The Most Overrated Sneaker: Ranking the Overhyped Footwear Trend

Choose the sneaker you think is the most overrated!

Author: Gregor Krambs
Updated on Apr 14, 2024 06:45
Are you tired of seeing the same overhyped sneakers everywhere you look? It's time to have your say! StrawPoll invites you to join the conversation and rank the most overrated sneakers of all time. Put on your thinking caps and take a step into the world of kicks, as we sort through the hypebeasts and fashion faux pas to uncover the ultimate list of overrated sneakers. With thousands of polls and rankings on various topics, StrawPoll is your go-to destination for heated debates and crowd-sourced opinions. So, lace up and get ready to vote for your most overrated sneaker or even suggest a missing option. Don't just stand on the sidelines - jump in and make your voice heard in the sneaker showdown of the century!

What Is the Most Overrated Sneaker?

  1. 1

    Nike Air Jordan 1

    Peter Moore
    While it is a classic sneaker, the hype and resale prices have become excessive.
    The Nike Air Jordan 1 is a legendary basketball sneaker that has become an iconic symbol of street fashion. It is highly sought after by sneaker enthusiasts and considered by many to be one of the most overrated sneakers of all time due to its popularity and hype.
    • Release Year: 1985
    • Design: High-top
    • Materials: Leather upper
    • Colorways: Numerous
    • Logo: Nike Swoosh and Jumpman logo
    Nike Air Jordan 1 in other rankings
  2. 2

    Adidas Yeezy Boost 350

    Adidas and Kanye West
    Created in collaboration with Kanye West, the sneaker has become popular among sneakerheads, but the high resale prices and limited availability make it overrated.
    The Adidas Yeezy Boost 350 is a highly sought-after shoe known for its comfort and style. It is a collaboration between Adidas and Kanye West, the famous American rapper and fashion designer. This shoe features a low-top design with a primeknit upper, providing a lightweight and breathable fit. The Boost technology in the midsole offers exceptional cushioning and responsiveness. The shoe also includes a rubber outsole for durability and traction. The Yeezy Boost 350 has a minimalist aesthetic with a unique pattern on the upper, showcasing the brand's signature style. It is available in various colorways, allowing for personal style expression. Overall, this shoe combines fashion and function for a premium sneaker experience.
    • Style: Low-top sneaker
    • Upper Material: Primeknit
    • Cushioning: Boost technology
    • Outsole: Rubber
    • Closure: Lace-up
    Adidas Yeezy Boost 350 in other rankings
  3. 3

    Converse Chuck Taylor All-Star

    Marquis Mills Converse
    While it is a classic sneaker, the quality has declined over the years, and the hype has become excessive.
    The Converse Chuck Taylor All-Star is a classic and iconic sneaker that has gained significant popularity over the years. It is known for its timeless design and versatile style.
    • Year Introduced: 1917
    • Upper Material: Canvas
    • Sole Material: Rubber
    • Closure: Lace-up
    • Toe Style: Round
    Converse Chuck Taylor All-Star in other rankings
  4. 4
    Nike Air Max 97
    Choledocho · CC BY-SA 4.0

    Nike Air Max 97

    Christian Tresser
    The design has become overplayed and the quality has declined over the years.
    The Nike Air Max 97 is a classic sneaker known for its sleek design and comfortable cushioning. It was designed by Christian Tresser and first released in 1997. The shoe features a unique wave-shaped upper, inspired by Japanese bullet trains, giving it a futuristic and aerodynamic look. The Air Max 97 is equipped with a full-length Max Air unit, providing excellent impact absorption and cushioning. The upper is made of a combination of high-quality materials like leather, synthetic overlays, and reflective detailing. The shoe has a low-profile design and a full lace-up closure for a secure and adjustable fit. The outsole features a durable rubber construction for traction and flexibility. The Air Max 97 also includes a pull tab at the heel for easy on and off. Overall, the Nike Air Max 97 is a stylish and comfortable sneaker suitable for everyday wear.
    • Release Year: 1997
    • Upper Material: Leather, Synthetic Overlays
    • Midsole Technology: Full-length Max Air unit
    • Outsole Material: Rubber
    • Closure: Lace-up
    Nike Air Max 97 in other rankings
  5. 5
    While it is a classic sneaker, the design has become overplayed and the quality has declined over the years.
    The Reebok Classic Leather is a popular pair of white sneakers known for their timeless design and exceptional comfort. This iconic sneaker is a reimagined version of the original 1983 Classic Leather model by Reebok. It features a clean and simple white leather upper with minimal branding, making it a versatile choice to pair with various outfits. The Reebok Classic Leather is loved by sneaker enthusiasts and casual wearers alike for its superior cushioning, durability, and all-day comfort.
    • Upper Material: Genuine leather
    • Color: White
    • Outsole Material: Rubber
    • Closure: Lace-up
    • Lining: Textile
    Reebok Classic Leather in other rankings
  6. 6

    Vans Old Skool

    Paul Van Doren
    The design has become overplayed and the quality has declined over the years.
    The Vans Old Skool is a classic skate shoe that combines style and comfort. It features a low-top silhouette with a durable canvas and suede upper, a padded collar for extra support, and the iconic Vans side stripe. The shoe is known for its cushioned footbed and flexible rubber sole, making it suitable for everyday wear or skateboarding.
    • Upper Material: Canvas and suede
    • Closure: Lace-up
    • Collar: Padded
    • Sole: Rubber
    • Outsole: Waffle tread pattern
    Vans Old Skool in other rankings
  7. 7
    While it is a classic sneaker, the design has become overplayed and the quality has declined over the years.
    The Nike Cortez is a classic sneaker that has gained significant popularity over the years. It features a sleek and minimalistic design, making it versatile and suitable for various occasions. The shoe is known for its comfortable fit and lightweight feel, making it an attractive option for everyday wear. With its retro appeal and iconic Swoosh logo, the Nike Cortez has become a symbol of casual style and urban fashion.
    • Upper Material: Leather or Synthetic Leather
    • Midsole: EVA foam for cushioning
    • Outsole: Rubber for durability and traction
    • Closure: Lace-up front
    • Weight: Approximately 12 ounces (size 9)
    Nike Cortez in other rankings
  8. 8

    Puma Suede

    Rudolf Dassler
    While it is a classic sneaker, the design has become overplayed and the quality has declined over the years.
    The Puma Suede is a classic sneaker that gained popularity and has been widely regarded as one of the most iconic sneakers in the industry. It features a low-top silhouette with a suede upper, giving it a luxurious feel. The sneaker is known for its minimalistic design, with the signature Puma Formstrip on the lateral sides. It has a lace-up closure system for a secure and adjustable fit.
    • Upper Material: Suede
    • Silhouette: Low-top
    • Design: Minimalistic
    • Closure: Lace-up
    • Brand Logo: Puma Formstrip
  9. 9

    New Balance 990

    New Balance
    While it is a classic sneaker, the design has become overplayed and the quality has declined over the years.
    The New Balance 990 is a highly comfortable white sneaker known for its exceptional cushioning and classic design. It offers a perfect blend of style and functionality, making it a popular choice among sneaker enthusiasts.
    • Cushioning: Extraordinary cushioning provided by New Balance's ABZORB midsole technology
    • Stability: Stability-enhancing design features such as ENCAP midsole technology
    • Support: Excellent arch support and stability offered by the dual-density collar foam
    • Durability: Premium quality materials ensure long-lasting durability
    • Comfort: Plush padded collar and tongue for added comfort
    New Balance 990 in other rankings
  10. 10

    Asics Gel-Lyte III

    Shigeyuki Mitsui
    While it is a classic sneaker, the design has become overplayed and the quality has declined over the years.
    The Asics Gel-Lyte III is a popular sneaker that is often considered overrated by some sneaker enthusiasts. It is renowned for its retro design and comfortable fit, making it a favorite among fashion-conscious individuals. The shoe features a split tongue design, which was not common in sneakers at the time of its release. The Asics Gel-Lyte III is known for its collaboration projects with various sneaker boutiques and designers, which have contributed to its hype and popularity.
    • Upper Material: Premium leather and mesh
    • Sole Technology: Gel cushioning system for shock absorption
    • Fit: True to size
    • Collaborations: Frequent collaborations with sneaker boutiques and designers
    • Color Options: Wide variety of colorways available

Missing your favorite sneaker?


Ranking factors for overrated sneaker

  1. Hype and popularity
    Analyze how much hype surrounds the sneaker and how popular it is among sneaker enthusiasts and the general public. This includes factors such as media attention, celebrity endorsements, and demand.
  2. Price
    Compare the retail price and resale value of the sneaker to other similar models or styles. Overrated sneakers tend to have inflated prices due to their hype and popularity.
  3. Availability
    Consider the sneaker's production numbers and if it is a limited edition or mass-produced. Overrated sneakers may be more difficult to obtain due to limited availability, driving up the demand.
  4. Design and aesthetics
    Evaluate the overall design of the sneaker and if it lives up to the hype surrounding it. Overrated sneakers may be more about the brand or collaboration than the actual design.
  5. Quality and materials
    Assess the quality of materials used and the construction of the sneaker. Overrated sneakers may have inferior materials and craftsmanship compared to similar models at a lower price point.
  6. Comfort and performance
    Evaluate how comfortable the sneaker is to wear and how well it performs for its intended use, such as running, basketball, or casual wear.
  7. Innovation and technology
    Evaluate if the sneaker offers any unique or groundbreaking technology or features that set it apart from other sneakers. Overrated sneakers may lack innovation or new technology compared to other models.
  8. Longevity and wearability
    Consider the durability of the sneaker and its ability to age gracefully and maintain its appearance over time. Overrated sneakers may not maintain their appeal or may lose value over time.
  9. Cultural significance and impact
    Analyze if the sneaker has had a significant impact on sneaker culture, fashion, or other industries. Overrated sneakers may have a short-lived moment in popularity rather than a lasting cultural footprint.
  10. Personal preferences and biases
    Finally, consider your own personal preferences and biases when evaluating if a sneaker is overrated. Your perception of a sneaker may differ from others based on your own style and taste.

About this ranking

This is a community-based ranking of the most overrated sneaker. We do our best to provide fair voting, but it is not intended to be exhaustive. So if you notice something or sneaker is missing, feel free to help improve the ranking!


  • 214 votes
  • 10 ranked items

Voting Rules

A participant may cast an up or down vote for each sneaker once every 24 hours. The rank of each sneaker is then calculated from the weighted sum of all up and down votes.

More information on most overrated sneaker

Sneakers have become a fashion staple in recent years, with people of all ages and backgrounds sporting their favorite pair. From classic brands like Nike and Adidas to up-and-coming labels like Yeezy and Off-White, the sneaker industry has exploded in popularity. But with so many options out there, it's no surprise that some sneakers have been deemed overrated by sneakerheads and casual wearers alike. Whether it's due to hype, limited availability, or simply a lack of originality, certain sneakers have failed to live up to the buzz surrounding them. In this article, we'll explore some of the most overrated sneakers on the market and why they may not be worth the investment.

Share this article