The Most Famous Phantom of the Opera: A Ranking of Legendary Performances

Choose the Phantom you think is the most famous!

Author: Gregor Krambs
Updated on Mar 5, 2024 07:16
Unmask the mystery and let your voice be heard in the ultimate showdown of the Phantoms! Here at StrawPoll, we're assembling the most enigmatic and talented Phantoms of the Opera from across the ages, and we need your help to determine who truly stands as the most famous and revered of them all. With thousands of polls and rankings on a plethora of topics, we invite you to step into the shadows of the Paris Opera House and cast your vote for your favorite Phantom. Be it the mesmerizing performance of Michael Crawford, the undeniable charm of Gerard Butler, or the chilling portrayal by Lon Chaney, the choice is yours! Is there a Phantom we've overlooked? Fear not, for you can suggest a missing maestro and add them to the list. So, don't let the music of the night fade away – join us now at StrawPoll to cast your vote and unveil the true legend that lies beneath the mask!

Who Is the Most Famous Phantom of the Opera?

  1. 1
    He originated the role in the West End and won an Olivier Award for his performance. He also starred in the original Broadway production and the 25th Anniversary concert.
  2. 2
    He played the role in the 2004 film adaptation, which brought the story to a wider audience.
    Gerard Butler in other rankings
  3. 3
    Ramin Karimloo
    Philip Romano · CC BY-SA 4.0
    He has played the Phantom in multiple productions, including the West End, Broadway, and the 25th Anniversary concert. He is known for his powerful vocals and emotional performances.
    Ramin Karimloo in other rankings
  4. 4
    He played the Phantom in the 2019 Australian production, which was filmed for a cinematic release.
  5. 5
    He played the Phantom in the original Canadian production and later starred in the West End and Broadway productions of Les Misérables.
    Colm Wilkinson in other rankings
  6. 6
    He has played the Phantom in multiple productions, including the West End and Broadway. He is known for his powerful and versatile voice.
  7. 7
    Hugh Panaro
    Bonnie Kavett (CapeTwirl at en.wikipedia) · CC BY-SA 2.5
    He played the Phantom in the Broadway production for over 2,000 performances and received critical acclaim for his interpretation of the character.
  8. 8
    He has played the Phantom in multiple productions, including the West End and Broadway. He is known for his emotional performances and powerful vocals.
  9. 9
    He has played the Phantom in multiple productions, including the West End and Broadway. He is known for his intense and dramatic portrayal of the character.
  10. 10
    He played the Phantom in a 1990 TV adaptation of the musical, which was based on the original novel. He brought a more sinister and menacing interpretation to the character.

Missing your favorite Phantom?


Ranking factors for famous Phantom

  1. Performer's Reputation
    The reputation and overall popularity of the performer who portrayed the Phantom can greatly affect their ranking. Established actors or singers might bring a level of recognition and fan base to the role.
  2. Stage Productions
    Different stage productions of the Phantom of the Opera have varied in terms of their success and impact. The scale, production quality, unique interpretations, and critical reception of a specific version can play a role in its fame.
  3. Film Adaptations
    Film adaptations of the Phantom of the Opera can also contribute to fame. The success and popularity of a movie version, as well as the performance of the actor playing the role, can elevate their ranking.
  4. Cultural Influence
    The cultural impact and longevity of a particular portrayal should be considered. If a specific Phantom interpretation has had a lasting impact on popular culture, it can be indicative of its fame.
  5. Box Office and Sales
    The box office success of a stage production or the commercial success of a recording can also be an important factor. Higher sales or ticket revenue can indicate a larger audience and popularity.
  6. Critical Reception
    The critical reception of a performance or production can influence its ranking. Positive reviews from theatre critics and scholars may solidify a version's prominence.
  7. Fan Base and Popularity
    The size and dedication of a fan base can contribute to the fame of a specific Phantom portrayal. A strong following, fan forums, and ongoing fan activities can highlight its enduring popularity.

About this ranking

This is a community-based ranking of the most famous Phantom of the Opera. We do our best to provide fair voting, but it is not intended to be exhaustive. So if you notice something or Phantom is missing, feel free to help improve the ranking!


  • 201 votes
  • 10 ranked items

Voting Rules

A participant may cast an up or down vote for each Phantom once every 24 hours. The rank of each Phantom is then calculated from the weighted sum of all up and down votes.

More information on most famous phantom of the opera

The Phantom of the Opera is a timeless classic that has captivated audiences for over a century. The story of the mysterious and disfigured musical genius who haunts the Paris Opera House has been adapted into countless movies, musicals, and plays. The titular character has become an icon in popular culture, with many actors and performers taking on the role over the years. From Lon Chaney's haunting portrayal in the 1925 film to Gerard Butler's brooding performance in the 2004 movie adaptation, the Phantom has been reimagined and reinvented time and time again. But who is the most famous Phantom of the Opera? Let's take a closer look at some of the most notable actors who have brought the character to life on stage and screen.

Share this article