The Most Popular Harry Potter Fanfiction: A Ranking of Fan Favorites

Choose the fanfiction you think is the most popular!

Author: Gregor Krambs
Updated on Apr 22, 2024 07:11
Welcome to StrawPoll, the magical realm where thousands of curious minds come together to voice their opinions and cast their votes! This time, we're brewing up a spellbinding ranking of "What is the most popular Harry Potter fanfiction?" — and we need YOUR help! Unleash your inner Potterhead and fly through our enchanting list of fanfictions, each more gripping than the last. But don't worry if your favorite story is missing from our Hogwarts-style feast; simply conjure up a suggestion, and we'll add it to the mix. So, grab your wands and join us on this enthralling journey where every vote counts and every story weaves a spell that keeps us wanting more. Together, let's discover which Harry Potter fanfiction reigns supreme in the hearts of readers around the world!

What Is the Most Popular Harry Potter Fanfiction?

  1. 1
    Despite its poor writing quality and nonsensical plot, "My Immortal" has become a cult classic among Harry Potter fanfiction readers for its unintentional humor and absurdity.
  2. 2
    This fanfiction follows the Marauders during their time at Hogwarts and is known for its well-written characterizations and attention to detail.
    The Shoebox Project is a popular Harry Potter fanfiction written by Lady Jaida and Dorkorific. It is an epic tale that follows the story of the Marauders (James Potter, Sirius Black, Remus Lupin, and Peter Pettigrew) during their time at Hogwarts School of Witchcraft and Wizardry. The story is mainly told through a series of letters, notes, and diary entries, giving it a unique and immersive narrative style. The Shoebox Project explores complex themes such as friendship, love, loss, and the challenges of growing up in a war-torn wizarding world.
    • Length: Approximately 684,000 words
    • Published: 2003-2008
    • Format: Epistolary style (letters, notes, diary entries)
    • Main Characters: James Potter, Sirius Black, Remus Lupin, Peter Pettigrew
    • Setting: Hogwarts School of Witchcraft and Wizardry
  3. 3
    This fanfiction explores what happened at Hogwarts during the year Harry, Ron, and Hermione were on the run in Deathly Hallows. It is known for its complex plot and well-developed OCs.
    Dumbledore's Army and the Year of Darkness is a popular Harry Potter fanfiction written by Thanfiction. The story takes place during the wizarding war against Lord Voldemort and follows the members of Dumbledore's Army as they face various challenges and personal struggles. It explores themes of friendship, loyalty, and the consequences of war. The fanfiction has gained a significant following for its intricate plot and well-developed characters.
    • Genre: Fanfiction
    • Fandom: Harry Potter
    • Setting: During the wizarding war against Lord Voldemort
    • Theme: Friendship, loyalty, consequences of war
    • Plot: Intricate
  4. 4
    This fanfiction is a reimagining of the Harry Potter series in which Harry is raised by a scientist and approaches magic from a rational, scientific perspective. It is known for its intellectual depth and exploration of scientific concepts.
    Harry Potter and the Methods of Rationality is a widely popular Harry Potter fanfiction written by Eliezer Yudkowsky. In this alternate universe story, Harry Potter is raised by a scientist and becomes a rational thinker. The narrative explores Harry's intellectual growth and his attempts to apply scientific methods to magic. With a unique blend of comedy, philosophy, and adventure, it has gained a large following among fans of both Harry Potter and rationalist fiction.
    • Genre: Fanfiction
    • Length: 661,619 words
    • Chapters: 122 chapters
    • Publication Dates: 2009-2015
    • Rating: 4.3/5 on
  5. 5
    This fanfiction follows Sirius Black and Harry as they accidentally travel to an alternate universe and have to navigate a world where Voldemort was defeated in a different way. It is known for its humor and creative world-building.
    A Black Comedy is a Harry Potter fanfic written by nonjon. It is a comedic parody of the original series, featuring a different approach to the story and characters. The main premise involves Sirius Black and Harry Potter accidentally ending up in an alternate universe, where they encounter various unexpected situations and characters from other fictional universes.
    • Rating: Mature
    • Word Count: 186,789 words
    • Published: 2004-2006
    • Genre: Comedy
    • Alternate Universe: Yes
  6. 6
    This fanfiction follows Lily and James during their time at Hogwarts and is known for its well-written characterizations and attention to detail. It is also one of the longest Harry Potter fanfictions, with over 1.2 million words.
    The Life and Times is a popular Harry Potter fanfiction written by Jewels5. This story features the marauders era and focuses on the life of Lily Evans and her relationship with James Potter amidst the growing threat of Lord Voldemort. It explores their friendships, school life at Hogwarts, and the challenges they face during a dark and tumultuous time. With its engaging plot and well-developed characters, the fic has gained a large following within the Harry Potter fanfiction community.
    • Genre: Fanfiction
    • Harry Potter Era: Marauders Era
    • Main Characters: Lily Evans, James Potter
    • Focus: Relationships, School Life, Adventure
    • Themes: Friendship, Love, Darkness
  7. 7
    This fanfiction is a parody of Fifty Shades of Grey, with Harry and Hermione as the main characters. It is known for its humor and satirical take on the original book.
  8. 8
    This fanfiction is a Christian reimagining of the Harry Potter series, in which Harry attends a Hogwarts that teaches Christian values. It is known for its unintentional humor and controversial take on the original series.
    The Hogwarts School of Prayer and Miracles is a Harry Potter fanfiction written by proudhousewife. It is a parody fic that takes a unique approach to the Harry Potter universe by incorporating Christian themes. The story centers around a highly religious version of Hogwarts where characters pray and follow biblical teachings instead of using magic. Here are ten important specifications about the fanfiction:
    • Genre: Parody
    • Setting: Hogwarts School of Witchcraft and Wizardry
    • Themes: Religion and faith
    • Characters: Harry Potter, Hermione Granger, Ron Weasley, etc.
    • Writing style: Satirical and humorous
  9. 9
    This fanfiction is a comedic take on what would happen if Voldemort accidentally turned Harry into a Horcrux. It is known for its humor and creative premise.
  10. 10
    This fanfiction follows Harry as he is sent back in time to his younger self and has to prevent the events that led to Voldemort's rise to power. It is known for its intricate plotting and attention to detail.
    Harry Potter and the Nightmares of Futures Past is a widely acclaimed Harry Potter fanfiction written by S'Tarkan. The story takes place during Harry's fifth year at Hogwarts, where a disillusioned and battle-hardened Harry Potter mysteriously gets sent back in time to his younger self. With the knowledge of the future at hand, Harry attempts to right the wrongs of the past and prevent the rise of Lord Voldemort.
    • Genre: Fanfiction, Time Travel, Action, Adventure
    • Word Count: Approximately 614,000 words
    • Status: Complete
    • Rating: Rated T
    • Main Characters: Harry Potter, Hermione Granger, Ron Weasley, Severus Snape, Lord Voldemort

Missing your favorite fanfiction?


Ranking factors for popular fanfiction

  1. Number of views/readers
    The popularity of a fanfiction can be measured by the number of views or readers it has garnered over time. This will give you an indication of the fanfiction's reach.
  2. Ratings/Reviews
    Positive reviews and high ratings from readers indicate that the fanfiction has been well-received. Ratings and reviews show how much the readers appreciate and engage with the content.
  3. Favorites/Bookmarks
    If a fanfiction has been added to a significant number of favorites or bookmarks lists, it is an indication that it has made an impact on its readers who wish to read or revisit it in the future.
  4. Author's reputation
    Some fanfiction authors have a strong following and are known for their writing skills and captivating storytelling. Fanfictions written by popular authors may be considered more popular.
  5. Recommendations
    Fanfictions that are often recommended by readers or mentioned in lists by the fan community showcase their popularity and influence.
  6. Awards
    Many fanfiction communities give awards for outstanding works in various categories, such as best plot, character development, or writing. If a Harry Potter fanfiction has received any accolades, it's a positive sign of its quality and popularity.
  7. Social media shares
    The number of times a fanfiction has been shared or talked about on social media platforms can also be used to gauge its popularity, as it shows how much buzz and discussion it has generated.
  8. Length and completion status
    Longer or completed fanfictions often have more views and reader engagement as they offer a more comprehensive and satisfying reading experience.
  9. Age and relevance
    A fanfiction's popularity can also be evaluated based on how long it has been in circulation and whether it remains relevant to the current fan community, adapting to changing preferences or developments in the source material.
  10. Universality and uniqueness
    Fanfictions that appeal to a wider audience or offer a unique perspective or plot are likely to be more popular as they can attract diverse readership and stand out from the crowd.

About this ranking

This is a community-based ranking of the most popular Harry Potter fanfiction. We do our best to provide fair voting, but it is not intended to be exhaustive. So if you notice something or Story is missing, feel free to help improve the ranking!


  • 192 votes
  • 10 ranked items

Voting Rules

A participant may cast an up or down vote for each Story once every 24 hours. The rank of each Story is then calculated from the weighted sum of all up and down votes.


More information on most popular harry potter fanfiction

Harry Potter fanfiction has been a popular genre since the release of the first book in 1997. Fans of the series have taken to writing their own stories set in the magical world created by J.K. Rowling, often exploring different plotlines and character relationships than those in the original books. With the rise of online communities dedicated to sharing and discussing fanfiction, there are now countless Harry Potter stories available to read, ranging from short one-shots to epic multi-book series. Some of these fanfictions have gained huge followings, with readers eagerly awaiting updates and discussing theories about what might happen next. With so much content available, it's no wonder that fans are always curious about which stories are the most popular among their peers.

Share this article