The Most Popular Baking Show: A Ranking of the Favorites

Choose the baking show you think is the most popular!

Author: Gregor Krambs
Updated on Apr 22, 2024 06:48
Rise to the occasion and let your voice be heard in the ultimate baking showdown! At StrawPoll, we're whipping up a fresh batch of rankings for the most popular baking shows, and we knead your help to determine the crème de la crème. From sweet-toothed amateurs to master pastry chefs, there's an array of scrumptious series to choose from. So preheat your opinions, dust off your favorites, and cast your vote to help us uncover the show that truly takes the cake! And if you feel we may have missed a hidden gem, don't hesitate to suggest a new contender to join the delicious battle for baking supremacy. Your vote counts, so click through and let the baking show countdown commence!

What Is the Most Popular Baking Show?

  1. 1

    The Great British Bake Off

    Love Productions
    This show has gained massive popularity worldwide due to its wholesome nature, talented contestants, and the charming hosts. It has been running since 2010 and has won several awards.
    The Great British Bake Off is a popular baking show that originated in the United Kingdom. It is a competition-based reality show where amateur bakers from all walks of life showcase their baking skills and creativity. The show follows a format where contestants face a series of challenges each week, including signature bakes, technical bakes, and showstopper bakes. This allows them to demonstrate their abilities in various baking techniques, flavors, and presentations. The contestants are judged by a panel of expert judges who critique their bakes, and one participant is eliminated each week until a winner is crowned. The show is known for its friendly and supportive atmosphere, as well as the contestants' ability to create incredible and delicious treats.
    • Original release date: 17 August 2010
    • Country of origin: United Kingdom
    • Original network: BBC (2010-2016), Channel 4 (2017-present)
    • Number of seasons: Over 10 seasons
    • Number of episodes: Over 100 episodes
    The Great British Bake Off in other rankings
  2. 2

    Cake Boss

    Buddy Valastro
    This show centers around the life of Buddy Valastro, a master baker and owner of Carlo's Bakery in New Jersey. The show is known for its elaborate cake designs and the drama that unfolds in the bakery.
    Cake Boss is a popular reality TV show that revolves around the daily operations of Carlo's Bakery in Hoboken, New Jersey. The show follows the life and work of Buddy Valastro, the creator and owner of the bakery, as he designs and creates extravagant cakes for various occasions. With his team of talented bakers and decorators, Buddy takes on challenging cake orders, often incorporating impressive sculptures, intricate designs, and innovative techniques. The show not only showcases the craftsmanship and creativity involved in cake baking but also highlights the tight-knit relationships and occasional drama among the bakery staff. Cake Boss has gained significant fame for its entertaining and visually impressive cake creations.
    • Genre: Reality TV
    • Original Release: April 19, 2009
    • No. of Seasons: 13
    • No. of Episodes: 236
    • Runtime: Approximately 40-45 minutes
    Cake Boss in other rankings
  3. 3

    Nailed It!

    Nicole Byer
    This show has gained a huge following due to its hilarious take on baking competitions. The contestants are amateur bakers who attempt to recreate complex desserts, often with disastrous results.
    Nailed It! is a popular baking show that combines comedy and baking challenges. The show features amateur bakers attempting to recreate intricate desserts and creations with hilarious results. Each episode is filled with entertaining moments as the contestants try to replicate professional-level sweets and often end up with comically disastrous results.
    • Genre: Reality competition
    • Running time: Approximately 30 minutes
    • Original language: English
    • Number of seasons: 4 (as of 2021)
    • Number of episodes: 46 (as of 2021)
  4. 4
    This cooking competition includes a baking component and has been running for over a decade. It features home cooks competing for a grand prize and has launched the careers of several successful chefs.
    MasterChef is a competitive cooking show where amateur home cooks showcase their culinary skills and vie for the title of MasterChef. The show is known for its intense challenges, high-stakes pressure, and expert judges who evaluate the contestants' creations.
    • First Episode Air Date: 27 July 1990
    • Original Network: BBC One
    • Country of Origin: United Kingdom
    • Number of Seasons: 17
    • Number of Episodes: 374 (as of 2021)
  5. 5

    Cupcake Wars

    Super Delicious Productions
    This show is all about cupcakes, with contestants competing to create the best and most unique cupcakes. It has been running since 2009 and has a loyal following.
    Cupcake Wars is a popular baking show that features contestants competing against each other to create the best cupcakes. The contestants face various challenges and must impress a panel of judges with their creativity, flavor combinations, and presentation skills. The show follows a tournament-style format, with each episode featuring four teams battling it out until one team emerges as the winner.
    • Format: Reality competition
    • Genre: Baking
    • Running time: Approximately 60 minutes
    • Original network: Food Network
    • Original release: June 13, 2010 – present
  6. 6
    This Netflix original show features teams of bakers competing in timed challenges to create the best desserts. It has gained a following due to its fast-paced format and talented contestants.
    Sugar Rush is a popular baking show where talented pastry chefs compete against the clock to create elaborate desserts. Each episode features four teams competing in three rounds: cupcakes, confections, and cakes. With a time limit of only a few hours per round, the contestants have to think on their feet and showcase their skills to impress the judges.
    • Seasons: 4
    • Episodes: 28
    • Running time: 45-50 minutes
    • Host: Hunter March
    • Judges: Candace Nelson, Adriano Zumbo
  7. 7
    This show is a seasonal favorite, with contestants competing to create the best holiday-themed desserts. It has been running since 2014 and is known for its festive atmosphere.
    The Holiday Baking Championship is a popular baking competition show in which talented bakers from all over the country showcase their skills and creativity in holiday-inspired baking challenges. Contestants compete against each other to win the title of Holiday Baking Champion.
    • Seasons: Multiple
    • Air Dates: Annually during the holiday season
    • Network: Food Network
    • Premiere Year: 2014
    • Host: Various hosts across seasons
  8. 8
    This show features talented young bakers competing for a grand prize. It is a family-friendly show that has gained a loyal following.
    The Kids Baking Championship is a popular baking show where talented young bakers showcase their skills and creativity in the kitchen. They compete against each other in various baking challenges, aiming to impress the judges with their delicious creations. From cookies to cakes and pastries, these young chefs display their passion and determination to be crowned the Kids Baking Champion.
    • Genre: Reality TV
    • Hosts: Valerie Bertinelli and Duff Goldman
    • First aired: February 2, 2015
    • Number of seasons: Currently in its 10th season
    • Number of episodes: Over 100 episodes
  9. 9
    This show features professional bakers competing to be crowned the best in the country. It has gained a following due to the high level of skill showcased by the contestants.
    The Best Baker in America is a popular baking show that showcases talented bakers from across the United States competing for the title of being the best baker. The show is filled with intense challenges, creative recipes, and skilled techniques that push the contestants to their limits. Each episode presents the bakers with different baking tasks, including cakes, pastries, bread, and desserts, where they are judged on taste, presentation, and execution. The show aims to find the ultimate master of baking.
    • Hosted by: Scott Conant
    • Number of Seasons: 4
    • Number of Episodes: 40+
    • Prize: $25,000 and the title of 'Best Baker in America'
    • Contestant Format: Professional bakers
  10. 10
    This seasonal show features contestants competing to create the best spring-themed desserts. It has been running since 2015 and has gained a following for its colorful and creative desserts.
    Spring Baking Championship is a popular baking show that features talented bakers from all over the country competing against each other in various baking challenges. The show focuses on spring-themed recipes and creations, incorporating seasonal ingredients and flavors. Contestants are judged by a panel of professional pastry chefs and industry experts based on the taste, presentation, and creativity of their dishes. The competition spans over several episodes, with each episode featuring different baking tasks and eliminations until a winner is crowned in the final episode.
    • Episodes: Multiple
    • Seasons: Currently airing Season 7
    • Contestant Format: Individual
    • Judges: Panel of professional pastry chefs and industry experts
    • Theme: Spring baking, seasonal ingredients

Missing your favorite baking show?


Ranking factors for popular baking show

  1. Viewership and ratings
    The number of viewers who tune in to watch the show and its ratings on various platforms (such as IMDb, Rotten Tomatoes, etc.) are crucial in determining its popularity.
  2. Social media following and engagement
    The show's presence on social media platforms (Facebook, Instagram, Twitter, etc.) and the level of engagement they receive (likes, shares, comments) can also be indicative of their popularity.
  3. Awards and critical acclaim
    Wins and nominations for prestigious awards (Emmys, BAFTAs, etc.) and positive reviews from critics can play a significant role in determining a show's popularity.
  4. Cultural impact
    The extent to which the show has become a part of popular culture, resulting in catchphrases, memes, and references in other media.
  5. Longevity
    The number of seasons the show has been on air and the average number of episodes per season can be an important factor in determining popularity.
  6. Streaming numbers
    With online streaming platforms becoming increasingly popular, a show's streaming numbers and presence on platforms like Netflix, Hulu, or Amazon Prime can contribute to its popularity.
  7. Star power
    The presence of well-known and respected judges, hosts, or contestants can help increase a show's popularity.
  8. Spin-offs and international versions
    The success of spin-offs or international versions of the show can demonstrate its impact and reach beyond its original audience.
  9. Reputation for talent
    A show known for discovering and showcasing exceptional baking talent may increase its popularity among viewers.
  10. Accessibility and inclusiveness
    A show that appeals to a wide range of age groups and features a diverse cast of contestants may be more popular among viewers.

About this ranking

This is a community-based ranking of the most popular baking show. We do our best to provide fair voting, but it is not intended to be exhaustive. So if you notice something or baking show is missing, feel free to help improve the ranking!


  • 164 votes
  • 10 ranked items

Voting Rules

A participant may cast an up or down vote for each baking show once every 24 hours. The rank of each baking show is then calculated from the weighted sum of all up and down votes.

More information on most popular baking show

Baking shows have become a popular genre in the world of television entertainment, showcasing talented and creative bakers as they compete against each other to create stunning desserts and pastries. From the Great British Bake Off to Cake Boss, viewers have been captivated by the drama, creativity, and delicious treats on display. But which baking show is the most popular? With so many options available, it can be challenging to determine which one takes the cake. In this article, we'll explore some of the most popular baking shows and take a closer look at what makes them stand out from the crowd.

Share this article