The Most Popular Girl Guide Cookie: Revealing the Top Choice

Choose the cookie you think is the most popular!

Author: Gregor Krambs
Updated on Apr 17, 2024 07:10
Craving for those scrumptious Girl Guide cookies? It's time to settle the great cookie debate once and for all! Welcome to StrawPoll's ultimate ranking of the most popular Girl Guide cookies. We've gathered thousands of cookie connoisseurs like you to vote for their all-time favorites or suggest an irresistible variety that's missing from our list. Indulge your sweet tooth and join us in this mouthwatering journey to crown the reigning cookie champion. Cast your vote now and let your taste buds be heard! Don't forget to share this delicious poll with fellow cookie lovers and let the cravings begin!

What Is the Most Popular Girl Guide Cookie?

  1. 1
    79
    votes

    Classic Vanilla

    Girl Guides of Canada
    The classic vanilla Girl Guide cookie is the most popular variant because of its simple yet delicious taste. The cookie contains a creamy vanilla flavor that is loved by everyone.
    The Classic Vanilla cookie is a delightful treat loved by many Girl Guide cookie enthusiasts. It features a delicious vanilla-flavored base that is both buttery and sweet. This timeless flavor brings joy to cookie lovers of all ages.
    • Size: 3 inches in diameter
    • Texture: Crunchy with a melt-in-your-mouth consistency
    • Calories per serving: 120 calories
    • Allergens: Contains wheat and soy ingredients
    • Ingredients: Enriched wheat flour, sugar, vegetable oil, whey powder, natural and artificial flavors
  2. 2
    36
    votes

    Chocolate and Vanilla

    Girl Guides of Canada
    The chocolate and vanilla Girl Guide cookie is another top-selling variant of the brand. It is a combination of two classic flavors that complement each other perfectly. The cookie is crispy, and the chocolate and vanilla flavor is balanced.
    The Chocolate and Vanilla Girl Guide cookie is a delicious treat that combines the rich flavor of chocolate with the classic taste of vanilla. This cookie has a satisfying crunch and a perfect balance of sweetness. It is a beloved favorite among Girl Guide cookie enthusiasts.
    • Packaging: Individually wrapped in plastic sleeves
    • Cookie Type: Chocolate and Vanilla
    • Flavor: Chocolate and Vanilla
    • Texture: Crunchy
    • Main Ingredients: Chocolate, Vanilla, Flour, Sugar
  3. 3
    15
    votes

    Chocolatey Mint

    Girl Guides of Canada
    The chocolatey mint Girl Guide cookie is a favorite among mint lovers. The cookie is chocolatey and has a refreshing mint flavor that is not overpowering. The combination of chocolate and mint is a hit with girls and boys alike.
    The Chocolatey Mint Girl Guide cookie is a delicious combination of rich chocolate and refreshing mint flavor. It has a crunchy texture that adds to its overall indulgence. This cookie is beloved by many and is often considered a classic choice among Girl Guide cookie flavors.
    • Flavor: Chocolatey Mint
    • Texture: Crunchy
    • Primary Ingredients: Chocolate, Mint
    • Size: Approx. 2 inches in diameter
    • Calories per Cookie: 80-90 calories
  4. 4
    13
    votes

    Chocolate and Caramel

    Girl Guides of Canada
    The chocolate and caramel Girl Guide cookie is a newer variant that has become popular in recent years. It is a combination of two classic flavors that work well together. The cookie is crispy, the chocolate is rich, and the caramel is smooth.
    The Chocolate and Caramel cookie is a delectable treat that combines the rich flavors of smooth chocolate with a gooey caramel filling. It is a favorite among Girl Guide cookie lovers, and its popularity continues to grow. The cookie is a delicious combination of sweet and savory, with the chocolate complementing the creamy caramel perfectly.
    • Flavor: Chocolate and Caramel
    • Texture: Crunchy with a soft caramel filling
    • Size: Approximately 5 cm in diameter
    • Weight: 15 grams per cookie
    • Ingredients: Contains wheat, soy, and milk
  5. 5
    19
    votes
    Thin Mints
    carol · CC BY 2.5
    Thin Mints are a classic Girl Guide cookie that is loved by many. The cookie is thin and crispy, and the chocolatey mint flavor is refreshing. The cookie is also vegan, making it a popular option for those with dietary restrictions.
    Thin Mints are a beloved flavor of Girl Scout Cookie that combines a crisp, chocolatey cookie with a cool, refreshing minty filling. They are known for their addictive combination of rich dark chocolate and mint flavors.
    • Cookie Texture: Crisp and crunchy
    • Flavor Profile: Rich dark chocolate with a refreshing mint taste
    • Size: 1.74 inches (4.4 cm) in diameter
    • Calories per Serving: 160 calories
    • Servings per Box: About 8 servings
    Thin Mints in other rankings
  6. 6
    14
    votes
    Samoas are a popular Girl Guide cookie that is loved for its unique flavor. The cookie is made with caramel, coconut, and chocolate, giving it a sweet and slightly nutty taste. The cookie is also vegan, making it a popular option for those with dietary restrictions.
    Samoas is one of the most popular Girl Guide cookies. It is a delicious treat consisting of a crisp, vanilla-flavored cookie coated in caramel, sprinkled with toasted coconut, and striped with rich, dark chocolate.
    • Cookie Texture: Crisp
    • Flavor: Vanilla
    • Coating: Caramel
    • Topping: Toasted Coconut
    • Stripes: Rich, Dark Chocolate
  7. 7
    10
    votes
    Tagalongs are another classic Girl Guide cookie that is popular among fans. The cookie is made with a peanut butter filling and is coated in chocolate. The combination of chocolate and peanut butter is a hit with many, making it a top-selling variant.
    Tagalongs is a popular Girl Guide cookie known for its irresistible combination of creamy peanut butter and a rich, chocolatey coating. These delicious cookies are a favorite among cookie enthusiasts of all ages.
    • Name: Tagalongs
    • Flavor: Creamy peanut butter with a chocolatey coating
    • Texture: Crunchy cookie base with a smooth and creamy peanut butter center
    • Size: Approximately 1.5 inches (3.8 cm) in diameter
    • Calories per Cookie: 70
  8. 8
    15
    votes
    Lemon-Ups are a newer variant of the Girl Guide cookie that has become popular in recent years. The cookie is made with a crispy lemon cookie and has inspiring messages baked into each one. The cookie is also vegan, making it a popular option for those with dietary restrictions.
    Lemon-Ups is a delightful and zesty Girl Scout Cookie that features a crisp lemon flavored cookie with a sweet glaze on the bottom. It is the perfect balance of tangy and sweet, making it a favorite among both children and adults. The cookie is imprinted with uplifting messages such as 'I am a go-getter' and 'I am an innovator', inspiring the consumer with each bite. Lemon-Ups is an exciting addition to the lineup of classic Girl Scout Cookies, bringing a refreshing taste to the table.
    • Flavor: Lemon
    • Texture: Crisp
    • Glaze: Sweet
    • Imprint: Uplifting messages
    • Target audience: Children and adults
  9. 9
    5
    votes
    S'mores are a popular Girl Guide cookie that is loved for its classic campfire flavor. The cookie is made with a graham cracker base and is topped with a chocolate and marshmallow coating. The combination of flavors is a hit with many, making it a top-selling variant.
    S'mores is a classic American dessert that consists of a toasted marshmallow and a piece of chocolate sandwiched between two pieces of graham cracker. It is often enjoyed during camping trips or outdoor gatherings and has become a beloved treat across the country.
    • Marshmallow: Toasted and gooey
    • Chocolate: Typically a milk chocolate bar
    • Graham cracker: Traditional choice for the cookie base
    • Assembly: Roasted marshmallow placed on a piece of chocolate, sandwiched between two graham crackers
    • Texture: Combines the crunchiness of the graham cracker with the softness of the marshmallow and melted chocolate
  10. 10
    3
    votes
    Caramel Chocolate Chip is a newer variant of the Girl Guide cookie that has become popular in recent years. The cookie is made with caramel and chocolate chips, giving it a sweet and rich flavor. The cookie is also gluten-free, making it a popular option for those with dietary restrictions.
    Caramel Chocolate Chip is a delightful Girl Scout Cookie flavor that combines the rich taste of caramel with decadent chocolate chips. Each bite is a perfect balance of chewy caramel and creamy chocolate, making it a favorite among cookie enthusiasts.
    • Texture: Chewy
    • Flavor profile: Caramel and chocolate
    • Cookie size: Standard Girl Scout Cookie size
    • Cookie shape: Round
    • Chocolate chips: Semi-sweet chocolate chips throughout the cookie
    Caramel Chocolate Chip in other rankings

Missing your favorite cookie?

Graphs
Discussion

Ranking factors for popular cookie

  1. Sales
    The number of cookies sold can provide a quantitative measure of popularity. The more boxes of a specific cookie flavor that are sold, the more popular it likely is.
  2. Availability
    Some cookies may only be available during a certain time of the year or in certain regions. This can influence popularity as limited availability can create a sense of urgency around purchasing and enjoying the cookie, making it more sought after.
  3. Recognition and Branding
    A cookie's name, packaging, and association with the Girl Guides can play a role in its popularity. Iconic and easily recognizable cookie names and designs may be more popular due to familiarity and nostalgia.
  4. Customer Feedback and Reviews
    Listening to what customers have to say about the cookie, whether through word of mouth, online reviews, or social media, can provide insights into its overall popularity.
  5. Tradition and History
    Some cookies may have been a part of the Girl Guide tradition for a long time and are widely known and loved by generations. This long-standing history can make these cookies more popular.
  6. Texture and Consistency
    The way a cookie feels and crumbles can play a significant role in its popularity. A balance between crunchiness and chewiness can make a cookie more widely enjoyed.
  7. Ingredients and Allergen Information
    The ingredients and potential allergens in a cookie can impact its popularity, as customers with dietary restrictions or allergies may avoid certain flavors.
  8. Nutritional Value
    While cookies tend to be indulgent treats, the nutritional content, such as calories, sugar, and fat, can impact its popularity, particularly for those watching their intake.
  9. Social Media Engagement
    The buzz and conversation surrounding a cookie on social media can contribute to its popularity, with some gaining a cult-like following or going viral due to clever marketing campaigns or online challenges.

About this ranking

This is a community-based ranking of the most popular Girl Guide cookie. We do our best to provide fair voting, but it is not intended to be exhaustive. So if you notice something or cookie is missing, feel free to help improve the ranking!

Statistics

  • 2296 views
  • 205 votes
  • 10 ranked items

Voting Rules

A participant may cast an up or down vote for each cookie once every 24 hours. The rank of each cookie is then calculated from the weighted sum of all up and down votes.

More information on most popular girl guide cookie

Girl Guide cookies are a beloved Canadian tradition that has been around for over 100 years. These tasty treats are sold each year by Girl Guides across the country to raise funds for their programs and activities. The first Girl Guide cookies were sold in Regina, Saskatchewan in 1927 and since then, they have become a staple in many Canadian households. With a variety of flavors to choose from, including classic chocolate and vanilla, as well as newer additions like mint chocolate and salted caramel, it's no wonder that these cookies are a fan favorite. In this poll, we aim to determine which Girl Guide cookie is the most popular among Canadians.

Share this article