The Most Overrated YouTuber: Revealing the Hyped-Up Channels Robbing the Spotlight

Choose the YouTuber you think is the most overrated!

Author: Gregor Krambs
Updated on Feb 12, 2024 05:45
Are you tired of the endless hype surrounding certain YouTubers? Do you find yourself rolling your eyes as their names dominate conversations time and time again? Well, you're not alone! Here at StrawPoll, we believe that your opinion matters, and that's why we've created a ranking where you can finally have your say. Introducing: "What is the most overrated YouTuber?" This is your chance to vote for the content creators you think are undeserving of their fame or suggest those who might be missing from our list. So, what are you waiting for? Join the ranks of thousands of voters and let your voice be heard. It's time to set the record straight and separate the overhyped from the truly deserving YouTubers. Click to cast your vote and find out who tops the list of the most overrated!

What Is the Most Overrated YouTuber?

  1. 1
    Despite his massive following, his content often includes controversial and offensive material, leading to accusations of racism and anti-Semitism.
    PewDiePie is a popular Swedish YouTuber known for his gaming commentary, vlogs, and meme reviews. He gained a massive following for his energetic and sometimes controversial style of content.
    • Subscribers: Over 109 million
    • Video Views: Over 26.8 billion
    • Channel Creation: April 2006
    • Video Uploads: Over 4.3 thousand
    • Content Genres: Gaming, commentary, vlogs, meme reviews
  2. 2

    Logan Paul

    Logan Paul
    Known for his stunts and pranks, he has faced criticism for his insensitivity and inappropriate behavior, including filming a dead body in Japan's "suicide forest."
    Logan Paul is a popular American YouTuber known for his controversial and often provocative content. He rose to fame through his daily vlogs and prank videos, which attracted a massive following on YouTube. However, his notoriety increased in 2017 when he received severe backlash for posting a video in Japan's Aokigahara forest, also known as the 'Suicide Forest,' involving the discovery of a dead body. Despite the controversy, Logan Paul has gained a significant amount of attention and continues to maintain a large fan base.
    • Subscriber Count: 23.1 million
    • Total Views: 6.93 billion
    • Video Uploads: 881 videos
    • Instagram Followers: 13.9 million
    • Twitter Followers: 5.3 million
    Logan Paul in other rankings
  3. 3

    Jake Paul

    Jake Paul
    Similar to his brother Logan, Jake Paul's content often includes offensive jokes and stunts, leading to controversies and backlash.
    Jake Paul is a popular YouTuber known for his vlogs, pranks, and music videos. He gained significant attention and fame through his controversial antics and his involvement in the YouTube group Team 10. Despite having a large following, Jake Paul has been widely criticized for his behavior and the negative impact it has on his young audience.
    • Subscriber Count: 20.6 million
    • Channel Creation Date: Sep 1, 2011
    • Content Genre: Vlogs, pranks, music videos
    • Controversial Behavior: Engages in controversial and attention-seeking behavior
    • Involvement in Team 10: Founder and member of the YouTube group Team 10
    Jake Paul in other rankings
  4. 4

    Tana Mongeau

    Tana Mongeau
    Her content often includes drama and controversy, leading to accusations of manipulation and fabrication.
    Tana Mongeau is a popular YouTuber known for her vlogs, storytime videos, and controversial content. She gained substantial fame and recognition through her bold and often outrageous personality. Tana Mongeau has built a significant online following, largely due to her ability to attract attention and create buzz around her videos and controversies.
    • Subscriber count: 5.48 million
    • Total video views: 1.3 billion
    • Content genres: Vlogs, storytime videos, controversial content
    • Controversies: Involved in multiple controversies with other YouTubers and influencers
    • Collaborations: Has collaborated with various popular YouTubers, musicians, and influencers
    Tana Mongeau in other rankings
  5. 5

    James Charles

    James Charles
    Despite his massive following, he has faced criticism for his behavior towards other content creators, and has been involved in multiple controversies.
    James Charles is a popular American beauty YouTuber known for his makeup tutorials and beauty advice. He gained significant attention for his collaboration with famous cosmetic brands. However, he has also faced controversy and criticism regarding certain incidents and social media behavior.
    • Subscribers: More than 22 million
    • Total Views: Over 2.6 billion
    • Joined YouTube: December 1, 2015
    • Content Category: Beauty, Makeup
    • Collaborations: With major beauty brands and other YouTubers
    James Charles in other rankings
  6. 6
    Known for her beauty and lifestyle content, she has been accused of promoting unrealistic and unattainable standards for her viewers.
    Zoella is a popular YouTuber known for her beauty, fashion, and lifestyle content. She gained fame through her engaging vlogs, beauty hauls, and product reviews. Zoella's channel has amassed a large following and she is regarded as one of the most influential YouTubers in the beauty community.
    • Subscriber Count: 11.7 million
    • Joined YouTube: February 2007
    • Total Views: 1.2 billion
    • Main Content: Beauty, fashion, lifestyle
    • Collaborations: Has collaborated with various popular YouTubers
  7. 7
    Miranda Sings
    Gage Skidmore · CC BY-SA 3.0

    Miranda Sings

    Colleen Ballinger
    While her character is meant to be satirical, her content has been criticized for promoting harmful stereotypes and offensive humor.
    Miranda Sings is a popular comedic YouTube character known for her exaggeratedly inept singing and acting talents. The character is portrayed by Colleen Ballinger, an American actress, comedian, and singer. Miranda Sings has garnered a massive following and generated a significant impact on YouTube culture. With her signature red lipstick, messy hair, and distinctive personality, Miranda Sings has become a recognizable and divisive figure in the online entertainment landscape.
    • Subscribers: 10.6 million
    • Views: over 2 billion
    • Uploads: over 700 videos
    • Debut: 2008
    • Regular Series: Miranda Sings' Covers, Vlogs, and Parodies
    Miranda Sings in other rankings
  8. 8

    Jeffree Star

    Jeffree Star
    Known for his cosmetics line and controversial behavior, he has faced accusations of racism and bullying towards other content creators.
    Jeffree Star is a popular beauty-focused YouTuber known for his makeup tutorials, product reviews, and personal vlogs. He has a bold and vibrant aesthetic and often showcases his own makeup brand, Jeffree Star Cosmetics. With a larger-than-life personality, Jeffree Star has amassed a significant following on YouTube and social media platforms.
    • Number of subscribers: 18.2 million
    • Number of video views: 2.6 billion
    • Channel launch: November 2006
    • Main content categories: Makeup tutorials, product reviews, vlogs
    • Owns makeup brand: Jeffree Star Cosmetics
    Jeffree Star in other rankings
  9. 9
    Shane Dawson
    Gage Skidmore · CC BY-SA 3.0

    Shane Dawson

    Shane Dawson
    While he has been praised for his documentary-style content, he has also faced criticism for his past use of blackface and other offensive material.
    Shane Dawson is a popular YouTuber known for his documentary-style and comedy content. He gained a significant following through his lengthy videos that explore various subject matters, often featuring celebrities and controversial topics. Dawson is also recognized for his collaboration with other YouTubers and his involvement in the beauty community. While some viewers appreciate his authentic and relatable approach, others criticize him for his past controversial remarks and behavior.
    • Subscribers: 23.2 million
    • Total Views: 4.6 billion
    • Joined YouTube: March 10, 2008
    • Genre: Documentary, Comedy
    • Average Video Length: 30 minutes
    Shane Dawson in other rankings
  10. 10

    Trisha Paytas

    Trisha Paytas
    Known for her controversial behavior and frequent public feuds, she has been accused of attention-seeking and promoting harmful stereotypes.
    Trisha Paytas is a controversial YouTuber known for her provocative and often attention-seeking content. She gained initial popularity through her vlogs and personal storytime videos, where she shared intimate details about her life and struggles. Trisha has been involved in various controversies and feuds with other YouTubers, often displaying dramatic behavior and making controversial statements. Despite receiving criticism for her actions and content, Trisha has managed to amass a large following on YouTube.
    • Content Style: Provocative and attention-seeking
    • Popularity: Large following on YouTube
    • Controversies: Frequently involved in controversies and feuds
    • Dramatic Behavior: Known for displaying dramatic and exaggerated behavior
    • Personal Storytime Videos: Shares intimate details about her life and struggles
    Trisha Paytas in other rankings

Missing your favorite YouTuber?


Ranking factors for overrated YouTuber

  1. Subscriber Count
    Compare the number of subscribers with the quality and impact of the content. A YouTuber with a high subscriber count but low-quality content may be considered overrated.
  2. Views and Engagement
    Analyze the average number of views per video and the engagement (likes, comments, shares) to determine if the YouTuber generates genuine interest and interaction among their audience.
  3. Content Quality
    Assess the quality of the content in terms of production value, creativity, and originality. An overrated YouTuber may have visually appealing videos that lack substance or don't offer anything unique to the platform.
  4. Relevance and Impact
    Determine if the YouTuber's content has a positive impact on their audience or society and how relevant their content is. An overrated YouTuber may create content that appears trendy but lacks depth or substance.
  5. Consistency
    Analyze how often the YouTuber uploads new content and if their content quality and engagement levels stay consistent over time. An overrated YouTuber may consistently upload mediocre content without improving or adapting their content over time.
  6. Authenticity
    Evaluate if the YouTuber appears genuine and authentic in their content, or if they are merely trying to capitalize on trends for views and revenue.
  7. Controversies
    Consider any controversies or negative issues surrounding the YouTuber that may affect their reputation or credibility. An overrated YouTuber may have multiple controversies that raise questions about their character and content.
  8. Audience Demographics
    Consider the age range and other demographics of the YouTuber's audience to determine if they cater to a specific group or have a wide and diverse viewer base.
  9. Sponsorships and Advertisements
    Examine the level of sponsored content and advertising within the YouTuber's content, and whether it detracts from the overall quality and authenticity of their channel.
  10. Social Media Presence
    Assess the YouTuber's presence on other social media platforms and their impact and engagement there. An overrated YouTuber may have a large following on one platform but limited or low-quality presence on others.

About this ranking

This is a community-based ranking of the most overrated YouTuber. We do our best to provide fair voting, but it is not intended to be exhaustive. So if you notice something or Vlogger is missing, feel free to help improve the ranking!


  • 186 votes
  • 10 ranked items

Voting Rules

A participant may cast an up or down vote for each Vlogger once every 24 hours. The rank of each Vlogger is then calculated from the weighted sum of all up and down votes.

More information on most overrated youtuber

Over the past decade, YouTube has become a major platform for creators to showcase their content and build a following. With hundreds of millions of active users, it's no surprise that some YouTubers have become household names. However, with fame comes scrutiny and criticism. Many viewers have become disillusioned with certain YouTubers, feeling that their content is overhyped or overrated. In this article, we explore the question of who the most overrated YouTuber is and why they may have fallen out of favor with their audience.

Share this article