The Most Delicious Tomato, Ranked

Choose the tomato you think is the most delicious!

Author: Gregor Krambs
Updated on Apr 27, 2024 06:23
In a small town known for its vibrant farmer's markets, a yearly debate among locals over which vendor sells the tastiest tomato has turned into a spirited tradition. This friendly competition among neighbors not only highlights the community's passion for fresh, quality produce but also showcases the importance of personal taste in determining the 'best' in everyday items. By participating in a wider poll to rank these beloved tomatoes, users contribute to a broader consensus, taking the guesswork out of selecting the best produce on their next market visit. Plus, voting on your favorites is a fun way to engage with a community of fellow enthusiasts, share culinary tips, and perhaps discover a new favorite yourself.

What Is the Most Delicious Tomato?

  1. 1
    47
    votes
    Known for its large size and sweet, juicy flavor, the Brandywine tomato is a favorite among tomato enthusiasts. Its deep red color and meaty texture make it perfect for slicing on sandwiches or using in salads.
    Brandywine is a large and exceptionally flavorful tomato variety that is highly regarded for its taste. It is often considered one of the best-tasting heirloom tomato varieties available. The Brandywine tomato has a classic beefsteak shape, with deep pink or red skin and a meaty flesh. It offers a rich, sweet and tangy flavor with a perfect balance of acidity. The texture of Brandywine is smooth and succulent, making it a favorite among tomato enthusiasts.
    • Size: Large
    • Color: Deep pink or red
    • Shape: Beefsteak
    • Flavor: Rich, sweet, tangy
    • Texture: Smooth, succulent
  2. 2
    24
    votes
    This heirloom tomato has a rich, smoky flavor that sets it apart from other varieties. Its deep purple color and juicy, meaty flesh make it ideal for slicing and using in salads or on sandwiches.
    Cherokee Purple is a highly regarded heirloom tomato known for its distinctive color and exceptional flavor. It is considered one of the most delicious tomatoes available.
    • Color: Deep, dusky purple with green shoulders
    • Size: Medium to large
    • Shape: Round to slightly flattened
    • Texture: Smooth and firm
    • Flavor: Rich, sweet, and savory with a hint of smokiness
  3. 3
    11
    votes
    These Italian tomatoes are known for their sweet, tangy flavor and low acidity. They are perfect for making sauces or using in dishes that require a sweeter tomato flavor.
    San Marzano is a variety of tomato known for its exceptional taste and culinary qualities. It is highly regarded by chefs and home cooks alike for its distinct flavor, sweet undertones, and low acidity. This tomato is widely considered one of the best for making pasta sauces, especially the classic marinara, due to its meaty flesh and rich flavor.
    • Texture: Smooth
    • Flavor: Sweet
    • Acidity: Low
    • Seed cavity: Small
    • Flesh: Meaty
  4. 4
    14
    votes
    This small, sweet tomato is perfect for snacking or using in salads. Its bright yellow color and sweet flavor make it a favorite among children and adults alike.
    The Yellow Pear tomato is a small, sweet and tangy variety that is highly regarded for its unique pear shape and vibrant yellow color. This tomato is known for its juicy flesh and low acidity, making it perfect for adding a pop of color and flavor to salads and other dishes. With a sweet yet slightly tangy taste, the Yellow Pear tomato offers a delightful balance of flavors.
    • Size: Small
    • Shape: Pear-shaped
    • Color: Yellow
    • Taste: Sweet and tangy
    • Flesh: Juicy
  5. 5
    21
    votes

    Green Zebra

    Tom Wagner
    This unique tomato has a tart, tangy flavor and a striking green and yellow striped skin. It is perfect for using in salads or as a garnish for dishes that need a pop of color.
    The Green Zebra tomato is a small, juicy and firm tomato variety with a unique appearance and taste. It has a vibrant green color with dark green stripes, making it visually distinct from other tomato varieties. The flavor of Green Zebra tomatoes is tangy, sweet, and slightly tart, providing a refreshing and zesty eating experience.
    • Size: Small
    • Color: Green with dark green stripes
    • Texture: Juicy and firm
    • Flavor: Tangy, sweet, and slightly tart
    • Ripeness: Best when fully ripe
  6. 6
    15
    votes
    This large, meaty tomato is perfect for slicing and using on sandwiches or burgers. Its juicy, flavorful flesh and thick skin make it a favorite among home gardeners and chefs alike.
    The Beefsteak tomato is known for its incredibly juicy and meaty flesh, making it one of the most delicious tomatoes available. With its rich flavor and vibrant color, it is a highly sought-after variety for culinary use.
    • Size: The Beefsteak tomato can grow to be quite large, with some specimens weighing over a pound.
    • Shape: It typically has a round, flattened shape, similar to a beef steak.
    • Color: The tomato ripens to a deep red color, indicating its readiness for consumption.
    • Texture: The flesh of the Beefsteak tomato is incredibly juicy and succulent, with a satisfying meaty texture.
    • Flavor: It offers a sweet, tangy, and distinctively rich flavor that is highly regarded by tomato enthusiasts.
  7. 7
    4
    votes
    These cherry tomatoes are known for their sweet, juicy flavor and high sugar content. They are perfect for snacking or using in salads and other dishes that require a burst of sweetness.
    Sweet 100 is an exceptionally sweet and flavorful cherry tomato variety that is highly popular among tomato enthusiasts. It is known for its small size and intense sweetness, making it a delightful addition to salads, pasta dishes, or as a healthy snack. The tomatoes are bright red in color and have a firm, juicy texture.
    • Size: Small
    • Flavor: Sweet and intense
    • Color: Bright red
    • Texture: Firm and juicy
    • Type: Cherry tomato
  8. 8
    11
    votes
    This heirloom tomato has a unique, smoky flavor and a deep red color. It is perfect for slicing and using in salads or on sandwiches, and is a favorite among tomato enthusiasts.
    The Black Krim is a unique and flavorful tomato variety that is known for its rich taste and striking dark color. It is believed to have originated from the Isle of Krim in the Black Sea region of Russia.
    • Color: Deep purplish-black with green shoulders
    • Size: Medium to large
    • Shape: Globe-shaped
    • Flavor: Sweet, smoky, and tangy
    • Texture: Juicy and meaty
  9. 9
    6
    votes

    Sun Gold

    Sakata Seed Corporation
    These cherry tomatoes are known for their sweet, fruity flavor and bright orange color. They are perfect for snacking or using in salads and other dishes that require a burst of flavor.
    Sun Gold is a cherry tomato variety known for its exceptional flavor and sweetness. These tomatoes have a bright orange color and a perfectly balanced sweet and tangy taste. The Sun Gold tomato is highly regarded for its complex and intense flavor profile, often described as a burst of tropical fruit with hints of citrus and apricot. It offers a delightful combination of sweetness and acidity.
    • Size: Small, cherry-sized
    • Color: Bright orange
    • Flavor: Sweet and tangy with tropical fruit and citrus notes
    • Texture: Juicy and tender
    • Plant type: Indeterminate
  10. 10
    13
    votes

    Mortgage Lifter

    Radiator Charlie
    This large, meaty tomato is perfect for slicing and using on sandwiches or in salads. It is known for its rich, sweet flavor and is a favorite among home gardeners and chefs.
    The Mortgage Lifter is a variety of tomato known for its exceptional taste and large size. It is often considered one of the most delicious tomatoes available. The tomato has a rich and meaty flavor with a perfect balance of sweetness and acidity. It is perfect for slicing and adding to sandwiches or salads.
    • Size: Large
    • Flavor: Rich and meaty
    • Sweetness: Balanced
    • Acidity: Balanced
    • Usage: Slicing, sandwiches, salads

Missing your favorite tomato?

Graphs
Discussion

Ranking factors for delicious tomato

  1. Texture
    The texture of a tomato is critical; it should be firm but not hard while maintaining a juicy and succulent interior. Overripe or mushy tomatoes are not as enjoyable to eat.
  2. Aroma
    A good tomato should have a pleasant aroma, which indicates freshness and taste. If there is no noticeable scent or a foul smell, it might indicate an inferior tomato.
  3. Color
    A richly colored tomato generally indicates better flavor. Look for a deep red for traditional tomatoes or a rich hue for heirlooms. A dull or uneven color may suggest either underripe or overripe tomatoes.
  4. Variety
    Different tomato varieties offer unique flavor profiles. Heirloom tomatoes, cherry tomatoes, and beefsteak tomatoes, for example, each have specific tastes that might appeal to diverse preferences.
  5. Organic and locally grown
    Organic tomatoes are grown without synthetic chemicals and are often considered more flavorful and nutritious. Locally grown tomatoes also tend to be fresher, as they have not traveled long distances and spent less time in storage.
  6. Season
    Tomatoes are at their peak during the warm summer months. Out-of-season tomatoes may not have the same flavor, as they are often picked before they are ripe and ripen artificially through storage and transportation.
  7. Ripeness
    A ripe tomato will feel slightly firm, but also give slightly when gently pressed. Overripe tomatoes may be soft or mushy, while underripe tomatoes will be hard and have little to no aroma.
  8. Shape
    Although this factor doesn't directly impact taste, some people are drawn to unique shapes and sizes, such as heirloom tomatoes, which can be visually appealing.
  9. Usage and versatility
    Depending on how the tomato will be used, specific factors also become important. For salads or snacking, cherry or grape tomatoes might be a top choice. For cooking, look for a tomato with the best flavor profile that suits your dish.

About this ranking

This is a community-based ranking of the most delicious tomato. We do our best to provide fair voting, but it is not intended to be exhaustive. So if you notice something or tomato is missing, feel free to help improve the ranking!

Statistics

  • 1480 views
  • 162 votes
  • 10 ranked items

Voting Rules

A participant may cast an up or down vote for each tomato once every 24 hours. The rank of each tomato is then calculated from the weighted sum of all up and down votes.

More information on most delicious tomato

Tomatoes are one of the most popular and versatile fruits (yes, they are a fruit!) in the world. Originally native to South America, tomatoes were introduced to Europe in the 16th century and quickly became a staple in many cuisines. Today, there are over 10,000 varieties of tomatoes, each with their own unique flavor, texture, and color. From juicy beefsteak tomatoes to sweet cherry tomatoes, there's a tomato for every taste preference. But what is the most delicious tomato? That's a question that's up for debate and one that we aim to answer with our poll.

Share this article