The Most Popular Bagel in New York, Ranked

Choose the Bagel you think is the most popular!

Author: Gregor Krambs
Updated on May 19, 2024 06:30
For countless breakfast lovers and morning commuters, the quest for the perfect New York bagel is a daily ritual. Each neighborhood boasts its own cherished bagel shop that claims to offer the best chewy delight in town. Yet with so many options, it becomes a Herculean task for both residents and visitors to decide where to enjoy this iconic New York staple. By collecting and analyzing the preferences of myriad bagel aficionados, this interactive list aims to shed light on this pressing question. Through your votes, a clearer picture emerges, highlighting which establishments really satisfy the palate. Participate in shaping this dynamic guide to help others find top-notch bagels based on shared community feedback.

What Is the Most Popular Bagel in New York?

  1. 1

    Plain Bagel

    A classic choice, loved for its simplicity and versatility.
    • Popularity: Most popular among traditionalists
  2. 2

    Sesame Bagel

    Topped with sesame seeds for a nutty flavor.
    • Popularity: Preferred by those who enjoy a subtle crunch
  3. 3

    Cinnamon Raisin Bagel

    Sweet bagel variety with cinnamon and raisins mixed into the dough.
    • Popularity: Popular among those with a sweet tooth
  4. 4

    Everything Bagel

    Covered in a mix of sesame seeds, poppy seeds, onion, garlic, and salt.
    • Popularity: Favored for its flavorful topping
  5. 5

    Poppy Seed Bagel

    Coated with poppy seeds for a slight crunch and unique flavor.
    • Popularity: Favored for its texture and taste
  6. 6

    Onion Bagel

    Features a topping of baked onions for a robust flavor.
    • Popularity: Preferred by those who enjoy a strong flavor
  7. 7

    Salt Bagel

    Topped with coarse salt for a simple, savory flavor.
    • Popularity: Loved by those who prefer a salty snack
  8. 8

    Pumpernickel Bagel

    Made with pumpernickel flour for a deep, rich flavor.
    • Popularity: Chosen for its distinctive taste and color
  9. 9

    Asiago Cheese Bagel

    Topped with Asiago cheese for a savory, cheesy flavor.
    • Popularity: Loved by cheese enthusiasts
  10. 10

    Garlic Bagel

    Infused with garlic for a bold taste.
    • Popularity: Chosen for its intense flavor

Missing your favorite Bagel?

Error: Failed to render graph
No discussion started, be the first!

About this ranking

This is a community-based ranking of the most popular Bagel in New York. We do our best to provide fair voting, but it is not intended to be exhaustive. So if you notice something or Bagel is missing, feel free to help improve the ranking!


  • 184 votes
  • 10 ranked items

Voting Rules

A participant may cast an up or down vote for each Bagel once every 24 hours. The rank of each Bagel is then calculated from the weighted sum of all up and down votes.

Additional Information

More about the Most Popular Bagel in New York

Plain Bagel
Rank #1 for the most popular Bagel in New York: Plain Bagel (Source)
New York City has a rich history of bagels. Immigrants brought the bagel to the city in the late 19th century. They brought their traditions and recipes. Bagels quickly became a staple in New York.

Bagels start with simple ingredients. Flour, water, yeast, and salt come together to form the dough. The dough is shaped into rings. Then, they are boiled before baking. This process gives them a unique texture. The outside is chewy, while the inside stays soft.

In New York, bagels are more than food. They are part of the culture. People eat them for breakfast, lunch, or a snack. Bagel shops are everywhere. Each shop claims to have the best bagels. The debate over which is best can be fierce.

One reason New York bagels stand out is the water. Many believe the city's tap water makes a difference. The water has a specific mineral content. This helps create the perfect dough. Some even say it is impossible to replicate New York bagels elsewhere.

Bagels come in many flavors. The plain bagel is simple and classic. It pairs well with any topping. Sesame seed bagels add a nutty flavor. Poppy seed bagels have a slight crunch. Onion bagels offer a savory taste. Garlic bagels are strong and aromatic. There are also sweet options. Cinnamon raisin bagels have a hint of spice and sweetness. Blueberry bagels are fruity and fresh.

Toppings are just as varied. Cream cheese is the most popular. It comes in many varieties. Plain cream cheese is smooth and rich. Flavored cream cheese adds extra taste. Lox is another favorite topping. It is thinly sliced salmon. It pairs well with cream cheese and capers. Butter is a simple but tasty option. Peanut butter and jelly can also be spread on a bagel. Some people make sandwiches with bagels. They add meats, cheeses, and vegetables.

Bagels are often enjoyed with a hot beverage. Coffee is the most common choice. Tea is also popular. Some people prefer juice or milk.

Bagel shops are busy places. They open early in the morning. Customers line up to get fresh bagels. The smell of baking bagels fills the air. Workers move quickly to keep up with orders. The atmosphere is lively and bustling.

New Yorkers take pride in their bagels. They are a symbol of the city's diversity. Each bagel tells a story of tradition and community. People from all walks of life enjoy them. They bring people together.

Making bagels is an art. It requires skill and patience. Bakers wake up early to start the process. They mix, shape, boil, and bake. Each step is important. The result is a bagel that is crisp on the outside and soft on the inside.

Bagels are more than just food in New York. They are a part of the city's identity. They represent history, culture, and community. Whether plain or topped with lox, New York bagels are beloved by many. They are a true taste of the city.

Share this article