The Most Popular AHS Character: Ranking the Beloved Characters of American Horror Story

Choose the character you think is the most popular!

Author: Gregor Krambs
Updated on Sep 17, 2023 14:30
Step right up, all American Horror Story fans! It's time to cast your vote in the ultimate showdown of your favorite AHS characters. From the spine-chilling Murder House to the wickedly enchanting Coven, we at StrawPoll have curated the most iconic and unforgettable faces that have haunted our screens. Now, it's your turn to decide who will reign supreme in our "Most Popular AHS Character" ranking. Will it be the enigmatic Tate Langdon, the fierce Fiona Goode, or perhaps a dark horse we've yet to uncover? The choice is yours, and every vote counts. Don't see your top pick on the list? No need for a witch's curse—simply suggest your missing favorite and rally your fellow fans to join the thrilling race. Join us now in this captivating journey through the twisted world of AHS and let the battle for the title of supreme character begin!

Who Is the Most Popular AHS Character? (September 2023)

  1. 1
    Tate Langdon is portrayed by Evan Peters, Tate is one of the most iconic characters in AHS history. He is the focal point of the first season, Murder House, and has a complex and tragic backstory that makes him a fan favorite.
  2. 2
    Sister Jude Martin is played by Jessica Lange, Sister Jude is a strict and often cruel nun who runs the mental institution in Asylum. Her character arc is one of the most compelling in the series, and Lange's performance is outstanding.
  3. 3
    Fiona Goode is portrayed by Jessica Lange, Fiona is the Supreme witch in Coven and is a powerful and manipulative character. Her relationships with her daughter Cordelia and the other witches make her a complex and intriguing character.
  4. 4
    Misty Day played by Lily Rabe, Misty is a witch with the power of resurrection in Coven. She is a gentle and kind character who quickly becomes a fan favorite.
  5. 5
    Cordelia Foxx is portrayed by Sarah Paulson, Cordelia is Fiona's daughter and the headmistress of the witch academy in Coven. Her journey from a timid and unsure character to a confident and powerful leader is one of the highlights of the season.
  6. 6
    Myrtle Snow is played by Frances Conroy, Myrtle is a quirky and eccentric witch in Coven. Her fashion sense and dry wit make her a memorable character, and her tragic backstory adds depth to her personality.
  7. 7
    Liz Taylor
    Studio publicity still · Public domain
    Liz Taylor is portrayed by Denis O'Hare, Liz is a transgender woman who works at the Hotel Cortez in Hotel. Her character arc is one of acceptance and self-discovery, and O'Hare's performance is outstanding.
  8. 8
    Kai Anderson played by Evan Peters, Kai is a charismatic and manipulative cult leader in Cult. His unpredictable behavior and twisted ideology make him a compelling and terrifying character.
  9. 9
    Constance Langdon is portrayed by Jessica Lange, Constance is Tate's mother in Murder House. Her Southern charm and manipulative nature make her a memorable character, and Lange's performance is outstanding.
  10. 10
    James Patrick March is played by Evan Peters, March is the ghost of the founder and owner of the Hotel Cortez in Hotel. His dark humor and sadistic tendencies make him a memorable and chilling character.

Missing your favorite character?


Ranking factors for popular character

  1. Screen time
    The amount of focus and importance given to a character throughout the series can contribute to their popularity.
  2. Character development
    Characters who undergo significant growth or transformation, have complex backstories, or are given intriguing arcs tend to be more popular.
  3. Acting performance
    The skill and talent of the actor portraying the character can greatly impact their popularity. Memorable and impactful performances often resonate with viewers.
  4. Memorable moments
    Characters who have standout moments, scenes, or quotes that become iconic within the fanbase are more likely to be popular.
  5. Fan base response
    The response and affinity of the show's fanbase towards a character can be a good indicator of their popularity. This can include fan art, fanfiction, cosplay, or online discussions.
  6. Cultural impact
    Characters that become symbols or representations of certain themes, issues, or trends can be considered more popular due to their broader impact and recognition.
  7. It's important to note that popularity can be subjective, and different characters may resonate with different individuals. Rankings may differ based on personal preferences and opinions.

About this ranking

This is a community-based ranking of the most popular AHS character. We do our best to provide fair voting, but it is not intended to be exhaustive. So if you notice something or your favorite character is missing from the list, feel free to help us improve the ranking.


  • 184 votes
  • 10 ranked items

Voting Rules

A participant may cast an up or down vote for each character once every 24 hours. The rank of each character is then calculated from the weighted sum of all up and down votes.

More information on most popular ahs character

American Horror Story (AHS) is a popular anthology horror television series that has been on air since 2011. Each season features a different storyline, setting, and cast of characters, but what makes the show stand out is the recurring actors who play different roles each season. With nine seasons under its belt, AHS has amassed a fan following that eagerly anticipates each new installment. In this poll, we aim to find out who is the most popular AHS character among the show's many memorable and terrifying characters. From the ghosts of Murder House to the witches of Coven, each season brings a new set of characters to love (or fear). So, who will come out on top as the fan-favorite AHS character? Let's find out!