The Most Underrated Chocolate Bar, Ranked

Choose the chocolate bar you think is the most underrated!

Author: Gregor Krambs
Updated on May 25, 2024 07:28
Many chocolate enthusiasts often find themselves sticking to tried and true favorites, potentially overlooking hidden gems in the confectionery aisle. By offering a chance to rank the most underrated chocolate bars, our community provides insights into delightful alternatives that might be missing from your radar. This approach not only broadens the horizons of taste but also supports lesser-known brands that deserve recognition. Every vote here shapes a real-time leaderboard that highlights these underrated selections based on community approval and experiences. Your participation is crucial as it imparts a more democratic view on what constitutes a great chocolate bar. Through your contributions, we can collectively shift industry focus towards these deserving treats, potentially influencing future product offerings.

What Is the Most Underrated Chocolate Bar?

  1. 1


    Whatchamacallit consists of peanut-flavored crisps topped with a layer of caramel and dipped in milk chocolate. Its name is as unique as its taste.
    • Manufacturer: Hershey
    • Introduced: 1978
  2. 2

    Zero Bar

    The Zero Bar is a combination of caramel, peanut and almond nougat covered with a layer of white fudge. Its unique flavor and color make it stand out.
    • Manufacturer: Hershey
    • Introduced: 1920
  3. 3

    Take 5

    Take 5 combines five ingredients: milk chocolate, peanuts, caramel, peanut butter, and pretzels, offering a unique salty-sweet taste and a variety of textures.
    • Manufacturer: Hershey
    • Introduced: 2004
  4. 4

    Violet Crumble

    An Australian classic, the Violet Crumble bar boasts a crispy honeycomb center coated in smooth milk chocolate. It's famous for its shattering crunch.
    • Country: Australia
    • Manufacturer: Robern Menz
  5. 5

    Sky Bar

    The Sky Bar is a unique offering with four different fillings - caramel, vanilla, peanut, and fudge - each in its own segment, coated with milk chocolate.
    • Manufacturer: Necco
    • Introduced: 1938
  6. 6

    Lion Bar

    The Lion Bar features a filled wafer, caramel, and crisp cereal covered in milk chocolate. It's known for its rugged appearance and satisfying texture.
    • Manufacturer: NestlĂ©
    • Introduced: 1976
  7. 7

    Idaho Spud

    The Idaho Spud Bar has been a favorite since it was first manufactured in 1918. It's a unique, marshmallow center drenched in dark chocolate and sprinkled with coconut.
    • Manufacturer: Idaho Candy Company
    • Introduced: 1918
  8. 8

    Milky Way Midnight

    Milky Way Midnight is the dark chocolate version of the classic bar, with vanilla-flavored nougat and caramel. It offers a richer taste for dark chocolate lovers.
    • Manufacturer: Mars, Incorporated
    • Variety Introduced: 2000
  9. 9

    Curly Wurly

    Curly Wurly is a fun and twisty chocolate bar made of milk chocolate-coated caramel. Its long, thin, and curly shape makes it a unique treat.
    • Manufacturer: Cadbury
    • Introduced: 1970
  10. 10


    Chomp is an affordable, no-frills chocolate bar with a simple caramel filling and a coating of milk chocolate. It's known for its satisfying chewiness.
    • Manufacturer: Cadbury
    • Introduced: 1976

Missing your favorite chocolate bar?

Error: Failed to render graph
No discussion started, be the first!

About this ranking

This is a community-based ranking of the most underrated chocolate bar. We do our best to provide fair voting, but it is not intended to be exhaustive. So if you notice something or bar is missing, feel free to help improve the ranking!


  • 25 votes
  • 10 ranked items

Voting Rules

A participant may cast an up or down vote for each bar once every 24 hours. The rank of each bar is then calculated from the weighted sum of all up and down votes.

Additional Information

More about the Most Underrated Chocolate Bar

Rank #1 for the most underrated chocolate bar: Whatchamacallit (Source)
Many chocolate bars line store shelves. Some stand out more than others. Yet, many remain overlooked. These underrated bars often offer unique flavors and textures. They deserve more attention.

Chocolate bars come in many forms. Some have nuts, others have fruit. Some mix in caramel or nougat. Each combination brings a new taste experience. Yet, the spotlight often shines on the same few brands. This leaves many great options in the shadows.

The origin of these bars often tells a rich story. Small, local producers craft many underrated bars. They use high-quality ingredients. They focus on the art of chocolate making. They take time to perfect their recipes. This dedication results in a superior product.

Many underrated bars use single-origin cocoa. This means the cocoa comes from one region. This practice allows the unique flavors of the cocoa to shine. It also supports local farmers. These farmers often use sustainable practices. This helps protect the environment.

Texture plays a key role in the enjoyment of chocolate. Underrated bars often excel in this area. They offer a satisfying snap when broken. They melt smoothly in the mouth. This texture comes from careful tempering. Tempering aligns the cocoa butter crystals. This process takes skill and patience.

Flavor is another area where underrated bars excel. They often have complex profiles. Some have fruity notes. Others have hints of coffee or spice. These flavors come from the type of cocoa bean used. They also come from the fermentation process. This process develops the bean's flavor before roasting.

Many underrated bars also avoid artificial additives. They use natural ingredients. This results in a purer taste. It also means fewer chemicals in your food. This focus on quality over quantity sets them apart.

These bars often come from ethical companies. They pay fair wages to their workers. They avoid child labor. They invest in their communities. This ethical stance adds value to their product. It also makes a difference in the lives of many people.

Packaging is another area where underrated bars shine. They often use eco-friendly materials. This reduces waste. It also shows their commitment to the environment. Some even use compostable wrappers. This helps reduce their carbon footprint.

Discovering these hidden gems takes some effort. They are not always in big stores. You might find them in small shops or online. Specialty food stores often carry them. Farmers' markets are another good place to look. Trying new bars can be an adventure. Each one offers a new taste experience.

In conclusion, many chocolate bars deserve more recognition. They offer unique flavors and textures. They come from dedicated producers. They use high-quality, ethical ingredients. They often support sustainable practices. They provide a richer, more satisfying experience. Exploring these bars can open up a whole new world of chocolate. Give them a try. You might find a new favorite.

Share this article