flavors: Available in various fruit flavors such as cherry, orange, and lime.

Packaging: Sold in small wax bottles, typically in packs of five.

Size: Each candy bottle is approximately 2 inches tall.

Texture: The wax bottles have a firm, chewy texture that gradually softens when bitten into.

Longevity: The flavors of Nik-L-Nip candies are long-lasting, providing an enjoyable taste experience.

Missing your favorite candy?

Graphs

Discussion

Ranking factors for underrated candy

Taste

The candy should be delicious and satisfying.
Availability

The candy should be widely available, so that people can try it and form an opinion.
Popularity

The candy should not be too popular, so that it is still considered underrated.
Sweetness

The candy should not be too sweet, but have a good balance of flavors.
Quality

The candy should be made with high-quality ingredients and be well-produced.
Uniqueness

The candy should have a unique taste or texture that sets it apart from other candies.

About this ranking

This is a community-based ranking of the most underrated candy. We do our best to provide fair voting, but it is not intended to be exhaustive. So if you notice something or Candy is missing, feel free to help improve the ranking!

Statistics

1996 views
166 votes
10 ranked items

Voting Rules

A participant may cast an up or down vote for each Candy once every 24 hours. The rank of each Candy is then calculated from the weighted sum of all up and down votes.

More information on most underrated candy

When it comes to candy, everyone has their favorites. But what about the candies that don't get the recognition they deserve? These are the underrated candies that may not be as popular as some of the classics, but are still worth giving a try. Whether it's a lesser-known brand or a flavor that doesn't get enough attention, there are plenty of underrated candies out there waiting to be discovered. So, which candy do you think deserves more love? Cast your vote and let us know!