The Most Overrated TV Show of All Time: Revealing the Overhyped Phenomenon

Choose the show you think is the most overrated!

Author: Gregor Krambs
Jun 16, 2023 10:18 (Updated on Dec 2, 2023 19:26)
Are you tired of hearing endless praises for TV shows that just don't live up to the hype? It's time to let your opinion be heard! At StrawPoll, we're hosting the ultimate showdown to determine the most overrated TV show of all time. Thousands of fans are casting their votes and making their voices heard, and now it's your turn. Is it the dragons of Westeros or the mysteries of Lost Island that just didn't do it for you? Perhaps the sitcoms that make everyone laugh, except for you? Dive into our rankings, vote for your "favorite" overrated show or suggest a new contender that's missing from our list. Unleash your inner critic and join the debate that's taking the TV world by storm!

What Is the Most Overrated TV Show of All Time?

  1. 1
    Despite its immense popularity, many argue that Friends is overrated due to its lack of diversity, unrealistic storylines, and reliance on dated humor.
    Friends is a popular American sitcom that originally aired from 1994 to 2004. The show follows the lives of a group of six friends - Rachel, Ross, Chandler, Monica, Joey, and Phoebe - who live in New York City and grapple with the trials and tribulations of adulthood.
    • Number of Seasons: 10
    • Total Episodes: 236
    • Original Network: NBC
    • Original Airdate: September 22, 1994
    • Finale Airdate: May 6, 2004
  2. 2

    The Big Bang Theory

    Chuck Lorre, Bill Prady
    This sitcom has been criticized for perpetuating negative stereotypes of geek culture and relying too heavily on tired tropes and one-dimensional characters.
    The Big Bang Theory is an American sitcom that aired from 2007 to 2019. It revolves around a group of socially awkward but highly intelligent scientists and their interactions with each other and the people around them. The show primarily focuses on the lives of roommates Leonard Hofstadter and Sheldon Cooper, along with their friends Howard Wolowitz, Raj Koothrappali, and later, their neighbor Penny. The Big Bang Theory is known for its blend of nerdy humor, pop culture references, and recurring themes of geek culture.
    • Genre: Sitcom
    • Original Network: CBS
    • Number of Seasons: 12
    • Number of Episodes: 279
    • Average Episode Runtime: 22 minutes
    The Big Bang Theory in other rankings
  3. 3

    How I Met Your Mother

    Carter Bays, Craig Thomas
    While the show was initially praised for its clever storytelling and ensemble cast, many fans and critics alike have since criticized its controversial ending, uneven writing, and problematic jokes.
    How I Met Your Mother is a popular American sitcom that aired from 2005 to 2014. The show follows the main character, Ted Mosby, as he recounts the story of how he met his children's mother to his friends. Set in New York City, the series primarily focuses on Ted's search for love and the various romantic exploits of his close-knit group of friends.
    • Genre: Sitcom
    • Country of Origin: United States
    • Original Language(s): English
    • Number of Seasons: 9
    • Number of Episodes: 208
  4. 4

    The Walking Dead

    Frank Darabont
    Though it was once a ratings juggernaut, The Walking Dead has faced criticism for its repetitive plotlines, inconsistent character development, and gratuitous violence.
    The Walking Dead is a popular TV show that revolves around a post-apocalyptic world infested with zombies, also known as 'walkers'. It follows a group of survivors as they navigate through dangerous situations, form alliances, and try to rebuild society. The show primarily focuses on character development and explores themes like morality, survival instincts, and the resilience of humanity.
    • Genre: Drama, Horror
    • Original Network: AMC
    • First Episode Air Date: October 31, 2010
    • Last Episode Air Date: Ongoing
    • Number of Seasons: 10
    The Walking Dead in other rankings
  5. 5

    Grey's Anatomy

    Shonda Rhimes
    Despite its longevity and devoted fanbase, Grey's Anatomy has been accused of relying too heavily on melodrama, soap opera-style plot twists, and unrealistic medical scenarios.
    Grey's Anatomy is a medical drama television series that follows the professional and personal lives of surgical interns, residents, and attending physicians at Grey Sloan Memorial Hospital. The show explores their struggles, relationships, and the intense and dramatic situations they encounter in their high-pressure work environment.
    • Genre: Medical drama
    • Number of seasons: 17
    • Number of episodes: 384
    • Original release: March 27, 2005 - Present
    • Average episode duration: 43 minutes
    Grey's Anatomy in other rankings
  6. 6
    Though it was once hailed as a groundbreaking fantasy epic, the show's controversial final season and controversial plot developments have led many fans to conclude that it was overrated all along.
    Game of Thrones is a highly popular and critically acclaimed American fantasy drama television series based on the novel series 'A Song of Ice and Fire' by George R.R. Martin. The show is known for its complex characters, intricate plotlines, and its blend of political intrigue, epic battles, and fantasy elements. Set in the fictional continents of Westeros and Essos, Game of Thrones explores the power struggles among noble families as they vie for control of the Iron Throne.
    • Genre: Fantasy, Drama
    • Number of Seasons: 8
    • Number of Episodes: 73
    • Running Time: 50-82 minutes per episode
    • Original Network: HBO
    Game of Thrones in other rankings
  7. 7

    The Office

    Greg Daniels
    While the show's mockumentary style and quirky characters earned it a loyal following, many argue that it ultimately overstayed its welcome and relied too heavily on cringe humor.
    The Office is a mockumentary-style sitcom that depicts the everyday lives of office employees working at the Scranton, Pennsylvania branch of the Dunder Mifflin Paper Company. The show presents their interactions and humorous mishaps through a documentary crew's lens.
    • Genre: Sitcom
    • Format: Mockumentary
    • Setting: Office environment
    • Location: Scranton, Pennsylvania, USA
    • Running time: Approximately 22 minutes per episode
    The Office in other rankings
  8. 8

    Breaking Bad

    Vince Gilligan
    While it was widely praised for its writing, performances, and cinematography, some argue that Breaking Bad's portrayal of drug culture was sensationalistic and its characters were ultimately unsympathetic.
    Breaking Bad is an American dramatic TV show that follows the transformation of Walter White, a high school chemistry teacher turned methamphetamine manufacturer, as he descends into a world of crime and power. The show explores themes of morality, ambition, and the consequences of one's choices.
    • Genre: Drama
    • Country of Origin: United States
    • Language: English
    • Number of Seasons: 5
    • Number of Episodes: 62
    Breaking Bad in other rankings
  9. 9
    Despite its status as a classic sitcom, Seinfeld has been criticized for its cynicism, unlikeable characters, and reliance on observational humor that has since become tired and predictable.
    Seinfeld is a popular American sitcom known for its unique brand of observational humor and self-referential storytelling. The series revolves around Jerry Seinfeld, a stand-up comedian, and his eccentric group of friends living in New York City. Seinfeld skillfully portrays the mundane and absurd aspects of everyday life, often deriving comedy from ordinary situations and conversations.
    • Genre: Sitcom
    • Original network: NBC
    • Original release: July 5, 1989 – May 14, 1998
    • Number of seasons: 9
    • Number of episodes: 180
  10. 10

    The Simpsons

    Matt Groening
    While it is widely regarded as one of the greatest TV shows of all time, some argue that The Simpsons has overstayed its welcome and become a shadow of its former self, relying too heavily on celebrity cameos and tired gags.
    The Simpsons is a popular animated television show that revolves around the lives of the Simpson family, consisting of Homer, Marge, Bart, Lisa, and Maggie, living in the fictional town of Springfield. The show is known for its satire, humor, and portrayal of American culture. It often tackles various social and political issues in a lighthearted manner, making it a favorite among viewers of all ages.
    • First Episode Air Date: December 17, 1989
    • Genre: Animated sitcom
    • Number of Seasons: 32 (as of 2021)
    • Number of Episodes: 703 (as of 2021)
    • Average Episode Length: Approximately 22 minutes
    The Simpsons in other rankings

Missing your favorite show?


Ranking factors for overrated show

  1. Hype and publicity
    Consider the amount of buzz and promotion surrounding the show, including advertising campaigns, celebrity endorsements, and social media presence. A show that is highly talked about and praised may not always live up to the high expectations set by the hype.
  2. Critical acclaim
    Analyze the reviews and ratings from critics and award recognition the show has received. If a show has received high praise from critics yet does not live up to these standards, it may be considered overrated.
  3. Audience reviews
    Look at what viewers and fans have to say, including user reviews on IMDb, Rotten Tomatoes, and Metacritic. An overrated TV show may have a high discrepancy between critical acclaim and audience reception.
  4. Cultural impact
    Consider if the TV show is often cited as iconic or influential in pop culture. If it is frequently referenced and parodied, but the actual content is lacking, it might be overrated.
  5. Longevity and consistency
    Analyze if the show has maintained its quality and popularity over multiple seasons or if it has overstayed its welcome or declined in quality. Shows that start strong but fail to maintain their initial appeal can be considered overrated.
  6. Premise and originality
    An overrated show may have a concept that is praised for its uniqueness, but its execution and storyline may not be as groundbreaking or engaging as its premise suggests.
  7. Acting and production quality
    Assess the skill of the actors, as well as the quality of the production elements such as writing, direction, and visual effects. A show that is highly praised but fails to deliver in these key aspects may be deemed overrated.
  8. Genre and target audience
    Consider the show's genre and intended audience. A show that is primarily aimed at a specific demographic or taste may not translate well to a broader audience, giving it an overrated impression for those outside its target group.
  9. Popularity vs. quality
    Sometimes, a show may become highly popular due to its appeal to a mass audience, leading to inflated ratings and acclaim. This does not necessarily equate to a high-quality show, and such cases can be considered overrated.
  10. Nostalgia
    Often, older shows may be held up as classics, based on nostalgia or because they were groundbreaking for their time. However, they may not hold up when compared to current standards in storytelling, acting, and production quality, making them potentially overrated when viewed through a modern lens.

About this ranking

This is a community-based ranking of the most overrated TV show of all time. We do our best to provide fair voting, but it is not intended to be exhaustive. So if you notice something or show is missing, feel free to help improve the ranking!


  • 181 votes
  • 10 ranked items

Voting Rules

A participant may cast an up or down vote for each show once every 24 hours. The rank of each show is then calculated from the weighted sum of all up and down votes.

More information on most overrated tv show of all time

Over the years, television has become an integral part of our daily lives. It has given us some of the most memorable moments and characters that have left an indelible mark on our minds. However, not all TV shows have been able to live up to the hype and expectations of the audience. Some have been overrated and have failed to deliver on their promise. This has led to debates and discussions about which TV shows deserve to be called the most overrated of all time. In this article, we will take a look at some of the contenders and try to understand why they failed to meet the expectations of the viewers.

Share this article