The Most Reliable Car Review Site, Ranked

Voting rules: Choose the car review site you think is the most reliable!

Updated on May 8, 2024 06:55

Choosing the right car can be a daunting task with the multitude of options and opinions available today. Reliable car review sites offer valuable insights that can guide prospective buyers in making informed decisions. However, with so many review sites claiming to be the best, it can be challenging for individuals to know which sources to trust. This dynamic ranking serves as a tool for users to cast votes on which car review sites they find most credible and useful. By participating, users contribute to a community-driven guide that highlights the most trustworthy sources. Such collective input ensures that the ranking remains reflective of real-world preferences and experiences, aiding others in finding quality information efficiently.

What Is the Most Reliable Car Review Site?

1

62
votes
Consumer Reports

Arthur Kallet, Colston Warne

Consumer Reports is a nonprofit organization that conducts independent and unbiased testing of various consumer products, including cars. They conduct extensive testing and provide detailed reviews of cars based on criteria such as reliability, safety, and performance. They also provide ratings for individual models, making it easy for consumers to compare cars.
Consumer Reports is a nonprofit organization that provides unbiased product reviews and ratings to help consumers make informed buying decisions. It conducts rigorous tests and research on various products, including electronics, appliances, vehicles, and more. Consumer Reports aims to empower consumers by providing reliable and trustworthy information.

Nonprofit Organization: Yes

Established year: 1936

Headquarters: Yonkers, New York, USA

Availability: Nationwide

Product Reviews: Yes
2

14
votes
Edmunds

Edmunds is a popular car review site that provides expert reviews, ratings, and comparisons of cars. They also offer a variety of tools and resources, such as a car payment calculator and a car finder tool, to help consumers make informed decisions. Edmunds also offers long-term reviews of cars, which can provide a more thorough assessment of a car's reliability and performance.
Edmunds is a well-known and highly regarded car review website that provides comprehensive and reliable information on various vehicles. It offers expert reviews, ratings, comparisons, and other valuable resources to assist consumers in making informed decisions when purchasing a car. With its vast database and extensive coverage of different makes and models, Edmunds has become a trusted source for car enthusiasts and buyers alike.

Vehicle Database: Offers information on a wide range of vehicles

Expert Reviews: Provides detailed reviews from automotive experts

Ratings and Rankings: Offers comprehensive ratings and rankings for vehicles

Comparison Tools: Allows users to compare multiple vehicles side by side

Price Analysis: Provides pricing insights and analysis
3

10
votes
Car and Driver

Car and Driver is a magazine and website that provides in-depth reviews of cars, along with news, features, and videos. They have a team of experienced writers and editors who test cars on a variety of road conditions and provide detailed analysis of their performance. Car and Driver also offers a variety of tools, such as a car comparison tool, to help consumers make informed decisions.
Car and Driver is a reputable car review site that provides comprehensive and accurate information on various car models. It covers a wide range of vehicles, from budget-friendly options to luxury cars. Car and Driver is known for its in-depth reviews, detailed specifications, and insightful analysis of the automotive industry.

Reliability: Provides reliable and unbiased car reviews.

Variety: Covers a wide range of car models and types.

Detail-oriented: Offers in-depth reviews with comprehensive information.

Expert analysis: Provides insightful analysis of the automotive industry.

Accuracy: Delivers accurate and up-to-date specifications of cars.
4

24
votes
Chevrolet · Public domain

Motor Trend

Motor Trend is a magazine and website that provides reviews, news, and features on cars. They have a team of experienced writers and editors who test cars and provide detailed analysis of their performance. Motor Trend also offers a variety of tools, such as a car comparison tool and a car payment calculator, to help consumers make informed decisions.
Motor Trend in other rankings
- Position 9 of 10 in Most popular automotive YouTubers
5

14
votes
Kelley Blue Book

Les Kelley

Kelley Blue Book is a website that provides expert reviews, ratings, and comparisons of cars. They also offer a variety of tools and resources, such as a car payment calculator and a car finder tool, to help consumers make informed decisions. Kelley Blue Book also provides pricing information for new and used cars, which can be helpful when negotiating with dealerships.
Kelley Blue Book is a widely recognized and highly trusted car review website that provides unbiased and comprehensive information about various car models and their market values. It helps potential car buyers make informed decisions by offering expert reviews, ratings, and comparisons.

Established: 1926

Owned By: Cox Automotive

Website: www.kbb.com

Available Regions: United States, Canada

Car Information: Detailed specifications, pricing, reviews, ratings, and comparisons
6

17
votes
Autotrader

Autotrader is a website that provides reviews, ratings, and comparisons of cars. They also offer a variety of tools and resources, such as a car payment calculator and a car finder tool, to help consumers make informed decisions. Autotrader also provides pricing information for new and used cars, which can be helpful when negotiating with dealerships.
Autotrader is a popular online platform for buying and selling new and used vehicles. It offers a wide range of cars, trucks, SUVs, and motorcycles from various manufacturers. Autotrader provides an easy-to-use interface, extensive search filters, and reliable listings to help users find their desired vehicle.

Founded: 1997

Headquarters: Atlanta, Georgia, USA

Available in: United States

Website: www.autotrader.com

Listing Types: New and used cars, trucks, SUVs, motorcycles
7

5
votes
CarGurus

CarGurus is a website that provides reviews, ratings, and comparisons of cars. They also offer a variety of tools and resources, such as a car payment calculator and a car finder tool, to help consumers make informed decisions. CarGurus also provides pricing information for new and used cars, which can be helpful when negotiating with dealerships.
CarGurus is a popular online marketplace for buying and selling new and used cars. It provides a platform for individuals and dealerships to list their vehicles and connect with potential buyers. CarGurus is known for its extensive inventory, user-friendly interface, and transparent pricing information, making it a trusted source for car buyers and sellers.

Founded: 2006

Headquarters: Cambridge, Massachusetts

Monthly Unique Visitors: approximately 28 million

Availability: United States, Canada, United Kingdom

Listings: over 5 million active car listings
8

9
votes
U.S. News & World Report · Public domain

U.S. News & World Report

U.S. News & World Report

U.S. News & World Report is a website that provides expert reviews, ratings, and comparisons of cars. They also offer a variety of tools and resources, such as a car payment calculator and a car finder tool, to help consumers make informed decisions. U.S. News & World Report also provides rankings of cars in various categories, such as best compact cars or best luxury SUVs.
U.S. News & World Report is a widely recognized and highly regarded car review site that provides unbiased and comprehensive information about various car models. It guides consumers in making informed decisions by offering detailed reviews, rankings, and ratings based on expert analysis and data-driven research.

Expert Reviews: Detailed reviews and opinions from experienced automotive journalists.

Ranking and Ratings: Rankings and ratings that offer objective evaluations of car models in various categories.

Safety Scores: In-depth analysis of safety features and crash test ratings.

Reliability Data: Reliability scores based on surveys and data collected from car owners.

Performance Metrics: Performance specifications and test results for acceleration, handling, and fuel efficiency.
U.S. News & World Report in other rankings
- Position 1 of 10 in Most reliable college ranking site
9

2
votes
Phil Guest from Bournemouth, UK · CC BY-SA 2.0

Top Gear

Jeremy Clarkson, Andy Wilman

Top Gear is a British television show and website that provides reviews, news, and features on cars. They have a team of experienced writers and presenters who test cars and provide detailed analysis of their performance. Top Gear also offers a variety of videos and other multimedia content, which can be entertaining and informative for car enthusiasts.
Top Gear is a British television series focused on automotive topics, primarily showcasing various luxury and sports cars. The show combines car reviews, motoring challenges, races, and celebrity interviews with a humorous and often irreverent tone. It has gained a massive global following due to its entertaining format and impressive production quality.

Original release: 20 October 2002

Presenters: Jeremy Clarkson, Richard Hammond, James May

Production company: BBC Studios

Number of seasons: 27

Number of episodes: 200+
10

3
votes
Patrick Hong, Road & Track Magazine · CC BY-SA 4.0

Road & Track

Road & Track is a magazine and website that provides reviews, news, and features on cars. They have a team of experienced writers and editors who test cars and provide detailed analysis of their performance. Road & Track also offers a variety of tools, such as a car comparison tool and a car payment calculator, to help consumers make informed decisions.
Road & Track is a renowned car review site that provides in-depth information and analysis on the latest vehicles in the market. With a long history dating back to 1947, it has established itself as a trusted source for automotive enthusiasts.

Established: 1947

Focus: In-depth car reviews and analysis

Target Audience: Automotive enthusiasts

Website: https://www.roadandtrack.com/

Written Content: Yes

Missing your favorite car review site?

Graphs

Discussion

Ranking factors for reliable car review site

Trustworthiness

The site should be transparent and honest in its reviews, and not have any conflicts of interest.
Expertise

The site should have expert reviewers who are knowledgeable about cars and can provide accurate and detailed information.
Range of reviews

The site should offer reviews on a wide range of car models, from different manufacturers, and provide comparisons between them.
User reviews

The site should allow users to post their own reviews and ratings of cars, so that visitors can get a broad range of opinions.
Timeliness

The site should provide frequent updates on new car models and changes to existing ones, so that visitors can access up-to-date information.

About this ranking

This is a community-based ranking of the most reliable car review site. We do our best to provide fair voting, but it is not intended to be exhaustive. So if you notice something or site is missing, feel free to help improve the ranking!

Statistics

1743 views
162 votes
10 ranked items

Voting Rules

A participant may cast an up or down vote for each site once every 24 hours. The rank of each site is then calculated from the weighted sum of all up and down votes.

More information on most reliable car review site

When looking to make a purchase as significant as a car, it's important to do your research and seek out reliable information. Car review sites can be a helpful resource, but with so many out there, it can be difficult to determine which ones are trustworthy. Some of the most popular car review sites include Consumer Reports, Edmunds, Kelley Blue Book, and Car and Driver. Each of these sites has their own approach to reviewing cars, with some focusing on objective data and others prioritizing subjective opinions. It's important to consider multiple sources and weigh the pros and cons of each review site before making a decision. Ultimately, the most reliable car review site is one that provides unbiased information and helps you make an informed decision about the car that's right for you.