The Most Popular Indie Game of All Time: Uncovering the Ultimate Fan Favorite

Choose the game you think is the most popular!

Author: Gregor Krambs
Jun 16, 2023 10:18 (Updated on Dec 2, 2023 08:14)
Welcome to StrawPoll, where your opinion takes center stage! Today, we're on a quest to discover the most popular Indie game of all time, and we need your help! From retro pixel art adventures to innovative, mind-bending puzzles, indie games have captured our hearts and minds, pushing the boundaries of creativity and storytelling. Dive into our carefully curated list of unforgettable indie classics, cast your vote for your all-time favorite, and help us crown the ultimate fan favorite. Don't see your beloved gem on our list? No problem! Show your passion by suggesting a missing option and rally your fellow gamers to make your choice rise to the top. Let's embark on this gaming journey together and explore the captivating world of indie masterpieces, only at StrawPoll.

What Is the Most Popular Indie Game of All Time?

  1. 1
    This game has sold over 200 million copies and has a massive community of players and content creators. It has influenced the development of countless other indie games.
    Minecraft is a sandbox video game that allows players to build and explore virtual worlds made up of blocks. It offers various game modes such as survival, creative, adventure, and spectator, giving players the freedom to play and create in their own style. With its pixelated graphics and endless possibilities, Minecraft has become a popular game across different age groups and has sparked a large community of dedicated players and creators.
    • Platform: Multiple platforms including PC, consoles, and mobile devices
    • Genre: Sandbox, survival, adventure
    • Multiplayer: Available for online multiplayer with friends
    • Game Modes: Survival, creative, adventure, spectator
    • World Size: Virtually infinite, procedurally generated worlds
  2. 2

    Stardew Valley

    Eric Barone (ConcernedApe)
    This farming simulator has sold over 10 million copies and has been praised for its relaxing gameplay and charming art style.
    Stardew Valley is a fun and relaxing farming simulation game available on the Nintendo Switch. It is a single-player game where players inherit a farm in a small town and must work to restore it to its former glory. The game offers a wide range of activities like planting crops, raising animals, fishing, mining, and interacting with the town's inhabitants. It also includes exploration elements, seasonal events, and various customization options for your farm and character.
    • Release Date: 2017
    • Genre: Farming simulation, role-playing
    • Platform: Nintendo Switch
    • Modes: Single-player
    • Graphics: Pixel art
    Stardew Valley in other rankings
  3. 3
    This RPG has gained a cult following for its unique storytelling, memorable characters, and multiple endings. It has sold over 3.5 million copies.
    Undertale is a critically acclaimed Indie game that was released in 2015. It was developed by Toby Fox, who is also credited for writing the game's story, composing the music, and creating the pixel art. Undertale is known for its unique gameplay mechanics, witty writing, and emotional storytelling. The game revolves around a human child who falls into an underground world populated by monsters. The player can choose to either fight or befriend the monsters they encounter, leading to multiple branching paths and multiple endings. Undertale also subverts traditional RPG expectations, allowing players to progress through the game without killing any enemies.
    • Release Year: 2015
    • Gameplay Style: Role-playing
    • Graphics: Pixel art
    • Platform: Microsoft Windows, macOS
    • Game Length: 6-8 hours
  4. 4
    This 2D sandbox game has sold over 35 million copies and has a vast world to explore and build in. It has also been praised for its diverse gameplay mechanics.
    Terraria is a sandbox adventure game that combines elements of exploration, building, combat, and mining. Players are immersed in a dynamically generated 2D world where they can craft items, build structures, dig underground for resources, and battle various enemies and bosses.
    • Platform(s): Windows, macOS, Linux, PlayStation 4, Xbox One, Nintendo Switch, iOS, Android
    • Genre: Action-adventure, Sandbox, Survival
    • Release Date: May 16, 2011
    • Game Modes: Single-player, Multiplayer
    • Graphics: 2D Sprite-based
  5. 5
    This puzzle-platformer was a critical and commercial success, winning multiple awards and selling over 1 million copies. It is known for its innovative time-manipulation gameplay.
    Braid is a challenging puzzle-platformer game that was released in 2008. It combines elements of time manipulation and intricate puzzles to create a unique gaming experience. In each level, the player controls the protagonist named Tim as he embarks on a journey to rescue a princess from a menacing monster. As the game progresses, the story unfolds in mysterious ways, leaving players to interpret its meaning.
    • Platform: Available on multiple platforms including Microsoft Windows, Xbox 360, PlayStation 3, macOS, and Linux.
    • Graphics: Features hand-drawn visual style with vibrant colors and detailed environments.
    • Time manipulation: Player can control time by rewinding and manipulating it to solve puzzles and overcome obstacles.
    • Puzzle complexity: Offers complex and mind-bending puzzles that require creative thinking and experimentation.
    • Narrative: Contains a thought-provoking and metaphorical storyline that unfolds gradually throughout the game.
  6. 6
    This atmospheric puzzle-platformer has won numerous awards and has been praised for its haunting visuals and sound design. It has sold over 6 million copies.
    Limbo is a unique Warframe that specializes in manipulating dimensions and rifts. With his abilities, Limbo can control and trap enemies in a realm between realities, rendering them helpless. He can also create protective barriers and banish himself or allies to the rift, making them invulnerable to damage. Limbo's playstyle revolves around strategic use of his abilities to control the battlefield and protect himself and his team.
    • Health: 100 (300 at rank 30)
    • Shield: 75 (225 at rank 30)
    • Armor: 65
    • Energy: 150 (225 at rank 30)
    • Sprint Speed: 1.15
  7. 7


    This puzzle-platformer has gained a cult following for its mind-bending gameplay mechanics and retro-inspired art style. It has sold over 1 million copies.
    Fez is a puzzle-platform video game that was released in 2012. It combines 2D platforming with a unique 3D perspective-shifting mechanic.
    • Platform(s): Microsoft Windows, Xbox 360, PlayStation 3, PlayStation 4, PlayStation Vita, Linux, macOS
    • Genre: Puzzle-platformer
    • Modes: Single-player
    • Release Date: April 13, 2012
    • Publisher: Polytron Corporation
  8. 8
    This challenging platformer has won multiple awards and has been praised for its tight controls and punishing difficulty. It has sold over 2 million copies.
    Super Meat Boy is a challenging platform game where players control a small, animated meat cube named Meat Boy. The game is known for its intense difficulty, requiring precise timing and precise control of the protagonist. It features various levels filled with hazards and obstacles that players must navigate through. The game is renowned for its unforgiving difficulty and addictive gameplay.
    • Genre: Platformer
    • Platform: Microsoft Windows, macOS, Linux, Xbox 360, PlayStation 4, PlayStation Vita, Wii U, Nintendo Switch
    • Release Date: October 20, 2010
    • Difficulty: Extremely Difficult
    • Number of Levels: Over 300
    Super Meat Boy in other rankings
  9. 9

    Don't Starve

    Klei Entertainment
    This survival game has sold over 10 million copies and has been praised for its challenging gameplay and unique art style. It has spawned multiple expansions and spin-offs.
    Don't Starve is a challenging and highly engaging survival game that tests players' ability to survive in a dark and eerie world. The game, developed by Klei Entertainment, offers a unique blend of crafting, exploration, and resource management.
    • Genre: Survival
    • Platform(s): PC, Mac, Linux, PlayStation 4, Xbox One, Nintendo Switch
    • Release Date: April 23, 2013
    • Single Player: Yes
    • Multiplayer: Yes
    Don't Starve in other rankings
  10. 10

    Castle Crashers

    The Behemoth
    This co-operative hack-and-slash game has sold over 2 million copies and has been praised for its humor, colorful art style, and addictive gameplay.
    Castle Crashers is a beloved indie game that falls under the action-adventure and beat 'em up genres. Players embark on a whimsical journey filled with humor, hack-and-slash combat, and entertaining boss battles. The game features hand-drawn 2D graphics combined with fast-paced gameplay, making it visually appealing and engaging for players of all ages.
    • Platforms: PlayStation 4, Nintendo Switch, Xbox One, Microsoft Windows, macOS
    • Release Date: August 27, 2008
    • Number of Players: Up to 4 players (local and online co-op)
    • Game Modes: Single-player, multiplayer
    • Playable Characters: Over 30 characters to unlock and choose from
    Castle Crashers in other rankings

Missing your favorite game?


Ranking factors for popular game

  1. Sales and revenue
    One of the primary factors in determining the popularity of an indie game is the number of units sold and the overall revenue generated. These figures indicate the game's success in attracting a large player base and generating consistent income.
  2. User reviews and ratings
    Players' opinions matter when it comes to ranking indie games. The average review score, number of ratings, and player testimonials provide insights into a game's overall quality and how satisfied the players are with their experience.
  3. Awards and recognition
    Indie games that have received critical acclaim, prestigious awards, and recognition from industry experts indicate a higher level of popularity and success.
  4. Community engagement
    Active engagement from the player base and a thriving community (in the form of fan sites, social media interactions, and online discussion forums) is a sign that the game has resonated with its audience.
  5. Impact on the industry
    The influence the game has had on the video game industry as a whole or on other indie games that came after it can be a crucial factor in determining its popularity. If a game has inspired other developers or brought attention to a specific genre or gameplay mechanic, it becomes more significant in the context of all-time popular indie titles.
  6. Accessibility and platform availability
    Wider availability on multiple platforms and devices helps indie games reach larger audiences, increasing their overall popularity.
  7. Media coverage and word-of-mouth
    Positive press coverage, video reviews, and word-of-mouth recommendations from other players contribute to the popularity and success of indie games.
  8. Innovativeness and originality
    The uniqueness of an indie game, be it in terms of gameplay, storytelling, or art style, can make it stand out and become more popular among the gaming community.
  9. Genre and target audience
    The popularity of an indie game can be impacted by the specific genre and target audience it caters to. A game that matches the preferences and trends of the gaming community is more likely to be successful in gaining popularity.

About this ranking

This is a community-based ranking of the most popular Indie game of all time. We do our best to provide fair voting, but it is not intended to be exhaustive. So if you notice something or game is missing, feel free to help improve the ranking!


  • 197 votes
  • 10 ranked items

Voting Rules

A participant may cast an up or down vote for each game once every 24 hours. The rank of each game is then calculated from the weighted sum of all up and down votes.

More information on most popular indie game of all time

Indie games have been gaining popularity in recent years, thanks to their unique gameplay mechanics, captivating storylines, and impressive visuals. These games are often created by small independent studios, without the backing of major publishers, and rely on word-of-mouth marketing and online communities to gain recognition. The indie gaming industry has produced some of the most iconic and beloved games of all time, such as Minecraft, Stardew Valley, and Undertale. These games have captured the hearts of millions of players around the world, and have inspired a new generation of game developers to create their own innovative titles. So, what is the most popular indie game of all time? With so many amazing titles to choose from, it's a tough question to answer. However, with the help of StrawPoll, we can gather opinions from gamers around the globe and find out which indie game reigns supreme.

Share this article