The Most Popular SML Character: Ranking the Fan Favorites

Choose the character you think is the most popular!

Author: Gregor Krambs
Jun 16, 2023 10:18 (Updated on Dec 2, 2023 21:50)
Welcome to StrawPoll, the ultimate online hub for your burning questions and opinions! Today, we're diving into the world of SML characters, and we need your votes to crown the most popular one. From the hilarious antics of Jeffy to the sarcastic wit of Bowser Jr., every character brings their own unique charm to the table. So, whether you're a die-hard SML fan or just dipping your toes into this wacky world, your vote counts! Head over to our rankings to cast your vote, or suggest a missing option if your favorite character is not on the list. Join the fun, fuel the debate, and help us unveil the true fan-favorite SML character!

What Is the Most Popular SML Character?

  1. 1
    As the main character, Mario is easily the most popular SML character. He is the face of the franchise and has appeared in countless games, cartoons, and merchandise.
    Mario is a popular game franchise created by Nintendo. It revolves around the adventures of Mario, a plumber-turned-hero, as he navigates various colorful and imaginative worlds to rescue Princess Peach from the villainous Bowser. Known for its iconic characters, platforming gameplay, and cheerful aesthetic, the Mario franchise has become one of the most recognized and beloved in the gaming industry.
    • Genre: Platformer
    • First Release: Donkey Kong (1981)
    • Main Protagonist: Mario
    • Primary Antagonist: Bowser
    • Main Gameplay Mechanic: Jumping and Stomping Enemies
  2. 2
    Jeffy is a newer character to the SML universe, but has quickly become a fan favorite due to his outrageous behavior and catchphrases.
    Jeffy is a popular character from the SuperMarioLogan (SML) YouTube channel. He is known for his unique personality and catchphrase 'Why?'
    • Catchphrase: Why?
    • Age: 6 (at the time of creation)
    • Gender: Male
    • Personality: Childish, mischievous, and often curious
    • Physical Appearance: Wears a blue helmet, a yellow shirt, jeans, and white sneakers
  3. 3
    As the main antagonist, Bowser is a beloved character by many SML fans. He is often portrayed as a bumbling villain with a soft side for his son, Bowser Jr.
    Bowser is a character featured in the Super Mario series of video games. He is a large, powerful, and menacing turtle-like creature who is often portrayed as the main antagonist.
    • First Appearance: Super Mario Bros. (1985)
    • Species: Koopa
    • Affiliation: King of the Koopas, leader of the Koopa Troop
    • Abilities: Superhuman strength, fire breath, shell spin attack
    • Size: Variable (usually much larger than other characters)
  4. 4

    Brooklyn T. Guy

    Logan Thirtyacre
    Brooklyn T. Guy is a police officer character who appears in many SML videos. He is known for his dry humor and deadpan delivery.
    The Brooklyn T. Guy is a fictional character from the SuperMarioLogan (SML) YouTube channel created by Logan Thirtyacre. He is known for his distinctive Brooklyn accent and quirky personality. The character often appears in SML skits and is a recurring cast member in the series.
    • Accent: Brooklyn
    • Personality: Quirky
    • Role: Recurring character
    • Channel: SuperMarioLogan (SML)
    • Platform: YouTube
  5. 5
    Woody is a cowboy doll who often appears alongside his friend, Buzz Lightyear, in SML videos. He is known for his southern accent and cowboy demeanor.
    Woody is a character from the animated web series Battle for BFDI (BFB).
    • Gender: Male
    • Color: Brown
    • Body Type: Wooden block
    • Personality: Anxious and fearful
    • Size: Medium
  6. 6
    Shrek is a beloved character from the DreamWorks animated film franchise. He has made several appearances in SML videos due to his popularity.
    Shrek is a fictional character created by American author William Steig and brought to life in an animated film series. He is a large, green ogre with a Scottish accent and a distinctive sense of humor. Shrek is known for his unconventional appearance and his unapologetic nature. Despite his grumpy demeanor, he possesses a kind heart and is known for his loyalty to his friends.
    • First Appearance: Shrek! (1990)
    • Film Franchise: Shrek series (2001-2010)
    • Voice Actor: Mike Myers
    • Age: Unknown (immortal)
    • Species: Ogre
  7. 7

    Black Yoshi

    Logan Thirtyacre
    Black Yoshi is a character who often appears in SML videos. He is known for his love of Call of Duty and his inability to pay his rent.
    Black Yoshi is a popular character in the SuperMarioLogan (SML) series. He is a mischievous and street-smart Yoshi with a dark skin tone, dressed in a black cap and black shoes. He often speaks in a distinctively urban dialect and has a love for video games, mainly Call of Duty.
    • Color: Black
    • Attire: Black cap and black shoes
    • Personality: Mischievous and street-smart
    • Dialect: Distinctively urban
    • Video Game Preference: Call of Duty
  8. 8
    Toad is a character from the Mario franchise who often appears in SML videos. He is known for his high-pitched voice and loyalty to Princess Peach.
    Toad is a popular character from the YouTube series Super Mario Logan (SML). He is a small, anthropomorphic mushroom with a high-pitched voice. Toad is often portrayed as a main character and has become one of the most recognizable and beloved characters in the SML universe.
    • Height: Approximately 2.5 feet (76 cm)
    • Voice: High-pitched and energetic
    • Color: White with red spots on the head
    • Personality: Loyal, excitable, and often naive
    • Role: Frequent companion to Mario and other characters
  9. 9
    Luigi is Mario's brother and often appears in SML videos. He is known for his timid personality and green overalls.
    Luigi is a fictional character who appears in various Super Mario games. He is the younger brother of the iconic character Mario and is known for his green outfit and tall, lean appearance. Luigi often joins Mario in his adventures and serves as the player's second character in multiplayer modes. Despite being overshadowed by his more famous brother, Luigi has gained a significant following and has become a beloved character in the Nintendo franchise.
    • Debut: Mario Bros. (1983)
    • Occupation: Plumber
    • Height: 5 feet 9 inches (175 cm)
    • Weight: 160 pounds (73 kg)
    • Personality: Timid, cowardly, but courageous when needed
  10. 10
    Chef Pee Pee
    T. E. Ryen · CC0

    Chef Pee Pee

    Logan Thirtyacre
    Chef Pee Pee is a character who works for Mario as his personal chef. He is known for his short temper and dislike of his job.
    Chef Pee Pee is a popular character in the SML (SuperMarioLogan) series. He is known for his significant role as the private chef for Mario and his friends. Often portrayed as highly stressed and easily irritated, Chef Pee Pee frequently finds himself dealing with the absurd and often chaotic antics of the other characters.
    • Appearance: Wears a white chef's hat, a white apron, and black shoes
    • Personality: Grumpy, perfectionist, easily frustrated
    • Occupation: Private chef
    • Skills: Culinary expertise, multitasking
    • Relationships: Frenemies with Mario, often clashes with other characters

Missing your favorite character?


Ranking factors for popular character

  1. Screen Time
    Characters who appear in more videos or have more significant roles in the videos are more likely to be popular among fans.
  2. Fan Engagement
    Characters who have a strong and engaged fan base, evidenced by comments, likes, and shares on social media, are likely to be popular.
  3. Character Development
    Characters who have evolved over time and have experienced changes or growth in their personality, storyline, or relationships with other characters may be more popular than those who have remained static and predictable.
  4. Memorable Moments
    Characters who have had standout or memorable moments in SML videos, such as iconic catchphrases or funny scenes, may be more popular among fans.
  5. Crossover Appeal
    Characters who appeal to a broader audience, including both children and adults, may be more popular overall.
  6. Merchandise Sales
    Characters who sell well in terms of merchandise, such as plush toys or t-shirts, may also be considered popular.

About this ranking

This is a community-based ranking of the most popular SML character. We do our best to provide fair voting, but it is not intended to be exhaustive. So if you notice something or character is missing, feel free to help improve the ranking!


  • 166 votes
  • 10 ranked items

Movers & Shakers

Voting Rules

A participant may cast an up or down vote for each character once every 24 hours. The rank of each character is then calculated from the weighted sum of all up and down votes.

More information on most popular sml character

Background Information: The Most Popular SML Character SML, or SuperMarioLogan, is a popular YouTube channel that creates comedic videos using Mario plush toys. The channel has gained a large following over the years and has spawned a variety of characters that have become fan favorites. One of the most popular topics among SML fans is the debate over who the most popular SML character is. There are a variety of SML characters that fans have grown to love, each with their own unique traits and personalities. Some of the most popular characters include Mario, Jeffy, Bowser, and Chef Pee Pee. Mario is the main character of the channel and has been a staple since the beginning. Jeffy, a newer character, has quickly become a fan favorite due to his quirky behavior and catchphrases. Bowser is another fan favorite due to his comedic antics and relationship with Mario. Finally, Chef Pee Pee is a beloved character due to his relatable struggles as a chef and his interactions with the other characters. While the debate over the most popular SML character may never be fully resolved, it is clear that each character has a dedicated fan base. StrawPoll is the perfect platform to gather opinions and determine which SML character reigns supreme among fans.

Share this article